Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To confront my SIL over my MIL's birthday cake?

196 replies

Sophiehoney · 26/02/2026 17:04

My MIL just had her 60th birthday at the weekend.

She has three kids all with spouses. We all agreed back in September that each couple would take on a different job to provide a nice birthday party for her. Bring in mind she does a hell of a lot for us in terms of babysitting all three sets of grandchildren and generally just being there over the years, it was universally agreed she deserves it.

BIL and wife were in charge of booking the venue and sending out invites. They did this brilliantly.

We (DH and I) were in charge of buying decorations and decorating the venue. We did this, at quite a cost as there were lots of personalised decorations, photo board etc, plus things we made ourselves, and it took a whole day to set up.

SIL and husband were in charge of providing the buffet and birthday cake.

All roles agreed on five months ago.

SIL asked back at the beginning of January if she was still OK doing the catering including cake. She said "yes, of course" Two weeks before the party we asked SIL how she was getting on with the food and if she needed any help and she said "yeah, I can do it if you want, when is the party again?" She was reminded and asked if she needed any help. She said no and asked for people's opinions on what flavour cake MIL would like because she was making the cake herself.

2 days before the party, SIL gets on the WhatsApp group and asks if people can come round and help her make buffet food the next day as she wouldn't be able to manage it in addition to making a cake. We said yes, we'd come after work in the evening and help her finish off.

Got there about 6pm and everything is sitting in shopping bags not even started. She hadn't been working that day and her kids had been at school. Her husband has been home since 4pm and has also done nothing. We worked until almost 10pm helping her make sandwiches, sausage rolls, chicken skewers, salads, fancy olive stick things, pasties, a cheeseboard, desserts etc etc loads of food, and then she announces she won't have time to make a cake now. I'm like.... You haven't made the cake?! And she just shrugs and says she'll have to get one tomorrow (the day of the party)

Morning of party she WhatsApps and asks if anyone happens to be going to a supermarket and can pick up a birthday cake. DH tells her I have bought a really fancy topper that goes with the beautiful, tall fancy birthday cake with fresh flowers she was planning on making, similar to one she made for her daughter, so she is able to make it, and that she showed to us all last year, and that it wouldn't work with a supermarket cake and she just said "well, I won't have time now"

So I rang around some bakeries and by some miracle found one that could provide me with a very nice cake that looks looked like someone had put some effort in, but which was a 40 minute round trip and would cost us over £100.

DH and I spend several hours decorating the venue and then get ready for the party, go get the cake and get there just in time to bring to the party.

The party goes well. All night people are complimenting SIL on the food, she takes all credit for it, and then someone asks her if she made the cake, and SHE SAYS YES, and then this person keeps telling everyone how impressed she is with SIL's baking all night and for the next couple of days while SIL and her family do nothing to correct them.

AIBU to think SIL is being a cheeky bitch and want to tell her so?

DH says to leave it, I didn't make the cake so it's not like it's my credit she's claiming, he was happy to do it all for his mum, and she didn't ask us to get a bakery cake, we could have just got a Tesco one.

But I'm just seething over how little effort she puts in when it's her that asks MIL for the most and then has the audacity to lie about it.

OP posts:
Sophiehoney · 26/02/2026 19:15

Keroppi · 26/02/2026 19:11

You should've said even in front of MIL that sil didn't do the cake! MIL should know her daughter is telling fibs lol I don't think that would've been a rude comment to make. It could have been funny 😁

Oh yeah, no she didn't make it, we got it from a cake maker. It's lovely though and SIL normally makes lovely cakes she just didn't have time.

MIL was mid-gush about how wonderful the party was, how lucky she is, how good everyone was to her, how spoilt and special she felt, relative added in the Great Job SIL did on the catering and cake and MIL agreed and then said what a great job we did too.

I wasn't about to piss all over MILs fireworks like that, when she was on such a high. I don't have the heart and neither does DH.

OP posts:
CorporealCarrot · 26/02/2026 19:16

Sophiehoney · 26/02/2026 19:06

Sorry, I meant to clarify, I wasn't around for the actual conversation. Otherwise "did you bollocks" would have shot straight out of my mouth.

A relative told us the next day that SIL did a great job on the cake and we didn't say anything as it was in front of MIL.

Then SILs daughter later confirmed her mum claimed it was hers. And seems to find this funny

So SIL could have been joking? If there's a big expensive cake at a family occasion half a dozen people will often claim to have made it (with a knowing wink) - are you sure SIL wasn't just joking around and then the relative took her seriously and then SIL and daughter had a good laugh. As soon as relative said SIL made the cake you should still have laughed snd said "ha! She's pulling your leg. No, I got it from a lovely bakers. But it's still a great cake even if not quite homemade in the family. Nice try SIL"

AnotherChangeDay · 26/02/2026 19:19

Sophiehoney · 26/02/2026 19:06

Sorry, I meant to clarify, I wasn't around for the actual conversation. Otherwise "did you bollocks" would have shot straight out of my mouth.

A relative told us the next day that SIL did a great job on the cake and we didn't say anything as it was in front of MIL.

Then SILs daughter later confirmed her mum claimed it was hers. And seems to find this funny

Would you heck as like have said that!

You didn't say anything about helping her for 4 hours when she had all day
You didnt tell HER to get the cake from the bakery
You haven't asked her for the cake money
You didnt say anything when her daughter was laughing about the cake credit
You didnt say anything another occasion when MiL was there

Yet all of a sudden you have a backbone and would have said "did you bollocks" to her at the party??!

Yeah, okay then

CorporealCarrot · 26/02/2026 19:19

Or maybe your MIL assumed the cake was homemade and was touched by it and your SIL was backed into a corner and didn't know how to say "actually we just got a last minute cake from a bakery"

traceybeakersbeaker · 26/02/2026 19:20

Sophiehoney · 26/02/2026 19:11

Then don't volunteer?! All six of us work and have kids.

As it happens DH and I are both full time and have children she works two days a week with school aged children.

Not that that means she should do more work of course, but she agreed she would.

I will ask again, who was paying for all the food for the buffet and the cake ingredients?

DownsideUpside · 26/02/2026 19:22

I’d go passive aggressive on this one and share some photos of the amazing cake on all my socials, tagging the bakery of course and publicly thanking them for the amazing cake!

Sophiehoney · 26/02/2026 19:25

traceybeakersbeaker · 26/02/2026 19:20

I will ask again, who was paying for all the food for the buffet and the cake ingredients?

Her of course.

That what you agree to when you agree to make the cake and do the catering.

We said we'd provide the decor. We spent a lot of money on it. We're talking lighting, backdrops, balloon arches, flower wall etc etc.

BIL paid for the venue.

If she couldn't afford it she didn't have to offer. If she wanted us to chip in, she could have asked. But she didn't. Just like she didn't take either of the offers of help we gave her until the last minute.

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 26/02/2026 19:26

Sophiehoney · 26/02/2026 19:06

Sorry, I meant to clarify, I wasn't around for the actual conversation. Otherwise "did you bollocks" would have shot straight out of my mouth.

A relative told us the next day that SIL did a great job on the cake and we didn't say anything as it was in front of MIL.

Then SILs daughter later confirmed her mum claimed it was hers. And seems to find this funny

And you haven’t said anything at all to anyone? Sorry, I find this bizarre!?

Did your SIL pay you back for the cake?

numberblocks54321 · 26/02/2026 19:26

I’m sure it’s been said before but you sound like a really lovely DIL. I’d be thrilled if my kids and their partners threw a party like that for me (even if one child was bloody useless)

Sophiehoney · 26/02/2026 19:30

Shinyandnew1 · 26/02/2026 19:26

And you haven’t said anything at all to anyone? Sorry, I find this bizarre!?

Did your SIL pay you back for the cake?

Well, DH doesn't want to and it's his family. I'm here asking if he's wrong. I think I should too.

No, she hasn't paid us back for the cake. DH says there's no point asking because she will just say "I didn't ask you to go to a bakery, I said go to Tesco" and he kinda has a point. But she did volunteer do do a fancy-shmancy one which she didn't deliver and which she knows I bought a themed cake topper for.

OP posts:
Bearbookagainandagain · 26/02/2026 19:32

Sophiehoney · 26/02/2026 17:52

SIL is the child of MIL.

The point is, she (very enthusiastically) agreed to it. She loves cooking, she loves making cakes, she put her name forward immediately and said she would do it.

She was offered help, more than once, and declined.

No, the three jobs aren't equal in terms of time and money but all three families have different amounts of both available to them. We took on the jobs we were able to do, it didn't need to be split equally as long as everyone was happy. Noone was forced, everyone volunteered their part.

What needed to be done was people sticking to their word.

I agree that this is the most important. I wouldn't confront her over "the cake". In the end if wants to pass a bakery cake for her own, it doesn't matter.

But she should be called out on the fact that she committed to providing the buffet and cake, was offered help that she rejected, and then due to her lack of planning and care ended up putting everyone in a stressful situation at the last minute. Next time she should just say so if she doesn't want or can't help.

I'm not sure it should come from you though, it's more something for her siblings to do.

canklesmctacotits · 26/02/2026 19:33

I think you’re bang out of order being pissed off that a daughter didn’t do what you think she should have done FOR HER OWN MOTHER. Not your mother, her own mother. Just because you love your MIL and think she’s the best, doesn’t mean SIL did or should or is obliged to feel that way. That mother-daughter relationship isn’t any of your business.

SIL was out of order not doing what she undertook to do.

SIL was out of order making you pay for the cake.

It was your call to get a fancy case, not your SIL’s fault.

You are out of order not saying it was a bakery cake that you sourced and collected and paid for.

Frankly, the whole thing sounds stupid.

traceybeakersbeaker · 26/02/2026 19:34

Sophiehoney · 26/02/2026 19:25

Her of course.

That what you agree to when you agree to make the cake and do the catering.

We said we'd provide the decor. We spent a lot of money on it. We're talking lighting, backdrops, balloon arches, flower wall etc etc.

BIL paid for the venue.

If she couldn't afford it she didn't have to offer. If she wanted us to chip in, she could have asked. But she didn't. Just like she didn't take either of the offers of help we gave her until the last minute.

You took the piss out of her. You KNOW that was too much for one person because YOU wouldn't dare volunteer to do it. You stuck up some decorations, the others sent envelopes in the post.
Yes, she offered but you bitching afterwards is lousy. She was probably embarrassed over the cake in case MIL didn't know. I actually feel sorry for her. Left with the donkey's work thinking she could do it, paid more than the rest of you, especially you OP, shopped for all the food and asked for help at the 11th hour because she was struggling. Did you want her to pay twice for the cake, she had already paid for the ingredients. Way too much work for one person especially when the others are doing feck all.
We all have different capacities, that made me laugh.

BIossomtoes · 26/02/2026 19:36

canklesmctacotits · 26/02/2026 19:33

I think you’re bang out of order being pissed off that a daughter didn’t do what you think she should have done FOR HER OWN MOTHER. Not your mother, her own mother. Just because you love your MIL and think she’s the best, doesn’t mean SIL did or should or is obliged to feel that way. That mother-daughter relationship isn’t any of your business.

SIL was out of order not doing what she undertook to do.

SIL was out of order making you pay for the cake.

It was your call to get a fancy case, not your SIL’s fault.

You are out of order not saying it was a bakery cake that you sourced and collected and paid for.

Frankly, the whole thing sounds stupid.

You managed to miss that Sil volunteered to do the food/cake, was given offers of help on numerous occasions which she refused and then fucked up and had to be saved by someone else. And then has the brass neck to take the credit for the last minute rescue cake.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 26/02/2026 19:37

Twasasurprise · 26/02/2026 17:47

Is it just me thinking that the cake and catering was the biggest, most expensive job by far? I'm not sure who is the CF here, but not yet convinced it is the SIL (who maybe isn't even the child of the MIL).

Edit: I see maybe not just me, from the cross-post above.

Edited

Tbh I agree re this being by far the biggest, most expensive and time consuming role. I thought this as I was reading!

However, god only knows why the SIL agreed to it in the first place!

Iamsotiredandfedup · 26/02/2026 19:38

I love the idea of tagging the cake maker on social media! I can’t believe she was brazen enough to lie like that

it brought back a memory of my mum having a macmillan coffee morning once, she’d bought lots of lovely cakes from a local bakery. And then told everyone that I had made them 😬

Faceon · 26/02/2026 19:39

You have a long and chequered history with this SIL… yes?

Faceon · 26/02/2026 19:40

Sophiehoney · 26/02/2026 19:15

MIL was mid-gush about how wonderful the party was, how lucky she is, how good everyone was to her, how spoilt and special she felt, relative added in the Great Job SIL did on the catering and cake and MIL agreed and then said what a great job we did too.

I wasn't about to piss all over MILs fireworks like that, when she was on such a high. I don't have the heart and neither does DH.

Push come to shove, you can bet your bottom dollar that your mil would climb over you to reach her daughter in a fire. So don’t think that you saying anything would have had any big impact at all

RS1987 · 26/02/2026 19:44

I’d be fuming!!! But the most important thing is your lovely MIL had a great time. Move on and make a private joke of it.

Faceon · 26/02/2026 19:53

Sophiehoney · 26/02/2026 19:30

Well, DH doesn't want to and it's his family. I'm here asking if he's wrong. I think I should too.

No, she hasn't paid us back for the cake. DH says there's no point asking because she will just say "I didn't ask you to go to a bakery, I said go to Tesco" and he kinda has a point. But she did volunteer do do a fancy-shmancy one which she didn't deliver and which she knows I bought a themed cake topper for.

It says a lot about you - that you are wanting to know if your husband is wrong when he doesn’t want to hurt his mother and causes issues in his family, and that you think you should say something

Solost92 · 26/02/2026 19:54

I'd be fuming. Where is all this poor SIL coming from?! Left with the donkey work. They all helped with the food, and OP bought and collected the cake. SIL didn't help her brother with the venue or invites. Which is more than sticking invites I'm the post. Do you know where all your mothers friends live? I bloody don't. And she didn't help OP with the decorating. So all she's done is do a big shop and helped make some sandwiches.

MIL is lucky to have a DIL that would everything OP did to make her feel special and OP should be pissed that SIL is taking that credit when she fumbled the ball.

BunnyLake · 26/02/2026 19:59

She’s a total flake. Without help she would have rocked up with no food and no cake. And she’s a brazen liar to boot. I’d have no respect for her.

canklesmctacotits · 26/02/2026 20:02

BIossomtoes · 26/02/2026 19:36

You managed to miss that Sil volunteered to do the food/cake, was given offers of help on numerous occasions which she refused and then fucked up and had to be saved by someone else. And then has the brass neck to take the credit for the last minute rescue cake.

Nope, covered all that in my post. As between the MILs three children and their spouses the SIL/DD is out of order and doesn’t have a leg to stand o . My main point is that OP as a DIL has a right nerve saying “I’m just seething over how little effort she puts in when it’s her that asks MIL for the most”. Who does OP think she is? MIL’s other DD? The other actual child of MIL (DH) has said to drop it and move on. And OP thinks she qualified to know better and wonder if he’s wrong in even HIS doings with HIS mother! Mental.

Netcurtainnelly · 26/02/2026 20:04

Move on. Your mil had a good party. Justrarn a lesson from this.

Netcurtainnelly · 26/02/2026 20:05

Netcurtainnelly · 26/02/2026 20:04

Move on. Your mil had a good party. Justrarn a lesson from this.

Just learn a lesson.