Just had a good read, and a scowl Shelly
This is the only thing I can agree with is, "The key to the perfect birthing partner is finding a mother figure who can help, keep a low profile and remain silent."
I believe that if a woman wants her partner there, then she has good reasons for doing so. Many women who feel their partner won't cope, or won't be supportive just don't have them there.
My partner will only enhance my labour, of that I am quite sure. Without him I will be more stressed and less likely to labour effectively. If I had any doubts - he would not be there.
I do think women benefit from having an older or experienced mum there who has had 2/3 or more births for their support and reassurance. I love those mums who are no nonsense 'I've done this 6 times, and so can you' attitude! Their daughters seem to do very well in labour. I like to think its because they believe they can do it, and have the support to do so.
I have seen some birth partners, both husbands and mothers give the most terrible 'support' which has been detrimental to the womans birth to be quite honest, so I do think you have to think carefully about who you have with you.
But no, I don't agree with the article! Although I do like Michael Odents other work particularly on water birth.
(This has just taken me 30 mins to post. Stupid MN GRRRR!)