Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be sick of DP's ex wife's demands

1000 replies

forestcookie · 02/07/2024 10:55

The dc live with her primarily but DP does loads. He takes the dc to school 2 mornings a week so she can go to work early and miss the traffic, he has to be at her house for 7.45am. He picks the children up once or twice a week, depending if it's his weekend or not - has them EOW for 3 nights. He would pick them up more but he works late 3 nights a week. He is on 25k, she is on something like 40k but she has standard office hours - 9-5, no late nights etc. He is in a tiny rented 1 bedroom flat, she has a large 3 bedroom house with a garden, driveway etc. She also gets child benefit and UC help, DP doesn't see any of that.

DP has just given her £300 towards their swimming lessons and summer holiday clubs - his "half", IMO she should pay more because she earns more, and I don't know why he is paying towards childcare because UC pay for it, but he didn't want her to kick off.

Now he usually picks up the children on Wednesday nights from after school club, again this enables her to work. She has just told him that tomorrow night she is going to see a friend for dinner and won't be back until 9.30pm. DP usually likes to leave her house by 9pm so he can get home and have dinner and prepare for work the next day. DP has told her this and she has kicked off saying she doesn't have a life or time to socialise (she does). I don't think she should be going out that night anyway, because DP has to be in her house without her which I don't really like. He has offered to have the kids overnight Wednesday nights but the dc don't want this.

AIBU to tell DP to put his foot down? He is knackered all the time from working late or looking after the DC while she gets to earn more and get home late as long as he is looking after them!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
AuntMarch · 07/07/2024 11:52

Him having the kids at their home is better for them when it's until 9pm. Suck it up.

AuntMarch · 07/07/2024 11:58

forestcookie · 03/07/2024 14:19

he shouldn't have to pay for 2x new wardrobes for them when the kids are only at his flat 2 weekends a month and they have more than enough clothes at their mum's house that DP has contributed to in the past!!! some of the stuff they used to wear is m&s, frugi etc not exactly cheap outfits

If what he contributed to doesn't fit any more, that's irrelevant

jrc1071 · 07/07/2024 13:09

Aylestone · 02/07/2024 11:11

Every other weekend and a few school runs is fuck all! And so is his financial contribution! Seeing as she’s the primary carer and he only has them a few days a month, he should be earning more than her and contributing far more than what he is. You seem to think he’s doing her a favour or something, when all he’s doing is helping facilitate her looking after his kids almost full time. You say he’d have them more but he can’t because of work, so she has no choice but to have them as much as she does. His small contribution to this is a couple of drop offs to enable her to get to work, so she can pay for and look after their kids, which he should be doing!

Edited

This. And I am seeing it a little differently.

If the father needs to take a job that is less paying to provide childcare (which a few nights a month and 2 school pick ups a week--- that is NOTHING), it would make sense if he is providing the appropriate 50% childcare. I mean, society still seems to expect women to do this ALL THE TIME including dropping out of the workforce to provide free, unpaid labor in the home.

He is barely doing 5% of the childcare. And we do not know if he is even paying child support.

So IMO it seems he is ok with earning less... I mean, he could get a much better job as he is not truly parenting. He has the time to do so.

So stop knocking on the mother. She is pulling MORE than her equal share and they BOTH has the kids.

And like most have already said-- none of your business. That is his to manage. If you do not want these complications, and a BF that earns a higher income that he can invest more in you, do not date men with children. That is on you.

upthehills1 · 07/07/2024 14:18

Coolmom81 · 06/07/2024 14:31

What she earns is completely irrelevant. They are not a couple so they don’t share their income. Good for her if she has a reasonably paid job - it’s not her fault your DP is on minimum wage. He’s got 3 children to support do is about time he pulls his finger out and earns enough to support them. He should be paying half of the cost to bring up their children. Do you not get that?!?

Paying ‘half’ the cost of the children isnt just a blanket rule… if someone earns £250k and the other parent £30k, they can never be 50/50 whether they’re a couple or separated.

Now the income disparity here isn’t quite that level, but there’s still a difference. If mum wants to buy the DC expensive things that he can’t afford how is he supposed to pay for it?

Many children in low income households only have basic needs met unfortunately, and this guy has a low income household. Everyone saying things like ‘he should pull his socks up’ and get a higher paid job… oh yeah that’s so easy, just go out and earn 6 figures!

Liahshi · 07/07/2024 14:22

Not being rude but your sounding like a hater and it not any of your business how much she earns or how she lives he’s only your boyfriend not your husband pray for yourself and worry about getting your money up to help him out if that’s the case hun !!!

TheAlchemy · 07/07/2024 14:23

I think that maybe having a DP that has existing children is not for you OP. You are absolutely clueless and I can only hope you’re not single parenting one day, you will be in for a hell of a shock.

put this one back for his sake and for yours and move on to the next victim.

Coffeerum · 07/07/2024 14:28

upthehills1 · 07/07/2024 14:18

Paying ‘half’ the cost of the children isnt just a blanket rule… if someone earns £250k and the other parent £30k, they can never be 50/50 whether they’re a couple or separated.

Now the income disparity here isn’t quite that level, but there’s still a difference. If mum wants to buy the DC expensive things that he can’t afford how is he supposed to pay for it?

Many children in low income households only have basic needs met unfortunately, and this guy has a low income household. Everyone saying things like ‘he should pull his socks up’ and get a higher paid job… oh yeah that’s so easy, just go out and earn 6 figures!

This all falls apart when you acknowledge that the ex wife isn’t demanding he pay half for expensive things he can’t afford and he did have a job earning significantly more which he chose to leave, apparently for his kids but I’m struggling to see any way in which it was for their benefit really as he doesn’t see them more and just financially contributes less.

upthehills1 · 07/07/2024 15:16

Coffeerum · 07/07/2024 14:28

This all falls apart when you acknowledge that the ex wife isn’t demanding he pay half for expensive things he can’t afford and he did have a job earning significantly more which he chose to leave, apparently for his kids but I’m struggling to see any way in which it was for their benefit really as he doesn’t see them more and just financially contributes less.

She mentioned about going to a more expensive gym pool for swimming rather than council pool so I guess that’s one example. Minimum wage earners would probably have to go to the council pool!

Yes I also don’t understand why he has taken lower paid work so I agree this is odd. Only makes sense if the parents had agreed he would do this and pick up more childcare duties, feels strange if it wasn’t discussed between them when he made that change.

Phoenixfire1988 · 07/07/2024 15:32

He doesn't do loads let's be honest he's not even a part time parent when he has them 6 days a month when she has them the other 25 !! You sound resentful that some of his time and money is going to his children not you you need to find someone without baggage because you sound ridiculous and childish

GillianCarole · 07/07/2024 15:40

forestcookie · 02/07/2024 10:55

The dc live with her primarily but DP does loads. He takes the dc to school 2 mornings a week so she can go to work early and miss the traffic, he has to be at her house for 7.45am. He picks the children up once or twice a week, depending if it's his weekend or not - has them EOW for 3 nights. He would pick them up more but he works late 3 nights a week. He is on 25k, she is on something like 40k but she has standard office hours - 9-5, no late nights etc. He is in a tiny rented 1 bedroom flat, she has a large 3 bedroom house with a garden, driveway etc. She also gets child benefit and UC help, DP doesn't see any of that.

DP has just given her £300 towards their swimming lessons and summer holiday clubs - his "half", IMO she should pay more because she earns more, and I don't know why he is paying towards childcare because UC pay for it, but he didn't want her to kick off.

Now he usually picks up the children on Wednesday nights from after school club, again this enables her to work. She has just told him that tomorrow night she is going to see a friend for dinner and won't be back until 9.30pm. DP usually likes to leave her house by 9pm so he can get home and have dinner and prepare for work the next day. DP has told her this and she has kicked off saying she doesn't have a life or time to socialise (she does). I don't think she should be going out that night anyway, because DP has to be in her house without her which I don't really like. He has offered to have the kids overnight Wednesday nights but the dc don't want this.

AIBU to tell DP to put his foot down? He is knackered all the time from working late or looking after the DC while she gets to earn more and get home late as long as he is looking after them!

She doesn't get CB - the children do, irrespective of which parent they live with.

GillianCarole · 07/07/2024 15:48

If she is earning £40k a year she definitely doesn't get Universal Credit. You need to be sure of your facts if you are going to say anything to him. Better still, don't say anything - he's not actually paying that much towards the children. She may be earning more - that doesn't mean he can contribute less.

Outofmydepth3 · 07/07/2024 17:41

forestcookie · 02/07/2024 10:55

The dc live with her primarily but DP does loads. He takes the dc to school 2 mornings a week so she can go to work early and miss the traffic, he has to be at her house for 7.45am. He picks the children up once or twice a week, depending if it's his weekend or not - has them EOW for 3 nights. He would pick them up more but he works late 3 nights a week. He is on 25k, she is on something like 40k but she has standard office hours - 9-5, no late nights etc. He is in a tiny rented 1 bedroom flat, she has a large 3 bedroom house with a garden, driveway etc. She also gets child benefit and UC help, DP doesn't see any of that.

DP has just given her £300 towards their swimming lessons and summer holiday clubs - his "half", IMO she should pay more because she earns more, and I don't know why he is paying towards childcare because UC pay for it, but he didn't want her to kick off.

Now he usually picks up the children on Wednesday nights from after school club, again this enables her to work. She has just told him that tomorrow night she is going to see a friend for dinner and won't be back until 9.30pm. DP usually likes to leave her house by 9pm so he can get home and have dinner and prepare for work the next day. DP has told her this and she has kicked off saying she doesn't have a life or time to socialise (she does). I don't think she should be going out that night anyway, because DP has to be in her house without her which I don't really like. He has offered to have the kids overnight Wednesday nights but the dc don't want this.

AIBU to tell DP to put his foot down? He is knackered all the time from working late or looking after the DC while she gets to earn more and get home late as long as he is looking after them!

@forestcookie he is their parent as much as she is. He doesn't have them 50/50 he has them less. Her earning more is none of your business, nor his and it's not relevant unless he is their primary care giver which he is not-his ex is.
To simplify, you wouldn't say to a restaurant owner "that lady over there earns more than me so I should pay less for my food!" Also on childcare, her mother having the kids or any childcare arrangements that she makes does not mean their father should parent less 🤦🏼‍♀️ why the heck would it?! I'm baffled at your reasoning

Domesticatedstillalittleferral · 07/07/2024 18:57

Honestly you sound bitter and jealous.
Your boyfriend doesn't really contribute much to the children, time or money wise. Having an issue because she has her mum pick up the kids sometimes is nothing to do with you or your boyfriend, she's arranged help because she's out there working to provide for her kids. Likewise, you seemingly having and issue that she's consolidated her hours into 4 days is nothing to do with you. She's doing what she has to do to provide a decent life for herself and her children, with minimal help from their father.
You say you don't want your own kids, but tbh it sounds like a relationship without step kids would suit you better. Whether it's your current boyfriend, or any other man you just don't seem to grasp how much a mother has to do, or what your partner should be doing.

And let's be real, saying she needs to provide clothing for his house because you saw their pjs were £35. She could have got them on sale, as a gift, 2nd hand, even if she did spend that much it isn't your business. I can only imajow you'd act towards her if you did meet the kids and become established in their lives.

StormingNorman · 07/07/2024 21:38

Well that thread didn’t go as planned 😂

XChrome · 07/07/2024 21:57

So, to sum up what almost every single reply is saying;

  1. You are jealous of his ex and full of spite because her lifestyle seems to be better than yours. Grow up. If you want a change in lifestyle, work towards it like she did. Don't depend on your brokeass, deadbeat little bitch of a boyfriend to give it to you.

  2. You know nothing about childrearing or what it costs to raise them. Shut up about her parenting and choices. Mind your own damn business.

  3. Your boyfriend hardly does anything for his kids and does not contribute financially to any acceptable degree. To say he does "loads" is bullshit. The only loads are the ones he puts in you when he uses you for a fucktoy.

  4. He doesn't want you around his kids. That suggests he is leading you on if he's saying he wants something permanent. He probably realizes you aren't exactly the maternal type. He may even want to get his ex back, which you suspect and are jealous of.

  5. He is not going to be able to afford a house and the pittance he pays for his kids every now and then isn't the reason. Get a clue FFS.

  6. Find somebody without kids, because you'd make a horrible step-mother if he ever decided to have a real relationship with you. The relationship you have now isn't serious and you're kidding yourself. He's using you.

  7. His complaints about having to pay anything towards his children are contemptible. His complaints about his ex are nonsense. He sucks. You deserve each other, but the kids deserve much better than him.

Did I miss anything?

So there you have it OP. The jury has come in. It's time to accept the verdict.

FTMaz · 07/07/2024 22:16

He sounds like a good guy and is working with his ex to support the children. However when you say he is doing ‘loads’ he really isn’t…

I don’t really know why you’re so worked up about it, isn’t the fact he is working with his ex and being there for his kids a positive trait in a partner? Are you quite young and childless?

Lokisbiggestfan · 07/07/2024 22:43

forestcookie · 02/07/2024 18:32

I am struggling to keep up with this thread !

Ex gets 85% of childcare costs back through UC. Yet she still expects (and DP pays) 50% from DP. so she is actually making a profit !! She sends DP the invoices so I can see how much they cost.

it is very much my business because we are saving to buy a house together. This will mean the dc can have their own room.

They are divorced and she bought him out of the house so he has some for a deposit but we live in a very expensive area and so he hasn't bought another property yet because his wage is low. Her house is worth at an estimate 390k but we will not be able to afford that !!! She has benefitted hugely from the rise in house prices. they bought the house for 300k. and now DP will not be able to use that money to buy an equivalent property.

I don't see why dp should have to remain single because he has children. he deserves a life outside the kids and work and if the ex hasn't moved on yet well that's not his problem. i love him and i want us to have a future together. i already know that i do not want children of my own, he doesn't want more either , so that is not going to be an issue.

On wednesdays he doesn't leave as soon as she gets home because he wants to spend time with the dc and like I have already explained , they don't want to stay in his flat during the week.
I agree his flat situation is unfortunate but we are both working hard to change that.

my dp and his ex are both late 30s

Then you have a dp problem not an ex problem. If DP is staying past her getting home then she is free to do what she wants when he is there. If you are uncomfortable with him being at her home with his kids then that is on him. He could take them to his house and he doesn’t so that’s that.

kkloo · 07/07/2024 23:11

upthehills1 · 07/07/2024 14:18

Paying ‘half’ the cost of the children isnt just a blanket rule… if someone earns £250k and the other parent £30k, they can never be 50/50 whether they’re a couple or separated.

Now the income disparity here isn’t quite that level, but there’s still a difference. If mum wants to buy the DC expensive things that he can’t afford how is he supposed to pay for it?

Many children in low income households only have basic needs met unfortunately, and this guy has a low income household. Everyone saying things like ‘he should pull his socks up’ and get a higher paid job… oh yeah that’s so easy, just go out and earn 6 figures!

He's earning 25k, getting help with his rent, he has a lump sum from when the ex bought him out and he doesn't pay maintenance because he doesn't earn enough apparently, he clearly hasn't declared his whole income or his lump sum or he wouldn't be getting any help with his rent.

He's paid her £300 twice this year by the sounds of it, of course he can afford that, he clearly just resents having to pay anything towards his kids.

kkloo · 07/07/2024 23:13

FTMaz · 07/07/2024 22:16

He sounds like a good guy and is working with his ex to support the children. However when you say he is doing ‘loads’ he really isn’t…

I don’t really know why you’re so worked up about it, isn’t the fact he is working with his ex and being there for his kids a positive trait in a partner? Are you quite young and childless?

I wouldn't see this man as a good guy or think it was a positive trait seeing as he appears to constantly moaning whenever he had to do any parenting or make any financial contributions.
Sounds like whatever he's doing he's doing it reluctantly, and making out he's doing favours for the ex. Definitely not a positive trait.

FTMaz · 07/07/2024 23:15

kkloo · 07/07/2024 23:13

I wouldn't see this man as a good guy or think it was a positive trait seeing as he appears to constantly moaning whenever he had to do any parenting or make any financial contributions.
Sounds like whatever he's doing he's doing it reluctantly, and making out he's doing favours for the ex. Definitely not a positive trait.

I didn’t get that vibe from the post. It sounded to me like he was trying and it was the OP moaning.

FTMaz · 07/07/2024 23:18

FTMaz · 07/07/2024 23:15

I didn’t get that vibe from the post. It sounded to me like he was trying and it was the OP moaning.

I retract my statement…I didn’t read the whole thread and have just seen other things the OP has said. They both sound like idiots.

fair play to the ex for making sure SHE is financially able to provide for her kids.

kkloo · 07/07/2024 23:18

@FTMaz
The fact that she knows absolutely everything about the exes finances and how much her house has went up in value and what pjyamas she's sending the kids in etc (despite never meeting them) makes me believe her boyfriend has to be the one telling her all this information, and I can't see why he'd be telling her if he wasn't complaining!

FTMaz · 07/07/2024 23:23

kkloo · 07/07/2024 23:18

@FTMaz
The fact that she knows absolutely everything about the exes finances and how much her house has went up in value and what pjyamas she's sending the kids in etc (despite never meeting them) makes me believe her boyfriend has to be the one telling her all this information, and I can't see why he'd be telling her if he wasn't complaining!

Agreed. He should be happy that his ex lives in a nice house and can raise the children there. I think OP must be quite young.

Pemba · 07/07/2024 23:53

She's 29,she says earlier in the thread. And doesn't want kids, which is probably a good thing, as she doesn't seem to have any insight into the responsibilities of being a parent. Or empathy towards the kids and their mother.

vodkaredbullgirl · 08/07/2024 01:16

And to close the post at 1000 😃

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.