Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to accept my parents' £1m+ gift when my sister gets nothing

776 replies

ForEagerRobin · 23/06/2026 21:00

My parents have recently told me they want to gift me assets worth just over £1m while they're still alive. It's a mixture of investments, funds and cash.

The problem is they don't intend to give my sister anything.

My sister is absolutely furious and says I should refuse the money unless they split everything equally between us.
For context, we had a very happy childhood. Our parents were loving, supportive and provided us with every opportunity. There was no obvious favouritism.

As adults, however, our relationships with them have been very different. I see them every week, help them with shopping, appointments, paperwork and generally make sure they're OK. They're in their late 70s and increasingly need support.

My sister has never really made much effort. She can go months without seeing them. A recent example was when they needed a lift to the airport. She was free and lived closest but simply couldn't be bothered. Another relative ended up taking them.

My parents are very hurt by this and have told me repeatedly that their decision is based on years of feeling ignored by her.
The thing is, I don't actually feel responsible for their decision. It's their money. They're mentally capable, fully understand what they're doing and have made their views clear.

My sister says that may be true, but by accepting the money I'm endorsing their behaviour and choosing money over my relationship with her.

My response was that turning down £1m doesn't magically mean she gets it. It simply means none of us do.

She says a decent sister would refuse it on principle.

DH thinks that's easy to say when she's asking me to sacrifice something that could transform our children's futures.

So AIBU for thinking this isn't my decision to make, and that refusing the money out of "solidarity" would be completely irrational and stupid.

I care for my sister but she has thrown away her life by herself. We came from very good backgrounds with potential, she chose to waste that. I am now in my 40s, I live a very modest life, DH is an engineer, I work for civil service I’ve been in the civil service for almost 20 years so I have worked my way up. I am not a luxury type of person, DH and I share a car, it’s over 10 years old we bought it brand new XC90 it does the job very well, our children are at private school but it’s not eton it’s very affordable and does the job too. They’re doing very well at school, we go on 3 holidays a year, we invest for them each year we save from them a certain amount tax free and my parents top that for them. They do the same for my sisters children. My sister has no bothered to do anything for her children. All the savings they have is from our parents which is quite sad. What kind of parent has children when they can’t save for their futures. She has a new car all the time, lives wayy above her means yet nothing to show for it just new things all the time. Conspicuous consumption. She is pushing 50 and has wasted her potential now wants to cry to me. We are both oxbridge educated, went to very good private schools, the world was our oyster.

OP posts:
KitchenColourandstyle · 25/06/2026 19:17

ForEagerRobin · 25/06/2026 19:08

I think we’re probably just using different definitions of “achievement” here.
I fully accept Cambridge & Oxford are academically selective, and I met the requirements and was offered a place, just like everyone else who gets in does.

What I’m saying is more about how it felt for me personally at the end of the day this was MY experience, and how it was viewed in my own family. It wasn’t treated as something extraordinary or defining it was simply the next step, and then you moved on with life. I did not achieve anything special I was no where near the top of my cohort.

I’m not trying to diminish Cambridge/Oxford or the admissions process. I can only speak to my own experience of it, which didn’t feel like some exceptional personal milestone, even if others would see it that way.

Both things can be true at once: they can be a highly selective institutions, and still not feel like a life-defining achievement to the individual going through.

Are you still not seeing that your sister might find this 'it's just what we do' pressure intolerable? Have her children all made it to Oxford/Cambridge or have they 'let the side down' and 'just' gone to elsewhere? When your children are uni age if they can't get in or don't want to go will be a OK or will they feel they have to make the grade, become the 5th generation of Oxbridge robins.

geminicancerean · 25/06/2026 19:26

Being in your family sounds fucking exhausting OP. I’m with delinquent sis.

SixtySomething · 25/06/2026 19:31

Yetanotherone12 · 25/06/2026 17:54

This is the issue though.

getting into Cambridge automatically makes you a “standout” “academic” student.

Cambridge does not accept “ordinary”. It’s a top university, which only takes the best of the best from around the world.

to get into Cambridge you are pretty much defined as an overachiever. As in you’ve achieved way more than most of the population. 16% of applicants are accepted, and less than 0.01% of the Uk population has a maths degree from Cambridge.

it’s an “exceptionally rare” academic achievement according to google.

so that’s hardly an “ordinary” achievement is it? So why are you insisting it is?

your “oh I just applied and got in” rhetoric does not ring true.

Yes, unfortunately, OP, there’s no way out of this.

The other day I heard about Cambridge Maths degrees that you can’t take a gap year because your brain loses its power during the year.
I don’t know whether or not that’s true.

What I do know is no one gets into Cambridge or Oxford by ‘satisfying the conditions.’ You have to be very highly motivated.

The only exception would be if you come from a family of brilliant mathematicians where you learned the subject with your cereal.

What is certain is that, if your story is true, there is a massive elephant in the room eg ‘My father was the Regius Professor of Mathematics at Cambridge.

Fess up now, what was it about you and your circumstances that made it an ordinary thing to roll into Cambridge?

How did you perform in the interview?
Were you nervous?
Did you get coaching for the interview?

ForEagerRobin · 25/06/2026 19:41

KitchenColourandstyle · 25/06/2026 19:17

Are you still not seeing that your sister might find this 'it's just what we do' pressure intolerable? Have her children all made it to Oxford/Cambridge or have they 'let the side down' and 'just' gone to elsewhere? When your children are uni age if they can't get in or don't want to go will be a OK or will they feel they have to make the grade, become the 5th generation of Oxbridge robins.

I haven’t said the pressure wasn’t sometimes difficult, and I’ve always acknowledged that my sister is entitled to her own feelings and experience.

From conversations growing up, she was genuinely excited about going to university. She was older than me, and I remember how much she was looking forward to that next stage. To this day, she still speaks fondly of her time there. I may simply have misunderstood her earlier comment about just “going and enjoying it,” as I took it in the context of her describing it as a very positive period in her early adulthood.

As for my own children, there is no expectation for them to go to university. They are both very creative. One has already won several design awards and is interested in pursuing something in the arts. That may well change as they get older, but if they do choose to go down that route, there are specialist art schools that would suit them far better than a traditional academic path, and we would fully support that.

They are still very young, and by the time they reach that stage, circumstances within our family may also be very different ie my parents might not be here. Unless they live past 100 and I don’t imagine my father when he is in his 90s sitting down after tutor sessions with my children to check their knowledge or quizzing them for university interview or much less caring what they decide to do.

In any case, there is no pressure placed on them from us. None of the other grandchildren who are university age have been pushed in the way we may have been, and I don’t anticipate that changing.

Ultimately, they are our children, and DH and I will support them in whatever direction they choose to take.

OP posts:
Oliveoy · 25/06/2026 19:47

SerenaCat93 · 25/06/2026 17:57

Because you're engaging in emotional blackmail after I didn't change my mind because you wanted me to. I explained the outcome of not saving for children's futures with very detailed explanations on the difference between my peers who got a bit of a helping hand to get going and didn't. You think that's irrelevant because if you make a child wonderful enough they can do it all on their own. No they can't. I've explained why they can't to you and you wheeled out the emotional blackmail instead of just either leaving it or admitting I have a point.

I am literally seeing the differences daily in my colleagues and friends. It's not imagined. It's true. If you've decided that's not important to you and the here and now is all that matters, fine. Just own it. You don't need to keep posting more and more emotionally charged reasons you don't save, when you have the means to, to convince me I'm wrong. This is my opinion, formed on seeing evidence everyday. You don't like it because you think your way is better and for some reason your reaction to that is try guilting me into saying sorry you're totally right what I've seen doesn't matter anymore. You seem desperate for me to either change my mind or approve of your parenting decisions which is weird because I'm a stranger to you so why do you care so much?

I'm telling you facts. Facts don't change because they upset people. Your daughter will be at a disadvantage of you don't save for her future, the fact that you live what sounds to me like a comfortable middle class lifestyle and still choose not to slice 20 quid a month off something really blows my mind. It honestly shocks me and I'll never agree with it, knowing what the end result of that decision is. Even the most brilliant entrepreneur in the world can't start a business without any money to get going. Starting an adult life is the same.

You won't change my mind so stop trying. It's awful that your daughter is ill, but you want her to have a good future as I do because I want that for every child. I hope it comes to fruition I really do, I just don't think you're making the right choice by choosing not to save for it.

It's unbelievable that you think it's fine to keep posting callous replies to me under the guise of facts but when I reply to you with my facts, I'm apparently being desperate and emotionally blackmailing. What are YOU getting out of this exchange with a stranger other than revelling in criticising them? Why are you so desperate for me to agree that actually yes I do have spare money to save?

A parent's worth isn't determined by an ISA and I'm doing the opposite of disadvantaging my DD. I won't be engaging with you further.

ForEagerRobin · 25/06/2026 20:23

SixtySomething · 25/06/2026 19:31

Yes, unfortunately, OP, there’s no way out of this.

The other day I heard about Cambridge Maths degrees that you can’t take a gap year because your brain loses its power during the year.
I don’t know whether or not that’s true.

What I do know is no one gets into Cambridge or Oxford by ‘satisfying the conditions.’ You have to be very highly motivated.

The only exception would be if you come from a family of brilliant mathematicians where you learned the subject with your cereal.

What is certain is that, if your story is true, there is a massive elephant in the room eg ‘My father was the Regius Professor of Mathematics at Cambridge.

Fess up now, what was it about you and your circumstances that made it an ordinary thing to roll into Cambridge?

How did you perform in the interview?
Were you nervous?
Did you get coaching for the interview?

The “elephant in the room”

My grandfather was a mathematician and held professorships at a few different universities during his career, though not at Oxford or Cambridge.

I did mention him in my interview, as you would naturally talk about family influences and interests, but I like to think I ultimately assessed on my own application and meeting the entry requirements but I could very well be wrong.

It doesn’t really matter. No one really cares, it’s been a long time since I was at university. Most people I grew up with went to university it wasn’t seen as this grand achievement.

OP posts:
SerenaCat93 · 25/06/2026 20:25

Oliveoy · 25/06/2026 19:47

It's unbelievable that you think it's fine to keep posting callous replies to me under the guise of facts but when I reply to you with my facts, I'm apparently being desperate and emotionally blackmailing. What are YOU getting out of this exchange with a stranger other than revelling in criticising them? Why are you so desperate for me to agree that actually yes I do have spare money to save?

A parent's worth isn't determined by an ISA and I'm doing the opposite of disadvantaging my DD. I won't be engaging with you further.

I don't care if you disagree. I literally don't care about your opinion of me either. I think you're wrong. That's it.

I'm not getting anything out of this, I'm trying to educate you and other parents about the reality of not saving for your children's future because many parents think it will be just fine. It won't. And their kids deserve better.

You're the one that keeps plugging away at this with more and more emotionally supercharged posts. I've been telling you to drop it ALL DAY because I don't care if you agree and I won't change my mind and you're only upsetting yourself yet you just keep throwing yourself at the wall. It's bizarre.

VickyEadie · 25/06/2026 21:36

ForEagerRobin · 25/06/2026 20:23

The “elephant in the room”

My grandfather was a mathematician and held professorships at a few different universities during his career, though not at Oxford or Cambridge.

I did mention him in my interview, as you would naturally talk about family influences and interests, but I like to think I ultimately assessed on my own application and meeting the entry requirements but I could very well be wrong.

It doesn’t really matter. No one really cares, it’s been a long time since I was at university. Most people I grew up with went to university it wasn’t seen as this grand achievement.

I went to university as the first person not only in my whole family, but the first person in the mining village in which I lived. My parents never had enough money to buy a home and we lived in poverty - as a result of the struggle to bring up a family in such circumstances, my mother was hospitalised with severe depression when I was 15.

I was "gifted" nothing because they had nothing to "gift" - apart from support for education as a way to better myself.

I also received the gift of knowing how privileged I was to get an education (state schools, obviously) AND that those whose education was bought for them would deem it "normal" - I met such people at Cambridge, whose families passed down their privilege to people who would never understand quite how overprivileged they were.

randomnamegenerated · 25/06/2026 21:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

AdjectiveColourNoun · 25/06/2026 21:44

My goodness this thread is going on and on! OP you have written about 150 posts, some of them very lengthy. Maybe you should invest some of that million quid into therapy as you seem to like talking and introspection.

AdjectiveColourNoun · 25/06/2026 21:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Flamingojune · 25/06/2026 21:56

ForEagerRobin · 25/06/2026 19:41

I haven’t said the pressure wasn’t sometimes difficult, and I’ve always acknowledged that my sister is entitled to her own feelings and experience.

From conversations growing up, she was genuinely excited about going to university. She was older than me, and I remember how much she was looking forward to that next stage. To this day, she still speaks fondly of her time there. I may simply have misunderstood her earlier comment about just “going and enjoying it,” as I took it in the context of her describing it as a very positive period in her early adulthood.

As for my own children, there is no expectation for them to go to university. They are both very creative. One has already won several design awards and is interested in pursuing something in the arts. That may well change as they get older, but if they do choose to go down that route, there are specialist art schools that would suit them far better than a traditional academic path, and we would fully support that.

They are still very young, and by the time they reach that stage, circumstances within our family may also be very different ie my parents might not be here. Unless they live past 100 and I don’t imagine my father when he is in his 90s sitting down after tutor sessions with my children to check their knowledge or quizzing them for university interview or much less caring what they decide to do.

In any case, there is no pressure placed on them from us. None of the other grandchildren who are university age have been pushed in the way we may have been, and I don’t anticipate that changing.

Ultimately, they are our children, and DH and I will support them in whatever direction they choose to take.

Even if they choose a life like your feckless sister?

Yetanotherone12 · 25/06/2026 22:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

University maybe not- but Oxford or Cambridge is not a “standard trajectory” for the vast majority. It is a fairly major achievement even it is the family norm to attend uni.

you don’t just apply and get in if you’re an “ordinary” candidate. You need stellar results and something to make you stand out to make the 16% of applicants that get a place.

AdjectiveColourNoun · 25/06/2026 22:20

I’m Oxbridge educated and can appreciate OP’s mindset that it feels not particularly exceptional. If you come from that MC background and surrounded by peers for whom 3 A grades were normal, it’s kind of just expected. It was never celebrated by my family. It’s only in later years where I’ve worked and mixed with a bigger range of people that it’s been seen as anything exceptional or impressive.

I wouldn’t ever think private schools and three holidays and significant savings could ever be seen as modest or average though 🤣🤣

AutumnLover1990 · 25/06/2026 22:22

Shitty parents. What a vile thing to do.

randomnamegenerated · 25/06/2026 23:19

Yetanotherone12 · 25/06/2026 22:07

University maybe not- but Oxford or Cambridge is not a “standard trajectory” for the vast majority. It is a fairly major achievement even it is the family norm to attend uni.

you don’t just apply and get in if you’re an “ordinary” candidate. You need stellar results and something to make you stand out to make the 16% of applicants that get a place.

Sorry, not sure what I said that got me deleted.

I was just responding to the OP's claim that university wasn't seen as a grand achievement. I agree that it's a fairly major achievement. I don't know about standing out - in my experience with my own kids, they did basically just apply, although the school sort of determined that they should. The only thing that really made one who ended up there stand out was a genuine passion for the subject. The other, who didn't, had equally good marks and probably better extracurriculars, but wasn't all that fussed about the subject (or going there).

If the OP went there in around 2000, the acceptance rate would have been a bit higher than it is now, partly because there would have been fewer foreign students, but not hugely so.

randomnamegenerated · 25/06/2026 23:22

Adding that my DCs school gets roughly 25 Oxbridge offers a year on average for 6th form leavers.

SixtySomething · 25/06/2026 23:51

randomnamegenerated · 25/06/2026 23:22

Adding that my DCs school gets roughly 25 Oxbridge offers a year on average for 6th form leavers.

I think you need to to specify exactly what sort of school this is and about how many in the sixth form.

I think one of my children’s schools got that number in but it was very highly selective in the first place and you had to be pretty driven to attend.

randomnamegenerated · 25/06/2026 23:56

SixtySomething · 25/06/2026 23:51

I think you need to to specify exactly what sort of school this is and about how many in the sixth form.

I think one of my children’s schools got that number in but it was very highly selective in the first place and you had to be pretty driven to attend.

Around 200 in upper sixth, and, yes, it's academically selective, but not (as the OP is fond of saying) Eton. I was only making the point that in certain circumstances, an Oxbridge place isn't incredibly unusual.

SixtySomething · 26/06/2026 00:05

randomnamegenerated · 25/06/2026 23:56

Around 200 in upper sixth, and, yes, it's academically selective, but not (as the OP is fond of saying) Eton. I was only making the point that in certain circumstances, an Oxbridge place isn't incredibly unusual.

Sorry but is the school private or grammar school?

randomnamegenerated · 26/06/2026 00:05

SixtySomething · 26/06/2026 00:05

Sorry but is the school private or grammar school?

Private

CoffeeAndCats3 · 26/06/2026 00:11

I think this is a fake post.
Bored, OP?

SixtySomething · 26/06/2026 00:28

randomnamegenerated · 26/06/2026 00:05

Private

Yes, I agree that some schools send a lot of students to Oxbridge but those type of schools don’t normally send students who don’t know how to use full stops.
Did you see the post where I asked OP whether her grandfather was a professor and she confirmed that indeed he was! 🤣
As pp has commented, her writing in the 2nd part of this thread has pulled its socks up….
I think one must be sceptical. Still it’s been an interesting discussion and unsurprising that OP is flagging.
Well done OP for a ripping good yarn. 🏅You would have convinced me if you had trotted out a few impressive maths formulae.

randomnamegenerated · 26/06/2026 00:39

SixtySomething · 26/06/2026 00:28

Yes, I agree that some schools send a lot of students to Oxbridge but those type of schools don’t normally send students who don’t know how to use full stops.
Did you see the post where I asked OP whether her grandfather was a professor and she confirmed that indeed he was! 🤣
As pp has commented, her writing in the 2nd part of this thread has pulled its socks up….
I think one must be sceptical. Still it’s been an interesting discussion and unsurprising that OP is flagging.
Well done OP for a ripping good yarn. 🏅You would have convinced me if you had trotted out a few impressive maths formulae.

I agree with your first point, and yes, I did see that.

I was the pp who pointed that out, but it got me deleted - not sure why.

Anyway, @ForEagerRobin , good luck. It's been some prime entertainment on a very hot week when I've been at home way more than usual!

JMSA · 26/06/2026 01:45

Awful behaviour.
You obviously take after your parents, and I hope you don’t bring up your own children to believe that love is conditional and built on a system of favours/rewards.