Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to miss BIL wedding in Scotland?

429 replies

NameChange9182 · 06/11/2019 08:31

I’m a regular poster (penis beaker, softzilla etc) but have name-changed as I’m worried SIL is on here.

BIL (DH’s brother) and SIL have just announced they are getting married in Scotland next year in the Highlands. The area is important to them as they visit every year to go hiking etc and they have loose, distant family heritage connections to the area. However they have never lived in Scotland and none of their living relatives or any of their friends live up there (we mostly live in London or are scattered across the south).

The problem for us with getting there is that it’s not possible to just travel up on the day and get there in time for the ceremony, so you have to travel up the day before. The wedding is on a Saturday but is during term time and DH is a teacher so can’t take the day off, so that means not leaving until around 4pm on the Friday.

Apparently other guests who are teachers are either getting the sleeper train that night to arrive the next morning, are flying up to Edinburgh after school and then hiring a car to drive the rest of the way that night, or are staying in Edinburgh for the night and then getting a train for the last bit on the saturday morning. None of those options would really work for us as we have two young children (DS will be 3 and DD will be 11 months) - they really need their sleep routine (I’m not being precious, they will genuinely be horrors at the wedding the next day if they haven’t slept) and all 3 options would mean keeping them up way past their bedtime.

I think BIL and SIL think they are being accommodating as they have researched and told us all the travel options and have also said they “don’t mind” if we’re not able to bring the kids (but have also asked DS to be page boy if he does come?!) I don’t feel able to leave them for two nights, even with my parents. They are fine looking after DS for a day but they’re not in the best of health and he’s a handful at the best of times, without adding the baby too!

So my suggestion is that DH goes alone on the sleeper train and I stay at home with the kids. Although tbh I’d be upset to miss it and I think BIL and SIL would be quite offended (most of their friends don’t have kids so I think they just don’t get it!). Overall I’m just pissed off that they’ve chosen somewhere so difficult to get to for all of their guests and haven’t made sure that it works for close family before choosing it. Just feels like we haven’t been considered properly and they don’t really care if our kids are there or not but will be offended if DH and I aren’t there.

WIBU to say it’s too difficult for me to go, either with or without the kids?

OP posts:
Mrsmememe · 06/11/2019 08:46

I’m pretty sure your husband could apply for exceptional circumstance leave and it would be approved. Its no different to when a teacher is off sick, they make last minute arrangements so at least he’s giving his superiors notice.
You are just being awkward.

Kahlua4me · 06/11/2019 08:48

I agree with pp and think the best option is for you travel up earlier with dc and dh travel later.

Could you check into a nice hotel in Edinburgh and meet him there? Maybe go up on Thursday then dc will definitely get a good sleep Friday ready for the wedding.

JenniferM1989 · 06/11/2019 08:49

Why can't you fly to Aberdeen or Inverness?

Anotherlongdrive · 06/11/2019 08:52

my point was that if they lived up there I would understand their choice and see it as an inevitable part of living far away from family. But they’ve never lived there, they’ve just picked it because they like it rather than thinking about where is feasible for their family to get to.

What's there to understand? Lots of people get married somewhere away from where they live. They have picked somewhere special to them for their wedding.

If they lived there it wouldnt be any easier for you to travel up. So doesnt make a difference.

If you dont want to go. Dont. But getting annoyed because they picked somewhere special to them, rather than priortise you, is very unreasonable

AmIThough · 06/11/2019 08:52

@Hwory irrelevant really.

I'm just making a suggestion - I wouldn't do it myself anyway.

SmileCheese · 06/11/2019 08:55

Like others have said I don't see why you have not considered the simplest option of you and the children travelling down earlier and DH meeting you there after work.

It does very much seem like you are looking for any reason to not attend when the reality is they have given you plenty of notice to work out arrangements.

GrapefruitGin · 06/11/2019 08:55

If you dont want to go. Dont. But getting annoyed because they picked somewhere special to them, rather than priortise you, is very unreasonable

This.
You’re being awkward and coming over as rather entitled. If you really wanted to go, you’d make something work. You’re looking for a reasonable excuse NOT to go. I feel sorry for your BIL & SIL.

WestSideSnorey · 06/11/2019 08:56

In situations like this is doesn't matter if you are being unreasonable or not, it only matters what the BIL & SIL think (and to a degree your DH).

These are the people who are either going to think you are a dick or not and they are either going to let that affect your relationship or not.

My personal thoughts are that they've chosen a far off venue and therefore shouldn't begrudge people not turning up. But they may expect people to make the effort as that's what they expect from their friends and family.

So really it's just about how they will feel, how they will react and if the fall out would be less preferable to the hardship of getting up there. None of us know the answers to this so despite it not being unreasonable and despite you having free will to do whatever suits your family, only you and BIL/SIL really know what's for the best. I suspect the fact that you made this post suggests that they'd be put out in which case you should probably think of a solution and if one genuinely doesn't exist, explain this to them.

Girlsmummy30 · 06/11/2019 08:58

It's their wedding. The choose what they want. Simple answer is for you to travel a day before dh with the children so you don't upset their routine.

aweedropofsancerre · 06/11/2019 08:59

Sounds fantastic and I would be making a weekend out of it. No idea why your DH can’t get a flight on Friday from London, it takes around 45mins to get to Edinburgh. There may even be a place to fly to closer to the wedding, like Inverness? Anyway for me I would be jumping to go. However I too live in London but come from Scotland so may be bias

ChicCroissant · 06/11/2019 09:04

I'll admit that I didn't attend a family event in the Highlands last year because it would have meant my secondary-age DD having three days off school - one for travel, one for the event and another day back, and that was with flights and a hire car! It is a long way, there's no doubt about that and very expensive to get to. DD didn't want to miss that much school (they do bang on about attendance ...)

Having said that your children are below school age so you could go up earlier than your DH and settle them in to the hotel. But it is a big ask to travel that far. There is only one set of flights per day from our local airport so not a lot of choice, and some of the other attendees just drove because they couldn't afford flights.

The event I'm referring to was not a planned one so travel was arranged at short notice.

HilaryBriss · 06/11/2019 09:05

I just wouldn't go if it were me. I wouldn't want to travel up a day or two before my DH with 2 small children and even if I did, that is extra expense.

I would just let DH attend on his own.

bluebeck · 06/11/2019 09:05

Agree with PP - YABU for thinking they should have their wedding in a location that suits you.

Just travel up with the DC ahead of time, simple solution.

maddening · 06/11/2019 09:08

You fly to Edinburgh in the morning on the Friday with the dc, get a holiday apartment for 1 night (lots available right in centre), dh can fly up after work and then hire a car to drive up next morning.

justmyview · 06/11/2019 09:09

In your shoes, I would miss a friend's wedding, but would go all out for immediate family. I think you could manage this if you wanted to

maddening · 06/11/2019 09:10

Or indeed fly to inverness, I did that to attend a concert there.

Invisimamma · 06/11/2019 09:11

Sounds like you don't want to go.

You could fly up earlier with the children and get them settled and dh join you.

There's a flight from Gatwick at 4:45pm to Inverness, arrives 6:35pm...not that late at all.
You then hire car to drive to wedding venue Saturday morning.

marshmallowss · 06/11/2019 09:11

Direct family- can't DH request an unpaid days leave? I did and was approved.

Aarghhelpplease · 06/11/2019 09:11

your husband would be able to get a day off for his brothers birthday even if he is a teacher. I am a teacher and others in the school I work in have had days off for weddings and funerals etc. Before a decision is made your husband should speak to his school.

Igneococcus · 06/11/2019 09:12

Where in the HIghlands is it? There are big differences how easy it is to get to the different parts of the Highlands from Edinburgh, and Glasgow might be the better option to fly to.

moominmammy · 06/11/2019 09:13

We have a wedding in Scotland coming up. DC will be 3 and 1 and a mess if they've done that trip the day before, so we're making it our holiday and spending the week before there as well. As your DH can't go in the week, could you go with DC a day or 2 before and make it a short break?

PollyShelby · 06/11/2019 09:13

I would fly up earlier and DH can fly up after work.

That'll be okay and you can all enjoy it.

Anotheronetwo · 06/11/2019 09:13

Has your husband asked for the Friday off work? My school let me miss a day for just a friend's wedding, so it's possible they would say yes for a brother.

Aarghhelpplease · 06/11/2019 09:13

Although it does sound like you just don’t want to go. You could make it work with young children if you wanted to.

justmyview · 06/11/2019 09:14

Where is the wedding?