Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate this current trend that girls should be raised to be fierce and fiery but boys shouldn't??

407 replies

Voodoohoodoyoudo · 11/05/2024 08:05

Now I'm not saying one gender is better than the other. But as a mother of sons I feel worried for their future because it seems this notion is currently being pushed that girls can get away with being drama queens but boys need to keep their feelings to themselves and pander to them or they might grow up to be abusive men? What happened to equal rights? I don't condone violence of any sort but this is totally unfair that boys shouldn't be able to do what girls do in terms of sticking up for themselves.

OP posts:
Notreat · 12/05/2024 16:44

I can't say I have seen it as a current trend at all.
I think boys these days are encouraged to show feelings much more now then when I was young when boys weren't meant to show any emotion at all! It was seen as weakness and boys weren't allowed to be weak.
I think the current trend is much more about equality so a girl can be strong and angry if that's how she is and a boy can be sensitive and caring if that's how he is. That doesn't mean boys can't also be strong and it angry or that girls can't be sensitive and caring. They can both be both.

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 12/05/2024 17:03

@TomeTome how many of you worry that your sons partners will abuse them, that they will pressure them into sex, that they will be “into choking” or “anal” because of their porn habit

For a start I will raise my daughter to just say NO, not happily go along with someone else's suggestion and then claim to be coerced.

ArseholeCatIsABlackAndWhiteCat · 12/05/2024 17:09

*Yes, the male privilege argument is far too black and white for me. People can have privilege in their lives at different times. So, for instance, I'm relatively young and fit. I can run for a bus. My brain and memory work well. Is that overweight man sitting over there on a mobility scooter, much older than me, really more privileged than I am because he's male? I could take him for God's sake.

It still comes down to wealth and circumstance to me, backed up by drive, motivation and a desire to succeed. If you're a male and you lack all of these, and there's a female who has all of these - which one is going to succeed and have a better life?*

You're comparing apples and oranges.

You should compare yourself to males that have the same background as you. Are you on the same rung on the career ladder ? Do you have the same wages? Did you have the same opportunities? Are /were your ideas ,suggestions,projects etc taken as seriously? And so on.

The disabled man should be compared to a disabled woman in the same position. How were they treated when they first started displaying symptoms. Length of diagnosis. Type of treatment etc. Was one of them dismissed, gaslit, told the pain is normal,fobbed off etc.

The way you put it means that no isms exist , because there will always be someone more worse off. That's not how it works. That's not how any of it works.

Sirzy · 12/05/2024 17:18

ArseholeCatIsABlackAndWhiteCat · 12/05/2024 17:09

*Yes, the male privilege argument is far too black and white for me. People can have privilege in their lives at different times. So, for instance, I'm relatively young and fit. I can run for a bus. My brain and memory work well. Is that overweight man sitting over there on a mobility scooter, much older than me, really more privileged than I am because he's male? I could take him for God's sake.

It still comes down to wealth and circumstance to me, backed up by drive, motivation and a desire to succeed. If you're a male and you lack all of these, and there's a female who has all of these - which one is going to succeed and have a better life?*

You're comparing apples and oranges.

You should compare yourself to males that have the same background as you. Are you on the same rung on the career ladder ? Do you have the same wages? Did you have the same opportunities? Are /were your ideas ,suggestions,projects etc taken as seriously? And so on.

The disabled man should be compared to a disabled woman in the same position. How were they treated when they first started displaying symptoms. Length of diagnosis. Type of treatment etc. Was one of them dismissed, gaslit, told the pain is normal,fobbed off etc.

The way you put it means that no isms exist , because there will always be someone more worse off. That's not how it works. That's not how any of it works.

Exactly you have summed things up perfectly.

TomeTome · 12/05/2024 17:33

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 12/05/2024 17:03

@TomeTome how many of you worry that your sons partners will abuse them, that they will pressure them into sex, that they will be “into choking” or “anal” because of their porn habit

For a start I will raise my daughter to just say NO, not happily go along with someone else's suggestion and then claim to be coerced.

The post was aimed at mothers of sons but well done for shifting the work onto the daughters. It almost seems you are suggesting girls should be raised fierce and fiery (as described by OP)?

Sirzy · 12/05/2024 17:54

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 12/05/2024 17:03

@TomeTome how many of you worry that your sons partners will abuse them, that they will pressure them into sex, that they will be “into choking” or “anal” because of their porn habit

For a start I will raise my daughter to just say NO, not happily go along with someone else's suggestion and then claim to be coerced.

Nice bit of victim blaming going on there!

CurlewKate · 12/05/2024 18:15

"For a start I will raise my daughter to just say NO, not happily go along with someone else's suggestion and then claim to be coerced."

Someone said the quiet bit out loud.......

JLou08 · 12/05/2024 18:41

Voodoohoodoyoudo · 12/05/2024 08:32

But on here when men are being slagged off they are

Cunts
Arseholes
Twats
Wankers

Etc etc.

How can you not see the double standards?

The terms you list there are used for both men and women and your misogynistic names are referring to female children!
I have never seen a post calling male children names like that.

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 12/05/2024 20:36

Newbutoldfather · 12/05/2024 12:57

@Sirzy ,

But it is about the level of privilege.

Having taught in a private school, I struggle to see the boys being more privileged in most ways. Both sexes have equal university ambitions, both are looking at middle class careers, both expect healthy relationships and, on the whole, to settle down and marry well. I still hear the less academic girls talk of ‘marrying rich’, which I have only heard once from a boy in my entire time teaching.

Boys are still louder and dominate the space in lunchtime and breaks, an area where their size and testosterone gives them privilege. OTOH, teachers tend to favour the girls and they do get away with more. The detention lists were about 4:1 boys/girls. In addition, many would argue that the way we the school system teaches favours the way girls learn, hence them outperforming by a significant margin.

Oh, and ‘toxic masculinity’ is a very popular phrase these days but what is the difference between ‘toxic masculinity’ and just plain old ‘masculinity’? Even if you can clearly see this, a lot of the messaging that boys get in schools (or hear even where schools are careful not to say it) is that they were born with the potential to be ‘toxic’. That is quite a grim message to be giving teens trying to find their identities in the world.

Now, I have also been a governor of a state school with a very different demographic. Many of children depend on their hot free meal as the main meal of the day, many wouldn’t consider university as the next step at all. They are not going home to warm houses or helped with their homework by parents.

If male privilege exists at the upper end of the income and education scale, which I am far from convinced of, and we look at the step analogy. Sex is worth 1cm whereas wealth is worth 1m.

Still working my way through this bizarre thread, but this stopped me in my tracks.

I too teach in a mixed private school. Your experience is vastly different from mine. Boys cause 90% of the problems in classrooms. Yes, they massively outnumber girls in detention because their behaviour is much, much worse. The rugby boys in the sixth form display toxic, attention-seeking, misogynistic behaviour all day long. Girls are marginalised, talked over and completely overshadowed by male voices every single day. Boys get away with more, unquestionably. Unenlightened teachers (possibly Boy Parents) say stupid things to the girls like “I’d expect this from the boys but not from you.” Girls suffer in mixed education settings, and in very particular ways in privileged mixed settings. I’m very, very surprised that you think otherwise.

surreygirl1987 · 12/05/2024 20:42

Actually OP, I think I sort of know what you mean. I read an article some time ago about a girl and boy in a nursery. The boy asked the girl if she would marry him. The girl punched him in the face as her response. The newspaper, and all comments were amused and praising the little girl. I hated it, however. What it was the girl asking the boy, and he punched her? He would (quite rightly) not have been treated the same way.

I view myself as a feminist, and am very much for equal rights. However, the key word there is EQUAL. Inequality exists for both sexes.

surreygirl1987 · 12/05/2024 20:43

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 12/05/2024 20:36

Still working my way through this bizarre thread, but this stopped me in my tracks.

I too teach in a mixed private school. Your experience is vastly different from mine. Boys cause 90% of the problems in classrooms. Yes, they massively outnumber girls in detention because their behaviour is much, much worse. The rugby boys in the sixth form display toxic, attention-seeking, misogynistic behaviour all day long. Girls are marginalised, talked over and completely overshadowed by male voices every single day. Boys get away with more, unquestionably. Unenlightened teachers (possibly Boy Parents) say stupid things to the girls like “I’d expect this from the boys but not from you.” Girls suffer in mixed education settings, and in very particular ways in privileged mixed settings. I’m very, very surprised that you think otherwise.

I work in a private school as well and I agree- this is my experince too.

surreygirl1987 · 12/05/2024 20:45

Hmmm although actually, on reflection, I don't think boys get away with more - girls do. Boys are punished more for the same things rhat girls do, eg talking in class or forgetting homework.

TomeTome · 12/05/2024 20:49

Less academic girls monetising their bodies and background to catch a rich husband surely can’t in anyone’s mind be a good thing? Do less academic boys have to consider this route or are they perhaps found less academic careers and allowed to stand on their own feet and marry for love?

I’m flabbergasted that anyone doesn’t see sexism in public schools. It literally smacks you in the face at every turn. Public schools create individuals like Rees-Mogg and Boris. In fact most of our mostly male government. Is it that you think the female public school alumni aren’t interested in politics? Wake up, this nonsense is strangling our country.

User135644 · 12/05/2024 20:53

KatyaKabanova · 11/05/2024 09:26

It's very regressive, @SpeedyDrama , and quite an agenda. One girl kicks one boy and suddenly males are the more vulnerable and oppressed sex?
I always think of that saying, that if you're used to privilege, equality feels unfair.

Equality would be kicking them back.

ArseholeCatIsABlackAndWhiteCat · 12/05/2024 20:54

surreygirl1987 · 12/05/2024 20:45

Hmmm although actually, on reflection, I don't think boys get away with more - girls do. Boys are punished more for the same things rhat girls do, eg talking in class or forgetting homework.

Actually the "getting away with" is fairly similar. The difference is boys (generalising here) tend to take it to a level that's unacceptable and consequence worthy more often than girls.

Concrete example:

"Suzie was drawing too!"
Yes she was drawing but she was doing it quietly while still listening. What she didn't do is an inappropriate drawing . Or she didn't draw, then turned the paper into a paper aeroplane which she then threw around the classroom.

Of course, at home the story always is "Miss picks on me. Miss never tells the girls off. Suzie was drawing too! She never gets told off."

RufustheFactualReindeer · 12/05/2024 20:56

For a start I will raise my daughter to just say NO, not happily go along with someone else's suggestion and then claim to be coerced

hopefully you’ll also raise your daughter to understand that sometimes NO doesn’t help and even if something awful happens that you will make sure no one tells her that she happily’ went along with it and is now ‘claiming’ that she didn’t

User135644 · 12/05/2024 20:58

jeaux90 · 11/05/2024 10:16

Bloody typical and why girls do better in single sex schools.

Boys and girls should be kept segregated in schools.

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 12/05/2024 21:00

surreygirl1987 · 12/05/2024 20:45

Hmmm although actually, on reflection, I don't think boys get away with more - girls do. Boys are punished more for the same things rhat girls do, eg talking in class or forgetting homework.

Not my experience at all. Boys get detentions for rudeness, defiance, fighting and repeated laziness in class/homework. The girls are generally much more conscientious.

surreygirl1987 · 12/05/2024 21:00

ArseholeCatIsABlackAndWhiteCat · 12/05/2024 20:54

Actually the "getting away with" is fairly similar. The difference is boys (generalising here) tend to take it to a level that's unacceptable and consequence worthy more often than girls.

Concrete example:

"Suzie was drawing too!"
Yes she was drawing but she was doing it quietly while still listening. What she didn't do is an inappropriate drawing . Or she didn't draw, then turned the paper into a paper aeroplane which she then threw around the classroom.

Of course, at home the story always is "Miss picks on me. Miss never tells the girls off. Suzie was drawing too! She never gets told off."

Yes, I semi agree with this. They are the same things but more exaggerated snd somehow more 'in your face' and a disturbance. Eg talking in class... the girls might do it but will whisper and it won't impact on the lesson, but the boys will do it loudly. Or a girl might forget their homework but be polite and apologetic about it, immediately coming up with solutions to rectify it, whereas a boy will forget it and act like they don't care, or he argumentative about it. I know I'm generalising massively, and I hate that, but this is what I see, day in day out.

Ladyzfactor · 12/05/2024 21:00

Voodoohoodoyoudo · 11/05/2024 14:02

I don't say those things with hatred in my heart. But I do believe in freedom of speech yes.

Freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom of consequences of that speech. Other people have just as much right to tell you that you're wrong and chose to not associate with you. It doesn't mean you're being cancelled or oppressed.

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 12/05/2024 21:06

surreygirl1987 · 12/05/2024 21:00

Yes, I semi agree with this. They are the same things but more exaggerated snd somehow more 'in your face' and a disturbance. Eg talking in class... the girls might do it but will whisper and it won't impact on the lesson, but the boys will do it loudly. Or a girl might forget their homework but be polite and apologetic about it, immediately coming up with solutions to rectify it, whereas a boy will forget it and act like they don't care, or he argumentative about it. I know I'm generalising massively, and I hate that, but this is what I see, day in day out.

Yes, I agree with this. Girls definitely talk in class. Boys call out in class. They claim all the attention in the room. They intimidate the girls.

I’ve been teaching for over 20 years. These trends have got worse, undoubtedly. The boys openly mock the girls and pick holes in everything they say and do. They’ve been emboldened by the likes of Andrew Tate; they think it’s their god-given right to critique girls and their appearance.

User135644 · 12/05/2024 21:07

FaeryRing · 11/05/2024 11:51

I just find it 🙄 that when women were on the back foot they just had to figure it out and break through the system themselves, but now men believe they’re on the back foot women have to rush to help and ‘understand’ them? They can bugger off and effect their own change, like we had to

Men's Rights groups get plenty of pushback when they try.

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 12/05/2024 21:11

User135644 · 12/05/2024 21:07

Men's Rights groups get plenty of pushback when they try.

That’s true. Women’s rights groups never had any pushback 🙄🙄

goldenochre · 12/05/2024 21:12

OP,
I think your son's school is the issue here, they are not taking you seriously.. you need to keep telling them until they listen!! I don't know how high you can go to complain (maybe council) but keep iterating the problem.

What is NOT agreeable is that you thought the last resort is to tell your child to kick the other child back!

Surely your's son teacher will be concerned if you go to them at school run one morning and tell them about the cause of your little boy's anxiety and fear and THAT will make them take it seriously??

I find it baffling that the school is not noticing a child being upset, anxious about the bullying incident and not instinctively raise it with the child and the parent!

It's massive failing from the school and the teacher!

User135644 · 12/05/2024 21:18

thurstonthethird · 12/05/2024 05:58

At the end of the day OP, your sons will experience massive privilege throughout life, just by virtue of being male.

I get that it feels unfair that they should have to deal with some girls being encouraged to be 'fierce and fiery' and that they might feel they have to take a backseat where perhaps sometimes they shouldn't.

But that is not going to have as much of a negative impact on them, as all of the unfairness, bias, sexism and misogyny that girls will experience throughout their lives.

The truth is that girls do need this encouragement more than boys because of the inherent privilege that males have by virtue of their sex.

Why are the vast majority of homeless men then? Or the vast majority of suicides? Must be all that privilege men are inborn with.

Privilege is class, not gender, at least in the 2020's. Was different a generation or two (and 3 and 4 etc) ago.

Swipe left for the next trending thread