Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Step mother gifting half brother his ‘birth right’ inheritance

396 replies

Undertherainbow00 · 04/06/2022 20:01

I just need somewhere to vent - I’m sure I will be shot down for being unreasonable but maybe someone will see my point of view or will enable me to view this through a different lens…
Family history in brief - step mother has been in my life since just before I turned five (I’m now 43) and she and my father began dating. My parents marriage broke down because of his alcoholism but being the 80’s, the judge decided he could still have my sister and I every other weekend. As a side note, step mother was eight years younger than my father and was approaching her 21st birthday when they got together. She too had a problem with alcohol but they masked their problems to the wider outside world… Her parents were not happy that she was dating an older man who was divorced with two children. However, as time went by, her parents (mainly her mother) warmed to my sister and I. When I was fourteen, my father and step mother had their child, a son. I should add that at this point neither of them drank but my father still had his uncontrollable temper that was often directed at me. She actively encouraged his discipline methods but would also be there to comfort me through my tears.
I fell pregnant at sixteen and to my astonishment both my father and step mother were supportive of my choice to keep the pregnancy. However, it could been seen as fulfilling a prophecy of their making… Problem child, pregnant at sixteen. I would just like to add, any problems I had were directed at myself - eating disorder, self harm and suicide attempts.
I completely got my life together once I was pregnant - worked and set up a home on my own.
That was all many moons ago now and since then I have made an attempt to improve my life chances. I returned to education as an adult and I have a career. However, at the ripe old age of forty three - I have never owned or have been in a position to save a deposit for a house.
Step mother engineered hers and my father’s will like this - their house split 50/50 her share to my half brother and my father’s 50 % share split three ways between all three siblings. Fair?
Anyway, her parents died several years back and left her a significant inheritance. She bought her two siblings out of the parents house as she didn’t want to sell it at that point. Today she has told me that she is selling it as my half brother is very anxious about approaching thirty without owning his own property. She is gifting him the entire proceeds of the house sale - a minimum of £500,000. I just sat there listening to her monologue of how much of his income is wasted in rent - I really can’t relate can I?
She waffled on that it was his birth right as they were his grandparents.
I feel SO angry as their property was bought from the sale of my parents house - so by that logic, my sister and I should have a greater share of their house.
My step mother has always spouted that she loves us all the same but words and actions are completely at odds with the reality of what our lives have been.
I feel bitter that I have forgiven them for their appalling behaviour when I was a child and I have never shared my experiences with my half brother. I have stood back and watched him have everything in life that I didn’t but this has really rocked me and I feel terrible for feeling like this. I am jealous that he will have a home of his own as I fear I never will.
I apologise for this ramble but if you got to the end - thank you! It was cathartic to just get it out of my head!

OP posts:
bellac11 · 07/06/2022 19:58

SurfBox · 07/06/2022 19:26

It's unbelievable that anyone thinks adult children should have an entitlement or say in how a married couple arrange or spend their money

it's easy to say when you aren't the victim of it and feel a sibling is getting favoritism. It's not just the money either, it's what it represents.

Victim?

Jesus, the mentality on here, everyone is a bloody victim

whumpthereitis · 07/06/2022 20:02

There’s no ‘must’ about it. It’s their money, if they want to leave it to the local dogs home they can. What came before is irrelevant, OP’s father has no issue with her doing what she sees fit to with her inheritance, and he’s the only person that could arguably be entitled to any claim on it in the event of divorce.

SurfBox · 07/06/2022 20:11

It’s their money, if they want to leave it to the local dogs home they can

Yea that's fair enough but it's different when it leads to inequality amongst children/siblings. Are you really telling me you'd be okay if your sibling inherited better from your parents?

AskingforaBaskin · 07/06/2022 20:27

SurfBox · 07/06/2022 20:11

It’s their money, if they want to leave it to the local dogs home they can

Yea that's fair enough but it's different when it leads to inequality amongst children/siblings. Are you really telling me you'd be okay if your sibling inherited better from your parents?

Half sibling. Inheriting from their family.

whumpthereitis · 07/06/2022 21:14

SurfBox · 07/06/2022 20:11

It’s their money, if they want to leave it to the local dogs home they can

Yea that's fair enough but it's different when it leads to inequality amongst children/siblings. Are you really telling me you'd be okay if your sibling inherited better from your parents?

Considering my older sibling does in fact have a completely different parent, yes I am. It’s never occurred to me not to be okay with that. If I wasn’t, it still wouldn’t be any of my business.

I don’t count on money unless I have it in my hand or under my name in a bank account. Until then, it’s not mine to claim.

Aprilx · 07/06/2022 21:19

SurfBox · 07/06/2022 20:11

It’s their money, if they want to leave it to the local dogs home they can

Yea that's fair enough but it's different when it leads to inequality amongst children/siblings. Are you really telling me you'd be okay if your sibling inherited better from your parents?

You are right, inequality amongst siblings is hard to condone. But that is not what is happening here. This is a mother passing her inheritance onto her only child.

beachcitygirl · 07/06/2022 21:28

Your step mother is behaving horrifically but legally.
I would be very very mindful of this day when either she or your dad need elderly care.
You'll be too busy working to pay rent or save to buy a house won't you, unlike your half brother who has had a half million gift.

People reap as they sew. Your stepmum is reaping. Eventually she will see what she has sewn.

whumpthereitis · 07/06/2022 21:40

beachcitygirl · 07/06/2022 21:28

Your step mother is behaving horrifically but legally.
I would be very very mindful of this day when either she or your dad need elderly care.
You'll be too busy working to pay rent or save to buy a house won't you, unlike your half brother who has had a half million gift.

People reap as they sew. Your stepmum is reaping. Eventually she will see what she has sewn.

People keep saying this but I imagine the stepmother and OP’s father will be absolutely fine, with or without family care. They have a house that can be sold to pay for fees. Of course this is the inheritance that OP can legitimately expect to get based on what she’s been told, so I’m not sure ‘leave them to rot’ is quite the stinging rebuke that those offering it anticipate.

SurfBox · 07/06/2022 21:43

You are right, inequality amongst siblings is hard to condone. But that is not what is happening here. This is a mother passing her inheritance onto her only child

ok and so are you forgetting that the mother is also giving half she house ops mother and grandparents paid for to her only child also?

beachcitygirl · 07/06/2022 21:53

@whumpthereitis

Oh I'm sure they will be fine financially, but a quick "oh will you nip to the chemist for me" " oh can you drop me at x appointment"
"Oh can you help me with funeral arrangements for your dad/stepmum" delete as appropriate
"Oh can I come to yours for xmas/Easter/New Years"
For me the answer would be a resolute, "sorry I have to work/spend time with my birth child" phone half brother.

Then a breezy bye

SurfBox · 07/06/2022 22:37

*Oh I'm sure they will be fine financially, but a quick "oh will you nip to the chemist for me" " oh can you drop me at x appointment"
"Oh can you help me with funeral arrangements for your dad/stepmum" delete as appropriate
"Oh can I come to yours for xmas/Easter/New Years"
For me the answer would be a resolute, "sorry I have to work/spend time with my birth child" phone half brother.

Then a breezy bye*

nope screw the passive aggressiveness, the only way to deal with it is to speak to the father in a calm and assertive manner.

dianthus101 · 08/06/2022 00:27

SurfBox · 07/06/2022 18:47

How do you know that she didn't contribute anything to the family home

op said it was all bought from his divorce settlement.

She didn't say that it was "all bought" from his divorce settlement. She said that the proceeds were used to buy a house but that could just be the deposit for a house.. The father would have only got half the marital assets so if he was able to buy a house from the proceeds presumably OP’s mother could have done too. The fact she didn’t suggests the actual amount wasn’t that substantial.

dianthus101 · 08/06/2022 00:30

SurfBox · 07/06/2022 22:37

*Oh I'm sure they will be fine financially, but a quick "oh will you nip to the chemist for me" " oh can you drop me at x appointment"
"Oh can you help me with funeral arrangements for your dad/stepmum" delete as appropriate
"Oh can I come to yours for xmas/Easter/New Years"
For me the answer would be a resolute, "sorry I have to work/spend time with my birth child" phone half brother.

Then a breezy bye*

nope screw the passive aggressiveness, the only way to deal with it is to speak to the father in a calm and assertive manner.

You do realise that the SM is only in her 50s and OP is in her 40s?

EmeraldShamrock1 · 08/06/2022 00:37

You do realise that the SM is only in her 50s and OP is in her 40s?
In that case I'm not sure why you are fretting over inheritance OP.
MIL may outlive you.
She perfectly entitled to set her DS up with housing it’s a parents dream to be in a position to help their DC financially.

Tata22 · 08/06/2022 06:13

NotMushroomInEre · 04/06/2022 21:39

@diddl yes, I totally agree.

@aSofaNearYou the split is disgusting, it is absolutely disgraceful. The son gets a half and a third. In what world is that right?

And surely OP has the same possible inheritance i.e. a 3rd from her dad and half from her own mum.

Her mum may not be in a position to to leave her anything but that's not relevant, such is life. If it was OP inheriting from her mother and the half brother not, no one would think it unfair.

And sorry but it's entitled as fuck to think you have any sort of right over the step mothers parents estate.

Tata22 · 08/06/2022 06:18

Are you really telling me you'd be okay if your sibling inherited better from your parents?

When one of the parents involved isn't your parent then yes of course it's okay. OP has a mother she can potentially inherit from.

If it had been OPs mother who'd been in the fortunate position of being able to give her an inheritance like this, no one would be harping on about the unfairness.

SurfBox · 08/06/2022 09:04

Her mum may not be in a position to to leave her anything but that's not relevant, such is life. If it was OP inheriting from her mother and the half brother not, no one would think it unfair

Yea but I've already outlined how the case is different-it is relevant when op's mum and grandparents on her mum's side paid for the house that unrelated stepbrother will benefit from.

dianthus101 · 08/06/2022 09:08

EmeraldShamrock1 · 08/06/2022 00:37

You do realise that the SM is only in her 50s and OP is in her 40s?
In that case I'm not sure why you are fretting over inheritance OP.
MIL may outlive you.
She perfectly entitled to set her DS up with housing it’s a parents dream to be in a position to help their DC financially.

Exactly. Even if OP outlives the SM she could easily be in her 70s when she receives the inheritance so probably not going help buy a house.

Tata22 · 08/06/2022 09:09

-it is relevant when op's mum and grandparents on her mum's side paid for the house that unrelated stepbrother will benefit from

No they didn't. That house is long gone and was sold what sounds like decades ago. We know that the sale proceeds (whether that was some or all we don't know) went into purchasing this new house that SM and the father own but we don't know that SM didn't put anything at all into their current house. For all we know the step mother could have paid half for their current home and the father paid for his half with the sale proceeds for his old home which he was granted in his divorce. It's entirely reasonable that the home that SM jointly owns with her husband (which is not the same home as OPs parents owned 40+ years ago and which they bought with the help of maternal GPs) is split 50/50 between them with their 50%'s going to whoever they choose.

Tata22 · 08/06/2022 09:13

Also, we have no idea whether OPs version of events relating to her parents divorce 40 odd years ago are factually correct. She was a child.

My parents divorced a long time ago. My dad kept the house, my mum was not financially shafted though. He had to buy her out, pay off their joint debts and she will be awarded a portion of his pension when he retires. Imo that house is now entirely my father's to do with whatever he wishes and the sale proceeds to go toward or split however he wants.

If OP thinks she's been unfairly treated she can speak to her dad and see what he says but the house they currently now live in some 40 years later is jointly owned with the step mother and she's as much right as anyone to do with what she wants with her share.

SurfBox · 08/06/2022 09:44

Also, we have no idea whether OPs version of events relating to her parents divorce 40 odd years ago are factually correct. She was a child

We have no way of knowing what is factually correct on aibu but we must go on what we are told. I am assuming op's mum told her and upthread posters supported this as in the 80s women would get badly shafted in divorces.

He had to buy her out, pay off their joint debts and she will be awarded a portion of his pension when he retires. Imo that house is now entirely my father's

Yea but their situation is different from ops as her mum was put into a council house,she did badly in the settlement due to dm as she had to flee the house...

Eugh I'm repeating the same stuff over and over and people still ignoring it. I'm out.

dianthus101 · 08/06/2022 09:50

We have no way of knowing what is factually correct on aibu but we must go on what we are told. I am assuming op's mum told her and upthread posters supported this as in the 80s women would get badly shafted in divorces.

80s women often did better in divorces compared with today actually. The reason OP's mother would have found things difficult would have been lack of childcare in the 80s which isn't the fault of SM or even the father. However, houses were a lot more affordable plus there were more council houses than today.

dianthus101 · 08/06/2022 09:52

Yea but their situation is different from ops as her mum was put into a council house,she did badly in the settlement due to dm as she had to flee the house...

She did badly compare with other women in the 80s as she would't have been able to live in the house until her children had grown up. She would have got half the value when it was sold though.

Aprilx · 08/06/2022 10:40

SurfBox · 07/06/2022 21:43

You are right, inequality amongst siblings is hard to condone. But that is not what is happening here. This is a mother passing her inheritance onto her only child

ok and so are you forgetting that the mother is also giving half she house ops mother and grandparents paid for to her only child also?

No because that is not happening!

whumpthereitis · 08/06/2022 11:50

SurfBox · 08/06/2022 09:04

Her mum may not be in a position to to leave her anything but that's not relevant, such is life. If it was OP inheriting from her mother and the half brother not, no one would think it unfair

Yea but I've already outlined how the case is different-it is relevant when op's mum and grandparents on her mum's side paid for the house that unrelated stepbrother will benefit from.

No, it’s not relevant, even if that were the full truth. It’s wasn’t, and isn’t, OP’s money that she has any claim on. Even if her mother had kept the house it still wouldn’t be OP’s unless her mother chose to leave it to her upon death, something she would actually be under no obligation to do.