Thank you thank you thank you Justine!!!
Brava - and brave.
Another of the silent "minority" here - I haven't posted for a couple of years since that password fiasco but lurk most days, often on feminism, and now actively delurking again for this.
I agree with a lot of PPs, in particular:
I will boycott any advertiser that pulls out of MN due to trans extremist pressure. Brands that are complicit in bullying women into silence will not get my custom
-
I'm one of the silent (probably) significant majority who also feel strongly about women's rights but don't post much on the feminism/ transgender debates
-
I also think it is more than a minority, I often read trans threads and agree with concerns but have never commented.
-
I fully respect transgender people and appreciate I have a lot more to learn about their issues, struggles and preferences. I show every courtesy to those who identify as a different gender to the one they were born into and think there is a lot of hysteria around this issue which has been overblown.
But there are many unanswered questions about how their right to self-expression can be resolved in the face of women's rights to male-free spaces (refuges, prisons, intimate medical examinations, sporting contests, etc.), and we have to be free to debate these issues respectfully.
-
I didn't realise the feminist chat threads weren't appearing in active.....so that's feminism and special needs not in my active threads. I'd quite like that to change.
-
I am immensely grateful to the posters on the Feminism Chat pages for the time, energy and thoughtfulness that they put into explaining calmly, rationally and patiently the issues with the GRA that will have a massively detrimental effect on the rights of women and girls. Mumsnet has opened my eyes to this....
I've been impressed with the respectful debate on Mumsnet. I, along with the vast majority of posters, just want to protect my and my daughters hard fought rights - I'm not a bigot, I'm not unkind, I'm not violent or exclusionary, I just want a respectful debate about the issues.