I have since read over all the posts and I dont think my opinion has changed personally.
Then you either can't have read them all, or you've failed to understand their meaning. Because you wouldn't be doubling down in this man's defence if you had.
You elbowed and put a hole in a wall? Sounds like he might be right about the anger comment?
You claim to have read all the posts, but must have missed the ones explaining what Reactive Abuse is. Also the informative link showing that is formally recognised by DA experts as a barrier to women getting help or leaving abusive men. It is a classic tool of coercive control, & is used to gaslight the victim into thinking she is at fault. That's why he calls her angry. That's why he acts so badly - he is goading her into responding with tears or temper, so he can pretend her REACTION is the problem, rather than his ACTIONS.
Imagine the post was that he punched a hole in the wall!! And the reaction of everyone here, you are right its inexcusable, what will be elbowed next time?
If OP has been gaslighting & abusing her H for years, refused to do any childcare or housework, assumed she could go out whenever she liked without even discussing it because in her mind, her H is the default parent, left him to be up & down all night with a sick child, then lay in bed after a heavy night out, only to finally come downstairs to lie on the sofa instead of interacting with her children - PP would have every sympathy for him finally losing his cool.
But that's not what's happening here, & I'm not sure why you can't understand that. Are you playing devil's advocate, or do you have trouble believing women's own words, & look to their husbands as the 'real' authority?
and despite the fact he seems slow to start the days, he is right a dishwasher doesnt need emptying that early in the morning does it? Be realistic, you cannot be upset with that, hes got up presumably rough, a dishwasher being emptied is the last thing so early in the morning.
Why are you singling out one solitary morning? He NEVER gets up for his DC. He doesn't get their breakfast, get them dressed or bathed, he doesn't play with them - he won't even change a nappy -
He has just walked in now, my son just woke up with a temp, I asked him to change a nappy and he said why are you inadequate?
Can you not see that this is a persistent pattern of behaviour?
And it's not just the refusal to lift a finger. It's the deliberate denigration of his wife, the constant undermining, the automatic push-back & aggression when he is asked to 'help' look after his own kids.
People are commenting with their own experiences
It's an advice forum. That's how they work.
one woman has said her ex was in the pub every weekend all weekend. That's not what's happened here,
So?
He went out when his child was sick, he doesn't even consult his co-parent about that because he reckons it's her job to suck up his parental neglect, he's going out again tonight, & is threatening not to come home - most likely because he knows OP has work at 7.30am & this will sabotage her day.
He goes out whenever he wants to, which is frequently enough that OP is perpetually knackered because SHE never gets time out.
She goes out socially about 6 times a year. No doubt because he will refuse to "babysit" his own children.
you both do things which is healthy and commendable
Oh ha ha ha
Quote one sentence from OP showing him doing ANYTHING for his kids or household.
but it doesnt sound like he does a lot really, theres too many men that are always drinking or in the pub, he isnt.
He's OFTEN drinking in the pub, or out having pizza, or whatever he gets up to, but that's not the main . The main problem is his emotional abuse of his wife.
And if you think there's no problem just because he's not in the pub EVERY night, your own bar is set very low indeed.
I stand by by opinion, although maybe now much more angles to this but theres a lot of issues from both sides that need resolving.
Tell us again what you think OP's issues are, & which of them couldn't be fixed by her no longer being abused by her H?