Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My exH refusing to collect children

341 replies

mrshectic · 04/03/2021 09:40

So I will try to keep this short.

Since I moved 7 miles away to a nicer village with more space for my children (they now have their own bedroom as opposed to being squashed in together), my ex is refusing to collect them for his time with them. He doesn't own a car, but he has always used his Mums car to pick them up from the school on his time. She also does his shopping for him at least once a week and he looks after her dog regularly to do so.

He says that because I moved, it's my responsibility to get the children to him and collect them afterwards. Now I have done because it's not fair on the kids that they miss time with him. But I simply cannot keep being expected to spend time and money doing ALL of the carting around using petrol money for him to sit at home doing nothing.

I work, and try hard to homeschool our 3 kids, which he does not help with, even though he doesn't work.

AIBU? Should I suck it up and take them because he tells me he's telling the children it's my fault they won't have time with him?

Fwiw, I have asked why he suddenly won't use his Mums car as he has a support bubble with her, but he simply says it's my responsibility.

OP posts:
Bibidy · 04/03/2021 14:18

@OhCaptain

Cannot roll my eyes hard enough at the “won’t someone think of the children wah wah wah” posts.

OP literally wanted to report this man for neglect.

Thinking of the children would be not driving them over there for weekends of neglect. Unless that’s magically all better now.

I guess you are talking about me??

I am only going on what OP has said on this thread, I am not familiar with any others.

I just think it's harsh people were having a go at OP for still dropping them to him when she is just trying to do what she thinks is right for her children but helping them continue a relationship with their dad. That's what my posts were in response to.

NovemberR · 04/03/2021 14:21

I'd just shrug and say That's a pity. Never mind, they can stay here and get on with life.

It sounds like he doesn't miss them or care if he sees them. He doesn't pay for them, doesn't work and now can't even be bothered to come get them.

They won't lose much. I'd not be running at his arse for him. If he's refusing to come 7 miles to get his children on his access weekends that's his problem.

mainsfed · 04/03/2021 14:22

@Bibidy

I just think it's harsh people were having a go at OP for still dropping them to him when she is just trying to do what she thinks is right for her children but helping them continue a relationship with their dad. That's what my posts were in response to.

Who is having a go at OP? We’re trying to support the OP.

LolaSmiles · 04/03/2021 14:22

He sounds like a lazy pain in the arse, but you moved away so I agree with him. The parent who moves is usually responsible for pick ups/drop offs.

Was the court order saying he picks up from before or after you moved away?

SpaceRaiders · 04/03/2021 14:22

Have you actually bothered to read even one response?!

The general tone of these type of threads usually absolve NRP for putting in minimal effort with their dc. So I apologise profusely if I didn’t read every single comment. Hmm

needsahouseboy · 04/03/2021 14:24

but why force a relationship that one party is not bothered about??

The children can clearly see that there Dad can't be arsed to see them...you think taking them there knowing that is good for them?

I'd stick to the court order and if he doesn't like it then he can take you back to court.

Chewingle · 04/03/2021 14:25

This thread is overwhelmingly, overwhelmingly, that she shouldn’t

Bibidy · 04/03/2021 14:25

[quote mainsfed]@Bibidy

I just think it's harsh people were having a go at OP for still dropping them to him when she is just trying to do what she thinks is right for her children but helping them continue a relationship with their dad. That's what my posts were in response to.

Who is having a go at OP? We’re trying to support the OP.[/quote]
Sorry I don't mean everyone!

I just didn't think it was fair to accuse OP of modelling passive behaviour just because she's trying to put her children's feelings first, even though it's a pain for herself to do the to-ing and fro-ing.

SpaceRaiders · 04/03/2021 14:28

@Chewingle I don’t know what your issue is. In which case, I clearly agreed with the majority. Confused

mainsfed · 04/03/2021 14:29

@Bibidy I definitely didn’t accuse OP of modelling passive behaviour! I said the ‘children will suffer’ / ‘won’t someone think of the children’ hand wringing (as Captain puts it) models passive behaviour.

Redruby2020 · 04/03/2021 14:31

@mrshectic

It’s a 15 min bus ride or maximum of a 10 min car ride. I’ve not moved county’s!
What?! 15 minutes and he can't do it, tell the lazy arse to shift himself! And he's not even working! You are the full time carer and provider you do enough, okay you moved out of choice, not force but it was for the benefit of your DC. When the court order was made were you still living at your old address? I don't know if it's flexible but could you share the drop off's etc?

I have an abusive ex and even he was making the journeys until contact was advised to stop.

TheSparkleJar · 04/03/2021 14:31

The "he shouldn't be penalized because you moved" argument simply doesn't stand up here. She's 10 minutes away, 15 on the bus. They're practically still local.

Why should the children be penalized and have to share a room because they have a lazy feckless father? And yes, if he thinks a 10 minute drive to see his children is "evil" he's feckless and lazy.

I would suggest you do the driving every other weekend. That way you are keeping them in contact. If he wants to see them more often, perhaps he can scrape together some go-getting energy and ask his DM if he can borrow the car for 20 minutes.

Redruby2020 · 04/03/2021 14:33

@needsahouseboy

I would normally say yes but as he is sat on his arse doing nothing while you are home schooling three children it's the least he can do.

7 miles is really not much to be doing for his children either.

He sounds like a right catch having his mum shopping for him?!?!

Exactly how lazy, okay we don't know everyone's circumstances, and we have had a lot of changes with Covid too. But I think it is disgusting when the NRP has the time and freedom to pursue a life and job etc and does nothing!
Chewingle · 04/03/2021 14:38

[quote SpaceRaiders]@Chewingle I don’t know what your issue is. In which case, I clearly agreed with the majority. Confused[/quote]
I just always find it a bit funny when posters join late saying “well I probably have an unpopular opinion...” but it concurs with 90% of the responses! Grin

TheSparkleJar · 04/03/2021 14:41

The parent who moves is usually responsible for pick ups/drop offs.

When they move a distance that would be prohibitory for the other parent to travel yes. That's not this.

There's a thread about someone moving their dc's 45 minutes away and changing school, and I think about 90% of commenters agreed she should be responsible for the driving. Actually I believe she agreed in the end to keep them in the school local to their father and do precisely that.

But fifteen minutes on the bus is nothing when it's about seeing your children. When NRP's act in this way, the writing is on the wall for the future relationship with their DC's.

FishWithoutABike · 04/03/2021 14:47

I think you should drop them to his and he should drop them back. That way he can’t just not turn up and if he doesn’t bring them back he’ll have to look after them for longer which I guess he’s not too interested in doing.

mrshectic · 04/03/2021 14:47

I have stuck to my guns and said no. He’s now trying to move the weekends around for when they are back at school. He has also said I’m a narcissist and guilty of parent alienation by not doing both trips. And has just put up a social media post about how people need to stop being controlling Hmm .

I honestly give up!

OP posts:
lazyarse123 · 04/03/2021 14:48

@Ermidunno

It doesn’t say anywhere he doesn’t work. It says he’s sat on arse doing nothing for the 10 minutes OP is driving the kids. Why should he be out of pocket. Around here a 6 mile bus ride would be £4 for an adult, no idea the cost for 2 kids. Why should he be so out of pocket because you moved?
It says he doesn't work in the op. Another deadbeat dad. When will they realise that the kids will be aware eventually of how he is behaving.
Lordamighty · 04/03/2021 14:49

It’s 7 miles, he is being ridiculous. If he can’t make the effort to see his own children then that’s his problem to deal with.

Graphista · 04/03/2021 14:52

Ugh! There are MANY threads like this to be honest

Op I think you need to be prepared for the real possibility this is just the beginning of him "easing" his way out of dcs lives - in such a way as he can tell himself, and the dc that it's not his fault/is your fault.

This is VERY common! My ex did the same. I battled to keep dd seeing her dad and quite honestly I now very much regret that, I should have "read the signs" and realised it was better for dd to let him sod off while she was too young to remember (don't know age of yours admittedly)

Frankly it goes like this:

Best - fully engaged dad who makes the effort

Next best - dad who sods off completely

Worst - half arsed dad who only sees kids when it suits him, expects everyone else to put the work in for him (as the kids get older this includes the kids) and moans and bitches constantly making out their worlds greatest dad (they're not!!)

I'm 48 I've also seen evidence to form my opinion above with other separated parent arrangements

My sisters ex (similar distance) was exactly the same as your ex!

7 miles is NOTHING it's 15-20 mins on a bus, 10-15 mins by train and he has a car at his disposal

RandomMess · 04/03/2021 14:52

Just ignore him you know it's lies!!!

If you and the DC don't mind swapping weekends tell him it's fine he can have 3 weekends on the trot to compensate.

Graphista · 04/03/2021 14:52

He just can't be arsed!

Legally you can't enforce contact - which surprised and annoyed me when I first learned this but actually it makes sense why enforce an uncaring parent on a child

Legally the onus is on the nrp to turn up for contact

Be honest with yourself, you know him, is it just this one issue or is he generally disinterested and likely to remove himself from their lives in the near future? How long ago did you split? How has he been about contact generally?

Sounds like he cares more about demonising you than he does his kids

Why should he be out of pocket.

Why should op?! These are HIS kids too and I'd bet good money IF he's paying cm it's cms minimum!

As annoying as it is I'd do what is best for the kids.

And what is that?! As I said I've seen/dealt/am dealing with the ramifications of a disinterested, unengaged nrp who's more interested in scoring points against the ex than in providing a stable supportive relationship to their child, my dd is 20 now and still desperately seeking approval
and unconditional love from my ex that she's unlikely to ever experience. It's SO damaging!

Friends of hers and mine where the children never knew their dad or he buggered off when they were too young to remember are faring much better emotionally

what's best for the child isn't always contact and a relationship with the nrp when it's emotionally damaging even abusive (and banging on about how horrible the rp is to them IS abusive) frankly it's time courts recognised this and FINALLY ACTUALLY prioritised the children

Kids aren’t stupid

While I agree, adults are vulnerable to gaslighting children more so, if he's telling them EVERY Time he sees them that you're obstructing contact they may well start to wonder if it's true

And no I don’t get a penny towards the children what a surprise - not!!

Has he been banned from driving and just doesn't want it to be known? that wouldn't surprise me either - would it you op? Another possibility is his mother has said he'll have to cover the petrol and he is not wanting to do that (and his mother has no responsibility to the dc)

He's a deadbeat and toxic, personally I think your kids are likely better off without him in their lives

He's still point scoring and bitching after 8 years! Wtf! Talk about holding a grudge!

But you are in London? It’s easy to be able to do a 7 mile journey in 15 minutes where I am. Not everyone lives in a city

Exactly - but even an hour if it means having a good relationship with your kids and a good co-parenting relationship is worth it yes? I checked 7 miles where I am tales about 20 mins

My ex kicked off about me moving (admittedly significantly further) BUT he was army and at the time where we were living wasn't near EITHER family, where I moved to was a major city in Uk which is very easy to get to/from from pretty much any other part of the Uk! So wherever he ended up posted to contact would still be very manageable and potentially he could have been posted very nearby (something he never even bothered to request - which he could have!), he was indeed posted less than 6 months after I moved and where he was moved to, if I had stayed where we were when we split it would have been murder and very expensive to maintain regular contact with dd

Oh, I forgot to mention - even when we first split and he was in WALKING DISTANCE of us he barely bothered!

I've also witnessed other forces nrps make loads of effort to maintain contact and good relationships with their kids, including when they were located overseas

It can be done IF the nrp actually gives a shit!

If they don't they won't bother even if the distance is 1 mile!

I bent over backwards to ensure dd had contact with her dad. I did the travelling (100's of miles no car) and paid for it all inc at times overnight in a hotel or B&b if I couldn't get return travel the same day. Ex would bitch and moan about collecting her from the train station near him!

Eventually it got to a point I could no longer afford to do it, around the same time dd came across something that meant she learned this was the case (I'd foolishly, based on the "what's best for dd" bollocks often spouted here and elsewhere in regard to separated parents and contact, shielded her from knowing he was basically making sod all effort! I was even having to chase him to book HIS annual leave for when dd was visiting - he "forgot" on a few occasions meaning dd didn't see much of him and she was mainly in the care of her step mum and grandparents, which I don't object to per se but the point was HE wasn't spending time with her!)

This led to a discussion with dd in which she asked me, and given my finances I agreed, to let ex be the one to organise, pay for and do the travelling necessary to see her. Within a year he was no longer having ANY contact with her - he'd even blocked her!! I shit you not, blocked her on everything! Dick!

She continued to write to him (via the army as I knew his service number which means the army can ensure letters are forwarded to his correct work address) send him cards etc and he never replied.

I will NEVER forgive him for his utterly shite treatment of her.

So no, not all nrps deserve or should be facilitated to have contact with their children.

I've seen similar issues in a couple of families I know where the nrp was the mother too. So while yes it's not only men, most nrps are men and most deadbeat parents are men.

You know him op, you know how he's likely to be in the future and you know your kids and what is likely to actually be best for them.

Some kids will want to know every effort was made by both parents, some will recognise that there's only so much a rp can do and that they can't be expected to make up for the failings of the nrp.

I honestly just wish courts, social workers etc would understand and recognise that it's not always in the best interests of the child to be forced together with a parent who isn't interested in BEING a parent

I'd go to CMS and claim maintenance. If he is on benefits for not working it will be a minimal amount

I've just done a dummy calculation based on info op gave and result is? He doesn't have to pay anything! Which is fucking disgusting!

This country has a ridiculously tolerant attitude towards men who don't contribute to their children's lives in any meaningful way.

Totally agree!

The children are going to be "involved" whatever you do

If as a pp says he's neglectful even when they are with him, then tbh they're definitely better off without him in their lives

The advice to “go back to court”
Is generally from people who have not had experience with the system
agreed. It's costly, stressful and time consuming (won't be costing him anything though! But will cost taxpayers - ie everyone else!) and in most cases makes fuck all difference cos the authorities do sod all when it comes to enforcement!

Op all you have to do legally is make the children AVAILABLE for contact, all that means is they're dressed and prepared and you're at the location he's supposed to collect from.

I had ALL this crap early on with my ex too, and was advised by lawyer to only wait for an hour or two and if he didn't show to go out and NOT be available - I WISH I had taken that advice

Maybe speak to your lawyer just to clarify, they will be very familiar not only with your case with the many cases like this. And TAKE THEIR ADVICE.

now they are older and he is able to have a relationship with them totally independent of me he doesn't bother his arse with them

Exactly mine and dds experience

It would not be nice for them to know that their dad can't be arsed coming to pick them up

I'm fairly confident the older 2 at least know exactly what a dead loss he is

Op Ignore all his goady nasty comments, mute on sm (don't block you still need access to check re any posts directly related to dc I would say, plus I don't think he would know you muted him but would notice blocking)

Stop letting him drag you down with him remember

Never fight with a pig, you both get dirty but the pig loves it!

cravingthelook · 04/03/2021 14:54

Oh I'd say ok I'll bring them and you return them. He will certainly get the car to bring them back.

Eddielzzard · 04/03/2021 14:57

I'd suggest the other way round. He collects and you fetch. He'll be late or not pitch up and he'll undeniably look like a shit, but you get to make sure they come home.

CherryDocsInYrBalls · 04/03/2021 14:57

My ExP moved a little further and expects me to do the driving otherwise he "can't afford the bus fare to see them" which is a load of balls because he smokes and drinks. I do it for my kids and the second they say they're not bothered about going I can rest assured it wasn't anything to do with me. Unfortunately we had children with absolute useless fuckwits and are now paying the price. Block him on social media and grey rock him, at this point anything he says to you is of no consequence to you

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.