Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I give my brother £15k?

195 replies

25doingtherightthing · 20/02/2025 12:14

My mum died last year and I need some advice, apologies if this is a long post. My brother and I didn’t have the easiest upbringing (think low income single parent household, addiction, neglect, emotional abuse). In her later years my mum came into relative money - through final salary pension and the inheritance of a privately owned council property. My brother lived at home rent free until late thirties when she passed, never paid rent or contributed to any house hold bills, never maintained her house, never saved a penny. I Ieft home at 18 to fend for myself. My brothers difficult behaviour alongside my mums was a contributing factor there.

A few years ago I was looking to get on the property ladder with my savings. My mum gifted me £30k, wrote a gifted letter etc. to my knowledge she never gave my brother the same money.

I now have 2 Dc (bro has none and is single) and my brother and I have now both inherited from her estate. The reason I’m posting is because I’m unsure as to whether I should give my brother £15k (half the £30k) to even things out. I’m sure my mum would’ve intended him to get the same, although didn’t amend her very old will.

We recently sold her house which was damp, damaged from my brother smoking (cigarettes and weed) inside and in a state of disrepair. The estate agent was clear that it could’ve been worth much more if it had been maintained. I also feel resentful about my brother having lived for free, while I had little support. However this is likely clouding my judgement.

I’d love to hear what others would do in this situation? Would you give your brother £15k? Please be kind, I'm trying to do the right thing, thank you.

OP posts:
WaltzingWaters · 20/02/2025 13:01

wednesday32 · 20/02/2025 12:18

In this situation, no, I would not give him an additional £15K. You received a gift in a lump sum, and in turn, he received rent-free living for X amount of years, which I'm sure far outweighs £15K, in that sector, he would owe you money. Leave it as is.

First response says it all.

No.

Allthenameshavegone1972 · 20/02/2025 13:01

No, I wouldn't give him the £15,000. Your mum left it to you. I've would probably be frittered away on crap & weed too

UnbeatenMum · 20/02/2025 13:02

No. He lived rent free at home for around 20 years. Even renting a room in a shared house would be something like £300 a month so the value of that could be estimated to be £72,000. Plus you say he devalued the house.

MzHz · 20/02/2025 13:03

Hell no.

whatonearthisgoingonnow · 20/02/2025 13:03

She would have given him some money at the same time as you if she'd intended him to have any, so no.

But I hope you declared it and paid tax on it.

Scottishskifun · 20/02/2025 13:03

Nope I wouldn't as others say if anything he has saved minimum over 100k!
Don't even get into it with him!

Normallynumb · 20/02/2025 13:04

No certainly not
He lived rent free with DM
It's not your responsibility to subsidise him now she's no longer here
If she wanted to make provision for him then she would have

ThePartingOfTheWays · 20/02/2025 13:04

I’m sure my mum would’ve intended him to get the same, although didn’t amend her very old will.

Can't see how you can be sure, since she doesn't appear to have ever said this. Your mum chose to give you a lump sum and him free housing. That was her choice, so you shouldn't be second guessing her now.

Pootles34 · 20/02/2025 13:04

Look, your mum didn't give him the money - why? Because she knew what would happen to it. Her giving him a rent-free place to stay was a more appropriate gift for him.

GRCP · 20/02/2025 13:06

Absolutely not! Why, to fritter it away on weed? He had much more than £30K from your mum in free rent. Save it for your kids future.

DaniMontyRae · 20/02/2025 13:06

whatonearthisgoingonnow · 20/02/2025 13:03

She would have given him some money at the same time as you if she'd intended him to have any, so no.

But I hope you declared it and paid tax on it.

Edited

There is no income tax to pay on financial gifts in the UK. So the OP did not need to pay tax on it.

Esdale · 20/02/2025 13:07

He lived there rent free until his late 30s. You moved out at 18.

Say he is 37 (is that the start of late 30s?).

37 minus 18 is 19 years.

19 × 12 months = 228 months in total.

He's lived rent (and bill?) free for 228 months.

15000 ÷ 228 = £65.79 per month. He could have very easily saved 15k on his own. Instead he devalued the house by being a lazy bum and not going outside to smoke.

Imagine if he had rented somewhere for himself for those 228 months, and managed to only pay £400 per month, that would still be £91,200 over those 228 months.

He's benefitted more than you have already.

Daleksatemyshed · 20/02/2025 13:09

Please don't let guilt influence you Op, he's lived off your DM all his life and if she'd lived another 20 years no doubt he'd still have been sponging off her. I'm sure she was happy to give you the help you needed to buy your own home.
I'm sorry for your loss Op, now go and keep your inheritence for something important in the future

GRCP · 20/02/2025 13:10

If you're worried about things being even, he should be giving YOU money!

mondaytosunday · 20/02/2025 13:11

No. He's had far more value in staying with her rent free.

CarpetKnees · 20/02/2025 13:11

No, of course not. You were given a lump sum, he was given 15 yeas of free accommodation, which he then damaged, so both your inheritance was a lot less than it otherwise would have been. If anything, he should be giving you money. But best to just leave it as it is.

TheoriginalMrsDarcy · 20/02/2025 13:12

No, i wouldn't give him any money. He's lived rent free for x number of years. I have a relative who has lived rent free for over 20 years. Had they paid rent, it would have costed them easily around £200,000.

He's probably cost you £15k in the house sale from all the damp and smoking weed etc...

Save the money for your own family and children. What if your children needed the money for education or an operation ( NHS waiting lists are very long) Your brother will likely spend the money on drugs anyway.

Wonderi · 20/02/2025 13:13

I now have 2 Dc (bro has none and is single) and my brother and I have now both inherited from her estate.

What have you both inherited?

Was the house sold and split?

Usually I would say everything should be 50/50 but I don’t believe that in this case.

Your mum gave that money to you.
Your DB has benefited in lots of other ways.
And you have kids.

If your DB got absolutely nothing from the house sale then I personally would lend him a couple of thousand but not mention your mums money.

If he inherited some money from the house then I definitely wouldn’t give him any.

Don’t even mention your mums money.

Richiewoo · 20/02/2025 13:13

Absolutely not. He had his fair share when living rent free

Diningtableornot · 20/02/2025 13:13

I don't see any reason to give your brother 15K. As you imply, he benefited in other ways from your mum's generosity when she was alive, and if she intended the 30K to be part of your inheritance she would have said so. You're fine. Sorry for your loss.

Cynic17 · 20/02/2025 13:14

Er, no. Absolutely no obligation to do so.

Bigfellabamboo · 20/02/2025 13:14

I wouldn't give him a penny. Sounds like he was an absolute sponger till the day your mum's house sold.

newtb · 20/02/2025 13:15

No, like pp have said he's had more than that over the years. Given what the agent has said he should be giving you money for the loss in value.

25doingtherightthing · 20/02/2025 13:15

TheoriginalMrsDarcy · 20/02/2025 13:12

No, i wouldn't give him any money. He's lived rent free for x number of years. I have a relative who has lived rent free for over 20 years. Had they paid rent, it would have costed them easily around £200,000.

He's probably cost you £15k in the house sale from all the damp and smoking weed etc...

Save the money for your own family and children. What if your children needed the money for education or an operation ( NHS waiting lists are very long) Your brother will likely spend the money on drugs anyway.

I should add we're in London, so rent is much more expensive here. And the estate agent valued the damages and lack of maintenance at £100-£150k.

Thank you everyone for the support, being entangled in these kind of family dynamics really shapes perspective.

OP posts:
Whatevershallidowithmylife · 20/02/2025 13:15

Another no from me!

Swipe left for the next trending thread