Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anybody else dislike Pride?

463 replies

coulditbeme2323 · Today 13:12

Does anybody else dislike Pride?

We have one in our town for the second year running, and it's just really off.

Now before I get the "don't be homophobic comments" I am very much live and let live.

It's just that it can be very adult in the middle of the day.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
MistressoftheDarkSide · Today 18:54

GeneralPeter · Today 18:41

@MistressoftheDarkSide
We seem to have lost perspective and the middle ground

This is an interesting point. I think there’s a different middle ground that we’ve lost sight of.

For a very long time, the middle ground has been a sort of soft-identitarian politeness, that seems to centre around strong principles that get shaded to make sure no virtuous group is too upset.

eg Of course we oppose criminalizing political speech, until it’s Farage and he might be read as being mean to minorities. Public bondage gear is fine, becuase the gays like it. Of course cutting school is bad an home-schooling suspect, except when it’s travellers, then it’s bad form to mention it. Naturally we oppose carried knives other than Sikh knives. Naturally we abhor misogyny but not if it’s suggested the misogynists are foreign, then we must all not notice. Women’s rights are great, save when if it means saying no to a particular group of men. Etc etc etc.

There is another middle ground that at least attempts to be much more principled and neutral. What are our principles? What’s permitted and not? Then if it’s good it’s good for everyone, and if it’s not then it’s not for anyone, and we navigate different claims by what the facts support.

I think that’s a much healthier middle ground in the long term.

Edited

Perhaps you could explain your preferred middle ground principles?

For me, it's mainly about not looking to persecute or punish a whole group of people for the individual "crimes" committed by one of their cohort. Which is what is being suggested with the rise of nationalism and populism being pushed at the moment. Throw in religious intolerance and calls to cultural conformity and we're repeating history.

Positid · Today 18:59

ClaudiaWankleman · Today 18:52

You don’t have to play the victim. You posted and I responded saying you were wrong. As it turns out, you don’t have any experience and are repeating some inaccuracies that were posted elsewhere in the thread.

Play the victim? Goodness that’s unpleasant. I want everyone to enjoy Pride and I still feel there’s a need for it. I don’t know what end of the stick you have got but I suggest there are better targets for your ire.

Namechangefordaughterevasion · Today 19:02

I live in Brighton. I love the Pride parade - a carnival of inclusiveness, but apart from that it's hell. For the entire weekend it's illegal for shops/bars to sell alcohol in glass containers because violence is 100% expected. The station is like a gulag with a massive police presence and an enforced one way system. The filth and litter in the streets is indescribable.

I time my holidays around Pride now. Brighton is always alternative and never squeaky clean or vanilla which for me is part of the appeal but Pride weekend is an absolute race to the bottom.

GeneralPeter · Today 19:09

MistressoftheDarkSide · Today 18:54

Perhaps you could explain your preferred middle ground principles?

For me, it's mainly about not looking to persecute or punish a whole group of people for the individual "crimes" committed by one of their cohort. Which is what is being suggested with the rise of nationalism and populism being pushed at the moment. Throw in religious intolerance and calls to cultural conformity and we're repeating history.

Framed like that, I agree.

The right reason to remove the kirpan exemption is not about whether to ‘punish’ Sikhs or not. It’s: how do we balance liberty with identity with safety. If it’s sometimes reasonable to carry a knife for identity or religious reasons then let us all have access to that claim. If not, then not, even if Sikhs are inconvenienced. Do we want want school exemption to be easy, hard, or impossible. Why and when? Then if it turns out travellers have it right, great. We can loosen up. If not, then tough luck travellers.

If anti-gay attitudes are a cause for condemnation then they are whether its Muslims or Mormons or Millwall. If freedom
of belief is more important then likewise.

If we don’t Believe Women, let’s not believe them across the board. Or let’s.

If only the oppressed group gets to define its own oppression then that means Jews too. If it’s a matter for public debate and policy calibration then we stop taking the knee.

etc etc etc.

ClaudiaWankleman · Today 19:11

Positid · Today 18:59

Play the victim? Goodness that’s unpleasant. I want everyone to enjoy Pride and I still feel there’s a need for it. I don’t know what end of the stick you have got but I suggest there are better targets for your ire.

When someone points out the inaccuracies in what you’ve posted and you respond with a disingenuous ‘I don’t understand what I’ve done to deserve this response’ that’s quite unpleasant behaviour actually.

LapisBlue · Today 19:14

Pride in Brighton (and elsewhere, it seems) was, back in the day about celebrating the right to be gay, lesbian or bisexual. It was an all-round fabulous event.

I've been here 28 years. I know.

And now Pride centres on trans, trans, and more trans. Same-sex attraction is bigoted. Men who claim to be women dominate. Men in nappies walk with men dressed as animals. Men with masks and sunglasses dressed entirely in black carry "anti Terf" banners, threatening violence, rape and death threats to women.

Lesbian groups I know have been banned from the event due to their "hateful" stance. I kid you not.

So-called "transmen" (women) hobble along with walking sticks or get pushed along in wheelchairs, damaged too early through osteoporosis caused by testosterone being pumped though their bodies.

Gay people simply aren't there anymore.

The whole thing is horrible. Utterly horrible.

ERthree · Today 19:16

MrsMcGarry · Today 14:01

So basically other people are allowed to live their lives how they want, as long as they conform to your ideas of what is appropriate for children to see.

And do you think it is ok for children to see men with their arses hanging out their jeans, people in bondage gear recreating sex scenes? Surely only people with very warped minds would think it is ok?

GeneralPeter · Today 19:23

MrsMcGarry · Today 14:01

So basically other people are allowed to live their lives how they want, as long as they conform to your ideas of what is appropriate for children to see.

As a liberal, I think this is a superb principle.

Let adults live their lives how they want, with maximal freedom consistent with the legitimate rights and interests of others.

Adults to debate (in fora like this) where those boundaries lie.

The rights and interests of children to be privileged in this framework, because they aren't yet adults, are vulnerable in various ways, and can't fully advocate for themselves.

If this is your platform I think a lot of people can get behind it.

LapisBlue · Today 19:28

And in Brighton, it's also crammed full of "be kind" straight students - hundreds of them - shouting about inclusion for trans people, accepting no debate and branding people nazis. Gay people are nowhere.

Even the Brighton Gay Men's Chorus's parade float is covered in trans flags.

Everywhere - men with fetishes.

Oh yes - these students are covered with glitter and falling over pissed.

I wonder what the founders of Pride think about it all.

Finally, Google Stephen Ireland Pride in Surrey. Just the tip of the iceberg.thede

nolongersurprised · Today 19:29

I agree, OP. Watching (mainly) men getting to parade their fetishes in public is tedious now.

Maray1967 · Today 19:31

What the bloody hell have I just seen? A child right next to a group of blokes in fetish gear?

And presumably her parents think this is great?

SapphOhNo · Today 19:57

LapisBlue · Today 19:14

Pride in Brighton (and elsewhere, it seems) was, back in the day about celebrating the right to be gay, lesbian or bisexual. It was an all-round fabulous event.

I've been here 28 years. I know.

And now Pride centres on trans, trans, and more trans. Same-sex attraction is bigoted. Men who claim to be women dominate. Men in nappies walk with men dressed as animals. Men with masks and sunglasses dressed entirely in black carry "anti Terf" banners, threatening violence, rape and death threats to women.

Lesbian groups I know have been banned from the event due to their "hateful" stance. I kid you not.

So-called "transmen" (women) hobble along with walking sticks or get pushed along in wheelchairs, damaged too early through osteoporosis caused by testosterone being pumped though their bodies.

Gay people simply aren't there anymore.

The whole thing is horrible. Utterly horrible.

Edited

Which prides do you go to? This is wholly untrue and I've been to many.

DilemmaDelilah · Today 20:02

Actually I think it's a bit much. It's not about love - it's all about sex, and quite frankly I'd rather not either be subjected to that myself or have my children subjected to it.

I don't care if a person is straight, gay, bi, trans or whatever, it is their own personal business not mine, and that is how it should stay.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page