Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Partner wants a new dog, I don't: end of the relationship?

262 replies

nomorequinoa · 15/11/2022 15:19

We've been together for 22 years. I'm 61, my DP's soon to be 60 and will be retiring in March 2023. I've freelanced from home for many years. DP works in IT as a contractor and has often worked abroad.

18 years ago we rescued our first dog, a young terrier. Soon after that DP took a 12-month contract in the Netherlands and I ended up looking after the dog for at least five days a week, with all the stress of training and caring for a young dog with behavioural issues. He'd come home for a couple of weekends each month and enjoy taking her on long walks, then be off again. Five years after that we mutually agreed to take on another rescue. I continued doing the lion's share of looking after them during the week. I loved them very much, but they were both quite challenging and they too often felt like a tie. Finding a reliable dog-sitter was always a challenge: I lost out on opportunities to go places and do things. The first dog died at 15 in 2017 and the younger one is about to turn 14 is just starting to look a bit stiff and doddery.

A week ago a friend of DP's asked if there was a chance of us rehoming a gorgeous terrier cross. The owners are divorcing and neither is in a position to take the dog. My DP went to see it without consulting me. It's clearly a sweet, much-loved pet and DP has as good as told them we will take it. Apparently he told them he'll just need to talk me round.

I don't want another dog once our current lovely old lad goes. I want us to be able to do all the things we've talked about doing in retirement without the stress of having to look after a dog. I want us to be able to take that three-month trip to South America we've talked about without the worry of dog care. I want to be able to take a last-minute trip away and do spontaneous things without having to factor in a dog. I don't want to have to continue putting on my boots and waterproofs and walking four miles in the cold and rain because the dog needs me to exercise him, as I've done for the last 18 years. I want a break from dog-care routine. DP says I'm making a mountain out of a molehill. He says the dog will be his, he'll walk it twice a day and take responsibility for it. I ask how he'll look after the dog when he's away on his sailing and cycling breaks with his brother and friends. He says he'll put it in kennels. We both know he'll expect me to look after the dog when he's away. He's working on the basis that I'll soften and give in, but I'm not going to. This is a hard, hard no from me.

I'd hoped he'd hear me and agree that once our current lovely boy has gone, we should be able to have at least a five-year break without a dog. Instead he's doubled down. We've never argued much, but in the last few days we've had some really hurtful rows that have made me see him in a new light. We've managed to work our way through things before, but this seems different.

AIBU? Has anyone else been through anything similar? I'd never imagined that it would be a dog that would end our relationship, but I think it might.

OP posts:
JaneFondue · 15/11/2022 15:23

You are so not BU. But I can't believe a 22 yr old relationship is breaking up over a dog.

SlipperyLizard · 15/11/2022 15:25

We have a dog, 6 years old, and although she’s lovely I won’t have another for all the reasons you describe (although DH does his fair share of rainy walks & doesn’t bugger off on trips). I just don’t like being unable to do things spontaneously without arranging dog care.

It seems a silly thing to split up over, especially as it sounds like your DP couldn’t look after a dog without you, but it also sounds like your feelings about your DP may have changed in light of recent arguments?

thecatsthecats · 15/11/2022 15:27

Maybe, to a certain extent, you both just aren't used to disagreeing?

It's a shame that this dog seems to be right dog wrong time, but you can get another dog in a few years when you're both ready, no big deal.

LaurieFairyCake · 15/11/2022 15:27

Well the problem is you WILL soften and give in because by then you will be attached to the dog and you're not going to want it to go into kennels either

If you can't talk him out of having the dog then you either have to break up or get him to agree the amount of time MAXIMUM he will go away in a month and see if you can 'live' with looking after it then

BMW6 · 15/11/2022 15:28

YANBU. Tell him bluntly that if the dog comes in, you're going out - forever.

We have a much loved dog, now 13. When he goes we won't be getting another as there are places I want to go to and you are very tied with a dog.

CheapWine · 15/11/2022 15:29

I bet you a million pounds if you split up he won’t take the dog.

JaneFondue · 15/11/2022 15:30

Am always amazed that posters on MN are always being told to get dogs if they are sad, lonely, bored.... It's such a huge responsibility that most people don't anticipate and most often one that women are forced to take on.

WomanWomenGirlsFemale · 15/11/2022 15:30

My husband of 32 years did this to me, got a dog and buggered off abroad to work and left me in charge of it. Don't get me wrong she was lovely but had been used for back yard breeding so was overweight and had never been walked or had training of any sort. I didn't have the heart to give her to a rescue centre so trained her myself , she had a huge amount of health problems and was only with us a short time, I do miss her but I've warned my husband if he ever tries that again I will divorce him. I don't have the time or energy for a pet so I understand how you feel.

PauliesWalnuts · 15/11/2022 15:33

Hard no from me. They tie you down more than children.

FuckoffeeBeforeCoffee · 15/11/2022 15:33

I love dogs more than most other things but even I think you're not being unreasonable.

I want to do your retirement plans. I'll come with you instead!

AryaStarkWolf · 15/11/2022 15:33

I have a dog and a cat, we've had dogs for our whole relationship too (20 years) and when these two go i want a break from the responsibility of pets as well OP, totally get you.

Cluelessdiyer · 15/11/2022 15:34

It’s not about thwndof though is it - it’s also about him not having respect for you and what you want.

i suspect behind all this is years of you doing an awful
lot of wide work while he gads about and has fun

stand your ground

and if he doesn’t shape about onwards and upwards with a lovely single retirement.

you can always get a signed you get lonely 😁

Always4Brenner · 15/11/2022 15:34

No I’d feel the same. It’s always the women who end up looking after pets etc.

hesbeingabitofadick · 15/11/2022 15:35

He says the dog will be his
Difficult to explain to the dog when your partner is off on one of his jollies...
Poor dog, but hopefully he'll find a home somewhere else.
Stick to your guns.
Don't get lumbered with your partners "Disney Dog Dad" aspirations.

FurAndFeathers · 15/11/2022 15:35

This is not about the dog.
it’s about him not being able to cope with not getting his way.

it sounds like you’ve facilitated and compromised throughout the relationship.

he cannot cope with you not doing what he wants

girlmom21 · 15/11/2022 15:36

That dog needs stability, not kennels and dog sitters.

You're not in a position to care for it.

Tell him to wait a year. 6 months until he retires and 6 months for him to enjoy being retired, then if he still wants a dog you'll discuss it properly.

Bookaholic73 · 15/11/2022 15:37

I love my 2 dogs, but once they die I won’t be getting another. They are such a tie, and for all the reasons you describe.

Fenella123 · 15/11/2022 15:39

All else aside it's not fair on the dog if it's being put in kennels an unusually large proportion of the time.

It doesn't have to be the end but, nonetheless, your other half needs to grow up a bit. Are you able to contact these friends of his and tell them your point of view (which you set out very well in your post)?

His intentions may be benign, but it sounds like the dog will be better off in another home. And there will be other homes. He needs to put on his big boy pants and concede that he spoke hastily.

You can go all these places without him - but, of course, him willing to ditch big parts of your early retirement plans and/or kennel a dog HE TOOK ON for long stretches - neither is going to make you think better of him. In that sense it's not about the dog...

SquishyGloopyBum · 15/11/2022 15:40

He knew you'd object - hence going to see the dog without telling you.

Stand your ground. It's not fair on the dog at the end of the day. Or you.

He's being very selfish and only thinking of himself here.

blobby10 · 15/11/2022 15:41

Definitely not BU! When my ex and I split 7 years ago (20 year marriage), I ended up with the children (not complaining at all) , dogs, cats, rabbits and guinea pigs! So whilst he was off enjoying his new life, I couldn't do anything spontaneous or suchlike without extensive planning for animal care! I'm now down to one of the cats and once she goes (she's 15 but will probably live to early 20s knowing my luck) I won't have another pet just so I can enjoy a year or two of no animal responsibilities. They are wonderful but SUCH a tie! And it hurts so much when they die.

The laugh for me is that my ex remarried a few years ago and after telling me after our split that he didn't miss the dogs or cats or me (yes that order) he now has cats and a dog and is complaining about restrictions on his freedoms Grin

Hoppinggreen · 15/11/2022 15:42

We have a dog we love and I have always had a dog/cat/cats but I have told DH that we aren’t replacing any of the existing animals when they go. I adore them all and have been a pet owner since I was a child but I feel like I’m done. When we retire I want to be spontaneous and just go places and do things without worrying about pets or kids.
I would say though, if this will end your marriage there are probably other issues as well

Vikinga · 15/11/2022 15:44

Yanbu. When he's in a position to look after a dog, and when he's actually pulled his weight with your existing dog then he has a case, but until then he can bugger off.

Vikinga · 15/11/2022 15:45

Oh and my kids used the same line on me about getting another dog. I told them to start practising with the dog we have now. They haven't. It is still me who does 99.9% of dog walks and dog care - which I don't mind but that is my choice.

Beadpark · 15/11/2022 15:45

It's not about the dog really is it? It's about the fact that he's prepared to take this big decision without you. Then that he's prepared to get nasty when you object. I was speaking to a friend with a new dog today and she said it's like deciding to have another baby. Huge responsibility and a real tie. I can totally understand why you are questioning your relationship.

Miss03852 · 15/11/2022 15:45

Would your life really be better as a single 60 year old than married but with a dog?

Swipe left for the next trending thread