Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For not wanting to contribute to the holiday?

230 replies

TwinklyRoseTurtle · 05/02/2026 16:56

I’m having mixed thoughts on this so would like others opinions please- I’m being vague so not too outing-

A close relative has asked me to contribute towards an expensive holiday for another close relative for a special birthday, but before asking me the had told the other relative it had already been agreed- I was caught off guard when asked in front of the other person and I’ve now found out that I wouldn’t just be paying for my relative- I would also be paying for their gf- for full clarity I would not be going on this holiday, AIBU to not contribute? I feel conflicted as this relative and I are close

OP posts:
Bimmering · 05/02/2026 18:59

JustGiveMeReason · 05/02/2026 18:52

I think it’s bothered me the most is I wasn’t asked prior to this and now feel like I have to contribute.

You are right to be bothered by not being consulted.
You are wrong to think you now "have to contribute".

Be reassured by everyone on this thread.
Say "I wasn't consulted, and I am not going to do that. As it is his 21st, I'm happy to increase my spending to £100. I don't mind getting something myself, of letting him have that towards something bigger if that is what he wants to do, but obviously I'm not giving such a ridiculous amount".

I wouldn't particularly mention the girlfriend, that is a bit of a red herring as far as I am concerned.

Yes, I think the gf part is a red herring

Most people don't want to go on holiday alone so I think it's normal if you are giving someone a trip or a holiday that you also pay for their partner or someone else to go with them. Otherwise it's a gift that costs them money as they have to pay to use it.

The much bigger issue is that they shouldn't have committed you to the present like this

binkie163 · 05/02/2026 18:59

ACynicalDad · 05/02/2026 18:34

This is on your parents to pay and they should give equal to you.

This 👍

AutumnLover1989 · 05/02/2026 19:00

JustGiveMeReason · 05/02/2026 17:17

I agree with @LionKing88

I would just say "No. Since when did we start giving each other presents worth hundreds of pounds? Confused. I never agreed to this."

This!! Cheeky buggers 😡

Gonners · 05/02/2026 19:01

Frankly your brother is a complete fool if he has booked this holiday (which he presumably can't afford) on the basis that others would be paying, without checking that everyone concerned was happy to pay.

lemonraspberry · 05/02/2026 19:01

Ahh it is always the flaky ones who suggest stuff like this. Like meals out - the ones who order the most always want to split the bill evenly.

Have you ever received something similar for your significant life events? If not I would just send £100 and tell them to fill their boots.

EscapeTheCastle · 05/02/2026 19:02

What?
No! No. Nope. NOOOOOOOO. No.
Pardon, say what now? No.
Ha ha HA!!!

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 05/02/2026 19:04

This sounds like a joke. No I wouldn’t be paying and I’d be saying why too. Brass neck of some people!

Vaxtable · 05/02/2026 19:05

Well I would pay a quarter if his cost, and if his cost is £600 then that’s £150. GF can get others to pay for her

SpanielLover356 · 05/02/2026 19:06

My mother had always wanted to go on a river cruise down the Rhein. I planned this for her 75th birthday as she'd looked after my DF (who had Parkinson's & dementia) for many years & he was in a home.

I thought Saga would be best as, although on the face of it, it's rather expensive, everything is included-travel to/from home, drinks, food, most excursions, smaller more friendly ships, tips, so not so expensive when you consider how much other cruise companies add on to their basic price.

I was going to pay for myself & also willing to pay her costs. Got in touch with all relatives saying what I'd planned & suggesting that, if they'd planned to send her a present, that they might like to contribute whatever they would spend on her birthday present to the cost of Mum's fare. I contacted my siblings inviting them to join us (at their own expense) telling them that my intention was that, we cover my mother's costs, though I was willing to pay for her on my own if they didn't feel able to contribute (I'm better off than my siblings so wanted them to join us & if that meant they couldn't contribute to mum's costs, that was OK). As it turned out we all went my siblings, my mother & me, siblings being able to pay for themselves.

My siblings, mother's brothers, sisters & our many cousins managed to pay for mum's fare & spending money.

Mum had a great time & died 18 months later still talking about her amazing holiday.

Imdunfer · 05/02/2026 19:10

TwinklyRoseTurtle · 05/02/2026 16:59

Sorry I was trying to be vague so not outing- parent has asked me to pay for sibling and gf

Absolutely not on, no way. There are many ways of showing your love for your sibling. Spending money you can't afford, or can afford but were bounced into, should not be one of them.

MinnieMountain · 05/02/2026 19:13

What's your point @SpanielLover356 ?

dove76 · 05/02/2026 19:14

Sorry that doesn't work for me! End of discussion

OriginalUsername2 · 05/02/2026 19:15

Madness.

Give them whatever you would normally spend for. 21st and say the truth, that you were asked in front of them so felt you couldn’t say no. Nip this manipulative tactic in the bud so it doesn’t become a pattern.

Blondeshavemorefun · 05/02/2026 19:15

Crazy. £600 is a massive amount for a present for a sibling. Assume it would be £300 if not paying for the gf

an that’s a huge amount

gf can pay her share

PhuckTrump · 05/02/2026 19:19

They don’t get a vote in the Gift category of your 2026 budget. Hand over the £100 and be done with it.

NewYearSameYou · 05/02/2026 19:19

TwinklyRoseTurtle · 05/02/2026 18:37

To answer some questions, we usually spend between £50-£100 per birthday. I think it’s bothered me the most is I wasn’t asked prior to this and now feel like I have to contribute. The main issue for me is paying for his gf- they will be 21 but still unsure why I’m expected to fund it. I’m much older and my sibling is great and would help me with anything which I think is why I feel guilty. But my own child has a big birthday also this year and my siblings isn’t until next year.

You don't have to contribute. You really don't.

Stand up for yourself. Your bank account is not theirs to spend or dictate how you spend it. You're an adult with your own life and own bills to pay and own future to plan for.

This is completely out of order, you know it, stand up for yourself.

nomas · 05/02/2026 19:20

I of course said I couldn’t afford it so close to Christmas… not many could!

So have you said no to contributing? Good!

NamingNoNames · 05/02/2026 19:23

@SpanielLover356 , your post is irrelevant.

Silverbirchleaf · 05/02/2026 19:24

Just read the updates. So someone is expecting you to pay £600, several times the usual agreed amount, without asking you first!

Silverbirchleaf · 05/02/2026 19:24

NewYearSameYou · 05/02/2026 19:19

You don't have to contribute. You really don't.

Stand up for yourself. Your bank account is not theirs to spend or dictate how you spend it. You're an adult with your own life and own bills to pay and own future to plan for.

This is completely out of order, you know it, stand up for yourself.

And this!

Shinyandnew1 · 05/02/2026 19:27

- I was caught off guard when asked in front of the other person

What do you mean? What was said? Have you not said no at any point here?

Does the brother believe that you and the other flaky sibling are going to cough up £1200 between you? I can't believe anyone (especially someone you get on with) is that unaware of finances!

User1367349 · 05/02/2026 19:30

If your DC’s birthday is a significant one, what is everyone getting them?!

TwinklyRoseTurtle · 05/02/2026 19:32

To clarify some questions on wether I said no or not… when asked initially I said I can’t afford it this year- so many outgoings like everyone else and I am also not even having a proper holiday this year due to how expensive everything is. However it was playing on my mind so I clarified the cost further today and asked why it was so much as this place in February should cost a lot less that’s when my parent said it’s for both of them- at this point I didn’t have any words to say I was speechless then my parent said in a nasty tone you can contribute or you can’t.

OP posts:
PhuckTrump · 05/02/2026 19:33

TwinklyRoseTurtle · 05/02/2026 19:32

To clarify some questions on wether I said no or not… when asked initially I said I can’t afford it this year- so many outgoings like everyone else and I am also not even having a proper holiday this year due to how expensive everything is. However it was playing on my mind so I clarified the cost further today and asked why it was so much as this place in February should cost a lot less that’s when my parent said it’s for both of them- at this point I didn’t have any words to say I was speechless then my parent said in a nasty tone you can contribute or you can’t.

“I can’t. I can’t even afford to go on holiday myself this year.”

TwinklyRoseTurtle · 05/02/2026 19:35

I was also considering at one point in taking my child away for their big birthday before Christmas - I may send a text asking them all to split the cost for both of us 🤣😅 I’m sure the would stop asking then. My sibling can definitely afford the holiday- despite age they earn above what you would expect and they are good at saving- I don’t begrudge my sibling the holiday but many posters have it right that favouritism is at play- I had nothing of what my siblings had likely due to age gap.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread