Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour asking me to take her to hospital appointments

343 replies

BecauseNothing · 02/10/2026 11:43

A neighbour has asked me to drive her to, stay with her and bring her home from 2 upcoming hospital appointments. The first is in 4 weeks time and the second the week after. I have said I can’t because I’m working and she has asked if I can book the time off. I haven’t replied but this seems cheeky to me after I’d said no. AIBU? I need my annual leave for things with my own family. She has people who visit her who I presume are family and friends but apparently has no one to go with her. I work full time at home and have children so with everything that comes with that I’m busy.

OP posts:
nomas · 02/10/2026 15:10

summertree1 · 02/10/2026 11:51

You’re not being unreasonable not to take her but don’t be unkind about it. She wouldn’t be reaching out to you if she had someone to take her, it’s quite sad really.

Just send her a polite reply and maybe recommend she checks with the hospital if there is any community support that can help her (in my area there is).

FFS, where has OP given any indication that she would be unkind to her neighbour? All OP has told her is that she can't take her because she is working.

Really hate this #BeKind nonsense.

MajesticWhine · 02/10/2026 15:11

The word cheeky is coming up a lot. I think it’s more desperate / needy than cheeky. Older people can be quite lonely and isolated and their family dynamics could be difficult. It’s ok for her to ask, and equally ok to say no.

nomas · 02/10/2026 15:12

malloryknox123 · 02/10/2026 14:45

You don’t have to, but would she be asking if she really did have other options? I would probably do it myself but then I’m a bit of a reluctant hero

Nothing heroic about being taken advantage of.

This is not OP's problem, the neighbour can ask one of the people who visit her.

nomas · 02/10/2026 15:12

MajesticWhine · 02/10/2026 15:11

The word cheeky is coming up a lot. I think it’s more desperate / needy than cheeky. Older people can be quite lonely and isolated and their family dynamics could be difficult. It’s ok for her to ask, and equally ok to say no.

No, it's not ok to ask when you've already been told no, let alone telling OP to take time off work.

You wouldn't like that so why pretend it's fine.

aloris · 02/10/2026 15:15

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 02/10/2026 14:51

I always wonder who all these people are who have never heard of taxis!

A taxi will cost the neighbour a lot less than a day off lost annual leave costs the OP - it’s much cheaper than a day of holiday club or having to take a day of parental leave further down the line to care for a child.

By all means explain in nicely Op but you’re under no obligation to take her.

I think some people who were SAHMS/ the partner of a SAHM back in the day don’t realise how working age women are just not free for all kinds of favours these days, and how difficult and expensive it is to cover the school holidays!

Sometimes it's because, back when they were SAHMs, they took lots of THEIR elderly neighbors to hospital and assumed that karma would one day bring those favors back to them. The world has changed and there are far fewer SAHMs around to do those sorts of things. And, current SAHMS usually are only asked to do favors for others but can never get reciprocation. That is why, as a SAHM, I am extremely unwelcoming to suggestions from working mums, that, as a SAHM, I should be the one to do all the free favors for other people.

Househunt2026 · 02/10/2026 15:19

MaidsRoom · 02/10/2026 13:17

I find these responses a little sad. No it’s not OP’s responsibility. But OP’s neighbour is probably feeling scared and lonely. They may not be allowed to leave hospital without a companion. There may be no family nearby who can help. For the sake of being my brother‘s / sister’s keeper, I hope I’d try to help if I possibly could.

Me too! Especially if it’s an appointment where you need someone to go home with you, and you might be woozy from sedation or something like that. She would trust OP much more than a random volunteer so I can see why she’s asking and then double checking. Seems like desperate rather than cheeky.

Aiming4Optimistic · 02/10/2026 15:19

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 02/10/2026 14:51

I always wonder who all these people are who have never heard of taxis!

A taxi will cost the neighbour a lot less than a day off lost annual leave costs the OP - it’s much cheaper than a day of holiday club or having to take a day of parental leave further down the line to care for a child.

By all means explain in nicely Op but you’re under no obligation to take her.

I think some people who were SAHMS/ the partner of a SAHM back in the day don’t realise how working age women are just not free for all kinds of favours these days, and how difficult and expensive it is to cover the school holidays!

Sahm are often seen as free sources of labour for other people's convenience. When I was a sahm, I had to field requests from people who thought my time was up for grabs. What they don't consider is that a sahm is going this for the benefit and convenience of her own family and that decision comes with financial and career costs. We aren't doing it so that working parents and neighbours and the PTA can have the benefit of our unpaid labour.
I was always willing to help out as a one off in an emergency, but not be the default back up for anyone other than my own family. You'd be surprised how many people think that women exist to facilitate other people's lives, even other women do it!

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 02/10/2026 15:23

emuloc · 02/10/2026 12:40

This, I can't understand why some people can't just be a bit more kinder about things. Labelling her a cheeky so, and so. One day, it could be them who need the help.

No but she IS a cheeky so and so. Asking an acquaintance to take two days of annual leave to take you to appointments rather than pay for taxis is absurdly cheeky. Annual leave isn't free, it's worth more than a couple of taxi trips.

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 02/10/2026 15:23

DidoAndAeneasWereInLove · 02/10/2026 12:47

I wouldn’t describe it as cheeky, more like desperate.

Taxis exist!?

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 02/10/2026 15:27

MaidsRoom · 02/10/2026 13:17

I find these responses a little sad. No it’s not OP’s responsibility. But OP’s neighbour is probably feeling scared and lonely. They may not be allowed to leave hospital without a companion. There may be no family nearby who can help. For the sake of being my brother‘s / sister’s keeper, I hope I’d try to help if I possibly could.

Would you take annual leave - twice - to take an acquaintance to hospital appointments involving you waiting around potentially for hours?

Allseeingallknowing · 02/10/2026 15:29

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 02/10/2026 15:23

Taxis exist!?

They do, and they’re VERY expensive!

ChainGanging · 02/10/2026 15:31

It's only as my own mother has got old old that I have come to understand how ageing undermines people, particularly women. My mother is highly educated and was fiercely assertive on my behalf when I was younger, but I've watched her lose confidence and become more hesitant as her strength declines and, at every turn, the world tells her she doesn't matter and she tidies herself away and puts up with being treated as a waste of space, a relic from another era, an inconvenience. It was quite upsetting to notice that a lot of the time she just accepts.

My mother uses the internet, she's fine with routine tasks, but she's nothing like as comfortable with working out new things as she used to be. I do some of the searching legwork for her these days. She'd probably think to phone someone if she needed a lift to a hospital appointment, but I'm not sure she knows about patient transport.

If I couldn't take her, I'd do the research on other options, send her the links and tell her to call me if she needed me to sort something out. Because she isn't going to do that without an invitation unless she's desperate, because as an elderly woman, her experience is that the world finds her a minor inconvenience - until she needs help, when she becomes an irritating burden who has outstayed her welcome on this planet.

I should add that my mother wouldn't say any of this. She's still independent and probably more capable than most women her age, but she does sometimes need kindness or advocacy. I'm glad she lives somewhere where people are kind and that she has me at the end of a phone line.

OP, If you really don't have time to help at all, you don't and that's all there is to it. However my guess is that you are - in this instance - your neighbour's last resort. Not because she's cheeky or lazy, but because she just hasn't the mental agility - or perhaps lacks the confidence- to come up with a better strategy. If you could spare the time to point her in a better direction it would be a kindness. If you don't want this situation to crop up again it might be worth investing time in helping her towards a more robust source of help and advice so that next time you're not her first, last or only resort. Obviously it's sensible to be frank about this - tell her your help must be a one-off and she can't afford to be picky about whatever alternative you help to set up.

Sorry, long and probably pointless post, but seeing the change in my own mother since she entered her eighties has completely changed my perspective on incompetent old biddies.

nomas · 02/10/2026 15:31

Allseeingallknowing · 02/10/2026 15:29

They do, and they’re VERY expensive!

That doesn't make it ok to ask your neighbour to take time off work after she has told her no.

OVienna · 02/10/2026 15:31

Katflapkit · 02/10/2026 14:51

That is my first thought.

Years ago, I used to help out an elderly neighbour thinking she had no family. Her requests became more than picking up a couple of bits from the shop or changing a light bulb. One day dropped off a card and some flowers to find a house full of local family. Apparently she told them she gave me little jobs to do as she felt sorry for me because I lived alone and it saved her bothering them.

It's always okay to ask but not if you know her person has a job and busy. It's bloody cheeky to ask if you would take annual leave. Her family or friends need to step up.

This is wild. How did you find out she had said that?

nomas · 02/10/2026 15:34

ChainGanging · 02/10/2026 15:31

It's only as my own mother has got old old that I have come to understand how ageing undermines people, particularly women. My mother is highly educated and was fiercely assertive on my behalf when I was younger, but I've watched her lose confidence and become more hesitant as her strength declines and, at every turn, the world tells her she doesn't matter and she tidies herself away and puts up with being treated as a waste of space, a relic from another era, an inconvenience. It was quite upsetting to notice that a lot of the time she just accepts.

My mother uses the internet, she's fine with routine tasks, but she's nothing like as comfortable with working out new things as she used to be. I do some of the searching legwork for her these days. She'd probably think to phone someone if she needed a lift to a hospital appointment, but I'm not sure she knows about patient transport.

If I couldn't take her, I'd do the research on other options, send her the links and tell her to call me if she needed me to sort something out. Because she isn't going to do that without an invitation unless she's desperate, because as an elderly woman, her experience is that the world finds her a minor inconvenience - until she needs help, when she becomes an irritating burden who has outstayed her welcome on this planet.

I should add that my mother wouldn't say any of this. She's still independent and probably more capable than most women her age, but she does sometimes need kindness or advocacy. I'm glad she lives somewhere where people are kind and that she has me at the end of a phone line.

OP, If you really don't have time to help at all, you don't and that's all there is to it. However my guess is that you are - in this instance - your neighbour's last resort. Not because she's cheeky or lazy, but because she just hasn't the mental agility - or perhaps lacks the confidence- to come up with a better strategy. If you could spare the time to point her in a better direction it would be a kindness. If you don't want this situation to crop up again it might be worth investing time in helping her towards a more robust source of help and advice so that next time you're not her first, last or only resort. Obviously it's sensible to be frank about this - tell her your help must be a one-off and she can't afford to be picky about whatever alternative you help to set up.

Sorry, long and probably pointless post, but seeing the change in my own mother since she entered her eighties has completely changed my perspective on incompetent old biddies.

It really doesn't mean the neighbour's last resort is OP. Probably that sees OP as a soft option.

There was a similar thread a few months ago where a neighbour asked OP to make the 2 hour trip to take her to hospital every week for a few weeks.

The neighbour had a partner who drove and children who drove but some people bizarrely decided that OP must be her only option.

MaidsRoom · 02/10/2026 15:36

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 02/10/2026 15:27

Would you take annual leave - twice - to take an acquaintance to hospital appointments involving you waiting around potentially for hours?

Bluntly, yes, and I have done similar things for various people, some of whom were neighbours or acquaintances rather than friends. So have most of my friends and family (in London - not always the world’s friendliest city). It often felt like a burden at the time. But I don’t regret it.

Sometimes people on MN ask “what happened to the village?” when they want help with their children. Well, this is the village. If we all sacrifice a little for our neighbours, then over time life gets a little nicer and friendlier for everyone. If our default instinct is “no, what a cheeky thing to ask” then we can’t complain when we discover we lead atomized lives and barely know anybody in our local community. We also can’t complain if, down the line, we find ourselves needing help for something and nobody offers.

When you make a habit of helping others out, you often find the biggest winner turns out to be you.

fumingrightnow1 · 02/10/2026 15:36

I wouldn't even take annual leave to take an adult relative to an appointment thats what taxis are for

nomas · 02/10/2026 15:37

MaidsRoom · 02/10/2026 13:17

I find these responses a little sad. No it’s not OP’s responsibility. But OP’s neighbour is probably feeling scared and lonely. They may not be allowed to leave hospital without a companion. There may be no family nearby who can help. For the sake of being my brother‘s / sister’s keeper, I hope I’d try to help if I possibly could.

So sad and yet it didn't occur to you to ask OP where she is in country in case you can help.

BoredZelda · 02/10/2026 15:41

summertree1 · 02/10/2026 11:51

You’re not being unreasonable not to take her but don’t be unkind about it. She wouldn’t be reaching out to you if she had someone to take her, it’s quite sad really.

Just send her a polite reply and maybe recommend she checks with the hospital if there is any community support that can help her (in my area there is).

How is any of that OP’s problem?

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 02/10/2026 15:42

Allseeingallknowing · 02/10/2026 15:29

They do, and they’re VERY expensive!

My annual leave days are worth a couple of hundred quid. Why is it ok to ask someone to spend their annual leave to save you money on taxis?

Thebookofcarolagain · 02/10/2026 15:42

MajesticWhine · 02/10/2026 15:11

The word cheeky is coming up a lot. I think it’s more desperate / needy than cheeky. Older people can be quite lonely and isolated and their family dynamics could be difficult. It’s ok for her to ask, and equally ok to say no.

Op has already said she has people visiting her, family and friends. Why isn't one of them giving up thier time or annual leave to take her?
Because it would be rude to inconvenience one of them but not just a neighbour?
One of those visitors can either take her or point her to patient transport/volunteer transport .

Its not ops business to give up her time and money to run around after an acquaintance who already has a network of people who visit.
No way would I expect someone to take AL to take me to hospital. I have taken volunteer transport before, yes I had to pay but its my responsibility not someone else's.

Aiming4Optimistic · 02/10/2026 15:42

Someone who feels able to ask a neighbour to give up 2 days of annual leave and wait around for hours, isn't someone who lacks confidence!
Young cheeky fuckers age and become old cheeky fuckers. The elderly are not all nice, vulnerable people with no options in life. Some of them are still the same entitled people they always were, just older!

BoredZelda · 02/10/2026 15:45

MaidsRoom · 02/10/2026 15:36

Bluntly, yes, and I have done similar things for various people, some of whom were neighbours or acquaintances rather than friends. So have most of my friends and family (in London - not always the world’s friendliest city). It often felt like a burden at the time. But I don’t regret it.

Sometimes people on MN ask “what happened to the village?” when they want help with their children. Well, this is the village. If we all sacrifice a little for our neighbours, then over time life gets a little nicer and friendlier for everyone. If our default instinct is “no, what a cheeky thing to ask” then we can’t complain when we discover we lead atomized lives and barely know anybody in our local community. We also can’t complain if, down the line, we find ourselves needing help for something and nobody offers.

When you make a habit of helping others out, you often find the biggest winner turns out to be you.

You’ve done it for various people. That’s not a village, that’s them using you as a taxi. Can you be 100% confident any one of them would also do for you? In my experience “the village” only seems to be requested when people want something. Nobody puts themselves out as “the village” to randomly offer help.

chattyness · 02/10/2026 15:45

Just say no, don't give any excuse or other reason, no is the reason. Is there a volunteer car scheme in your area ? We have one here but we have to pay £10 for each return journey then get a form from the cash office at the hospital and the car scheme claims used this to claim the rest of it back.

Swipe left for the next trending thread