Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tell me what to say: DD and arrogant BF

272 replies

ODFOx · 24/05/2024 22:20

Please bear with me (it's long)
She's the youngest and last one to go to Uni (this year). Her Dad died when she was 11, her self worth is poor and her self belief is less that zero (in spite of all our efforts).
She's beautiful, clever, funny, artistically talented and terribly troubled.
Current BF (although apparently they aren't dating although they spend every evening together and are intimate (this is linking not dating?) ), seems to be horrid to her: tells her she needs to be prettier and calmer and not swear and change her clothes etc etc before he can introduce her to his parents, that she shouldn't talk about losing her father, that being accepted to a fine art degree isn't a proper degree, that she needs to dress better, speak better, behave better.
At this stage I know neither this young man (not saying boy or lad) or his parents and he seems a bit of an idiot to me, but it's important to her that we make a good impression.
Anyhoo, he's coming for Sunday dinner, one of a group of 12 (16 total) and she has told us that his Mother is a trained chef and he 'despises parents who can't cook well', as well as a string of opinions on a range of topics that make me want to poke him in the eye and DH was to punch him on the nose.
I won't be cowed on dinner and will churn out the usual 'pick what you want and we won't mind either way and if there's really nothing you fancy I'm happy to make egg or beans on toast' but...
He's going to make judgements and comments about us, our home, the food we serve and the life we
lead; and while I already don't rate his opinion I know that DD cares very much. I honestly have nothing in my practical or emotional battery to help her right now, without actually being rude to him.

Please can anyone help me with stock phrases and tips to keep calm? DD likes him even though she can see that he isn't kind to her.
He treats her disrespectfully and it makes me furious given that he's also telling her how to behave to be acceptable to meet his family.
I struggle with small talk. Can anyone help me with innocuous phrases to help an introvert aspi (DS) and me (NT but knackered), navigate the way though without causing to much anguish between DD and him, or her and me. Thanks

OP posts:
Bollindger · 25/05/2024 15:23

If he says something bad about your food, look him in the eyes, left to right as if looking for an answer , smile and say well you won't offend me if you don't eat it.

If you cook Pork and he says he likes Beef you agree...
Oh yes Beef is nice, but today we have Pork. Smile and look away.
He says your house is old fashioned
Oh yes I agree it is But we like it. So homely.
He says your DD is doing a duff degree.
Oh yes an art degree is not for everyone, however I am sure DD will do well, and a degree is to show your capable more than what your studying.

See agree then you add but, however and add your side by agreeing your cut his argument down.

ArnottL · 25/05/2024 15:31

Nothing to do with boyfriend/girlfriend situation - but I don't let anyone in the house at all, apart from my family, my dh family, dd's female school friends (now uni friends - never their parents) and friends so close, so decent (4 people) that I don't have to think about any untoward behaviour, judgement, etc. I just don't let social contacts in the house. We meet in a cafe/restaurant/pub, that is it. No need. This was not a genius idea of mine, it was imprinted upon me by a friend, many many years ago, she told me how her school friends' parents when picking their children up after a playdate, were invited inside for a coffee and subsequently verbally destroyed the interior, the house, the neighbourhood - her mum told her that it had come to her attention through other people. Respect yourself - did William and Harry invite their mates to HM's residences when they were 18? They would not have dreamed of even asking about it - not because they were embarrassed of the premises, but because it is a great honour to be invited, once in a lifetime and not bestowed of the people not worthy of it.

MisterMagnolia · 25/05/2024 15:34

Perhaps you could rope him into helping you cook lunch given that he comes from such proficient stock! Make him work for his supper. I bet that his skills are on par with Brooklyn Beckham - i.e. pretty shit. I would just allow him to talk bollocks and in fact, i would encourage it. I bet that he has lots of great opinions on food and wine. Your daughter will probably find him embarrassing as will her friends. With a bit of luck one of them will say something.

If he does say anything derogatory about your daughter, obviously pick him up on that and tell him some very positive things about her.

afterfive · 25/05/2024 15:35

ArnottL · 25/05/2024 15:31

Nothing to do with boyfriend/girlfriend situation - but I don't let anyone in the house at all, apart from my family, my dh family, dd's female school friends (now uni friends - never their parents) and friends so close, so decent (4 people) that I don't have to think about any untoward behaviour, judgement, etc. I just don't let social contacts in the house. We meet in a cafe/restaurant/pub, that is it. No need. This was not a genius idea of mine, it was imprinted upon me by a friend, many many years ago, she told me how her school friends' parents when picking their children up after a playdate, were invited inside for a coffee and subsequently verbally destroyed the interior, the house, the neighbourhood - her mum told her that it had come to her attention through other people. Respect yourself - did William and Harry invite their mates to HM's residences when they were 18? They would not have dreamed of even asking about it - not because they were embarrassed of the premises, but because it is a great honour to be invited, once in a lifetime and not bestowed of the people not worthy of it.

That is no way to live though..life is way too short.

MisterMagnolia · 25/05/2024 15:38

As an aside, it's a bit strange that he puts your daughter down for doing a fune arts degree, whilst bigging his mother up for being a chef! Not very academic is it! 😉

BirthdayRainbow · 25/05/2024 15:43

It's terrifying how many people think behaving like this at 18 is fine as they are only 18

I have an 18 year old and two other kids who have been that age and none of them would ever behave like this. I brought them up well..

Tagyoureit · 25/05/2024 15:44

He sounds like a cunt, put eye drops in his drink!

verdibird · 25/05/2024 15:47

IdleAnimations · 25/05/2024 13:16

This male is showing classic signs of being an abuser. You need to educate your daughter on signs of abuse and controlling behaviour.

Personally if a jumped up lad with no life experience started criticising my life I’d bring him to task on it. At 18 you’re a child masquerading as an adult and you as the adult shouldn’t be made to feel small in your own home by this lad. Show your daughter what not putting up with fragile male egos looks like.

Edited

YES

Barney16 · 25/05/2024 15:48

He sounds like a twat but I wouldn't say that to her working on the you may inadvertently make him seen more attractive principle. Take heart, when she goes to uni she will meet lots of much more lovely boys. As for the lunch, I would just deflect and love bomb him. If nothing else he will be disconcerted.

Ohlookwhoitis · 25/05/2024 15:48

Waterlooo · 25/05/2024 13:00

You haven’t actually met this young man yet - not sure how old he is but I assume around 18 - and yet you’ve got grown adults online talking about pouring boiling hot gravy over him based on what your daughter has said.

I’ve read your OP again and he just sounds like a lot of 18 year olds - immature, foolish and arrogant - which you’d expect given his age. Telling her not to talk about her father is strange, but everyone is anxious about introducing their partner to their parents.

I don’t swear in front of my parents and would expect a partner not to if I was to introduce them. I would likely tell them to mind their language but I certainly wouldn’t expect to be accused of being abusive for it!

My brother once had a girlfriend who was dreadful, and we were relieved when he finally got rid of her given how abusive she was. She would swear freely - dropping cunts and fucks loudly in restaurants, dress inappropriately, talk openly about what she gets up to at raves and all the drugs she’d be high on, she’d argue with him, scream at him and tell total strangers about her mental health struggles and suicide attempts and generally didn’t seem to know how to behave. All of this would be in front of parents, cousins, elderly grandparents and extended family.

I’m not saying your daughter is like this, but I don’t think a person who asks someone not to swear, to cover up, to be calm and not have a meltdown and to generally behave themselves in front of their family is an abusive arsehole.

Andrew Tate fan are you?

Waterlooo · 25/05/2024 15:50

Ohlookwhoitis · 25/05/2024 15:48

Andrew Tate fan are you?

Enlighten me how you came to that conclusion.

greengreyblue · 25/05/2024 15:51

He would not be invited to my home and I would do everything o could to get her to see the prick that he is. He is abusing your daughter mentally. Why are you entertaining him???

Grendacious · 25/05/2024 16:03

Don't be tempted to say anything sarky or rude or jibing. Just pretend like he's nice and ask about his mum, his course, all the normal things. Don't rise to his digs, take them as if he meant them pleasantly even if it makes you look a bit dim. The purpose is showing DD that you can be trusted to share this messy bit of her life with without making things harder for her. Have the more honest conversation with her privately at a later date whilst being clear that despite you feeling very strongly that he doesn't treat her well enough, she will always be welcome to bring him round and you won't embarrass her. You guys being decent and him being a git will be quite the contrast. Plus they'll talk about the visit afterwards and you don't want to give him any fodder to point out how rude or inadequate you are. When he criticizes you, you need DD to be able.to think how mean he is, not that he has a point. She sounds very vulnerable and needs you to tread carefully imo.

JLou08 · 25/05/2024 16:04

No, I won't be giving you any helpful phrases. This thing is abusing your daughter and you are going to show her that's okay by inviting him to your home and being polite.

Ohlookwhoitis · 25/05/2024 16:07

Waterlooo · 25/05/2024 15:50

Enlighten me how you came to that conclusion.

You haven’t actually met this young man yet

you’ve got grown adults online talking about pouring boiling hot gravy overhim based on what your daughter has said

he just sounds like a lot of 18 year olds

Telling her not to talk about her father is strange, but everyone is anxious about introducing their partner to their parents

Apart from basically calling OPs daughter a liar, you have made every excuse for this young mans behaviour and then you go on to tear apart your brothers ex girlfriend for her abusive behaviour...but not him. Every bit of his behaviour is abusive but yet you excuse it. That's how I know.

Whiteglasshouse · 25/05/2024 16:10

MyOtherCarisAVauxhallZafira · 24/05/2024 23:36

Isn't variety wonderful, yes we do all like different things, oh you prefer x it's y for me! Oh your mother sounds like a marvellous cook, you are ever so lucky to have her.
He sounds like an absolute dick, I also think it's highly unlikely he'll say anything to your face, I think he'll be fake and then tear you down/sneer to your daughter after. Bullies aren't brave.

This.

DutifulDaughterWifeMother · 25/05/2024 16:13

What became of Chopin? Did she see the light?

Ariela · 25/05/2024 16:19

Are there going to be others there in terms of old family friends, or relatives that are not immediate family? If so, are any of those forthright and not averse to speaking out? If so I'd mention the issue carefully beforehand to them and suggest that if they need to speak out to 'please feel free to do so'. In this way it's not come from direct family but a wider circle of have noticed enough to comment 'That's not a kind thing to say' or 'MiniODFOx is very talented with fine art, you shouldn't underestimate her ability to shine in this field' or 'Just because it's not to your taste doesn't mean ODFOx isn't an excellent cook, I think it's lovely and it's very unkind to criticise' etc
That might help the penny drop as it's not you/immediate family criticising.

JLou08 · 25/05/2024 16:24

Caiti19 · 25/05/2024 05:14

As daughter of a Mother who did not speak up in a similar situation many years ago, I'd be telling her out straight "I love you and respect your choices, but I believe you're in an abusive relationship which could have very serious implications for your health and happiness now and in the future. The most important thing right now is that you know you can speak with us about your feelings and that you do not let this person isolate you emotionally." I am really not sure of the message it sends her to welcome this person to your table, but if he is a dick when he visits, I'd be assigning the task of letting her know that to as many of those 16 guests as possible. I do understand the reasons for a hands-off approach, but I also think young people sometimes need the guidance. I know I did.

I was in a similar situation. I felt and still do feel my parents really let me down. It was over 20 years ago and I have never been to them with a problem since and have no trust in them.

Bushwhacked20 · 25/05/2024 16:25

I'd have to stop myself from taking the proverbial but then I've met a hell of a lot of arseholes over the years... I have been splitting my sides laughing at some of the comments on this thread though. I might employ some of them with the entitled tits I'm currently having to deal with in my new job at a tiny provincial hospital that seems to think it's Barts or somewhere. Packed with people just like Captain Superior....

HereILayStillAndBreathless · 25/05/2024 16:28

I wouldn't kowtow to some nasty little prick or my jellyfish of a daughter. I would tell her he's not welcome in my home and for her to open her eyes, get some self-respect and dump his ass. I didn't get rid of every shit in my life at the smallest whiff of a red flag and raised her to be the same to tolerate her being and absolute doormat. I don't respect people like that, daughter or not.

azlazee1 · 25/05/2024 16:32

Just be yourself. I wonder if he'll act up being a guest in your home. If he does start saying rude things, call him on it and let him know we don't act that way in this house.

Waterlooo · 25/05/2024 16:39

Ohlookwhoitis · 25/05/2024 16:07

You haven’t actually met this young man yet

you’ve got grown adults online talking about pouring boiling hot gravy overhim based on what your daughter has said

he just sounds like a lot of 18 year olds

Telling her not to talk about her father is strange, but everyone is anxious about introducing their partner to their parents

Apart from basically calling OPs daughter a liar, you have made every excuse for this young mans behaviour and then you go on to tear apart your brothers ex girlfriend for her abusive behaviour...but not him. Every bit of his behaviour is abusive but yet you excuse it. That's how I know.

Edited

his behaviour being asking her to not swear in front of his parents.

daisychain01 · 25/05/2024 16:43

JLou08 · 25/05/2024 16:04

No, I won't be giving you any helpful phrases. This thing is abusing your daughter and you are going to show her that's okay by inviting him to your home and being polite.

Fair enough, but wouldn't you give him one chance to see how he behaves before making any rash judgment about him, especially as the OP says in their first post

At this stage I know neither this young man (not saying boy or lad) or his parents so getting all information about him second hand and never having met him before!

Surely it would model the right behaviours to the DD to be measured and calm about this before writing him off as an abuser.

doesn't mean you can't change your mind and explain that you wanted him to have the opportunity to show he could be civilised and respectful, but he's shown who he is, with examples of his behaviour to illustrate why it's unacceptable.

mrstreacle · 25/05/2024 16:55

Ohlookwhoitis · 25/05/2024 15:48

Andrew Tate fan are you?

That's what I was thinking too