Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'i would die for my kids' ..but would people really?!

243 replies

ShouldIGoHigher · 19/09/2024 21:34

Had a very interesting discussion today with my mum and wondered other peoples thoughts.

We were talking about how a lot of people say 'i would die for kids' as a testament of how much they love their children but don't actually mean it or really think about what that actually means and actually.. wouldn't.

So in my mind if someone says they would die for them I take that to mean there's nothing on this earth they wouldn't do for them and to keep them safe.
But then so many people say that but yet won't do basic things for their DC if it's at an inconvenience to themselves let alone put themselves in harms way.

Several examples of this from minor to more extreme.

A work colleagues mum and dad wouldn't watch their grandchildren so my colleague could attend a mammogram for possible cancer. They didn't want to use up annual leave for it. Colleague had to postpone to appointment and unfortunately did have cancer. Of course her parents have said 'i wish I could trade places with you!' ..but they wouldn't even use a leave day for a scan?!

A more extreme example, one of my closest childhood friends has recently left an extremely violent man. She took years of absolute hell from him including violent sex attacks. He battered her in the end and caused lifelong injuries.
Before the final attack she had left him. Her parents new all the ins and outs and saw the bruises. When she left they gave all the lip service of he's a bastard and evil etc. gave her praise for leaving. But the police wouldn't do anything to keep her safe. She kept saying she was worried he was going to come and kill her and he said he would. They saw him say it and knew he was capable. Yet.. they did nothing. Didn't want to get involved and instead gave moral support. I understand this for a friend but your own child?!
In the end he did find her and he absolutely battered her.

My mum knows this friend and her family well and the was aghast at the lip service of how they could say in one breath 'id die for my kids' and in the next sit back and watch their daughter's life be under threat.
She said if it were me or my siblings in that situation with the police unable to help then she would've moved into my house during this period of threat or is with her, without question. Then been prepared to spend the remainder of her days behind bars or dead herself than let him lay a hand on her children.
I honestly believe her and know she would. But then when I think of my kids, I know id do the same. I could definitely make peace with going to prison for the rest of my days for my children's life. How can you say your prepared to literally die for your kids but not go to prison to protect them?

There's also people who say they'd die for their kids but yet they'd not help them financially when they themselves are rich and kids are on the breadline etc.

Do these people genuinely believe it when they say it?
What do they actually mean?

Am I being unreasonable when I say loads of people don't truly mean it when they say it?

YABU - parents do mean it
YANBU - it's lip service because it sounds good to a lot of people.

OP posts:
OnlyWhenILaugh · 19/09/2024 21:38

All these people go around saying "I'd die for my kids "?
I've never heard it said other than in a rather throwaway manner.

But I'm certain many parents really would put themselves in danger if it saved their child - especially whilst the dc was a child. I would, but have never said that sentence.

EveryKneeShallBow · 19/09/2024 21:41

I’d step in front of a train to push my child or dgc out of the way and I’d donate a body part, including a heart or something I couldn’t survive without. And yes, I do mean it literally. If one of them needed a lifesaving operation, I’d sell my house without a second thought.

Titsywoo · 19/09/2024 21:44

Well if someone was holding us hostage and they were going to shoot me or one of my kids I would tell them to shoot me so yeah I would die for them

GrazingSheep · 19/09/2024 21:45

My mum died a long time ago. The night she was admitted to hospital with incurable cancer she said she was glad it was her and not one of her babies. That was the last coherent thing she said.

HeySummerWhereAreYou · 19/09/2024 21:45

I don't WANT to die, but if someone was holding me and my 2 DDs hostage, and they said either I have to die, or they do, I would pick me - obviously. I would think someone utterly batshit if they said they'd choose to live - and let their children die.

GreenLambo · 19/09/2024 21:46

I can't comprehend treating any of my children in the way you've described. I'd struggle to treat anyone in that way, let alone my kids. However, I know that my mother is the same, she believes she is a good mother but there is only one thing she's ever done to help us in 15 years. I can't confidently say she would help in either of those situations which is a heartbreaking thing to admit.

DinosaurMunch · 19/09/2024 21:46

Some would, some wouldn't. People are all different. A lot are totally selfish. A lot are all about their own self image.

More talk = less action in my experience.

Littletreefrog · 19/09/2024 21:47

Well if my dying would save them from dying I would do it in a heartbeat. Do I want to pick up the dirty clothes from their floor for the 4th time this week when no ones life is in danger, no I do not.

DancingPhantomsOnTheTerrace · 19/09/2024 21:48

But then so many people say that but yet won't do basic things for their DC if it's at an inconvenience to themself

Well yes - I'd die for my child if the alternative was them dying. That doesn't mean I put their wants before mine all the time.

Your example of the parents of someone being abused is horrible, I would absolutely take my child in in that situation.

Bessica1970 · 19/09/2024 21:49

I would put my own life in danger to protect the lives of my young children.
I’m not sure I would for my adult children though. Not because I don’t love them, but because it might leave my younger children motherless. It’s difficult to imagine in abstract though - maybe instinct would kick in.

I don’t think rich parents need to subsidise their adult children though.

Clumsy12345 · 19/09/2024 21:49

I think people say this about children not adult children.

poppyzbrite4 · 19/09/2024 21:50

I know someone who wanted to tell the police she was responsible for the crime her son had committed as he was going to prison. She was prepared to go to prison for him.

However it really aggravates me when I hear someone living with an abuser say, "I'd do anything for my kids". Except keep them safe, obviously.

parietal · 19/09/2024 21:50

When people say things like that they are thinking of the extreme hostage situation that never actually happens. When they should be thinking of the everyday support and kindness needed with the cancer scan and getting away from the violent ex.

I think people who say "I'd die for them" are the ones who don't actually do the living things that are needed.

Izzadoraduncancan · 19/09/2024 21:51

None of us know how we will react in that situation. During my last labour we experienced a prolapsed cord - I know as they attempted to get consent from me to administer general anaesthetic I told them to forget about me and get me baby out alive

CrouchingTigerHiddenChocolate · 19/09/2024 21:51

I would absolutely die for my kids, and i would kill for them, even though I can't be arsed going snail hunting for the 18th time, or cooking 3 separate dinners, or switch off when they are talking about Minecraft for 45 minutes.

Parenthood is weird.

StressedQueen · 19/09/2024 21:52

I mean these are adults. You don't say this a lot about them I suppose. Most of the time these comments come across from actual children. And yes I'd die for all of my kids, without a second thought.

I don't think you're being unreasonable though because a lot of these situations are quite sad.

CableCar · 19/09/2024 21:52

The scenarios you've given above depend on a lot of factors. It isn't just as black and white as someone taking annual leave to look after their grandkids for a medical appointment... Grandparents honouring a work contract and having limited leave doesn't reflect how much they care and love their child. People show love in different ways and they may be gift givers or verbal affirmers, more so than showing love by acts of service, but it doesn't mean they don't care.
Similar with parents lending their kids money... You can't just forever bail someone out through poor financial decisions...again how much ££ they spend doesn't reflect love.

Beezknees · 19/09/2024 21:52

Well I presume it means if their child's life was in danger they'd do anything to protect them.

I'd die for DS in that scenario.

I wouldn't however always put his wants over my wants in day to day life. It's not even remotely comparable.

The abusive partner scenario, what realistically could the mother have done? Highly doubt she'd be able to physically defend her DD from a grown man.

cuu · 19/09/2024 21:53

I guess it's easier in a way to die for your kid thank make an effort to do something

stayathomer · 19/09/2024 21:54

I always disagree with the rich parents part- if you have x money and are retired, you don’t know how long you’re going to live and you’re not getting a wage, just a crappy pension and you don’t know if you’ll have to pay for your own care so why on earth would you give it away? The rest though, yup would die for my kids! The examples you give are horrible though, scary they didn’t help their kids out there

cuu · 19/09/2024 21:54

CrouchingTigerHiddenChocolate · 19/09/2024 21:51

I would absolutely die for my kids, and i would kill for them, even though I can't be arsed going snail hunting for the 18th time, or cooking 3 separate dinners, or switch off when they are talking about Minecraft for 45 minutes.

Parenthood is weird.

Yeah that's it really!

Wolfpa · 19/09/2024 21:54

I think there is an age limit on the statement. Once a child gets over the age of 18 there is less of an urge to protect

ellie09 · 19/09/2024 21:55

I would die for my child and I would also kill for them.

I dread to think what I would do if I knew somebody intentionally abused or seriously injured them. I would happily go to prison for taking care of that.

3luckystars · 19/09/2024 21:56

I would definitely give them a kidney or anything else they needed but I probably need to stay alive for my other children, so there’s that to think about too.

gannett · 19/09/2024 21:56

"I would die for you" is just words. I don't take it seriously and I don't take anyone who says it seriously. They always imagine they're in a movie scenario (hostages! runaway trains!) but actually dying for someone in real life would probably be a lot more prosaic and painful. And also unnecessary because how many times in your everyday life would this even be a plausible choice?

Easy to say "I'd die for you", much harder to actually show your love in your actions on an everyday basis.

Swipe left for the next trending thread