Part of respecting motherhood is acknowledging that it’s a “role”... just like some professions..
You do learn on the job. And so someone who has been a mother for a while does have more experience than someone who hasn’t.. there isn’t badges of honour or rewards or milestones that mothers go through to prove theyre doing well at being mothers and so you can’t decide whose style is working better than who.,,
But what you can be sure about is that their experience taught them something which you have no clue about...
Unless you have fostered or adopted , which is another journey in motherhood but has most things in common to do with parenting then you reallt don’t have the experience to formulate a valid opinion,
You are entitled to think what you wish, but going to a Periatric surgeon challenging his approach and acting like you know better, without evidence or facts... is slightly arrogant.
His opinion trumps yours unless yours.. until you have some evidence for what you are saying and then it’s worth a discussion.
Here is the hierarchy:
Personal opinion
Trial and error experimentation
Facts and evidence backed by experts
But an opinion of an inexperienced person against someone who has been through the trial and error, in a patronising manner is really quite arrogant. And not usually received well.
I find that a lot of my childfree friends feel they want to contribute to my parenting and they share their theoretical tips. I usually do enjoy the discussion here and there..
But when they start insisting that I’m doing it all wrong and they know better, that’s when I usually find them draining and pull away. Because that’s a level of ignorance that won’t be resolved by a discussion and I wouldn’t want to hang around them feeling judged based on standards they pulled out of their magic dreams.
We tend to misunderstand motherhood as a society. We tend to not know how much in involves and how it’s a different journey for everyone, for every mother and every child and every family.
Forcing everyone to fit into one theory is usually the most thing mother dread and dislike.. strippping away their right to be individuals and deal with their own parenting decisions and trust their own instincts and not just have rules dictated is what motherhood is about..
And denying a mother her own opinions on her own lives, is one of the reasons why many mothers feel their role is under appreciated. It’s coming from a place of superiority.. as if her experience and journey and instincts mean nothing compared to your judgement..
It’s really not respectful of her as an individual.