I wasnt fully aware of this gentle parenting lark until I read all this. I've now realised
that is what is happening at my friends primary school:
Child (5) behaves badly towards another child, is invited for a "chat" about what caused the behaviour and then invited...INVITED to draw a picture for the other child if they would like to apologise.
Of course they want to draw a bloody picture and "have a chat". That's absolutely zero consequences for them!
My flabber has never been so gasted I can tell you.