This thread is one of the reasons I really don't like school nurseries, the fact that this government is so in favour of them and feel so frustrated with so many aspects of early years (and education in general tbh!) in this country.
Early years practitioners should be about the development of the whole child and each child should be treated as an individual. Children achieve milestones at different times, with different levels of support and some children may never achieve some milestones due to additional needs, or they may achieve them years after others - each one of those children deserve access to good early years education through play.
Being able to use the toilet is a developmental milestone, like any other, that involves lots of different processes, including successfully wiping your bum! This can be easy for some and difficult for others, some children really struggle to actually reach! Not being able to wipe well is not purely down to parents not bothering to teach their children.
There are all sorts of reasons why children may struggle with toileting, not just additional needs. It should also be pointed out that many many children with additional needs will not have a diagnosis or even had those needs identified at this age. Early years practitioners should work with parents, children and professionals (as necessary) to support the child.
Before 2010 early years settings (and schools) could say that children needed to be fully toilet trained before admission, and parents called in if there were accidents but then the Equality Act stated that this was discriminatory practice. I am very surprised to hear of schools that are not allowed to wipe a child's bottom if needed.
I work in a term time, school hours preschool (committee run, ages 2 and a half - school start), we do have a qualified early years teacher, but still work to a ratio of 1:8 for over 3s, as we believe this is in the best interest of the children. I absolutely see part of my job to be supporting children in toileting, encouraging independence...yes, but also assisting when necessary. I am shocked to hear that people think it shouldn't be, or that there isn't enough time.
Nokidshere - all your posts have been great.