Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - boarding school?

196 replies

marateach · 31/10/2021 21:32

My partner and I are thinking about having children soon however we have quite different ideas about their upbringing. He went to a boarding school from age 11 and loved it. He has said that if we have children he would like to give them the option to go away to boarding school from KS2 onwards.
I can’t imagine only seeing my children during school holidays!

AIBU?
If you / your children went to boarding school, were they / you happy? Do you have any regrets?

OP posts:
XelaM · 01/11/2021 22:55

Have PP seen the documentary about "Sunningdale"? It was very similar, but about the boys school. Was that not meant to be an advert for the school? I think the school actively commissioned it and probably thought it makes them look good? I also think they were inundated with applications after that programme, but I found it completely heartbreaking. It was called "Britain's Youngest Boarders"

Pl242 · 01/11/2021 23:27

Only managed 15 mins of the documentary linked to upthread. What struck me was that the whole approach from the school was to suppress your feelings and keep yourself busy. As if to distract from the fact that sending an 8 year old away from home is an entirely unnatural thing.

Hogwarts4Christmas · 01/11/2021 23:31

My dd chose to go to boarding school at 16. Managed to get a scholarship, so she really put the work in herself.
She loves it and it's been really good for her, but each child is different. My others wouldn't have coped so well and I think younger than 11/12 is far too young.

NowEvenBetter · 01/11/2021 23:42

I don’t want a kid, so I choose, happily, not to reproduce. Rich people who don’t want a kid have the option to discard the child into ‘boarding school’ and bleat about how amazing it is. How the child ‘loves it’. It’d be funny if it weren’t so depressing.
And yes, I do have experience of being discarded by parents, but the poor version. HTH.

Hogwarts4Christmas · 01/11/2021 23:42

Also, her school isn't too far from us and she can choose to come home on weekends if she wishes or we go there and take her out for the day, which we do a few times over the 6 week term.

It's been really good for her and had had the benefit of getting her away from her phone a lot as they're often playing board games and actually chatting together or watching movies, etc.

NowEvenBetter · 01/11/2021 23:44

‘My kid loves being nowhere near me ☺️‘
Maybe examine that. No one needs to be defensive if they’re literally not psychologically destroying their kid, so it’s fine.

whattodo2019 · 01/11/2021 23:55

My DH and I both boarded from the age of 8. My parents lived in Hong Kong so I came over to the u.k. on my own. I absolutely loved boarding and so did my Dh. Our DD wanted to board so she flexi boarded from Year 3 and full boarded from Year 7. Our DS has never wanted to board so he is a day pupil. It's a brilliant opportunity for the right child in the right school and utter disaster if you get the wrong fit. Don't worry about it now but do consider in the future. Small family boarding houses and small nurturing prep schools are brilliant when the kids are young.

Platax · 02/11/2021 00:12

People who loved boarding school, what was it you loved about it? Did you really not miss home and your families? Didn't you think it was a bit of a weird set-up where you were being sent off to live with a load of strangers who had considerable power over you?

JustKickin · 02/11/2021 00:12

I think the worst of it is often the damage only becomes apparent so late. The whole thing of treating homesickness like a little silly small-child wobble that they all soon get over if there are enough organised games at the weekends. Being removed from your family unit at that young age can simultaneously damage you, and teach you to hide the damage even from yourself. It's an awful combination.

Every single time someone says their own child loves to board, I hear my mum's voice saying exactly the same thing. I don't really have much of a relationship with them these days.

alexdgr8 · 02/11/2021 05:00

the widow lady who said it might be good for her young son to establish close friendships in case he should lose her too; no.
can you not see if that were to happen he would be even more bereft, to think the time he could have had with you was wasted being somewhere else.
the whole system was devised to toughen up boys to ignore their feelings and go and rule the empire, far from home.

alexdgr8 · 02/11/2021 05:24

@choirmumoftwo

I think that's the issue with this type of programme. It has more 'entertainment/shock' value depending on how it's edited. Perhaps the schools were quite naive in taking part. I did watch the series at the time and felt that our lived experience of boarding would not have looked the same on TV once edited, to our detriment. I found it very uncomfortable viewing.
but you seem determined not to consider that maybe it was uncomfortable viewing because it that is how it is, rather than some trick of editing. maybe your children's experience was better. but you cannot dismiss wholesale what many posters on here are attesting to. and the parents' breezily declaring oh johnny/janey absolutely loves it, is part of the distortion that pupils have to learn to live with. like feeling lonely; ignore it and put on a happy face, keep busy. if people become numb to their own feelings, it's quite likely that they will also dismiss or ignore other people's feelings. the whole category of feelings has been hollowed out. this is the lived reality of so many.
rrhuth · 02/11/2021 05:29

@JustKickin

I think the worst of it is often the damage only becomes apparent so late. The whole thing of treating homesickness like a little silly small-child wobble that they all soon get over if there are enough organised games at the weekends. Being removed from your family unit at that young age can simultaneously damage you, and teach you to hide the damage even from yourself. It's an awful combination.

Every single time someone says their own child loves to board, I hear my mum's voice saying exactly the same thing. I don't really have much of a relationship with them these days.

Absolutely this. The parents who say their kids love it are often completely oblivious.
elbea · 02/11/2021 07:23

@NowEvenBetter lots of children in boarding schools aren’t from rich families. They are their because it is the best way to get an good education. Children like those who live in the islands of Scotland where there aren’t secondary schools and the children of soldiers.

choirmumoftwo · 02/11/2021 07:23

@alexdgr8 you've misinterpreted me I'm afraid. I was talking about editing as a particular tool in the production process, designed to have maximum emotional impact and perhaps focus on the negatives. I haven't once commented on the lived experience of others with experience of boarding, and certainly have not dismissed the very real issues raised.

expatmigrant · 02/11/2021 07:31

Both my DC abondened me and went to boarding school from Y9. I was the one who was bereft. Neither my DH to would have ever had the opportunity but we were in a financial position where we could afford it and they wanted to try it.
My DD went first, followed by my DS a few years later. It was their choice completely and they both knew that they could come home to a local school if they didn't like it. They are both sporty and immersed themselves in everything the school had to offer.
My DS has some learning difficulties so benefited from the small class sizes and the excellent learning support at this particular school.
We were overseas but saw them as much possible either with us coming back to see them and they spent all their holidays with us. We ensured we attended school events and sport matches when ever possible.
Family and friends know that it was their choice so we have never been criticised for sending them 'away'.
We also know children where boarding school did not work out and the children returned to being schooled at local schools.
They have both finished school now and are successful in their chosen lives.

Marvellousmadness · 02/11/2021 07:47

At age 7? That sounds like neglect more than boarding school
It is a hard no for me. Never ever

Libelula21 · 02/11/2021 07:52

Thanks for this perspective @alexdgr8 .

It’s very theoretical just now, though it would never be more than 4 nights per week, 90 mins drive away, from teen years. And the hope would be to have more quality time together, not less. I’d be able to work much later those nights, for example.

Hekk · 02/11/2021 08:16

I come from a boarding family. I judge people who send their children to board, unless they are an army family or have ill parents etc.

For some kids it can be great, for others it will shut them down. Why would you take that chance?

I particularly judge people who do it for social reasons.

Namenic · 02/11/2021 08:31

Platax- you are around friends, you don’t have to spend time travelling to school and activities each day. Lots of sport. Homework built into the day. I went to a single sex girls school. Hardly anyone wore make-up. Relatively little boy drama (did not feel left out if I didn’t have boyfriend). Get involved in stuff you wouldn’t normally do - like performances etc (as they had house competitions - older students organised and put stuff together).

This is aside from good academic support in general (which you can get at day schools too).

There were drawbacks of being in single sex boarding school - I didn’t really know that much how to interact with boys my age at uni. I think I felt mildly homesick once or twice in about 7 years - so it wasn’t a big deal for me. I’m really close to my siblings and parents - go on holidays and stuff together. I’m really grateful for the education I received personally (though I know not everyone who went to boarding school feels like this).

Would I send my kids? No - due to cost and also I think I’d want to keep a closer eye on internet use etc.

LittleGwyneth · 02/11/2021 11:32

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

You wouldn't only see your children during school holidays. Lots of boarding schools have a Monday morning drop off and a Friday evening pick-up, which is a nice compromise.

Even the proper boarding boarding ones have regular exeats where you come home for the weekend.

Fine if parents and children prefer that. Personally, we want to see and spend time with our 9yo every day - and he would say exactly the same about us.

There are only a handful of schools who will take boarders from nine now. The vast majority are from 11 or 13.

It's fine that you don't want to do boarding for your child, but there's absolutely no reason to be judgemental of those who do. I loved boarding, I am incredibly close with my parents, and very grateful that they spent a small fortune on an amazing education for me.

LittleGwyneth · 02/11/2021 11:39

@Platax

People who loved boarding school, what was it you loved about it? Did you really not miss home and your families? Didn't you think it was a bit of a weird set-up where you were being sent off to live with a load of strangers who had considerable power over you?
I went at 13, at which point I really wanted space to work out who I was and not to be supervised by my parents. I loved being with my friends 24/7 and having some control over my own routine. I also loved that when I went home it was quality time with my family and we were excited to see each other.

There was always something fun going on, watching TV with 20 people is more fun than doing it alone. I liked spending summer evenings in the back fields playing rounders and smoking. Long chats while you're falling asleep about political issues and boys you fancy.

I didn't find anything weird about it at all, I loved that all the discipline stuff was outsourced to teachers, so I got to enjoy my parents as people.

I spoke to my parents on the phone for an hour a couple of times a week, went home almost every weekend, exchanged letters and texts with my mum - it was lovely. We're incredibly close now.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/11/2021 11:48

the widow lady who said it might be good for her young son to establish close friendships in case he should lose her too; no.
can you not see if that were to happen he would be even more bereft, to think the time he could have had with you was wasted being somewhere else.

Exactly - definitely a parent/child version of 'better to have loved and lost than never to have loved at all'. Plus, without wanting to be harsh about it, if she did die whilst he was still at school, I can't see his 'school family' being willing to suddenly take over all of his fees and living costs until he's an adult.

Moreover, plenty of adults will shun and avoid bereaved people, because they don't know what to say or how to relate to them; I can imagine this being amplified with other children, who might now also be extra frightened of losing their own parents and project their fears on to the 'orphan boy'.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/11/2021 12:13

Bold fail

Otherpeoplesteens · 02/11/2021 14:36

@Platax

People who loved boarding school, what was it you loved about it? Did you really not miss home and your families? Didn't you think it was a bit of a weird set-up where you were being sent off to live with a load of strangers who had considerable power over you?
I boarded from age nine, mid Eighties through to mid Nineties, and was from an overseas family. No Facetime or Skype, no email, just aerogrammes once a week and a ten minute phonecall during exeat or half term.

At first I loved the sheer breadth of the opportunities available. It was a rural school close to two national parks so as well as the academic curriculum and the normal team sports there was a huge focus on outdoor pursuits: rock climbing, caving, mountaineering, kayaking were all normal things, available to us several times a week at no additional cost. That's before more normal things which would often still be lacking in many day schools: squash, Fives, debating society, choir, orchestra, Tiddlywinks Club, drama. It meant that we were able to move freely between several 'tribes' based on interests without real cliques forming.

And because everything is under one roof and fee-paying, they tried to make everything work for us: during the summer I used to get first choice for practice time on the organ because I also played the rather time-consuming cricket and couldn't be in both places at once. In the winter, I was happy to take what I was given because I didn't play rugby.

It built up a sense of how to live in a community. Because I couldn't leave it all behind when the bell rang at 3pm I learned to live with people I couldn't stand, as well as with those I liked. By the time I left, it wasn't the classroom or the sports or the outdoor pursuits I loved most, it was being in House, with 55 other kids ranging from 13 to 18 years old.

The older kids were able to take on tremendous amounts of responsibility if they were so inclined and capable; running swimming sessions, instructing in campcraft or survival, or more formal leaderships roles around the school or in the CCF or both. There were times when at 17 or 18 I would be walking around the campus in the dark, often with a teacher and sometimes not, on a Saturday night checking that no-one was smoking behind the bike sheds or in the Music School bogs at the same time as making sure that if anyone overdid it in the 6th Form bar then they got back to their house safely, whilst intervening in a fight between two 15 year olds over something or nothing, before going back to House to comfort a 13 year old who had just received word that his family dog had died. I loved it.

I'm still in touch with many of the kids from my House, including those both much older and much younger and view them as family. The teacher who lived in my House at the Resident Tutor when he was a young man in his twenties I'm also still in touch with. He came to my wedding 20 years after I left the school, and when he got made redundant from his last teaching post and set up his own business I helped him with it.

I wouldn't characterise it as a weird set up being sent off to live with a load of strangers who had considerable power over me. It was a whole, massive, second family that I built in the way I wanted. They did not replace my own family, rather the experience amplified the strong relationship I had with my own family. Of course I missed my family, but I appreciated them a lot more than my friends who didn't board.

Several of my schoolfriends were, indeed, 'sent away' and they knew it. For some the experience again amplified that already dysfunctional relationship with their families; for others boarding provided them with stability and affection for the first time in their lives.

The school instilled in me a sense of values that I hold dear today, and I know that I would probably trust someone who went to my school with my life, even if I hadn't met them.

Otherpeoplesteens · 02/11/2021 14:46

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

Plus, without wanting to be harsh about it, if she did die whilst he was still at school, I can't see his 'school family' being willing to suddenly take over all of his fees and living costs until he's an adult.

Funnily enough, one of my close former school friends recently approached me about this situation. He has no living relatives, his wife none outside the former USSR and none who speak a word of English between them. They haven't sent their two children to boarding school because it's not her preference and it's beyond them financially. What they have done, though, is make provision that if they both die then the fees at our old school are covered through life insurance etc, and I would take care of them otherwise.

Not quite the same thing, but you'd be surprised at what boarding school families do for each other. At my school one boy effectively walked away from his own highly dysfunctional family into another's. It happens.

Swipe left for the next trending thread