Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tell me what to say: DD and arrogant BF

272 replies

ODFOx · 24/05/2024 22:20

Please bear with me (it's long)
She's the youngest and last one to go to Uni (this year). Her Dad died when she was 11, her self worth is poor and her self belief is less that zero (in spite of all our efforts).
She's beautiful, clever, funny, artistically talented and terribly troubled.
Current BF (although apparently they aren't dating although they spend every evening together and are intimate (this is linking not dating?) ), seems to be horrid to her: tells her she needs to be prettier and calmer and not swear and change her clothes etc etc before he can introduce her to his parents, that she shouldn't talk about losing her father, that being accepted to a fine art degree isn't a proper degree, that she needs to dress better, speak better, behave better.
At this stage I know neither this young man (not saying boy or lad) or his parents and he seems a bit of an idiot to me, but it's important to her that we make a good impression.
Anyhoo, he's coming for Sunday dinner, one of a group of 12 (16 total) and she has told us that his Mother is a trained chef and he 'despises parents who can't cook well', as well as a string of opinions on a range of topics that make me want to poke him in the eye and DH was to punch him on the nose.
I won't be cowed on dinner and will churn out the usual 'pick what you want and we won't mind either way and if there's really nothing you fancy I'm happy to make egg or beans on toast' but...
He's going to make judgements and comments about us, our home, the food we serve and the life we
lead; and while I already don't rate his opinion I know that DD cares very much. I honestly have nothing in my practical or emotional battery to help her right now, without actually being rude to him.

Please can anyone help me with stock phrases and tips to keep calm? DD likes him even though she can see that he isn't kind to her.
He treats her disrespectfully and it makes me furious given that he's also telling her how to behave to be acceptable to meet his family.
I struggle with small talk. Can anyone help me with innocuous phrases to help an introvert aspi (DS) and me (NT but knackered), navigate the way though without causing to much anguish between DD and him, or her and me. Thanks

OP posts:
Olivia2495 · 25/05/2024 17:00

Come on everyone, this little fucker isn't going to barge into the house and start being a prick in front of 14 other guests. We all know the type, he's a typical bully who will be a grovelling wimp in front of anyone apart from the dd.

If the prospect of having a guest causes you so much anxiety you have to start a thread about how to respond to their abusive comments, that guest should not be invited, no matter who they are. You’ve made a rod for your own back op by indulging your daughter and creating an audience for this nobhead.

He is going to feel really really important. More fool you. This is what I mean about boundaries. If your daughter wants to listen to his bullshit and create an audience for him she can. It doesn’t mean you have to.

Your post is asking how do I deal with my daughters abusive boyfriend. The simple answer is that you don’t. Your daughter deals with him privately away from the family.

Ohlookwhoitis · 25/05/2024 17:00

Waterlooo · 25/05/2024 16:39

his behaviour being asking her to not swear in front of his parents.

Really? Is that all? That's what you got from this entire thread and all OPs posts?
Why is that the only bit you're mentioning?

tells her she needs to be prettier and calmer and not swear and change her clothes etc etc before he can introduce her to his parents, that she shouldn't talk about losing her father, that being accepted to a fine art degree isn't a proper degree, that she needs to dress better, speak better, behave better

Ohlookwhoitis · 25/05/2024 17:01

mrstreacle · 25/05/2024 16:55

That's what I was thinking too

He's not hiding it very well is he?

Waterlooo · 25/05/2024 17:08

daisychain01 · 25/05/2024 16:43

Fair enough, but wouldn't you give him one chance to see how he behaves before making any rash judgment about him, especially as the OP says in their first post

At this stage I know neither this young man (not saying boy or lad) or his parents so getting all information about him second hand and never having met him before!

Surely it would model the right behaviours to the DD to be measured and calm about this before writing him off as an abuser.

doesn't mean you can't change your mind and explain that you wanted him to have the opportunity to show he could be civilised and respectful, but he's shown who he is, with examples of his behaviour to illustrate why it's unacceptable.

Edited

Exactly, she hasn’t met this man before and she admits her daughter is troubled.

Maybe he’s a ghastly individual. Or maybe this second hand information has been embellished by her daughter. Or maybe the OP is very protective of her daughter and has embellished things herself.

Maybe the daughter has said she doesn’t feel smart enough to meet his parents, and he’s said it can wait until she feels prettier.

I say many things in private which I wouldn’t share with a wider audience. I don’t like eating a diet full of ultra processed food, for example. I can see how that can be twisted into “I don’t like people who can’t cook”.

The point is no one actually knows and the sensible thing is to reserve judgment until you can find out for yourself.

Waterlooo · 25/05/2024 17:09

Ohlookwhoitis · 25/05/2024 17:01

He's not hiding it very well is he?

You seem obsessed with me.

JLou08 · 25/05/2024 17:10

daisychain01 · 25/05/2024 16:43

Fair enough, but wouldn't you give him one chance to see how he behaves before making any rash judgment about him, especially as the OP says in their first post

At this stage I know neither this young man (not saying boy or lad) or his parents so getting all information about him second hand and never having met him before!

Surely it would model the right behaviours to the DD to be measured and calm about this before writing him off as an abuser.

doesn't mean you can't change your mind and explain that you wanted him to have the opportunity to show he could be civilised and respectful, but he's shown who he is, with examples of his behaviour to illustrate why it's unacceptable.

Edited

No, I wouldn't feel the need to verify my daughters version of events.
Abusive men are very good at putting on a show and being charming. Would you doubt your daughter if you were charmed by a man she told you was abusive?

Ohlookwhoitis · 25/05/2024 17:10

Maybe the daughter has said she doesn’t feel smart enough to meet his parents, and he’s said it can wait until she feels prettier

What does 'feels prettier' mean? Can you elaborate?

Ohlookwhoitis · 25/05/2024 17:12

Waterlooo · 25/05/2024 17:09

You seem obsessed with me.

Of course you would say that. We've already established you're an Andrew Tate fan. Now you've been called out for defending abusive behavior, you're calling me names and trying to gaslight me. Textbook.

1mabon · 25/05/2024 17:16

Tell her to run as fast as she can, he's a real b....d.

Tillievanilly · 25/05/2024 17:35

If he’s rude ask him to repeat. Then ask him if he’s ok that came across harsh etc. Then turn it back on him I’m wondering why you said that. If he is a clever toxic type he will be nice as put in front of other people won’t he….
You need to play in carefully as you don’t want him refusing to come to your house and she spends her whole time at his. Hopefully she will come to her senses I did at that age!

Conniebygaslight · 25/05/2024 17:46

Think yourself lucky he’s coming to your house. Our beautiful 18 year DD is in a dreadfully abusive relationship and he refuses to acknowledge anyone in her world. As a result she is becoming more and more distant from us, she’s lost all her friends and her life is totally focussed on his needs and wants. It’s an awful place to be and I wouldn’t wish it on my worst enemy.

Hugosmaid · 25/05/2024 17:54

Olivia2495 · 25/05/2024 17:00

Come on everyone, this little fucker isn't going to barge into the house and start being a prick in front of 14 other guests. We all know the type, he's a typical bully who will be a grovelling wimp in front of anyone apart from the dd.

If the prospect of having a guest causes you so much anxiety you have to start a thread about how to respond to their abusive comments, that guest should not be invited, no matter who they are. You’ve made a rod for your own back op by indulging your daughter and creating an audience for this nobhead.

He is going to feel really really important. More fool you. This is what I mean about boundaries. If your daughter wants to listen to his bullshit and create an audience for him she can. It doesn’t mean you have to.

Your post is asking how do I deal with my daughters abusive boyfriend. The simple answer is that you don’t. Your daughter deals with him privately away from the family.

This. I was going to say very similar.

This is not a game. Your daughter is in an abusive relationship and you’ve invited him in to your home to be the star guest.

If you want her to start putting down some boundaries - you need to do it yourself.

You’ve put yourself in a position where he will have ammunition to pull her family apart. I’d honestly cancel.

If she wants a sit down meal then you go out to eat away from the safeness of her home.

There is absolutely nothing you can do to stop her being in a relationship with him - nothing. What you can do is set a boundary for yourself and impress how important she is and how much you love her.

She tells you these things because she knows they are wrong. At what point are you going to say anything ?

BreatheAndFocus · 25/05/2024 17:59

Pretend you think he’s joking if he makes a rude or unkind comment. “Art is a stupid degree” - “Yeah, that’s what they told Leonardo da Vinci” then snigger. DD needs to be prettier? Laugh like you think he’s joking and then smile proudly and tell him how people often comment on her beauty.

Seriously, your DD is worth more than this jumped up prick. Never directly criticise him. Try to get her to see the light herself, maybe by asking her if she’d say those unkind things or if she’d be happy if a friend had a BF who talked like that about her.

This arrogant little fellow sounds grossly insecure, as well as a bully. If I was mean, I’d tell him that to his face. Just let him ramble on about how much he knows/does and how brilliant he is, and nod along. If you let him take over all the talk hopefully your DD will see how conceited and full of himself he is.

ChickyBricky · 25/05/2024 18:06

Be prepared for him to be nothing like you imagine.

Maybe take the heat off by making a joke of it, "We've heard that your mum is a trained chef, so feel free to run away if our best efforts here are intolerable."

StoneAgeRed · 25/05/2024 18:11

ODFOx · 24/05/2024 22:20

Please bear with me (it's long)
She's the youngest and last one to go to Uni (this year). Her Dad died when she was 11, her self worth is poor and her self belief is less that zero (in spite of all our efforts).
She's beautiful, clever, funny, artistically talented and terribly troubled.
Current BF (although apparently they aren't dating although they spend every evening together and are intimate (this is linking not dating?) ), seems to be horrid to her: tells her she needs to be prettier and calmer and not swear and change her clothes etc etc before he can introduce her to his parents, that she shouldn't talk about losing her father, that being accepted to a fine art degree isn't a proper degree, that she needs to dress better, speak better, behave better.
At this stage I know neither this young man (not saying boy or lad) or his parents and he seems a bit of an idiot to me, but it's important to her that we make a good impression.
Anyhoo, he's coming for Sunday dinner, one of a group of 12 (16 total) and she has told us that his Mother is a trained chef and he 'despises parents who can't cook well', as well as a string of opinions on a range of topics that make me want to poke him in the eye and DH was to punch him on the nose.
I won't be cowed on dinner and will churn out the usual 'pick what you want and we won't mind either way and if there's really nothing you fancy I'm happy to make egg or beans on toast' but...
He's going to make judgements and comments about us, our home, the food we serve and the life we
lead; and while I already don't rate his opinion I know that DD cares very much. I honestly have nothing in my practical or emotional battery to help her right now, without actually being rude to him.

Please can anyone help me with stock phrases and tips to keep calm? DD likes him even though she can see that he isn't kind to her.
He treats her disrespectfully and it makes me furious given that he's also telling her how to behave to be acceptable to meet his family.
I struggle with small talk. Can anyone help me with innocuous phrases to help an introvert aspi (DS) and me (NT but knackered), navigate the way though without causing to much anguish between DD and him, or her and me. Thanks

He sounds like an arrogant little so and so. I'm sorry I don't have much good to offer, but I wonder if her friends might have some more influence? Does she have a nice one who could come to dinner? Or do you have an outspoken friend who could put the little sh*t in his place? I suspect when your daughter goes to uni and meets other arty people, she'll be fine

Olivia2495 · 25/05/2024 18:22

They’re not even dating! He is not her partner.

There is comment after comment advising you how to deal with this 18 year old nasty little boy in your own home. Let’s face it, you wont be able to say half of this stuff and you definitely won’t be confronting him.

Like a pp says, this isn’t a game. It’s a serious situation that requires boundaries and for you to set a good example. He doesn’t give a fuck what you or your daughter think and your plan going forward is to impress him?

Why don’t you have a conversation with your daughter and explain that her expectation is unreasonable. You might be willing to tolerate him in a misguided attempt to support your daughter. Her friends wont and she will end up isolated. She can see him privately. Nobody else has to have a relationship with him. It’s her choice and her private business.

I would question why she’s so keen to involve this non partner in your family and expect you to impress him.

Echobelly · 25/05/2024 18:27

Olivia2495 · 25/05/2024 17:00

Come on everyone, this little fucker isn't going to barge into the house and start being a prick in front of 14 other guests. We all know the type, he's a typical bully who will be a grovelling wimp in front of anyone apart from the dd.

If the prospect of having a guest causes you so much anxiety you have to start a thread about how to respond to their abusive comments, that guest should not be invited, no matter who they are. You’ve made a rod for your own back op by indulging your daughter and creating an audience for this nobhead.

He is going to feel really really important. More fool you. This is what I mean about boundaries. If your daughter wants to listen to his bullshit and create an audience for him she can. It doesn’t mean you have to.

Your post is asking how do I deal with my daughters abusive boyfriend. The simple answer is that you don’t. Your daughter deals with him privately away from the family.

I suspect you're on the money. He'll 'behave' in front of a bigger audience in all likelihood.

If he is an arsehole, my tendency would be either to grey rock him ('How interesting', 'OK' etc) or, as others have suggested, highlight it: 'Wow, that's a very rude thing to say', 'Did you mean to say that?', 'Sorry, I didn't hear you'

YoureALizardHarry11 · 25/05/2024 18:30

Why are you allowing this abusive dickhead in your house speaking to your daughter that way? I’d tell him straight and he’d be out of that door quicker than his legs could carry him.

Bollindger · 25/05/2024 18:35

Once many years ago, my friends daughter was with this guy, he was controling , but she stuck with him..
I accidentally was reading him chatting to his friend, going on about how if you took a woman's virginity she belonged to you.
I was livid. Told her mum

We took her to help with the shopping.
I told her point blank what he had said, and it was old fashion twaddle.
That neither me it her mum had married our first.
And if she wasn't happy now a wedding ring wouldn't help.
Said no more and a month later be was gone.

LlynTegid · 25/05/2024 18:58

He would not come in my house.

BellaItalia242 · 25/05/2024 19:15

Flopsythebunny · 25/05/2024 09:29

Do what I did. Take him quietly to one side and threaten to have him knee capped.
This was after he'd smashed my daughter's living room up when she was 3 weeks post partum because she'd dared to voice her opinion.
Luckily she saw the light and he was gone within a month.
He's had a couple of reminders over the last 10 years when he's been an arse when he's come to pick his son up for contact. But he knows that I know people who would actually do this for a small price.

Hello, fellow Norn Irish person lol

BellaItalia242 · 25/05/2024 19:23

Waterlooo · 25/05/2024 17:09

You seem obsessed with me.

Did you say that to yourself in a Mariah Carey voice?

BellaItalia242 · 25/05/2024 19:25

but I don’t think a person who asks someone not to swear, to cover up, to be calm and not have a meltdown and to generally behave themselves in front of their family is an abusive arsehole.

But he didn't ask her not to do any of those things.

What thread are you reading?

Olivia2495 · 25/05/2024 19:29

It’s your job to teach your daughter about respecting other people’s boundaries. Bringing home an abusive non partner and expecting your mum to serve him and impress him really isn’t ok. Why does she think it’s ok for you to be uncomfortable in your own home and impress this stupid fucker?

She really is taking the piss and I’d tell her so. Tell her to keep her non relationship non partner bullshit away from the family. She’s made a bad choice. She doesn’t get to inflict her bad choices on other people and make them feel uncomfortable.

You feel anxious because it goes against your values to impress this twat. Ask her why she expects you to pretend.

DisabledDemon · 25/05/2024 20:07

My goodness me, someone needs a clip round the ear, doesn't he?

When he comes out with one of his derogatory comments, pin him with a death stare and pronounce 'I don't know how things work in your household but in this one, we show respect to each other. I'm sure you understand?'