Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to tell siblings about mothers death?

233 replies

SunsetSenora · 23/01/2021 19:34

I am one of 4 children, a lot younger than my siblings. My parents were 18 when they married, each desperate to escape a hated mother, and it did not make for a happy family - all of the kids have been estranged from the family at some point. As an adult I worked through a lot of stuff and reconciled with my mother, spending the last 10 years living near her, and helping nurse her for the last few. My brother lives in the same town but cut off contact with my mum about 10 years ago, which was devastating to her. He could have made contact at any time, as my sister and mother have lived in the same houses since before he cut himself off. He has always been the type of person who takes no responsibility for his actions, uses what ever he can get his hands on, and sponges off (or steals) from the people around him. I have spent hours listening to her when she wanted to talk about this, and when it became obvious she was dying, offered to go and find him. She said she didn't want the hassle, but I think it would have been heart-breaking if she know he knew how ill she was and didn't respond. I have another sister who lives overseas, who is very similar to my brother but even more so. We have not talked to for about 4 years, since she told me she was going to 'go out for a slap up meal and celebrate that woman's death' when talking about my mother. I pointed out that, not only was that a horrible sentiment about anyone, but she was also talking about my mother and she hung up. So, the question is -now mum has died should I try to track them down to tell them? I don't want to, but part of me feels really bad about the whole situation.

OP posts:
dottypotter · 27/01/2021 14:47

Don't talk such bollocks. Not all parents do the best they can, and even if they do, when that best is terrible, its not enough and it doesn't make it ok.
You have no idea what you are talking about.

I do.

What is not enough? Do children always tell the truth about their childhoods or do they sometimes rewrite history?

Its all down to the child not the parents as said above. Otherwise how do you explain children still wanting to know their parents when they have been put into care etc.

Nimue21 · 27/01/2021 14:49

Its all down to the child not the parents as said above. Otherwise how do you explain children still wanting to know their parents when they have been put into care etc

Wow. There's something wrong with you.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 27/01/2021 14:50

Dotty, you are ridiculous

Mittens030869 · 27/01/2021 14:52

@dottypotter

With respect, you appear to be assuming the other way, though. My F gave every impression of being a loving father to my DSis and me. He even convinced my DM of that fact and manipulated us into believing that he had our best interests at heart. (Because at other times, he really did act the caring father.)

The reality was that he was sexually abusing us virtually under her nose and she couldn't see it because he had done a number on her as well.

Obviously I'm not saying that this is the case with the OP's siblings. And it doesn't justify their behaviour now. I resent the fact that my DM didn't know what was going on when I was a child, but I accept that she didn't know and know that she was a victim, too, of my F's gaslighting and coercive control of her.

Family relationships are complicated and sometimes things are not as they appear.

Daisypaisy2 · 27/01/2021 16:30

@dottypotter

None of your children speak to you, right? Can see why.

no you know nothing dont assume!!

Dont always assume its the parents fault though. Plenty of children bought up in care and they often go back to their parents. They also want to be in their parents lives. Lots of Children who have had loving parents are emotionally abusive and estrange for no given reason. So therefore its down to the individual child and their personality nothing to do with the parenting.

If that was the case some people wouldnt love their parents and want their company even though they have given them up/being abusive etc.

Its good to look at it from all sides.
I believe alot of respect is also missing today from the younger generation towards their parents. I could never have cut my parents off even though we didnt always see eye to eye. Too much respect lus couldnt have upset them like that. Its selfish.

It’s different times I agree. It’s not even a bit comparable there’s many reasons. For one in today’s society women want high flying careers years ago it was not the case. Something has to give because you cannot be parenting to your best ability, running a household and holding down a career too.

If someone has cut you off it’s more than “you don’t see eye to eye”. It’s better to cut someone off rather than arguing constantly it’s no good for anybody’s metal health.

Daisypaisy2 · 27/01/2021 16:39

@dottypotter

Parents do tge best they can. Nobody is perfect not even the kids. It's a total lack of respect to cut your parents off unless there really is some very bad reason. Says alot about you if you do that to your parents and totally selfish too.
Wow to your comment. What do you mean parents do their best meaning what?

I’m assuming you have a relatively good relationship to say something like this.

Children do not automatically owe their parents in life!

LizFlowers · 27/01/2021 18:11

I feel for you, Sunsetsenora. Whatever you decide you can't be right or wrong.

If your siblings can be found, I still think my original suggestion of just sending them a card informing them of your mother's death is a good one. It's easy and then you can forget them (as far as you can), because they sound pretty horrendous, frankly. However you would have done the right thing as far as you can.

Then move on and live your life.

Good luck.

SeaEagleFeather · 29/01/2021 15:14

People showing 'sorrow' and 'sadness' at a funeral of someone they haven't said a single fucking word to in a decade or more, really boils my piss

I will cry buckets because I really, really want a relationship with my Dad, but my stepmother stopped it and poisoned it and him so that whenever I saw him he did nothing but put me down, be nasty and hurt me. After 30 years of it I had enough; no matter how much a man is your father, 30 years abuse is enough.

But my heart hurts and will never stop hurting, and sometimes I will be angry, because he is the father of my heart and I wish so much we could have had a relationship.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page