Do you prefer Ivy or Winter for a girl?

[NameChanged15729]

Dd2 is due January and agreeing on a name has become difficult! Dh has vetoed all my suggestions and these are the only two names left.
One is an absolute love of mine and the other is dh’s favourite. What would you go for?

Both lovely, but if I had to choose: Ivy

Winter. I know several little ones named Ivy

Ivy

Winter.

Ivy

Ivy. I wouldn’t see winter as a name

Ivy. Winter is silly.

Have you considered other festive names like Holly or Robin?

Ivy would be my pick.

Lovely names, OP! I like them both equally, so for me it would come down to which sounded better with my surname.

Winter by far, its a beautiful name

Ivy

Winter. I think it’s lovely.

Ooh I love them both, but thinking from the perspective of her being an adult, I’d go with Ivy

Ivy

Ivy is my favourite name at the moment but it’s very popular. I’d go with Winter Ivy Surname.

Winter is a boys name. So Ivy is at least a girls name.

Winter Ivy surname is beautiful!

Winter ❤️

Winter is beautiful! I like it spelt Wynter too

Ivy

Ivy.

Is Winter even a name?

Thank you everyone! I love the suggestion of Winter Ivy.
Dh wants to use Ivy and while I do really like it Winter just has that edge for me. I wanted to use it for dd1 as well but her birthday is in May so it didn’t feel quite right.

I agree that Winter Ivy is a lovely combination. I know a Holly Winter IRL and have always liked that as well.

If for some reason she decides she prefers Ivy in the future, she can always decide to be known by her middle name, I know a few people who've opted to do that.

Winter

Ivy