Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To agree with Andy Burnham that it’s about time the middle classes took their fair share

1000 replies

Morningteacup2 · Yesterday 18:11

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/08/11/burnham-middle-class-areas-must-take-more-hotel-migrants/

Not a huge fan of Labour I must say, but this is well overdue!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
20
Newname26 · Today 15:17

TeaAndALittlePeace · Today 15:16

Do you really think all the arrivals are genuine asylum seekers and none are economic migrants?

Not for a second. I'd return them all ASAP. Straight to Heathrow cheerio

But thats not a popular view

BermudaRhombus · Today 15:17

Windsurf · Today 15:13

It's American democrat boomer slop isn't it? Cookies?

The Guardian reader's favourite meme.

I think you’ve completely missed the point. But you’re not the only one. That’s why we’re in this mess.

Paganpentacle · Today 15:18

GunnelVallquist · Today 15:08

Exactly.

Wake up ffs.

And please, for the love of God, don’t trot out the old ‘we have rapists in this country’

As if we need to importing any more right?

EasternStandard · Today 15:19

BermudaRhombus · Today 15:17

I think you’ve completely missed the point. But you’re not the only one. That’s why we’re in this mess.

What do you think should happen @BermudaRhombus?

suburburban · Today 15:19

PinkBottle75 · Today 12:18

I can't help but feel this is a Labour plant as there are no other posts by this user and they haven't come back to defend their position.

It's Labour once again gauging public opinion.

Last time around white women were instrumental in getting Tony Blair voted in on numerous occasions.

They're testing the water with this to see what the appetite is.

The answer is a resounding NO. We don't want more illegal immigrants in middle class areas or ANY AREAS for that matter.

It feels like an invasion of another race, 99% men, Muslim, from another culture and era of time.

Stop the boats once and for all. Reform have put out a very clear plan and I will vote for them without issue.

Andy Burnham superfically comes across as a nice chap. But he needs to do the hard work and sort these illegal crossings once and for all.

they aren't refugees or asylum seekers. They are economic migrants.

I now wait for the plant to come back and defend their position...

That is my position on this

i wish TB had never started the free movement, it was so much better in the UK before this imo

skill shortage nonsense

Paganpentacle · Today 15:20

Newname26 · Today 15:17

Not for a second. I'd return them all ASAP. Straight to Heathrow cheerio

But thats not a popular view

Its probably more popular than you think- however, people are fearful of speaking openly about this.
And also 'cocks in frocks'
Stating the obvious gets you sacked

suburburban · Today 15:22

BermudaRhombus · Today 15:01

Nor sure who they’re going to direct your attention to once the immigrants have gone.

They’re not going to all go so it’s not really relevant

Hellokitty0 · Today 15:24

BermudaRhombus · Today 15:01

Nor sure who they’re going to direct your attention to once the immigrants have gone.

Slow clap….

This isn’t going to work any more.

smallglassbottle · Today 15:25

DeterminedRat · Today 11:43

Do you genuinely believe that Europe will be like Iran within 20 years? Can you walk through how you see it happening? A coup? A voting majority of Muslims who want to see Sharia law, not all Muslims will want that so the majority of Muslim population would have to be pretty big. How would this massive rise of Muslims happen? Not 200 a time in dingys surely, will they upgrade to cruise ships? Muslims make up about 6% of Europe's population right now, 700million people in Europe aren't Muslim vs 45million who are and not all of those would like to see Europe be like Iran. That's a heck of a lot people they need to make that majority up in 20 years.

20 years ago the Muslim population of Europe was 4%, if they are so desperate to take over why have they done it so slowly so far and why have they suddenly decided that they are going to ramp those efforts up considerably to becoming a majority within the next 20? Was there a big Muslim meeting about it where they all came together and decided they had been slacking so far and they need to get their heads in the game?

So yeah I'd love if you could walk us through this takeover?

Edited

Oh it's not solely about numbers. Numbers are only part of it. We will undoubtedly be in a worse place economically by then. Our population is ageing rapidly. They're apathetic, weak, often stupid and certainly demoralised. Successive governments appear intent on facilitating these people and providing them with somewhere to live, money, legal assistance etc. This is only going in one direction. Don't underestimate the snowball effect and don't forget that their faith is designed to enable the domination of existing religions and social systems within a targeted country. It's a perfect storm.

You can laugh all you want. Get back to me in 20 years, although I doubt this place will still exist by then.

suburburban · Today 15:25

Papyrophile · Today 14:47

Accommodation in single sex tented barracks, without phones or TV, on remote islands, with deportation the usual outcome. It won't take long for word to get around, and back to northern France or the Maghrebb. That will damage the people smugglers' business model faster than anything. Destroy the pull factors.

Yes, maybe on a Scottish island or an oil rig in the North Sea

Shitshowpolitics · Today 15:26

LuckyHazelFox · Today 15:15

Must watch out for the next time somebody's called a racist. I might tag you in so you can explain to them what you've just said here. In fact, somebody's already called this a racist thread.

Feel free to tag me. I'd apply exactly the same standard.

If someone calls a particular comment racist, I'd expect them to be able to explain what was said and why they consider it racist. Likewise, if someone claims there is “blatant hatred of white people”, it's perfectly reasonable to ask them to identify the supposed hatred.

As for somebody calling this a “racist thread”, that's their assessment of the thread as a whole. Ask them what specifically they're referring to and let them explain it.

I'm not sure what contradiction you think you've found here. My position is pretty simple: if you're going to make a serious accusation of racism or racial hatred, you should be able to point to what was actually said and explain why you think it's racist.

GunnelVallquist · Today 15:28

Paganpentacle · Today 15:18

As if we need to importing any more right?

It’s so simple, isn’t it?

GodDamnitDonut · Today 15:29

Hellokitty0 · Today 15:24

Slow clap….

This isn’t going to work any more.

I agree. This kind of argument worked 5 years ago, it has lost its power. What next ? A comparison to 1930s Germany again?

GunnelVallquist · Today 15:30

suburburban · Today 15:19

That is my position on this

i wish TB had never started the free movement, it was so much better in the UK before this imo

skill shortage nonsense

I agree to a certain extend but this is not just down to Blair or a UK only problem or even just down to Merkel.

Sweden had problems way before 2015.

Windsurf · Today 15:31

BermudaRhombus · Today 15:17

I think you’ve completely missed the point. But you’re not the only one. That’s why we’re in this mess.

Ah yes. This is how you described me.

"toothless simpletons"

"Those simpletons have been very easily manipulated and misled. It is very sad to see."

Was there a point other than to reiterate your opinion that we are "toothless simpletons?

PinkBottle75 · Today 15:32

suburburban · Today 15:19

That is my position on this

i wish TB had never started the free movement, it was so much better in the UK before this imo

skill shortage nonsense

I so agree. While I applaud the hard work of all the Eastern European builders who came and have been a happy recipient of it myself, it was the start of the crazy housing market and things went nuts. If there hadn't been these cheap builders maybe property wouldn't have risen so quickly and we'd never have had Kirsty and Phil! Oh the glory days of the 1990s...

BermudaRhombus · Today 15:34

GodDamnitDonut · Today 15:29

I agree. This kind of argument worked 5 years ago, it has lost its power. What next ? A comparison to 1930s Germany again?

Edited

Nobody’s arguing that immigration isn’t a serious issue. But the amount of airtime it gets is both disproportionate and counterproductive. A large section of the public has been gaslit and radicalised into thinking that every problem we’re facing is caused by immigration. If people don’t start realising this then we really are doomed.

LuckyHazelFox · Today 15:35

Shitshowpolitics · Today 15:26

Feel free to tag me. I'd apply exactly the same standard.

If someone calls a particular comment racist, I'd expect them to be able to explain what was said and why they consider it racist. Likewise, if someone claims there is “blatant hatred of white people”, it's perfectly reasonable to ask them to identify the supposed hatred.

As for somebody calling this a “racist thread”, that's their assessment of the thread as a whole. Ask them what specifically they're referring to and let them explain it.

I'm not sure what contradiction you think you've found here. My position is pretty simple: if you're going to make a serious accusation of racism or racial hatred, you should be able to point to what was actually said and explain why you think it's racist.

A very noble idea but given that these threads and similar are littered with the R word, it would take a while to address each accusation. It's set in stone that it's a problem to say I would like there to be less diversity but not when you say you invite more. No wonder people have lost patience with it. This thread has allowed for more open discussion.

BermudaRhombus · Today 15:35

PinkBottle75 · Today 15:32

I so agree. While I applaud the hard work of all the Eastern European builders who came and have been a happy recipient of it myself, it was the start of the crazy housing market and things went nuts. If there hadn't been these cheap builders maybe property wouldn't have risen so quickly and we'd never have had Kirsty and Phil! Oh the glory days of the 1990s...

And these two posts just demonstrate my point.

the80sweregreat · Today 15:35

Newname
It is a popular view point with my family and friends and people I know as acquaintances and so on.
I overheard a conversation in a coffee shop with someone saying that we needed Trump to run the UK and people were nodding. People are tired of it all and we know that not all of them are genuine and it’s putting a strain on everything. I didn’t used to think like this, but something has gone wrong with controlled immigration of people we need to work and pay their way and not enough acting on the ones we don’t in my own opinion.
Why can’t they go through the proper channels ? They have money to give over to gangs , why not for visas or whatever you need to live somewhere else ? Why arn’t they vetted first, asked about their finances and so on as I would be if I fancied living elsewhere!
I can’t believe they haven’t got a grip on the boats and people are dying and risking their lives and the authorities do nothing about it and then it’s a problem of where they can live and we have enough homeless people of our own.
I haven’t got the answers , but it feels like a crisis that nobody is really addressing and the French take our millions and don’t seem to do much ( because they don’t want them either I guess)
Something has gone really wrong , but politicians won’t be suffering only lecturing people about living together as a happy community and how racist we are for feeling a bit worried about the future of our own people
I know I’ll be flamed or called racist, but seeing so many on the boats is concerning and many people don’t feel listened to.

ChattyKnickers · Today 15:35

GunnelVallquist · Today 14:45

And frankly, on a site that is predominantly female, it’s quite disturbing to see so many posters argue for uncontrolled immigration from countries where women aren’t exactly valued.

There's a "white man bad too" kinds of response

LuckyHazelFox · Today 15:36

BermudaRhombus · Today 15:34

Nobody’s arguing that immigration isn’t a serious issue. But the amount of airtime it gets is both disproportionate and counterproductive. A large section of the public has been gaslit and radicalised into thinking that every problem we’re facing is caused by immigration. If people don’t start realising this then we really are doomed.

People will talk about it as much as they want.

EasternStandard · Today 15:37

BermudaRhombus · Today 15:34

Nobody’s arguing that immigration isn’t a serious issue. But the amount of airtime it gets is both disproportionate and counterproductive. A large section of the public has been gaslit and radicalised into thinking that every problem we’re facing is caused by immigration. If people don’t start realising this then we really are doomed.

It gets airtime because the images are striking and immediate, and it’s a long lasting issue. It’s also very much not just the U.K., countries in the EU are seeing similar with the backlash.

BermudaRhombus · Today 15:37

LuckyHazelFox · Today 15:36

People will talk about it as much as they want.

Clearly! It’s all you seem to talk about (that and ‘lefties’)

LuckyHazelFox · Today 15:37

ChattyKnickers · Today 15:35

There's a "white man bad too" kinds of response

White man bad, white man knuckle dragging flag shagger. These seriously are the words coming from supposedly intelligent women.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.