To think fish finger sandwiches should be made with toast and Bacon Sandwiches with bread?

[WindsurfingDreams]

Just idly pondering this as I make bacon sandwiches for lunch for everyone.

DH made me a fish finger sandwich the other day but with bread and it just felt wrong for some reason

Other way around. Every time.

No idea why I capitalised one type of sandwich and not the other...

Other way round.

Toast has no part in a fish finger sandwich. It has to be buttered white bread. That’s the law, you’re welcome.

Not sure where you’ve got that rule from, fish finger sandwiches are best with white bread imho. The poncified version my local gastro pub serves up on brioche is just miserable.

bacon and tomato sandwiches need to be toasted bread to cope with the extra moisture.

Neither should be made with toast!

No, why on earth would you want toast with fish fingers?!

or bacon; to be honest, both should be made with bread.

In both cases, these are my rules

1. Absolutely NO butter or margarine
2. White sliced bread. Not sourdough, or anything artisanal.

😱

I think it's a texture thing for me. Fish finger sandwiches with bread feel too soggy.

I guess I will have to cancel the divorce papers

You're a wrong 'un!

both need soft white bread!

I'd be interested to try it with toast, but certainly my default would always be buttered bread for a fish finger sandwich or a bacon sandwich. Maybe you're on to something. I'm going to give it a try.

This is correct.
Toast is for topping, not containing.

Toast is for club sandwiches only.

I bet you hang the toilet roll with the paper behind too.

YABU for making me crave a bacon sandwich.
The best bacon sandwiches are made by dipping the (white) bread in the bacon fat.

No, bread for fish fingers fir sure bacon can be either

I just balance it precariously on top of the holder

Bacon sandwich made with thickly sliced white bread and real butter. Fish fingers in a buttered large crusty roll/bap with a generous dollop of mushy peas on top with salt and vinegar. You’re welcome.

Toast for a bacon sandwich sometimes but not very toasted and not always. My absolute favourite was when my dad used to make me a bacon sandwich for breakfast before school and then I faffed around getting ready for ages so he'd put it in the hot oven to keep warm. The bread would get slightly crisp but not really toasted. It was lush.

I quite like brown or seeded bread with bacon but fish finger sandwiches should always be on white. And with both butter and a lashing of tartare sauce.

You couldn't be more wrong. Fish finger sandwich with bread, butter and mayonnaise and bacon sandwich with bread, butter and ketchup.

CORRECT!

Yep agree with this!

The solution to that is cooking the fingers properly, not toasting the bread.

better still leave the fingers on the 🐟 & 🐷 alone and buy fishless fingers & plant based 'bacon' 💕

Jury's out on divorce papers... depends on his coffee in bed & tea with butties talents

I’m now cooking bacon.

I've never made either with toast. I'm going to try both.