Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Craicnet

The traitors

263 replies

Magnalux · 31/08/2025 23:02

i love the English version. The first episode is always a bit manic so will reserve judgement. It’s interesting though the names of two traitors have already been brought up!

OP posts:
MsFelicityLemon · 15/09/2025 08:46

Oyin would be an amazing traitor but it would be crazy to recruit her as a one because it would mean your demise. You really need to recruit a person who is suspected as a traitor and could be banished, leaving you to get to the final.

it would be funny if every time Paudie (accidentally because I really think he's not got an actually game plan) recruited soneone they got banished straightaway. They'd be banishing Traitors every night, so theoretical doing amazingly but in reality not succeeding 🤣.

So that said he should recruit Patrick, then the next day lean on the thinking he's a traitor. Or Nick and thren try push the idea (to others) he was actually recruited and pretended he wasn't - but that's riskier as I think Nick is less suspected than Patrick is, so it'd be more work.

ComeAsYouAreAsAFriend · 16/09/2025 09:05

Poor Christine killed herself there leaning in for that hug. Think they handled the murder in plain sight pretty well. Love Paudie with his "I'm not a hugger" leaving Nick to do the lions share. Not mad about Nick but he makes a good traitor. No idea why people suspected Will he's pretty useless but very obviously not a traitor. No idea whose next for banishment think it will take an unexpected turn with Christine gone.
I'd like to see Vanessa and Oyin stay to the end they're playing the game well and not getting too personal with it as the other girls seem to be.
And how many times did Faye say "that's your opinion nothing I've actually done or said" it sounded so rehearsed, that alone would make me suspicious of her.

MsFelicityLemon · 16/09/2025 09:50

It's strange how in this series who has a shield is always known, this is the closest it's been with one group knowing the other has a sheild but not who specifically. In other previous Traitors it could be unknown to everyone; meaning the Traitors could end up trying to murder someone with a sheild.

My terrible memory is not allowing me to recollect which group Christine was in, and which group the traitors were in!! Where they both in the same group?

Fuckish · 16/09/2025 10:00

ComeAsYouAreAsAFriend · 16/09/2025 09:05

Poor Christine killed herself there leaning in for that hug. Think they handled the murder in plain sight pretty well. Love Paudie with his "I'm not a hugger" leaving Nick to do the lions share. Not mad about Nick but he makes a good traitor. No idea why people suspected Will he's pretty useless but very obviously not a traitor. No idea whose next for banishment think it will take an unexpected turn with Christine gone.
I'd like to see Vanessa and Oyin stay to the end they're playing the game well and not getting too personal with it as the other girls seem to be.
And how many times did Faye say "that's your opinion nothing I've actually done or said" it sounded so rehearsed, that alone would make me suspicious of her.

I’m gutted Christine is gone! I liked that kind of mad-eyed stare she did. But it had to be Nick doing the hugging (agree that Paudie suddenly walking up and hugging someone would have been highly irregular and outed him immediately as a traitor), and he almost certainly had to hug someone who was physically demonstrative and who would accept a hug casually, rather than saying ‘Oyin! You look like you need a hug!’.)

I thought it was hilarious how Nick’s expression and body language suddenly got much more unsure once he got recruited. Given that he seemed perfectly happy to be a ‘traitorous’ faithful…

With Christine gone, my faithful allegiance has switched to the emergent immigrant trio of Oyin, Vanessa and Joanna (Johanna?)

My 13 year old is baffled at Wilkin attracting so much suspicion, unless the half-sleeping dopiness is an Oscar-winning performance.

CheeseDanish · 16/09/2025 10:55

Sorry that I am to lose Christine, it may actually have been a good move on the traitors' part -- everyone liked her, and no one ever thought she was a plausible possible traitor because she was so transparent and talkative. So she wasn't going to be banished, ever.

I'm glad Patrick was banished. I got impatient with him just not appearing to grasp that whether or not you're a traitor is less important than whether other people think you are, which is possibly the most basic rule of the game. He went to no effort to appear likeable, and his continual air of 'You're a bit dopey and I'm pointing out logic of which you should be aware but aren't' didn't endear him to anyone. Even his final speech was couched in terms of everyone else getting it wrong, and breaking their run of finding traitors. There's no point in having casino experience if you strike everyone as a pain in the hole they're delighted to suspect!

I do think that Patrick took a lot of the heat off Paudie for a bit, so who knows whether that will ramp up again now he's gone. (And was that argy-bargy between Nick and Paudie at the round table staged so that it didn't look as if Nick's previous suspicions had magically vanished, or a warning that Nick will throw Paudie under the bus asap?)

The tasks are woeful in this series, though.

MsFelicityLemon · 16/09/2025 12:35

Aren't the tasks terrible? I mean the Irish theme to all of them is brilliant to see, but the actual tasks aren't great i reakon the budget is much lower - apparently Siobhán is wearing her own clothes as there's no (or low) budget for wardrobe.

I read a comment somewhere that Wilkin is still wandering around Slane castle because production is forgot about him and he's unaware the game is over.

CheeseDanish · 16/09/2025 12:50

I read a comment somewhere that Wilkin is still wandering around Slane castle because production is forgot about him and he's unaware the game is over.

Grin Grin

TartanCulshie · 16/09/2025 13:10

Wilkin is gas. He is on another planet.

I'm not sure how I could keep the head with him and his vacantness!

I keep swinging about nick. Now he's a traitor I'm back to liking him. But I want him to work with Paudie and not against him.

Was it Christine who said Paudie and Nick were scheming. And now she's dead. That might look bad.

I wonder if they'll reveal the murder was done in plain sight? Or would that be too telling?

FlipFlopShopInHawaii · 16/09/2025 13:30

I couldn't watch live Sun or Mon, so only catching up now.
So many thoughts.... can't keep up with them all.

Very sad to see Christine go, she was a great addition to the show.
Don't get the heat on Wilkin? Love the idea that he's still wandering around Slane 🤣😆

Did anyone else take note that Siobhán ordered "3 coffins for tomorrow" at the start of Monday's ep? Presume that's for tonight - so excited!!

FlipFlopShopInHawaii · 16/09/2025 13:39

I remembered something else.... if I remember correctly; Paudie hasn't received a vote at the round table since ep. 5 when Eamon was banished. The heat is completely off him now. Will he go all the way???

CheeseDanish · 16/09/2025 14:02

TartanCulshie · 16/09/2025 13:10

Wilkin is gas. He is on another planet.

I'm not sure how I could keep the head with him and his vacantness!

I keep swinging about nick. Now he's a traitor I'm back to liking him. But I want him to work with Paudie and not against him.

Was it Christine who said Paudie and Nick were scheming. And now she's dead. That might look bad.

I wonder if they'll reveal the murder was done in plain sight? Or would that be too telling?

Wilkin reminds me of an old student friend of mine, who gave the impression of being permanently amiably half-asleep or stoned. When he proposed to another friend of ours, we were primarily astonished that he'd stayed awake long enough.

Comedy demands that someone, at some point, recruits Wilkin as a traitor, surely?

I can't get past how piss-poor the tasks are. Surely it wouldn't necessarily cost too much to evolve better ones? Even if we dispense with helicopters and lasers or expensive things, or terribly athletic things that would involve too much set up and safety checks.

Aren't there obstacle race sets from Ireland Fittest Family they could borrow or something?

Just orienteering-type running around in the woods following a map to get to certain coordinates, but where the controls you have to get a clue from are alive and masked and can run away from you.

Blow up giant gym balls and try to get them through an obstacle course.

An endurance challenge like Survivor, where you have to stand on something with your hand on the prize for as long as you can.

A blindfold challenge, where a blindfolded person is guided to find clues by someone at a distance giving them directions via an earpiece or loudspeaker.

Or you have to get buckets of water from the river and throw the water into something to get a floating key or clue high up enough to reach in and grab it.

Scaled-up game of Battleship.

Even something really simple where there's a selection of objects in a line, and then each person has to run back to their own spot and put the items in the right order.

(I'm stealing lots of these from Survivor, especially in the season where 9/11 meant they had to switch locations at the last minute and had to invent simple challenges.)

Obviously, some people are fitter than others, so you need a mix where some people on a team do the running and others do the puzzle-solving.

I think they should also have separate shield challenges.

CheeseDanish · 16/09/2025 14:03

FlipFlopShopInHawaii · 16/09/2025 13:30

I couldn't watch live Sun or Mon, so only catching up now.
So many thoughts.... can't keep up with them all.

Very sad to see Christine go, she was a great addition to the show.
Don't get the heat on Wilkin? Love the idea that he's still wandering around Slane 🤣😆

Did anyone else take note that Siobhán ordered "3 coffins for tomorrow" at the start of Monday's ep? Presume that's for tonight - so excited!!

Yes, I was wondering if they were going to do a version of the Buried Alive challenge from the UK one? Or the 'hold a funeral for three contestants' and someone doesn't get saved?

TartanCulshie · 16/09/2025 15:37

Also,
Mind Oyin got the shield, then there was no murder. That never rolled over, she never got her immunity. I love her.

Funny how Faye and Vanessa have turned on each other . I agree with Patrick when he said on uncloaked there was no cohesion with the women and that made them vulnerable. They run the risk of being picked off one by one.

CheeseDanish · 16/09/2025 15:52

TartanCulshie · 16/09/2025 15:37

Also,
Mind Oyin got the shield, then there was no murder. That never rolled over, she never got her immunity. I love her.

Funny how Faye and Vanessa have turned on each other . I agree with Patrick when he said on uncloaked there was no cohesion with the women and that made them vulnerable. They run the risk of being picked off one by one.

Though I feel the need to point out that they've all lasted longer than Patrick! Even poor huggy Christine.

You can have all the strategic thinking in the world, but if people think you're a dry shite, you're not going to survive long enough to get strategic. Strategic can also mean making people like you and seeming unthreatening till a certain point in the game.

(Though my 13 year old and DH claimed Patrick only attracted so much suspicion because he was bald and had a cranky expression, whereas Paudie has nice hair and looks amiable. He's smiling in the photo on the breakfast room wall and barely recognisable as the same man.)

Dontlletmedownbruce · 16/09/2025 16:48

I admit I have a little crush on Andrew. I was sorry to see him go for that reason.

I would have loved to see Christine recruited rather than killed, I wonder would she have gone to the other side or let herself go. The thing about these alliances is when they fall apart they can be brutal. I hope someone from the girly BFF gang gets recruited soon.

Oyen is amazing, so perceptive. She doesn't seem to be showing any personality though. I'd like to see more of her. Can't stand Ben and Nick!

MsFelicityLemon · 16/09/2025 17:23

When did Siobhán order the coffins? That went right over my head!!

I think it's got to be more than being a dry shite, Nick is the driest shite of them all. (Honestly not sure he could knows what fun is.) Patrick figured him out perfectly yet he got banished. I worry he'll oust Paudie and team up with the ball of agro Ben

Berlinlover · 16/09/2025 17:53

@MsFelicityLemon Siobhan ordered three coffins in yesterday’s episode.

CheeseDanish · 16/09/2025 18:02

MsFelicityLemon · 16/09/2025 17:23

When did Siobhán order the coffins? That went right over my head!!

I think it's got to be more than being a dry shite, Nick is the driest shite of them all. (Honestly not sure he could knows what fun is.) Patrick figured him out perfectly yet he got banished. I worry he'll oust Paudie and team up with the ball of agro Ben

Honestly, I think Patrick just looked like everyone's angry Fifth Year maths teacher, and he was always pointing out what everyone else had done wrong, or failed in their logic, as if he came from some unique position of Pure Reason.

Nick is also awful, I agree. His fleece is starting to annoy me. I'd be tempted to say that 'Nick, you're getting my vote because your fleece is annoying. I voted to banish Nina because her multi-coloured one was also awful.'

Siobhán ordered the coffins in the phone box just before the task/ mission/challenge whatever we're calling them now started.

MsFelicityLemon · 16/09/2025 21:12

Well I completely missed Siobhán doing that.

Magnalux · 16/09/2025 23:31

Ah poor Paudie, but in fairness it was only a matter of time! I’d say nick will recruit Ben or Faye. They’re all so ridiculously over the top., Faye was crying today like she was actually going to be murderd.. get a grip love! It amazes me though that Kelly’s name hasn’t been mentioned at all ever really, she would be a good recruit in that no one would suspect her but I don’t think she’d have the stomach for it!!

OP posts:
MsFelicityLemon · 17/09/2025 09:18

So sad Paudie has gone.

Nick and Ben are totally insufferable. They way they celebrated like all traitor banishment has been on them.

I need Nick to be banished!! Wonder who he'll "blackmail" (and yes, as someone mentioned up thread, how come the contestants knew to switch from "recruited" to "blackmailed"?)

MsFelicityLemon · 17/09/2025 09:38

I've edited this part of my post as it's a spoiler for UK S1. Only click Edited if you watched it or don't mind spoliers.

Stowickthevast · 17/09/2025 11:05

I didn't realize there was a thread here - I've just caught up on last night's episode. Sad to see the Paudfather go but it was inevitable.

Ann really enjoying the Irish series though, it's far better then the last English one despite the terrible tasks. And I adore Siobhan.

I kind of hope Nick does recruit Ben as then at least one of them will go. But I wonder if it will be Kelly or Amy as we've had quite a few interviews with them both which makes me think either they go deep or become a traitor.

Rooting for Oyin, Vanessa & Johanna to win but don't know if they'll make it.

ComeAsYouAreAsAFriend · 17/09/2025 12:20

Sorry to see Paudie go but it's been a long time coming. As much as I hate Nick and Ben they are definitely entertaining to watch. We were all howling at the funeral scenes it was hilarious especially when the extras all left with the tea and sandwiches 😂

I hope Nick does recruit Ben so they can implode and turn on each other. Faye is one of those faithfuls who can dish it out but then takes it personal when it's her in the firing line. I thought it was completely inappropriate when she got angry with Joanna querying her behavior in the funeral fgs it's a game about murder what are you doing there if you get so distressed about it. Has she never watched the UK one! Would like to see her go next @MsFelicityLemon not sure she'll get that far tbh.

CheeseDanish · 17/09/2025 12:22

I assume everyone saw this? 😀

The traitors