Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Manchester terrorist attack today shows the growing Anti-Semitism

1000 replies

Longingdreamer · 02/10/2025 21:17

... and how Jews are not protected in this country.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
nomas · 03/10/2025 13:29

cordialzempy · 03/10/2025 13:24

I’m not sure that this is the gotcha you think it is! You’re naming ethnic backgrounds, not religions, and the first two ethnicities are frequently Muslim (eg Albanians, Kosovans, Algerians, Moroccans).

I totally get that you don’t want what I said to be true - I don’t want it to be true! But I was trying to explain some reasons that are behind the statistics about Muslim children being in secular state schools and Jewish children far less so.

You yourself posted a link that proved that the open day debacle was true, and yet you used it to try to say that day was night. What is your agenda? Why are you so determined to disprove peoples’ lived experiences?

There isn't a gotcha, just an attempt to understand. You said 3 schools had deliberately scheduled open days on Yom Kippur, and I shared a link showing that the open days have been scheduled on various days in Sep and Oct.

There are 3 on 9 October, is that a holy day for a religion too? The

You're now attempting to say most of the kids are Albanians, Kosovans, Algerians, Moroccans without evidence. It's completely bizarre.

www.walthamforest.gov.uk/schools-education-and-learning/apply-school-place/apply-secondary-school/school-open-evening-dates-2025

EdithStourton · 03/10/2025 13:29

Notsandwiches · 03/10/2025 13:04

How does the attack show Jews aren't protected? Are you expecting them all ti have armed guards?

The fact that synagogues and Jewish school require security tells us that there is a credible threat against the British Jewish community.

Antisemitism has been accepted in the UK for far too long. You could tell things were rotten when no one was prosecuted after a couple of car loads of 'pro-Palestine activists' drove around north London shouting antisemitic abuse.

The whole atmosphere in the UK has permitted this. It has been facilitated by parts of the media, and by the (in)action of some politicians and the police.

Whatthistime · 03/10/2025 13:29

anotherside · 03/10/2025 13:22

I agree it’s absolutely wrong. However, a point of difference is that senior Israeli figures frequently equate criticism of Israel with being anti Jewish ie antisemitic full stop. There are obviously hundreds or even thousands of examples of this over the years, but as I live in Ireland I’ll put this one from last year, with the Israeli foreign minister calling the leader of Ireland “antisemitic”


Last night Ireland's anti-Semitic Prime Minister Simon Harris said in an interview 'Ireland is not anti-Israel but Ireland is absolutely anti the starvation of children'," Mr Saar said.
https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2024/1217/1486987-ireland-israel/
….

So to that extent, certain Israeli leaders are frequently trying to create animosity between Jewish people and their respective governments on a global level, not just on an “Israelis vs X” level. This then in turn creates the (unreasonable) expectation or perception that Jewish people globally are politically all on the same page.

Edited

when your president promotes Holocaust inversion and community of what (5 thousand?) is non stopped vilified then being offended that someone calls it what it is - antisemitism - is dishonest.

anotherside · 03/10/2025 13:30

29Braydon · 03/10/2025 13:27

Actually people have the right to have different political opinions than you, and not be attacked or harassed for them.

Of course. But I’d like to see the Israeli government also apply this logic rather than always rushing to label its global critics as antisemitic. One quick example, as I’m in the country in question.

www.rte.ie/news/2024/1216/1486678-israeli-embassy/

Juniperberry55 · 03/10/2025 13:31

Winter2020 · 03/10/2025 13:16

It's not the Government stopping them is it. It's oppressive culture that does not align with British values of freedom and security.

Which women do you think don't have the right to wear what they like?
Muslim women, white British women, Jewish women?
In reality all of these have the ability to be oppressed and abused by family and partners, that's misogyny. There are women in America being oppressed in America made to be 'trad wives' that aren't allowed to work, have to dress a certain way, have dinner on the table for their husband. Does it matter which country or religion this happens within? Any abuse or oppression is awful but it's not specific to one culture or religion

It was in a previous post where apparently the government wouldn't come out and say its a right of all women to wear and do what they want within the law... But they literally do, so that's why I included the point that the government doesn't say it isn't British values or the right of women to do those things.

anotherside · 03/10/2025 13:32

Whatthistime · 03/10/2025 13:29

when your president promotes Holocaust inversion and community of what (5 thousand?) is non stopped vilified then being offended that someone calls it what it is - antisemitism - is dishonest.

Please quote Simon Harris “promoting Holocaust inversion”

clipboardz · 03/10/2025 13:32

They didn't say 'everyone is scared.' They said, 'Jewish people are scared.'

Surely they were talking in this manner because of the context of a terrorist attack against jewish people yesterday?

But Muslim people are scared, Sikh people are scared. Christian people are scared. I could go on. I won't assume it is just one group that is scared. Because if I do, it seems like they may be the only target.

Of course most people are scared of terrorist attacks, I certainly am. But imo it's inappropriate to centre myself when I wasn't the target yesterday. Hope that helps.

nomas · 03/10/2025 13:32

Unfinishedkitchn · 03/10/2025 13:21

I read a comment earlier about Jewish people should make an effort to integrate more or along those lines. The neighbours of the victim's from yesterday's attack have been describing what wonderful people they were. One of them used to even buy Eid gifts for his Muslim neighbour's children. Yet he was mindlessly attacked just for being Jewish. We need to speak out against this heinous attack together.

I saw that video, it was heartening to see a lovely friendship between them and sad that such a great guy is gone. This is what we need more of, what neighbours to talk to each other. The internet has meant many people isolate themselves from their neighbours.

https://news.sky.com/story/two-men-killed-in-manchester-synagogue-attack-named-as-police-step-up-patrols-13443311

MyKhakiPanda · 03/10/2025 13:32

Israel call anyone who disagrees with their 'policies' , for want of a better word, antisemitic regardless of how barbaric those polices are. The government there has lost all credibility in the wider world. They're rapidly becoming a pariah nation.

HavingYouTubeDoesntMakeYouAFilmmaker · 03/10/2025 13:34

CleopatraSelene · 03/10/2025 11:24

Hmm? That's not how I'd see it..

I know you're American. What gives you the authority to pronounce on what English is...

A deep-seated sense of American exceptionalism?

PraisebetoGod · 03/10/2025 13:34

jacksonlamb · 03/10/2025 13:21

Regarding different religions and integration, I can share my experience of working at several 'non faith' junior schools where we had children from a range of religious backgrounds: Christian, Muslim, Jewish, Sikh, Hindu and atheist. As part of the curriculum children had RI lessons where they were given an introduction to each of the religions; this was done in a very neutral way, eg 'These people believe that...this is their holy book...this is how they worship etc'. It saddened me that, whereas all the Christian, Jewish, Sikh and Hindu parents were happy for their children to learn about other religions, the majority of the Muslim parents demanded that their children should only learn about Islam. The exceptions were Muslim refugees from Eastern Europe who seemed far more open minded and tolerant. It seems to me that if Muslim children were allowed to learn about other religions, they would realise that all faiths have a tremendous amount in common and they might be less aggressive (when adult) towards 'infidels': the unpleasant way in which some Muslims abuse westerners.
Interestingly the natural inclination of all the children was to make friends with anyone regardless of religion. They are taught to hate.

Well there's no surprise. Muslims are taught not to read other holy books. There's a great quote from Thomas Aquinas
“On the contrary, he [Muhammad] perverts almost all the testimonies of the Old and New Testaments by making them into fabrications of his own, as can be seen by anyone who examines his law. It was, therefore, a shrewd decision on his part to forbid his followers to read the Old and New Testaments, lest these books convict him of falsity. It is thus clear that those who place any faith in his words believe foolishly.”

clipboardz · 03/10/2025 13:34

There has been lots of threads about the rise of flags etc around the country & how minorities have felt about that. I would never dream of going on one of those threads & saying don't worry I'm scared of terrorist attacks as well.

27trousers · 03/10/2025 13:34

Juniperberry55 · 03/10/2025 12:41

I think if the aibu unreasonable was ' did anyone else think the terrorist incident in Manchester was horrific ' must people on here would have agreed it was horrific and tragic. But the Jewish population are protected in this country, the police responded quickly. Without having armed guards accompanying each Jewish person, the police couldn't have done much more.
There will obviously always be a few people that have disgusting views but I doubt it's nearly 1/3 people who voted

I'm sure there will be an investigation into the shooting of Jewish worshippers by Manchester Police. Stray bullets they say.

clipboardz · 03/10/2025 13:36

whataboutery. 101

yep

Jujujudo · 03/10/2025 13:37

inamarina · 03/10/2025 13:16

It’s showing compassion for every minority group in the UK that is unjustly attacked.

Following the same logic, saying “All lives matter” would be showing compassion for every life, yet people object to that phrase.
Why can’t antisemitism be discussed as a separate issue, without mentioning all the other minorities and their struggles?

Because this person think that we consider ourselves as special chosen people.

Jujujudo · 03/10/2025 13:38

samthepigeon · 03/10/2025 13:16

Except that one poster here said they do support Israel's actions. There may be more. I don't know.

Ah ok then. So point the next bloke called Jihad in their direction and then he can sort them out.

YouveGotNoBloodyIdea · 03/10/2025 13:38

For anyone still confused about the whole antisemitism/antizionism thing.... here is a "pro-pal" march in the UK in 2021 - with a group of young men, the age of the Manchester attacker, shouting the first part of a chant referencing the massacre of Jewish tribes in Saudi Arabia at the foundation of Islam. The same chant was recorded being shouted during the Oct 7th massacres in Israel.

Israel is under attack BECAUSE it is a Jewish state. The Jew hatred is real and pervasive in large parts of the Islamic middle east - that hatred has been brought here with them.

This is what the politicians and police have not stamped out on these marches, this is what is leading to the climate of fear for British Jews.

https://x.com/LizaRosen0000/status/1973829685315534998

Liza Rosen (@LizaRosen0000) on X

London, England 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 Muslims chanting: "Khayber Khayber Ya Yehud, jaish Mohammad sauf ya’ud." A call for the beheading of Jews on the streets of Britain. Are Jews safe in Britain?

https://x.com/LizaRosen0000/status/1973829685315534998

27trousers · 03/10/2025 13:39

nomas · 03/10/2025 13:32

I saw that video, it was heartening to see a lovely friendship between them and sad that such a great guy is gone. This is what we need more of, what neighbours to talk to each other. The internet has meant many people isolate themselves from their neighbours.

https://news.sky.com/story/two-men-killed-in-manchester-synagogue-attack-named-as-police-step-up-patrols-13443311

Edited

Tank you for sharing this - we need to see and hear more about how normal people get along just fine as neighbours, colleagues, school parents and friends.

MyHeartyCoralSnail · 03/10/2025 13:39

27trousers · 03/10/2025 13:34

I'm sure there will be an investigation into the shooting of Jewish worshippers by Manchester Police. Stray bullets they say.

It was a bullet going through the door of the synagogue as the Jewish congregation tried to stop the Islamic terrorist entering and slaughtering more people on his anti semetic rampage. The terrorist is responsible for their deaths too, not the police, the Islamic terrorist. He is also responsible for the effects that this will have on the police involved. The man was scum, he has wrecked many lives, don’t you even dare to try and shift any focus on to the police, their actions undoubtedly saved many lives yesterday.

Juniperberry55 · 03/10/2025 13:39

27trousers · 03/10/2025 13:34

I'm sure there will be an investigation into the shooting of Jewish worshippers by Manchester Police. Stray bullets they say.

If a policeman has shot an innocent person, then an investigation is quite right to happen. It doesn't automatically mean it was on purpose to kill a Jewish person.

nomas · 03/10/2025 13:39

PraisebetoGod · 03/10/2025 13:34

Well there's no surprise. Muslims are taught not to read other holy books. There's a great quote from Thomas Aquinas
“On the contrary, he [Muhammad] perverts almost all the testimonies of the Old and New Testaments by making them into fabrications of his own, as can be seen by anyone who examines his law. It was, therefore, a shrewd decision on his part to forbid his followers to read the Old and New Testaments, lest these books convict him of falsity. It is thus clear that those who place any faith in his words believe foolishly.”

Codswallop.

The Quran says:

“Rather, the Qur'an is clear verses [preserved] in the hearts of those who have been given knowledge."

“Given knowledge” means true engagement with the Quran requires intellectual and spiritual insight. It’s a call to scholars, seekers, and thinkers.

In essence, the Quran doesn’t discourage questioning—it demands it.

Whatthistime · 03/10/2025 13:40

anotherside · 03/10/2025 13:32

Please quote Simon Harris “promoting Holocaust inversion”

you don't even know what i talking about do you?
Do you really thing that using Holocaust against Jews is moral and not antisemitic?

How would you feel about English politician using famine to prove that Irish people are born evil?

MyKhakiPanda · 03/10/2025 13:40

clipboardz · 03/10/2025 13:34

There has been lots of threads about the rise of flags etc around the country & how minorities have felt about that. I would never dream of going on one of those threads & saying don't worry I'm scared of terrorist attacks as well.

unless you are for some reason AND it's completely reasonable to point out that extreme views - whether they are Islamophobic or racist or anti immigrations etc - seem to be on the rise throughout the UK as they are in the same context. And if you read some of the comments on those threads you will find people who are voicing their own fears. Whether or not you agree with those fears or the fact they're being voiced is another thing altogether.

YouveGotNoBloodyIdea · 03/10/2025 13:41

27trousers · 03/10/2025 13:34

I'm sure there will be an investigation into the shooting of Jewish worshippers by Manchester Police. Stray bullets they say.

The statement from the GMP says the bullets went through the synagogue doors while people were trying to hold them closed against the attacker and the police were shooting him.

27trousers · 03/10/2025 13:41

MyHeartyCoralSnail · 03/10/2025 13:39

It was a bullet going through the door of the synagogue as the Jewish congregation tried to stop the Islamic terrorist entering and slaughtering more people on his anti semetic rampage. The terrorist is responsible for their deaths too, not the police, the Islamic terrorist. He is also responsible for the effects that this will have on the police involved. The man was scum, he has wrecked many lives, don’t you even dare to try and shift any focus on to the police, their actions undoubtedly saved many lives yesterday.

I agree

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread