Please or to access all these features

Bereavement

Find bereavement help and support from other Mumsnetters. See also your choices after baby loss.

Should we let our 6 year old see his dead granny?

206 replies

Thunderbolted · 07/09/2020 15:00

Just that really.
We're taking him to the funeral but wondered whether to let him see the body the day before. Apparently she's nicely laid out. I know I found it helpful as an 11 year old to see a dead relative but I don't know if 6 is too young.
We're very open about death and what's happened so my inclination is to give him the option and let him choose. They weren't super close.
I know it's totally different but he saw our dog after he died and decorated the coffin and I think that helped him grieve.

OP posts:
Afternooninthepark · 10/09/2020 12:39

My mother in law passed away last week. I sat with her for an hour and a half after she passed and in that short time I could see the deteriorating in her face and body. I certainly won’t be allowing my 12 and 15 year old to see her in the funeral home. In hindsight I’m not so sure I should have seen her tbh, it’s having a big affect on me this week.

happymummy12345 · 10/09/2020 12:57

It's difficult because everyone has their own views on things like that and that said I don't think anyone is right or wrong because there is no right or wrong with things like this.
But I would never ever want to see anyone after they had died. I know I couldn't do it and would prefer to remember them as they were.
I was 11 when my Nan died and I was extremely close to her. Much younger than that I feel is too young to go to a funeral but again that's my personal opinion

frustratedstep · 10/09/2020 12:59

No. 6 is too young in my opinion

MitziK · 10/09/2020 17:44

@Tollergirl

To answer the OP's question- my advice is that you know your own DC and that is your best guide. My DC lost two very close relatives in the space of a year and they didn't want to attend either funeral service (but came to the reception afterwards). I had no problem with this- they still grieved and understood that those people were dead.

I do take issue with much of what's been said on here regarding cultural differences though. Which is that English funerals are cold and the English are fearful of death, whereas the Irish are much better at dealing with death. My own experience tells a very different story.

My DGM was Irish but left to escape being locked up in a Magdalen laundry in the 1930s as she was pregnant and unmarried. She married my English DGF and they had 50 years together. Her funeral was the full Catholic mass which seemed to go on forever (she had been so indoctrinated that even though she had never set foot in a church since arriving in England she still wanted a Catholic burial). The Priest knew nothing about her or her life and the church was packed with people who thought it was a grand day out! Several of her siblings came and came back to the house afterwards. They drank and ate everything and anything and waxed lyrical about their childhood memories of my DGM. Funnily enough not one of them had been in contact with her for the 50 years she had lived in England!!

As for the "cold English funeral" of my DF twenty years ago- nobody wore black, we had no church service, but we stood in a beautiful woodland and played his beloved jazz whilst drinking Champagne and celebrating about his life. The small number of people who attended were his actual friends and close family who had known and loved him.

Furthermore I don't believe it's unhealthy to fear dying, particularly if you are not religious. For us there is no redemption or afterlife so it seems logical to want to have the best life on earth and part of that involves being afraid of how and when it will come to an end.

Also please no more of the cold hearted English trope. Some of us like to do our grieving in private. Doesn't mean our feelings are any less. And it has bugger all to do with 'What would the Queen do'.

Ok - rant over...

I think I know the people I share some DNA with more than you do.

'Emotionally stunted and bereft of all human emotion other than anger' would be a generous description.

But what else can be expected from somebody who declared years ago that 'I hate him and wish he'd die so I never have to see his stupid face again' about her own child?

It was completely about What Would The Queen Do. Except for her, shaking hands with your children was a bit icky as well. Punching them, fine especially in the side of the head so there weren't any visible bruises. But getting close enough to touch them for any other reason? Good Lord, no. That's 'Terribly Non U, We simply don't do things like that^.

Thunderbolted · 10/09/2020 21:11

OK, I can now report back on the viewing.

DS continued to be adamant that he wanted to see his Granny, so he did.

He took in a little gift she'd given him and placed it on her to be buried with her.

We spent about 5-10 minutes in there. She looked very dead and not like herself. DS wasn't bothered at all. He was disappointed he couldn't see her legs, just her top half!

He asked if he could touch her to which we said yes if you want, but she might have make up on which you could rub off and she'll be very cold. He changed his mind about this.

He skipped out of there, is totally happy and normal and said to me at bedtime 'I liked seeing Granny'.

So, all in all a positive experience which was really driven by what he wanted.

I explained to him this evening that some people won't let children see bodies or attend funerals and he was totally puzzled by this - couldn't understand it at all.

OP posts:
IHateCoronavirus · 10/09/2020 21:13

Flowers I’m glad it went well for him op. It is never easy to grieve and parent at the same time.

SionnachRua · 10/09/2020 21:36

Good for you OP! Sounds like a really positive experience for him and I love that he got to put in a little gift. I did the same at that age and it's something that I will always remember. Can also empathise with him about the legs thing Grin

orangejuicer · 10/09/2020 21:37

Absolutely not.

orangejuicer · 10/09/2020 21:38

Oh hell, sorry OP. Glad it went well!

GreenTiles22 · 10/09/2020 22:46

Glad it went well OP x

hometownfunk · 11/09/2020 01:24

That’s lovely OP Flowers At 10 years old I was able to see my grandad just after he passed away in hospital. I’m glad I was able to say goodbye and I’m sure your son will be to.

Torvean32 · 11/09/2020 01:37

I wouldnt i think 6 is too young. It's totally different than seeing a dead animal.

I saw my grandmother die when i was 3. It terrified me and i was scared that my parents were going to die too.

What about taking him to tge graveside and letting him cut some flowers to take there.

BiddyPop · 11/09/2020 11:15

Glad it went well OP.

1forAll74 · 11/09/2020 14:13

No six is much too young. I know a child who was taken to see a deceased relative, and then became obsessed with drawing coffins with pretend bodies inside. Not so nice for a child who is very imaginative.

tearinyourhand · 11/09/2020 14:50

Kids draw things that they have seen. If they see a house, they draw one. If they see a coffin, they draw one. They go through phases. Both my children studied the Titanic at school aged about six and spent about six months drawing pictures of sinking ships.

I'd be disturbed by a child drawing pictures of a murder or something, but a coffin and a body is no big deal to me.

Animum2 · 13/09/2020 20:32

When my Step dad died, there was an open coffin wake the day before and lots of under 10s came and they were all fine with seeing him, I guess it just depends on the child

Reader1984 · 13/09/2020 20:33

No.

Voice0fReason · 13/09/2020 22:37

I'm so glad it went well.
It shows that this is absolutely fine for many children, with the right support.

dewisant2020 · 13/09/2020 23:07

As a nurse working with the elderly for many years I have seen more dead bodies than most could imagine. However I'd never been to the chapel of rest to see a loved one up until recently, I never knew what to expect going to the funeral home but it bought me peace & comfort but my DS didn't look like him, he was bloated and cold.
My DD wanted to go and see her brother and I was nervous but it helped bring her peace.
You know you DS better than anyone and I am a believer that death is something we should embrace

Starlightstarbright1 · 13/09/2020 23:16

Glad it went well Op. you know your child best

Sciencebabe · 13/09/2020 23:39

I wanted to see my nan when I was about 8 and wasn't allowed to. My parents respected my innocence for me, and I'm thankful as children have vivid imaginations. What has been seen cannot be unseen. Six is way too young to see a dead person, mentally that age group is very fragile to suggestion/imagination/horror/obsessing.

Shocked12 · 13/09/2020 23:48

I did at 7 and it fucked me for life. Months of nightmares at the time too. To the posters saying it will be okay what if it isn't. Every child/adult is different.

Shocked12 · 13/09/2020 23:51

Oh just read you've done it. Hope it stays positive for your son op.

MaddeningtheUnhelpful · 13/09/2020 23:53

I have never seen a dead body and have no desire to. Was with my Nan only hours before she died. On receiving the phone call DM asked me if I wanted to see her. My sister did, as did my mum but personally I had no desire to weep over her body. My Nan was amazing and vibrant, that's how I choose to remember her. I see no reason for that to be anyones last memory of a loved one

caughtalightsneeze · 14/09/2020 04:54

@Shocked12

I did at 7 and it fucked me for life. Months of nightmares at the time too. To the posters saying it will be okay what if it isn't. Every child/adult is different.
And the same is true in reverse. The child might regret forever that they weren't allowed to be included in the grieving rituals in the same way as everyone else.