Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another meal bill splitting thread...

215 replies

frenchfancy17 · 25/01/2018 16:12

Went out for a family meal today. I had a meal and dessert which came to £12.
I asked my mum to give my share of the money to person who paid the bill on their card for convenience as I had to dash for the School run and then I'd pay her back.

Get a text off my mum asking me if I'd known we were paying a bit towards my grandparents meal too (it was my grand birthday.) I text her back saying I didn't know this and how much was it then?

She texts back saying £20.
There was 10 of us at the meal including grandparents. 4 others had alcohol and expensive meals compared to mine... My auntie decided that we could just split the bill (8 of us.)

My mum said she said this at the table AFTER the meal. I didn't hear it!

She's being a CF isn't she?
My mum's also annoyed at it being decided for us!

OP posts:
Deshasafraisy · 25/01/2018 16:46

Extra £8?
Non issue.
Next...!

Winteriscoming18 · 25/01/2018 16:47

Your moaning on here over 8pounds seriously?

MiddleClassProblem · 25/01/2018 16:47

It’s not even £8... They didn’t leave a tip

JamdaniSari · 25/01/2018 16:49

These type of threads always amuse me. I can't believe people can be so stingy....especially with their own grandparents!

Chapterandverse · 25/01/2018 16:50

So everyone there apart from your grandparents had to pay £8 more?

So 8 of you had to pay £8 more? I don't know what your grandparents had that cost £64?

Or was it that it was £20 each between 8 people paying? And that covered grandparents meals as well as the wines etc??

I'd have no issue paying towards my grandparents meal - but I wouldn't want to be paying for the others' boozing.

midnightmisssuki · 25/01/2018 16:50

Confused £8? Youre annoyed over that? Ask for the money back from grandparents maybe? Maybe aunt thought wasn’t a big amount so didn’t ask/check. Maybe aunt assumed you would automatically be ok with paying towards grandparents meal. Maybe she just forgot to ask when you were there.

1ndig0 · 25/01/2018 16:50

Omg - sorry OP, but you do sound neurotic about money. You've obviously clicked how much other people's food and coffees were. This is unusual.

Also, you gave your GP's money for their birthday? This is also slightly odd.

They shouldn't have had to pay for anything. Could you not have bought two elderly people fish and chips fgs!

DrRanjsRightEyebrow · 25/01/2018 16:51

Non-issue. Wouldn't mind at all. If I had spent £12 and they were asking for £18 I would round up to £20 anyway. And I'm not even near wealthy, just hate stinginess around bill paying.

mrsharrison · 25/01/2018 16:51

Op and what would your response have been if you'd been asked?

WonderLime · 25/01/2018 16:51

I'm actually baffled by this post. You weren't there when the bill was being discussed so unfortunately you lost out on your say - and you've said you don't mind contributing anyway so what's the issue?

Delatron · 25/01/2018 16:52

It wouldn't be an issue for me. Though I wouldn't have left the exact amount I had eaten, I would have always left a bit extra, so £20 at least anyway. You can't have been subsidising much alcohol (shock horror) if the £8 covers both grandparents meals and the 'boozers'. Let it go and be generous. It's £8 and its family.

lastnamefirstfirstnamelast · 25/01/2018 16:52

I always find its the people that have tap water/cheapest meal option etc that go through this and it frustrates me so much. A song and dance is always made about it. next time just say that you are having the basics and you just want to pay for what you have.

I dont drink and money is quite tight but i alway dont mind paying my split bill as i just like to see my family have a fun time etc. i dont want to be the grumpy one whinging about the bill at the end of it all just because I had tap water and a salad.

MiddleClassProblem · 25/01/2018 16:53

Chapterandverse I think everyone paid £20 rather than everyone paid £8 more so total bill was £160.

MiddleClassProblem · 25/01/2018 16:55

lastnamefirstfirstnamelast exactly. It’s not hard to see that a bill might just be split rather than itemised for simplicity so if you don’t want that you have to state it not just assume.

CapnHaddock · 25/01/2018 16:58

I think you're tight not to leave enough for your tip tbh. I would have left £14.

afishnotabird · 25/01/2018 17:02

Even if I knew I was splitting the GPs share, I'd be expecting to pay 1 and 1/4 meals, not 1 and 3/5 meals, regardless of the actual costs, so I'd be annoyed. I probably wouldn't say anything though, but I'm a wuss.

Andylion · 25/01/2018 17:04

I always find its the people that have tap water/cheapest meal option etc that go through this and it frustrates me so much. A song and dance is always made about it. next time just say that you are having the basics and you just want to pay for what you have.

I find the opposite. It's always the people that drink tons of booze and wait until the bill arrives to say "Oh, we'll just split it."

As I don't drink much, I am always on the side of the tap water folk. Why should we have to announce, "I'm not subsidizing your boozing."
No song and dance if people didn't take the piss. This doesn't include paying for GPs which I would, happily, do.

Only1scoop · 25/01/2018 17:04

Were you leaving a tip in with your 12.00??

TBH it wouldn't have bothered me I'd have expected to cover my GP's dinner as it's a nice gesture on a birthday

bastardkitty · 25/01/2018 17:05

I wouldn't mind paying £20 if I had £12 of food and drink, but I agree, it depends on your ability to pay. I also think it's usual for people who have had extra courses and alcohol, when others didn't, to offer to pay more.

Floralnomad · 25/01/2018 17:05

As it’s family I would pay however as a tight non drinker there is nothing I hate more than subsidising other peoples alcohol consumption so in general if I’m out in company I ensure that it’s either pay for your self or a separate bill for alcohol upfront .

rogue8 · 25/01/2018 17:05

£8 extra for your grandma's birthday which happens once a year - not an issue! If it grates, you know to make your excuses for the next family birthday meal.

VivaJen · 25/01/2018 17:06

I get why you're miffed, when you do the maths it means that the cost of each of your Grandparent's meals was £32 each which does seem a lot when you compare it to your £12 and it does look like you have subsidised the rest of the party.

ChocolateWombat · 25/01/2018 17:07

Tricky to ask if you've already gone.
And when Aunt suggested the system for paying, you could have spoken up. Anyone can with these things and if you feel strongly, you do have to be willing to, even if you find it embarrassing or don't feel you should have to. Of course if you leave early, or aren't then for the discussion, then you can't say what you think.

Someone has to say something about the bill at a group meeting. Anyone can state before the meal, how they would like it sorted. You could have done that. Often no one says anything until the bill comes. People often suggest splitting because it's easier in terms of calculations - it's not always because they want a cheap price for a big meal. Whoever makes a suggestion cannot consider everyone's individual circumstance or be expected to be aware of exactly what everyone ate when there's a big meal. Often the bill is plopped down in front of one person who hasn't given the bill any thought before. If you don't like splitting you need to speak up sooner rather than later. Many people won't mind.

Large group meals often involve splitting. Everyone knows that. If you choose to attend them, you have to accept you may pay for more than you ate and drank or you need to be willing to state sooner or later that you would prefer to split. If you have this feeling, say it at the start, not the end. This means that people might keep a beadier eye on what they are ordering and the prices, plus when the bill comes there is no shock or suddenly confusion because people haven't had a sense of the price of their meal. You didn't speak up at any point - so it's difficult to now complain.

And re drinks it is especially tricky. I know that if you've drunk tap water all night, it does t seem fair to pay for a boozer. Especially when people are sharing bottles of wine, it becomes very difficult - someone may have just had one glass of wine, but they were drinking, someone else had 3, should they pay more. You can't expect people to keep tabs like this. That's why the drinkers usually split the drink bill at least. Often a non drinker will be excluded from this part of the bill - but again you might need to speak up, because people might assume everyone was drinking and why should they notice that you in a large group wasn't. Again, helps to say up front that you are on tap water to save money and are keen not to split the drinks bill.

Will people think you're stingy if you say these things? Some might, but you'll have to decide if you value their opinion or your money more.

And re paying for a special guest, I think you need to be willing to do that if you go to a group event like this.

Rudgie47 · 25/01/2018 17:07

Next time you eat with family just make an announcement that you want all costings upfront at the start of the meal.Bang on your glass with a fork and stand up. Say you want transparancy in their financial intentions.

rogue8 · 25/01/2018 17:07

I might not feel so generous for an acquaintance though I would probably still write it off for the sake of mutual friends' relations.