Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't vote reform

379 replies

Crispynoodle · 02/07/2024 11:20

Obviously I can't tell you who to vote for but then there is this:

news.sky.com/story/second-reform-candidate-quits-and-backs-tories-over-racism-and-misogyny-13162247

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Jumpingthruhoops · 03/07/2024 14:12

Goldenbear · 03/07/2024 14:08

so you are using the terms I used to describe the entitlement of the Reform voters - how is it ‘arrogant’ to have different voting priorities? It is arrogant, like i posted above to think that every other voter should persuade you of their way of thinking, why why should I persuade you to vote for another party, I’m not a politician, if you want to vote for your little worries that are just going to make you poorer, go ahead!

'Little worries'. Oh dear...
And you seriously wonder why Reform are galvanising support?

😂😂

Thumbelinatinylittlething · 03/07/2024 14:14

Whatafustercluck · 03/07/2024 14:06

Wait, wasn't the original premise of Reform (the Brexit Party) that by leaving the EU it would be a silver bullet to solving all of the UK's problems, which all stern from uncontrolled immigration? Well, we've left the EU now and nothing has improved. So was the Brexit Party (I.e. Nigel Farage) wrong that leaving the EU would solve everything? Which is pretty much what he was told at the time, by Remainers on both sides of the political fence. So, now he's standing on a slightly different platform, because he's a self serving opportunist first and foremost.

Also, the old adage remains true: not all Reform voters are racist. But all racists will vote Reform. People intending to vote Reform need to ask themselves whether they're content to lie down with dogs.

Again, you are conflating genuine held concerns about numbers living in this country being too high and not being dealt with, with racism. Most people can differentiate the two.

How Brexit was implemented wasn't in the gift of Nigel Farage. Boris Johnson took the decision to remove restrictions on immigration from non EU countries.

firef1y · 03/07/2024 14:16

Well as at least one Reform candidate compares autistic people to vegetables, I think I'm going to vote for the broccoli party

Thumbelinatinylittlething · 03/07/2024 14:17

Goldenbear · 03/07/2024 14:11

Why do Reform Voters speak like this, they aren’t ‘peoples concerns’ they are some people who vote Reform concerns.

I'm.not a Reform voter.

Recent cross party and national polls have found that immigration has risen from voters 5th concern to 3rd. That's not exclusive to Reform voters; that's all voters.

Thumbelinatinylittlething · 03/07/2024 14:19

Thumbelinatinylittlething · 03/07/2024 14:17

I'm.not a Reform voter.

Recent cross party and national polls have found that immigration has risen from voters 5th concern to 3rd. That's not exclusive to Reform voters; that's all voters.

And if you are dismissing the wide-spread concerns re high immigration levels as just a Reform voter niche issue, you have got your head in the sand.

IwillNOTplayfastandloosewithpublicfinances · 03/07/2024 14:24

“Also, the old adage remains true: not all Reform voters are racist. But all racists will vote Reform.”

EXACTLY THIS

Goldenbear · 03/07/2024 14:24

LadyCrumpet · 03/07/2024 13:23

pretty arrogant to assume your concerns are those of the nation

Brexit showed they are..

they need to engage in discussions about what is important to us, listen to what we are saying about Economic Growth, listen to our concerns about preserving freedom and democracy, listen to our concerns about Climate change etc. whatever the concerns of people voting for different parties are

These issues ARE being talked about. No one is dismissing these topics.

but do Reform Voters think they are the only ones entitled to this special treatment, this accommodation of their feelings.

No one thinks this at all, Reform voters just want the illigal immigration issues addressed, discussed, resolutions found, rather than being dismissed and instantly shouted down as racist for bringing it up.

Edited

Brexit was a marginal vote so not a great argument. Wasn’t Farage moaning about the Romanians and Bulgarians before Brexit, he was even moaning about Europeans working here. So now they’ve gone and he got his Brexit; he’s moaning about migration from further afield, when is he going to stop jumping on band wagons. Equally, please make him stop with this I’m a common geezer clap trap, he went to Dulwich College FFS, I grew up in London not far from Dulwich more West and it was occupied by kids that looked like the characters from People Just Do Nothing, Dulwich College was for Poshos - he is so insincere, who the hell is fulled by this crap!

Whatafustercluck · 03/07/2024 14:26

Thumbelinatinylittlething · 03/07/2024 14:14

Again, you are conflating genuine held concerns about numbers living in this country being too high and not being dealt with, with racism. Most people can differentiate the two.

How Brexit was implemented wasn't in the gift of Nigel Farage. Boris Johnson took the decision to remove restrictions on immigration from non EU countries.

Well, perhaps Reform can help me differentiate the genuine concerns from racism by stopping racists from standing for election and unequivocally condemning what their candidates have said. Dear Nigel has stopped short of doing that, preferring instead to minimise:

"Speaking at a Reform UK event in Boston, Lincolnshire, party leader Nigel Farage said the party was not "perfect".

"We've had one or two candidates that have said things they shouldn't have said," he said. "In most cases they're just speaking like ordinary folk.

"They're not part of the mainstream political Oxbridge speak, we understand that. In some cases one or two people let us down and we let them go."

Minimising racism and extreme prejudice as "oh, they're just speaking like ordinary folk" shows what an abhorrent, odious little toad this man really is.

If Reform really want a sensible conversation about immigration, then they'd do far better to stop fielding racists.

By the way, anti-semitism didn't just explode overnight in 1930s Germany. It crept in off the back of extreme poverty caused by WW1 reparations. Poverty found a voice in a charismatic individual who told the population what they thought they needed to hear ("we'll make everything OK for you"). It just so happened that it was the Jews who were scape goats back then.

Spot any parallels yet?

Thumbelinatinylittlething · 03/07/2024 14:29

Whatafustercluck · 03/07/2024 14:26

Well, perhaps Reform can help me differentiate the genuine concerns from racism by stopping racists from standing for election and unequivocally condemning what their candidates have said. Dear Nigel has stopped short of doing that, preferring instead to minimise:

"Speaking at a Reform UK event in Boston, Lincolnshire, party leader Nigel Farage said the party was not "perfect".

"We've had one or two candidates that have said things they shouldn't have said," he said. "In most cases they're just speaking like ordinary folk.

"They're not part of the mainstream political Oxbridge speak, we understand that. In some cases one or two people let us down and we let them go."

Minimising racism and extreme prejudice as "oh, they're just speaking like ordinary folk" shows what an abhorrent, odious little toad this man really is.

If Reform really want a sensible conversation about immigration, then they'd do far better to stop fielding racists.

By the way, anti-semitism didn't just explode overnight in 1930s Germany. It crept in off the back of extreme poverty caused by WW1 reparations. Poverty found a voice in a charismatic individual who told the population what they thought they needed to hear ("we'll make everything OK for you"). It just so happened that it was the Jews who were scape goats back then.

Spot any parallels yet?

No I don't. Not everything is the same as Nazi Germany. That was a very specific set of circumstances that are not replicated in the UK of 2024.

I do agree with you that unsavoury types will be attracted to Reform and that is something they will need to get a handle on before they can start to get taken seriously.

Jutemat · 03/07/2024 14:30

Seems to be a big push on local facebook page groups for Reform. Not sure it thats representative or if it just tells you about the average facebook local group user!

Goldenbear · 03/07/2024 14:31

Thumbelinatinylittlething · 03/07/2024 14:17

I'm.not a Reform voter.

Recent cross party and national polls have found that immigration has risen from voters 5th concern to 3rd. That's not exclusive to Reform voters; that's all voters.

You aren’t a Reform voter, I actually thought you maybe working to their campaign office, doing your best to drum up support in the last 24 hrs that’s why I asked if he could drop the London relatable geezer act with his Dulwich College schooling 😂

IwillNOTplayfastandloosewithpublicfinances · 03/07/2024 14:33

Unbelievable that Farage’s response to that Reform campaigner who was filmed saying that the army should shoot illegal immigrants from the cliffs of Deal and the horrific racial slur about Sunak was to argue that the whole thing is a conspiracy by Channel 4.

FFS Nigel. Own it. Deal with it.

Stop all this pathetic whinging that the BBC and now Channel 4 are in a conspiracy against you. The problem is YOU and the racists you give a platform to. How stupid do you think people are?

Auvergne63 · 03/07/2024 14:38

Thumbelinatinylittlething · 03/07/2024 12:46

The Telegraph is. I don't read the Mail. Presumably you read both to be able to compare them with the Guardian. I've read the Guardian and it's quality is reflected in its readership figures, although the cookery/restaurant section is very good.

I was actually being sarcastic!

Thumbelinatinylittlething · 03/07/2024 14:38

Goldenbear · 03/07/2024 14:31

You aren’t a Reform voter, I actually thought you maybe working to their campaign office, doing your best to drum up support in the last 24 hrs that’s why I asked if he could drop the London relatable geezer act with his Dulwich College schooling 😂

Yes that really was a great gag. Well done. And you've said it twice too for extra comedy.

Reform doesn't have a monopoly on concern about high levels of immigration. As previously mentioned, it is a concern shared across the political spectrum.

cupcaske123 · 03/07/2024 14:39

Apparently there was a car emblazoned with Reform blasting out Land of Hope and Glory in the local high street yesterday. Desperate times.

Thumbelinatinylittlething · 03/07/2024 14:39

Auvergne63 · 03/07/2024 14:38

I was actually being sarcastic!

I know

Whatafustercluck · 03/07/2024 14:41

Thumbelinatinylittlething · 03/07/2024 14:29

No I don't. Not everything is the same as Nazi Germany. That was a very specific set of circumstances that are not replicated in the UK of 2024.

I do agree with you that unsavoury types will be attracted to Reform and that is something they will need to get a handle on before they can start to get taken seriously.

No, we haven't had a world war. But we have had large amounts of the population destabilised by the poverty created by a global pandemic, which followed hot on the heels of a disastrous Brexit deal. And total mismanagement by the sitting government. It's not too much of a stretch to see how the social conditions in the UK, Europe and across the Atlantic are perfect for the rise of the far right and another charismatic leader telling people what they want to hear whilst scapegoating and 'othering' large swathes of the population. Take one of Reform's flagship policies: higher taxes for companies who employ immigrants. Isn't that straight out of the Nazi play book? So yes, I'm extremely wary of parties who say they want a proper conversation about immigration, whilst simultaneously refusing to accept that there is a whole host of other reasons, besides immigration, that we're in the state we're in.

Goldenbear · 03/07/2024 14:43

Thumbelinatinylittlething · 03/07/2024 14:38

Yes that really was a great gag. Well done. And you've said it twice too for extra comedy.

Reform doesn't have a monopoly on concern about high levels of immigration. As previously mentioned, it is a concern shared across the political spectrum.

Well it kind of does, oh yes, I forgot about them, the Conservatives have their Rwanda plan.

IwillNOTplayfastandloosewithpublicfinances · 03/07/2024 14:44

“Geezer of the people.” Ha! The man is an ex-public school banker.

Do depressing that he can put on his tweed jacket and red waistcoat and be filmed with a pint in a pub and some people seem to think he’s ‘oh look, Nigel’s one of us.’

Meanwhile, he’s talking about giving tax breaks to those who pay school fees.

We pay school fees - why would we get a tax break for that?

He excuses casual racism by saying, “that’s how people talk in pubs.” WTF!

What pubs are these Nigel? Only the ones you are aware of and drawn to, like a rat to shit.

He knows exactly who and what he is appealing to and the rest is just fluff. He plays the game of the acceptable face of racism, but it’s a thin veneer.

Thumbelinatinylittlething · 03/07/2024 14:47

Goldenbear · 03/07/2024 14:43

Well it kind of does, oh yes, I forgot about them, the Conservatives have their Rwanda plan.

I don't mean the political parties sorry, I mean the voters or whoever has a political opinion. High levels of immigration is a concern for both those of the left and right persuasion.

Auvergne63 · 03/07/2024 15:08

IwillNOTplayfastandloosewithpublicfinances · 03/07/2024 13:38

Farage is a vile hypocrite.

He deliberately targets the very worst sentiments in society. He cynically appeals to the most dispossessed, who just want something / someone to blame, as well as people who are xenophobes and particularly unpleasant.

If all the constituencies he could stand in - he chooses Clacton. A place he would never touch with a barge pole otherwise.

In the same way as Hitler rose to power in an economically shattered Germany by promising to make Germany great again and blaming ‘others’ (ie the Jews), this is exactly the tactic Farage takes. He He is a nasty, cynical piece of work and he knows it.

All this ‘man of the people’ malarkey - he was educated at Dulwich College. I know one of his kids is (was) at a particular boarding school because I know someone who was at that school. Yet, people think that his photo ops, with a pint in a pub, make him ‘one of the people.’ What does he know about poverty or poor education.

He was almost expelled from his public school for expressing fascist ideology.

This man made his whole adult life had been agitating for Brexit. What does he do the day after the vote? RESIGN!

Since then he has wittered on and on about how govts have not done Brexit right. But what did he do to show us the great benefits of this Brexit he campaigned (lied) for - NOTHING.

Does he not see the irony of going to the D-Day memorial when he is, in 2024, forming a political party that the Nazis would approve of?

He is disgusting.

Totally agree with you.
He tried to obtain a German passport two months after the Brexit referendum, a claim he has never denied. If people did a quick search, they would find some of his racist, xenophobic, sexist and Islamophobic comments; too many to quote.
How he presents himself and who he truly is are two different things.
Let's not forget that he has toxic connections to extreme and far-right figures across the world, and Thatcherite beliefs that he has tried to hide from communities in former industrial towns.

OneTC · 03/07/2024 15:18

Would be quite funny if they won though

Thumbelinatinylittlething · 03/07/2024 15:18

Auvergne63 · 03/07/2024 15:08

Totally agree with you.
He tried to obtain a German passport two months after the Brexit referendum, a claim he has never denied. If people did a quick search, they would find some of his racist, xenophobic, sexist and Islamophobic comments; too many to quote.
How he presents himself and who he truly is are two different things.
Let's not forget that he has toxic connections to extreme and far-right figures across the world, and Thatcherite beliefs that he has tried to hide from communities in former industrial towns.

"Thatcherite beliefs". It's fairly obvious to anyone sentinent that he holds those and that's nothing to be ashamed of. Margaret Thatcher was the biggest enabler of social mobility in the 80s.

The rest I can't comment on. The passport thing if true is disappointing. Regarding the "racist, xenophobic, sexist and Islamophobic" comments it would be useful if you could set those out in context so we can have a proper look and discussion.

EasternStandard · 03/07/2024 15:24

IwillNOTplayfastandloosewithpublicfinances · 03/07/2024 14:01

Another disgusting example if Farage’s racism was his retort to Laura K when she challenged him on his comment that Sunsk’s early departure from the D Day memorial was evidence that he does not share “our” values.

His way around the racism charge was to point out that many from the Commonwealth fought alongside Britain in the war.

Well that may be so but WTF does that have to do with Sunak who was born in the U.K. and therefore as British as Farage is?!

How dare he.

My husband is of Indian heritage - he is not not a ‘commonwealth person’ who deserves a patronising pay in the back by the likes of Farage. He was born here. He is British.

This is aside from the issue of the an colonised people being required to fight in the side of the coloniser.

I understand you here and I wasn’t happy about that whole D Day take

I do think this unrest will grow as we see more of the same pressure after Labour get in. I would have taken policy but it’s about to be scrapped. The new approach will likely see the rise of trafficking and with that a rise in backlash.

It is possible to avoid this, all this rising tension here and EU - see Aus for example. Border control is bipartisan and hardline. It’s frustrating to watch how we are dealing with it.

IwillNOTplayfastandloosewithpublicfinances · 03/07/2024 15:24

Sadly, he will probably win in Clacton tomorrow. Does this mean -

a) He will have to buy a house in Clacton and actually spend lengths of time there?

b) He will have to give up his shows in GB news and LBC?

I suppose every cloud has a silver lining.

Swipe left for the next trending thread