Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be getting irate at friends with adult DC who do not work?

676 replies

goldenteapot · 17/03/2026 09:39

My DC are in their mid-late 20s and all in work - but are the exception among family and friends. They have around 12 cousins - none of whom have ever worked in so much as a local pub or shop, and all live in their parents' naice houses gaming all day. Lots have one or two degrees, so are not stupid by any means! I think statistically about 50% of young adults of this age that are not working - but among my family and friends it's very much higher.

It's a similar story with friends: every adult child is depressed or anxious and/or autistic so cannot work. The assumption seems to be that the jobs market is too difficult and their children can't cope. Conversation when we meet is all about how frustrated everyone is because they can't get their DC to work or do anything around the house.

I just want to shake them all! They are providing no tough love or reasons that these children will ever work and live independently.

AIBU to be losing my patience with everyone, or am I a bit of a bitch and working life really is too tough these days for young people?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
ObelixtheGaul · 21/03/2026 11:56

leftyberefty · 21/03/2026 10:30

If you earn even minimum wage you earn double my total income from benefits LoyalMember. My parents have to pay most of my bills so I'm able to afford food and the medications I can't get on the NHS. I don't think people in minimum wage jobs realise how lucky they are compared to many disabled people who get far less despite having costs that are far higher, and have no prospect for ever changing this.

And what kind of job is equivalent in skill and effort levels to sitting in a pub for 3 hours once every 2 to 4 weeks and lifting a drink to your mouth every so often? One that would let you call in sick at short notice 50% of the time or give you 6 weeks off every three months for operations and all the post operative treatments needed in the immediate aftermath?

All bar one of my disabled friends (who had serious schizophrenia from a young age and was in and out of psychiatric hospitals) worked our whole lives too until it became impossible - our employers either told us we couldn't meet the requirements of the jobs we were doing anymore or the DWP assessed us as being unable to work due to it being dangerous for us or others or just completely unrealistic (they don't do this unless it's pretty obvious you would be a liability in the work place and need more time off than any employer would accept).

Also, I'd add that you don't undergo a selection process to have a pint. Disabled people who are capable of working often never get past the interview stage. Doesn't matter that there are laws against discrimination, employers don't have to state why they didn't hire you, and you can't prove it was because your medical history put them off, or they aren't willing to make reasonable adjustments.

So many people get stuck in a depressing cycle of being written off for the disability everyone keeps being told isn't a viable reason for not working. It's a crap situation all round.

ruethewhirl · 21/03/2026 12:35

LoyalMember · 21/03/2026 11:45

I am right, and they're not the only ones I know. It's endemic in the whole country, and bickering about it on Mumsnet's hardly going to change anything, I'll leave things now.

Yes, I think that's a good idea, given that you seem to just want people to mindlessly agree with you. I just hope you never find yourself in a situation where you're reliant on benefits and others make the sort of assumptions you've been making on this thread.

thankgoodnessforpuppies · 21/03/2026 21:26

XenoBitch · 21/03/2026 10:46

Ok, so...

sitting and having a drink at home = unfit and incapacitated
sitting and having a drink in a pub = swinging the lead and needs to get a job

How does that make sense? I have seen people go to the pub with carers/PAs. Are they taking the piss too?

Are disabled people not allowed to leave the house and do anything nice, lest they get accused of being a fraud?

It doesn't make sense.

Someone who is gaming may be mentally escaping for a bit. Mental incapacity is just as valid as physical incapacity. I suspect the poster you are replying to is the type to confront people parking in disabled spaces because they have an invisible disability and it's not obvious.

Going to the pub and gaming doesn't rule out serious disability.

thankgoodnessforpuppies · 21/03/2026 21:29

LoyalMember · 21/03/2026 10:43

Not as unfit and incapacitated as they claim, clearly, though.

"You did something you might have enjoyed a bit. How dare you! You are clearly able to work!" I don't think you really understand disability.

Is it only acceptable for people on benefits to sit at home staring at their navel feeling miserable all day?

thankgoodnessforpuppies · 21/03/2026 21:33

ObelixtheGaul · 21/03/2026 11:56

Also, I'd add that you don't undergo a selection process to have a pint. Disabled people who are capable of working often never get past the interview stage. Doesn't matter that there are laws against discrimination, employers don't have to state why they didn't hire you, and you can't prove it was because your medical history put them off, or they aren't willing to make reasonable adjustments.

So many people get stuck in a depressing cycle of being written off for the disability everyone keeps being told isn't a viable reason for not working. It's a crap situation all round.

I know someone who is now doing a lot better after significant disability and wanting to get back into work. There is a significant gap in the work history. It's so hard for them to get a job with that. Having been disabled becomes a disability itself when trying to get work.

1000StrawberryLollies · 21/03/2026 21:39

goldenteapot · 17/03/2026 10:01

I am glad, but they really worked for it. One was told she was 'working too much' (at a shop) by her tutors over A-Levels and it really threw her - but I encouraged her to continue: those skills were just as important IMO.

Why did it throw her? We encouraged ds to stop doing his weekend job once he started Year 13. He'd earned quite a lot of money by that point and we all agreed he should concentrate on his studies and also leave a little time for leisure. He's no shirker, barely ever spends any money or asks us for anything, and he's got the rest of his life to work. He has an offer from a top uni and needs to get his grades- that's a lot more important to him and us than working in a pub every weekend.

XenoBitch · 21/03/2026 21:57

thankgoodnessforpuppies · 21/03/2026 21:26

It doesn't make sense.

Someone who is gaming may be mentally escaping for a bit. Mental incapacity is just as valid as physical incapacity. I suspect the poster you are replying to is the type to confront people parking in disabled spaces because they have an invisible disability and it's not obvious.

Going to the pub and gaming doesn't rule out serious disability.

Yup, there was a post on a thread a while back where someone said that if someone can attend a day centre then they should be made to get a job... bearing in mind that day centres tend to be for people with learning disabilities and dementia.

It made me laugh that someone upthread suggested that gaming be banned. DM games and she is not far off 70. Some ND folks use gaming to self regulate. It is their safe thing to do.

I emptied my kitchen bin today. I guess that means I should be applying to work on the council emptying bins 🙄

XenoBitch · 21/03/2026 22:01

thankgoodnessforpuppies · 21/03/2026 21:33

I know someone who is now doing a lot better after significant disability and wanting to get back into work. There is a significant gap in the work history. It's so hard for them to get a job with that. Having been disabled becomes a disability itself when trying to get work.

I know someone who was reassessed and declared fit to work... after 30 years out the workforce. The job centre was trying to make him apply for care work. He has schizophrenia and can not even look after himself.
Guess what... the stress of it all made him relapse and now he is not fit for work again.

No way would any employer look at his CV and give him a chance. He had nothing on it!

thankgoodnessforpuppies · 21/03/2026 22:27

XenoBitch · 21/03/2026 22:01

I know someone who was reassessed and declared fit to work... after 30 years out the workforce. The job centre was trying to make him apply for care work. He has schizophrenia and can not even look after himself.
Guess what... the stress of it all made him relapse and now he is not fit for work again.

No way would any employer look at his CV and give him a chance. He had nothing on it!

30 years is a long time out. The person I know has only been out ten years, which is still a lot, but they did have a good work history before they became disabled. I'm sure there is someone out there willing to give them a go and a hand up, just have to find them.

XenoBitch · 21/03/2026 22:31

thankgoodnessforpuppies · 21/03/2026 22:27

30 years is a long time out. The person I know has only been out ten years, which is still a lot, but they did have a good work history before they became disabled. I'm sure there is someone out there willing to give them a go and a hand up, just have to find them.

Yes it is, but he spent a lot of his life in and out of hospital.

The trouble is, no one wants to take the chance on someone with such a massive gap in their work history. He will never be someone's first choice to employ. He is also late 50s, so the age thing is a factor too.

ThatFairy · 22/03/2026 00:34

I'm 36, and apart from a couple of months in 2020 when I had child care, I haven't worked for 17 years. I have delayed sleep phase disorder, it means my circadian rhythm is opposite to normal people- I can sleep well in the day time but cannot fall asleep at night without sleeping pills, which I would not get consistently from NHS. I had no support from my son's father and not consistent support from family. Obviously I couldn't leave my child at home alone all night when he was younger.

Then in 2020 I developed schizophrenia and just was in no state to hold down a job. Another barrier to work was the state of my teeth. I wasn't raised to brush my teeth, it just wasn't a thing, and so even though I cleaned them daily as an adult the damage was done, the enamel was wrecked, and they just continued to deteriorate as I got older even though I spent a lot of time in the dentist chair. I've needed implants for several years.

My teeth are in such a state I can't bring myself to talk to people other than my family, and I can't imagine going for job interviews and associating with coworkers like this. It causes me debilitaing social anxiety.

Thankfully my family are now taking a loan for me to get implants and I will be starting the treatment soon. I am so excited. It will change my life. And I am receiving private healthcare for sleeping pills. But I think it will be a night job I will go for once my implants are done, as I don't want to have to rely on pills for the rest of my life. And my son is old enough to be alone at night.

I'm also now on an effective antipsychotic and have made it 8 months without a break or continuing paranoia.

So it feels like I'm finally turning my life around, and I can't wait to work. I've been bored out of my mind since my son stopped needing my attention all the time. It is daunting after all this time, but I will do it. I am even thinking of pursuing higher education. Night classes or Open University (I failed my studies last time due to psychotic breaks)

Just saying, to look at me you would assume and think why don't I work. But these things can be hidden disability

I think if the government want people in work there needs to be a better standard of medical care

cshp · 22/03/2026 22:08

KarmenPQZ · 17/03/2026 11:33

I spent some time recently with my aunty who’s well into her 70s and has just taken a board level position and is showing no signs of retiring. I can’t help but think if she would just retire already and let the next generation take those senior jobs. But it’s a scary decision to make I guess especially for someone who defines themself by there career.

At the same time her daughter in law is out of work because she tried a career change and it didn’t pan out now she’s struggling to get back into work. Aunty is actually very patient and sympathetic but her other daughter was quite mean about how she’s freeloading off her brother.

the reality is since we’re working til we’re in our 70s I don’t think it’s sustainable to have one single long career that time working 5 days a week. I think there needs to be more acceptance that careers can start later for some and not be linear and the standard min-Fri 9-5 isn’t desirable to younger adults who want for a better balance. Plus it’s a tough market and maybe younger kids are paving the way away from the 5 days a week to a better work life balance I think.

PS why is nice spelt with an ‘a’. Surely they just live in a nice house not ‘naice’

Edited

What, why should she retire 'already'
I dont imagine the early 20s grads would get her job...
Maybe they should ask her about her career path as a successful woman and learn something

LoyalMember · 22/03/2026 22:08

thankgoodnessforpuppies · 21/03/2026 21:29

"You did something you might have enjoyed a bit. How dare you! You are clearly able to work!" I don't think you really understand disability.

Is it only acceptable for people on benefits to sit at home staring at their navel feeling miserable all day?

I do understand disability. My wife's disabled in actual fact. She still works full time. She has to, though, we don't have a choice.

cshp · 22/03/2026 22:49

Shuffletoesxtreme · 17/03/2026 12:04

What are the jobs and volunteer positions they have held? Asking for ideas my own early teenagers.

Charity shop, retail work incl. Warehouse, support work volunteer roles, agency work, paper rounds

ruethewhirl · 22/03/2026 23:27

LoyalMember · 22/03/2026 22:08

I do understand disability. My wife's disabled in actual fact. She still works full time. She has to, though, we don't have a choice.

Does she not qualify for any form of assistance?

leftyberefty · 22/03/2026 23:30

LoyalMember · 22/03/2026 22:08

I do understand disability. My wife's disabled in actual fact. She still works full time. She has to, though, we don't have a choice.

It sounds like you perhaps understand your wife's disability while lacking understanding of disability more broadly. While I appreciate disability affects people in very different ways, if your wife is able to work full time while also maintaining a relationship, she would be considered by the current model to be living with a lower level of disability than many who have been deemed eligible for certain benefits . Even those of us who manage to spend a few hours in a pub or restaurant now and then!

If you can't work, you sadly don't have a choice about not being able to work.

Gowlett · 22/03/2026 23:41

They’re in a comfort zone. Life is different nowadays…

Me & my mates would have been young adults in the late 90s. We were from nice homes, but all worked in McDonalds / petrol garage / local restaurant or shop.

When we moved to London, Paris, NYC, Sydney we slept on floors & worked in bars. We had a bloody good laugh too! Doctors were handing out Prozac, but…

Everyone wanted to leave home. Experience life. Even the hard bits. Making friends, break-ups, bad bosses, paying the bills. It helped make is who we are today.

It was different times. But I enjoyed my youth, at least. For the most part. It’s sad to think that kids are missing out on all of this character-building stuff. On life itself, it seems…

cshp · 22/03/2026 23:54

Shouldreallybeworking · 17/03/2026 12:39

I have 2 children , both of whom had jobs in their teenage years pot washing at a local pub. My youngest has now been diagnosed with depression and doesn’t leave their room (they are in their year at uni and isn’t currently attending lectures)A lot of me really wants to push them and tell them they need to just get on with it but I really don’t see how that is going to help then. And I really can’t see how they are going to get a job when they leaves uni (possibly without even a degree seeing as they aren’t engaging with tutors or lecturers at the moment). This is the hardest time of being a parent that I have ever had and the stress I feel is like nothing I’ve felt before. Reading the OP and her views just makes me want to cry as I don’t know what I can do and makes me feel like a shit parent. I don’t feel I have enabled my children and I have encouraged a work ethic both by example and ensuring they have had jobs. So what have I done wrong??

I was your dc with a whole lot of trauma beforehand. Id had jobs and volunteering before, lots of, but at the time I was lost and barely functioning. My cpn suggested I get a job and a few agencies, luck gave me a really inspiring workplace, not a great job let's be real but honestly a lot learned over that Summer. I was already regularly volunteering in a charity shop.
Its 25 yrs later or so, im now a respected professional, managing a team and earning a fairly good wage, bought my own home with no help. I still struggle with my mental health not in a small way but work full time in a responsible job.
Sometimes we need a push. Being around people and having a purpose I am fairly sure have more positive benefits than negative on mental health.

OonaStubbs · 22/03/2026 23:57

cshp · 22/03/2026 22:08

What, why should she retire 'already'
I dont imagine the early 20s grads would get her job...
Maybe they should ask her about her career path as a successful woman and learn something

Yes but someone else a bit younger would get her job. And someone else a bit younger still would get that's persons vacated job. And it would filter down and an entry level position would open.

cshp · 22/03/2026 23:59

OonaStubbs · 22/03/2026 23:57

Yes but someone else a bit younger would get her job. And someone else a bit younger still would get that's persons vacated job. And it would filter down and an entry level position would open.

That's not the reason young graduates dont have jobs..
Imo

cshp · 23/03/2026 00:02

cshp · 22/03/2026 23:54

I was your dc with a whole lot of trauma beforehand. Id had jobs and volunteering before, lots of, but at the time I was lost and barely functioning. My cpn suggested I get a job and a few agencies, luck gave me a really inspiring workplace, not a great job let's be real but honestly a lot learned over that Summer. I was already regularly volunteering in a charity shop.
Its 25 yrs later or so, im now a respected professional, managing a team and earning a fairly good wage, bought my own home with no help. I still struggle with my mental health not in a small way but work full time in a responsible job.
Sometimes we need a push. Being around people and having a purpose I am fairly sure have more positive benefits than negative on mental health.

Apologies not 25 yrs, 15. Aged myself unnecessarily!

CraftandGlamour · 23/03/2026 01:05

Speaking on wider cultural trends, I do wonder if a lack of early independence is a factor. We know there are windows in childhood development where we gain certain social competencies - what if those experiences aren't happening in those windows? All the 20-somethings I know doing well now have parents who allowed them unstructured and unsupervised play from when they were small and expected them to do chores and take on responsibilities as they got older. These kids seemed to have been in the minority. They got themselves to school, were expected to have part time jobs and do chores. So going into the world, for them, hasn't been such a big leap, they already knew they can navigate new situations and get on with others - and experienced the rewards of independence.

I do think a combination of novel circumstances have converged to the detriment of young adults within our culture: 24hr, in your room entertainment, as mentioned; online addiction (and mistaking online for real world experiences); a lack of in-person socialisation; the removal of social stigma at failing to launch; identities wrapped up in mental health diagnosis forming, in some cases, self-created limitations (whilst also garnering social kudos with peers for said limitations); a pathological dislike of any kind of discomfort or uncertainty; too many university degrees from institutions only interested in their bottom line rather than standards (leading to an academic arms race, and further loans, to prove the grad actually knows anything) - and that's without even touching on the job market.

Honestly, I don't envy any parent battling with this issue. It must be very worrying and deeply frustrating but they're not helping their kids by indulging them. Boundaries are needed. The kids need to learn to function in a world that will not pick up after them and will not have patience for learned helplessness.

(Obviously, I am not talking about young people with serious disabilities)

Firefly1987 · 23/03/2026 01:33

@CraftandGlamour I think you might be right about your points re less independence for kids etc. but I don't know about there not being any stigma about "failure to launch"-even the label is stigmatising! And it seems like the only group of people it's acceptable to make fun of/talk down about these days.

There has always been people who didn't marry and lived with their parents. A neighbour of my nan's did and he died a few years ago at nearly 80 having lived in his parents house all his life. No one was describing those people as having "failure to launch" back then, at least I don't think so. It's a fairly recent term. And it never used to bother people like it does now. Even if someone works it's still seen as a bit sad when it's literally no one else's business.

Most people I know who moved out early moved in with a partner. I was not so lucky!

thankgoodnessforpuppies · 23/03/2026 02:23

LoyalMember · 22/03/2026 22:08

I do understand disability. My wife's disabled in actual fact. She still works full time. She has to, though, we don't have a choice.

So your wife is disabled and able to work full time. Lucky her. She is one person. That doesn't mean she is representative of all disabled people.

You might think you have no choice but, if she had no choice but to not work, you'd also have no choice but to find a way to manage.

CraftandGlamour · 23/03/2026 07:10

Firefly1987 · 23/03/2026 01:33

@CraftandGlamour I think you might be right about your points re less independence for kids etc. but I don't know about there not being any stigma about "failure to launch"-even the label is stigmatising! And it seems like the only group of people it's acceptable to make fun of/talk down about these days.

There has always been people who didn't marry and lived with their parents. A neighbour of my nan's did and he died a few years ago at nearly 80 having lived in his parents house all his life. No one was describing those people as having "failure to launch" back then, at least I don't think so. It's a fairly recent term. And it never used to bother people like it does now. Even if someone works it's still seen as a bit sad when it's literally no one else's business.

Most people I know who moved out early moved in with a partner. I was not so lucky!

Its fair to not like the term so let's but that aside, its quite clear the phenomenon has gone from being unusual to very common, hence, I guess, naming it. I do disagree that it's socially frowned upon. Thread after thread here has posters proudly pointing out that their adult children still live at home and will always have a place there with them, as if aspiring for an adult child's independence, or roughing it for a few years, is somehow a bad thing.

Just editing to say that, as this is primarily a parenting forum, its probably more likely to attract those who are still very invested in the parenting aspect of their lives, even if their children are at the stage of decision-making adulting so that might be skewering my impressions here.