Skip to main content
Skip to main navigation
Skip to talk navigation

Active discussions

Please or to access all these features

Add post

Watch this thread

Save thread

Start a new thread

Flip thread

Hide thread

My feed

Saved Active Unanswered threads

Getting started FAQ's

Unanswered threads Acronyms Talk guidelines

Hide shortcut buttons

Talk

Flip

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

AIBU?

To think NZ’s plans to make it illegal to sell cigarettes to anyone born after 2004 are a bit draconian?

162 replies

CounsellorTroi · 02/05/2021 10:14

www.theguardian.com/world/2021/apr/16/new-zealand-aims-to-create-smoke-free-generation-cigarettes

I’ve never smoked (well, had a drag of my friend’s fag at 15, didn’t like it so didn’t do it again) but I can’t help feeling that making it illegal to smoke anywhere other than in your own home would suffice.

OP posts:

Share

Report

Am I being unreasonable?

AIBU

You have one vote. All votes are anonymous.

Thethingswedoforlove · 02/05/2021 10:16

I think it’s brilliant. Over time there won’t be anyone left for whom it is legal to sell cigarettes to. The industry will die but slowly. No one has their liberties affected who already chooses to smoke. Lives will be saved. I think it is genius.

megletthesecond · 02/05/2021 10:18

No. I think we'll go the same way eventually and cigarettes will be harder to buy and as the older smokers die it'll be phased out. Give it 100 years and only small numbers will smoke I reckon.

Ilovechinese · 02/05/2021 10:18

I think it's a good idea. All countries should do this

Arbadacarba · 02/05/2021 10:22

I don't know what NZ is like, but over here it's quite easy to buy tobacco 'under the counter'. I would imagine if it's banned for under-18s it may boost an illegal market. There's a thriving global market for illegal drugs and if tobacco is outlawed it will just be another one on the list.

I think generally tobacco is scapegoated. It only harms its consumer - no one beats their partner up because they've smoked too much or goes on a tobacco-fuelled bender. Are they going to ban fast food and sugary drinks as well? What about cars - RTAs account for a high number of deaths?

romdowa · 02/05/2021 10:22

It will just make the black market cigarette trade boom. Making drugs illegal hasn't eliminated drugs nor did prohibition stop people drinking. If people want them they will get them.

emilyfrost · 02/05/2021 10:26

YABU. It’s a great idea (a little light I think personally - we should just making smoking illegal and stop them cold turkey, tough shit).

RampantIvy · 02/05/2021 10:27

In principal I like the idea, but sadly, I think romdowa is right. The police have enough on their plate without having to deal with illegal smokers as well.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 02/05/2021 10:29

Alcohol will be mext, won't it

idontlikealdi · 02/05/2021 10:31

So as we crack down on nicotine and alcohol probably next we start legalising weed. I like all three but weed has a bundle of potential mental health issues. Have a look at some of the stats from CO re gun use.

user1471447863 · 02/05/2021 10:31

It's a brilliant idea. There will now be no new smokers coming into the market and as the existing smoker base literally dies off the whole thing will die out.
In fact as the smoker base decreases it will be less and less profitable for shops to stock them and they should be harder and harder to come by and progressively less and less visible as a thing

ILoveCrap · 02/05/2021 10:32

As an ex smoker I’ve often thought this is the solution, will be interesting to see how it plays out in NZ and whether other countries follow suit.

ThePlantsitter · 02/05/2021 10:33

Tobacco does harm others through passive smoking. Plus tobacco's not really that fun like drugs/booze so there's a chance it'll work. I smoked for years by the way. It's something that starts as a social thing and is a completely meritless addiction - by which I mean it doesn't block out sorrow or give nice feelings - by the end in my view.

grantoderek · 02/05/2021 10:33

I smoke, I am starting at 47 to feel the damage. I am desperately trying to stop. I think it's a brilliant idea. I think alcohol should be taken more seriously as well, in terms of DV and the damage it does to people around them.

MaxNormal · 02/05/2021 10:34

Do people really think making something illegal will stop people doing it?

PicsInRed · 02/05/2021 10:36

It's brilliant. This has been talked about in NZ for years and I'm delighted it's finally happened.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 02/05/2021 10:36

@MaxNormal

Do people really think making something illegal will stop people doing it?

Exactly. I started smoking under 18. Many if us did and we all managed to buy ciggies.

Not like coke or E are not being used here even though it's illegal🤷🏻 Or weed

ThePlantsitter · 02/05/2021 10:36

I think it might work because they're making it illegal to sell it not do it. There are plenty of rules about selling already so you can just tack it on to the enforcement for that.

grantoderek · 02/05/2021 10:37

I smoke far far far less when I am in the UK.. Too bloody cold to go outside and the stink of a recently smoked fag when people come back inside puts me off doing it. I was furious when they banned smoking indoors but totally respect it now.

Mydogdoesntlisten · 02/05/2021 10:37

Why is everyone on here so keen to tell others what to do? As a pp said, where does it end? Sugary drinks? Fatty foods? Anything bad for us?

Mydogdoesntlisten · 02/05/2021 10:41

And as well as the erosion of personal liberty (and yes, I get that some things we choose to do are bad), it will surely just become another illegal drug which people get hold of, but without the government taxing it.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 02/05/2021 10:42

Imagine the tax hole if this was done in the UK. What are income taxes in NZ like?

ThePlantsitter · 02/05/2021 10:42

Not keen to tell everyone what to do. But if you can stop corporates making big bucks out of others' deathly addictions by stopping people needing to do something I'm all for it. I don't know if it will work but it's worth a try.

Nanny0gg · 02/05/2021 10:46

Eat what you like. That doesn’t affect me. Your smoking does

notagainmummy · 02/05/2021 10:48

It's a brilliant idea, but my liberal self says it's also draconian

LindaEllen · 02/05/2021 10:50

@emilyfrost

YABU. It’s a great idea (a little light I think personally - we should just making smoking illegal and stop them cold turkey, tough shit).

Yeah great idea, let's just withdraw an addictive substance from millions of people simultaneously. What could possibly go wrong?!

Flip

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

Trending

Mumsnet Shopping

Sign up to continue reading

Mumsnet's better when you're logged in. You can customise your experience and access way more features like messaging, watch and hide threads, voting and much more.

Continue with Facebook Continue with Google Continue with Apple

Already signed up?