Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel overwhelmed by this? What do i do? Boyfriend pressuring abortion

207 replies

nutellacrumpet8991 · 12/10/2020 11:17

This is a very tricky situation and i feel overwhelmed. It is not a case of being irresponsible, just stupid. I had a stomach bug last month and did not cross our minds that that would make the pill ineffective. I’ve been on the pill for years and this never happened.

I just found out i am about 6 weeks pregnant according to the date of my last period. I am 22, my boyfriend is 24. If we keep the baby we’ll be 23 and 25 when the baby arrives.
We’ve only been together for 6 months. Been living together for 4 months. Our relationship seem very stable, we both see it as something serious that will hopefully lead to marriage and kids(later).

We both work full time and together make around 40k a year before tax. So not a lot of money but not poor either.

When i showed him the many positive tests his first reaction was excitement and happiness. He started making future plans. Like we’ll move into his parents empty house so we don’t need to pay rent, his retired parents will be more than happy to babysit once maternity leave is over so we don’t need to pay for daycare, he will trade in his very expensive car for a cheaper one, so pretty responsible reaction.

I had no initial reaction because i was in shock. I just felt and still feel fear.

However he changed his opinion very fast. He told me he’s made his decision and that is abortion. He said it’s the smart thing to do and he does not want to give up his life for a baby.

I agree it is the smart thing to do and i am pro choice. Before this happened to me i always thought that if it happened i would choose abortion. But now that it actually happened it is not that easy. I don’t know if it is the pregnancy hormones or what, but i feel a weird sense of attachment towards the thing growing in my stomach. Also strong feelings of guilt and ‘what ifs’. I don’t know if i can go through with abortion. I know i will regret it all my life and it will haunt me. If i abort it will be mostly for my boyfriend.

Whatever decision i make i feel like i can’t win. If i keep the baby i feel guilty for forcing him to have a baby he doesn’t want. If i abort i will feel guilty for killing my baby and will always wonder what could have been and i know i will resent my boyfriend.

He says he is scared that his life is not in his hands anymore because i have the ultimate say. He says he is scared he will grow feelings of resent towards me and the baby. He keeps repeating that he made his choice and that is pressuring me.

I don’t want to be a single mum and i told him that if i decide to keep it he can leave. He says no, he will need to be part. But words are words and i don’t want to be a single mum. I doubt he would walk away because he’s been broody ever since we met, always talking about kids and how he can’t wait to be a dad one day. He even had his names chosen. This was before the accident though.

I feel overwhelmed. I really don’t think i can go through with an abortion. I don’t know what to do. I am terrified. I already resent my boyfriend because i feel it is so easy for him to just say he’s made his decision because he is not the one who is suffering the consequences of having to do something he does not want to do.

OP posts:
DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 12/10/2020 14:08

He trusted Op & unfortunately she made a mistake

She made a mistake? They both had sex and Contraception is not infallible.

Nottherealslimshady · 12/10/2020 14:12

I think it sounds like you're in a pretty decent position, you're hardly fresh out of school, you're earning decent money, have childcare available, have suitable home. Seems like he's just getting cold feet. I dont see the need for an abortion.
But at the end of the day it's your choice, it's your body, if you go through with it for him and regret it it'll ruin your relationship anyway.
I wouldn't. But my opinion is skewed, I'm 25 and just got pregnant deliberately after a recent miscarriage, and I'm not really very supportive of abortions just because it's not the perfect time to have a baby. If you choose an abortion, make the decision sooner rather than later as early abortions are far kinder to your body and mind.
Goodluck in whatever YOU decide.

Nottherealslimshady · 12/10/2020 14:14

Also, this is not OPs fault. They both were aware she had a stomach bug, it was both of their responsibility to use alternative contraception.

Shayisgreat · 12/10/2020 14:14

I think the relationship is over now really. One of you will always resent the other which ever option you choose. Now you decide what's best for your mental health, wellbeing, and life plan with the understanding that you will probably be a single parent.

Meuniere · 12/10/2020 14:16

He trusted Op & unfortunately she made a mistake

Contraception is a SHARED responsibility. He knew about the ABs, so was also just as able to think about the fact it might influence contraception (or he could have asked etc....).
A bit of easy for him to wash his hands from it all and rely 100% on his partner and then make it out that she has to do as he says because ‘it’s all HER fault’.

It’s not. They BOTH made a mistake. It can happen. It could also well have been an issue with the pill nit working (nothing is 100% safe). If he didn’t want children that badly, then he should have used a condom just in case.

CaraDuneRedux · 12/10/2020 14:18

I was just about to say what Shay's said: the relationship is probably dead in the water either way.

Either you have the abortion, then the resentment for him grows until you walk, or you have the baby and he walks. I don't see him coming round to the idea, sorry.

So really, take him out of the decision making process and decide what you want. Good luck with whatever you choose. Flowers

TweeBree · 12/10/2020 14:21

Did he ask you what you wanted? He doesn't seem interested in your feelings.

diddl · 12/10/2020 14:22

@Meuniere

He trusted Op & unfortunately she made a mistake

Contraception is a SHARED responsibility. He knew about the ABs, so was also just as able to think about the fact it might influence contraception (or he could have asked etc....).
A bit of easy for him to wash his hands from it all and rely 100% on his partner and then make it out that she has to do as he says because ‘it’s all HER fault’.

It’s not. They BOTH made a mistake. It can happen. It could also well have been an issue with the pill nit working (nothing is 100% safe). If he didn’t want children that badly, then he should have used a condom just in case.

I did put that he should have used condoms as well!
CrappleUmble · 12/10/2020 14:27

The relationship is dead either way, so don't make a decision based on trying to save it. Assume that whatever happens now, the two of you are finished.

VettiyaIruken · 12/10/2020 14:28

A joint decision? Interesting.
How does a joint decision work in a situation where the person whose body it is wants to proceed and the person whose body it is not wants the opposite?
Toss a coin? Heads I have control of my body, tails I am taken to hospital by police and subjected to a forced abortion?

It is not a joint decision. He gets an opinion. Nothing more.

blueberrypie0112 · 12/10/2020 14:41

@VettiyaIruken

A joint decision? Interesting. How does a joint decision work in a situation where the person whose body it is wants to proceed and the person whose body it is not wants the opposite? Toss a coin? Heads I have control of my body, tails I am taken to hospital by police and subjected to a forced abortion?

It is not a joint decision. He gets an opinion. Nothing more.

It was his decision not to wear a condom, they were dating 6 months, I think that’s too early to drop his guard and decide whatever happen happens. The rest is her Decision. Once the child enter the picture, it will be a joint decision because it will not be about either parents. Only if the parent want to be involved in the child’s life.
Kinkybutkind · 12/10/2020 14:47

@Shayisgreat

I think the relationship is over now really. One of you will always resent the other which ever option you choose. Now you decide what's best for your mental health, wellbeing, and life plan with the understanding that you will probably be a single parent.
I couldn’t agree more with this. There is no future for this relationship based on the situation you found yourself in. Having experienced a termination, I felt and still to a large extent feel (nearly 20 years on) , a mix of regret and relief.

Parenting is hard and parenting alone is even harder, it’s made more complicated by trying to co-parent with a person who bitterly blames you for putting them in the position of being one.

It’s a tough decision, probably one of the hardest and I think you do need some professional advice. I wish you all the best for the future Flowers whatever you decide.

Frost1nMay · 12/10/2020 14:48

your body, your choice.

It is a horrible and completely unenviable position to be in, but the decision is yours.

Please do not be pressured into doing something that is not your final decision.

Babies are wonderful and amazing, and your life will almost certainly be richer for it. However your life will also be forever changed and in some ways could be much harder.

It is your choice. No one can tell you what to do.

I had an abortion at Uni. No regrets I went on to have 2 children with my DH.

fishonabicycle · 12/10/2020 15:15

Horrid position, but you are very young - you will have plenty of time for more babies, when you are older.

Otherwise prepare yourself to be a single mother. And that isn't easy.

AmIACowBag · 12/10/2020 16:08

Your choice OP. All single mums think they cannot cope at first. I was considering putting my 2 year old up for adoption as I thought I couldn't work and raise a baby on my own with no input from his dad, but I could and I did. You will be ok x

AmIACowBag · 12/10/2020 16:09

Reading that back it sounds dramatic but I think I was having a breakdown at the time

VenusClapTrap · 12/10/2020 16:42

Second, I would strongly recommend that you try to take the guilt out of this, from both sides of this decision.

I think this is really good advice. If you want a baby, have a baby. But don’t do it out of guilt. Likewise, don’t have an abortion out of guilt. Do it because you want to. As other posters have advised, ask him to move out for a couple of weeks so you have some headspace to think things through, and work out what you want. Look at the practicalities and finances involved in having a baby right now.

Getting impartial counselling to help you make your decision is a really really good idea.

Merryoldgoat · 12/10/2020 16:58

I doubt your relationship will survive because the reality is you’re in disagreement.

If you keep the baby you may feel either he’s only with you for the baby or that he is playing along, both of which will lead to resentment.

If you have an abortion you don’t want you will resent him.

There’s no real happy ending here for you as a couple in my opinion.

Therefore do whatever you feel gives YOU the best chance at happiness.

At 23 I couldn’t have had a baby. But my mum had me at that age and was fine, as it is for many.

NewlyGranny · 12/10/2020 17:26

He's clearly in shock and I think you are, too. A great many babies do arrive unplanned but not unwanted - there's a big difference! I wonder why he was initially thrilled and then did a U turn. It's not very encouraging, is it? Who did he tell, do you know? Is he usually strongly influenced by whoever he last spoke to?

How do you know he wouldn't turn again later if you terminate and pile the guilt on for destroying his child?!

He needs to stop harping on about his decision, leave you in peace to think and do some thinking himself. I wouldn't ask for time apart unless he won't shut up and stop pressuring you.

He may not feel ready for fatherhood, but fatherhood is clearly ready for him! If he really didn't want children yet, he should have used condoms to be extra sure. A termination is not contraception, is it? It's a much more complicated and emotional business.

It's clear from what you say that you aren't happy with the idea of a termination, let alone being hustled into it by your bf! I wonder if it's worth asking him the big $64 000 question:

If the choice he had were to be you and his baby as a package, or lose you and end the relationship, which would he choose? Eliminate the third and all other options and ask him to think about just the all in or all out options. Give him time, you don't want an instant answer.

What he tells you will show you who he is. If he refuses to choose or says he wants out, he's failed you and he's not worth keeping. An option A answer gives you a firm place to start negotiating from because it shows live and commitment.

Be prepared to lose him, OP, because it's a short relationship and he has already shown himself to be pretty wobbly. 😢

Single motherhood is very few people's favoured option, but lots of women manage it nevertheless.

20mum · 12/10/2020 18:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

embaex · 12/10/2020 20:26

Similar situ but not exactly the same..just wanted to share my story I guess.

This time back in March, I was in the same situation with my children's dad. So would have been baby number 3.

He flat out wouldn't give me a response/his feelings/anything at all tbh and I ended up going through with it and I still regret it to this day and keep thinking 'what if' to this day. (Probably was a good thing long term as he's a shite dad to the children we already have and of course was not planned-was also having an affair which was prob the reason for the not answering!)

But in your situ, I think if you're already questioning the what ifs etc then you know what you want deep down, I'm unsure how his reaction has changed so quickly but it's very unfair he's pressuring you.
I do hope you make the right choice for you OP x

embaex · 12/10/2020 20:31

*I meant the termination-sorry that wasn't clear in my original reply x

Suzi888 · 12/10/2020 20:38

Would he attend a counselling session with you?

ArnieLinson · 12/10/2020 20:45

He says he is scared that his life is not in his hands anymore because i have the ultimate say. He says he is scared he will grow feelings of resent towards me and the baby. He keeps repeating that he made his choice and that is pressuring me. This is manipulative.

Op, assume you will be a single parent when making your decision. Can you manage?

lockdownalli · 12/10/2020 21:03

Honestly OP I would tell him it isn't his decision. I have a son in his twenties and I can assure you he is aware that no contraception is 100% effective, and anytime you have sex, it might result in a pregnancy. And that he will have absolutely no say in whether that pregnancy goes ahead or not.

Will you have support from your family if you are a single parent? I don't think not wanting to be a SP should come into it really as that can happen to anyone at any point so nobody would ever have a baby if that was their main concern.

If you want the baby then that's that. He will have to pay you 15% of his net pay I believe as child maintenance. I hope he has another sudden change of mind, but even if he does, you will always remember this reaction. Do you think his parents have had a hand in his sudden turn about? Flowers

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.