[quote TonMoulin]@Ihatefish,
I think the difference between you and the DH is that I’m assuming you’ve always found it hard. Whereas her DH hasnt. He was actually quite good at it.
It also doesn’t explain why he failed to take his dd shopping even though she reminded him. Or why she didn’t push him and did something creative instead. My teens would have pestered DH when she seemed to just accept it wasn’t going to happen (which makes me think he has form).[/quote]
The OP said he asked her father repeatedly.
Then when he didn't take her, instead of giving her mum nothing she's apparently put a lot of time into making gifts for her.
I don't think the DD is at fault here.
The reality is the DH for years managed to get nice gifts but over time "has forgotten" how to do it.
He's not incapable nor is he really thoughtless (he can get gifts for his sisters) he just can't be arsed to do it for his wife - despite the fact she puts a huge amount of effort in Christmas for all the family to enjoy (including him).
It takes hardly any time to order something nice online.
DH is hard to buy for but I "listen out" during the year for things he mentions he likes and make a note so I have ideas for Christmas and birthdays.
It's not about a big expensive gift.
It's about someone taking the time to choose something personal to you - it shows you know them, listen to them and care about making them happy.