Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Vaping around children?

192 replies

onemumtwocountries · 28/02/2017 09:02

What's the general consensus? Just curious to hear your opinions. I'm fighting a constant battle with DH at the moment and I wonder if I'm being unreasonable.

OP posts:
Orangebird69 · 03/03/2017 12:17

I wasn't comparing vaccinations and vaping. I was comparing your attitude ie you couldnt care less what proper evidence there is, you believe what you want ti believe and that's that. Look like I was right.

hollinhurst84 · 03/03/2017 12:20

If people didn't want me to vape around children, fine. If I was in a room alone in someone else's house I would be a bit Confused if they said no as it doesn't linger

Applebite · 03/03/2017 12:21

Well, here is your attitude. I think I prefer mine!

  • Despite knowing smoking is really bad for me, I decided to smoke anyway.
  • Now I want to do something else that is better than smoking, but might well be found to be problematic in the future.
  • I deserve praise for that, and should be entitled to do it wherever I feel like, regardless of what other people think of it, because it means I'm not smoking the cigarettes that I knew were really bad for me when I decided to smoke them in the first place.
Hmm
Applebite · 03/03/2017 12:22

If you were staying in my spare room, Hollinhurst, and opened the window, fine. If you did it in the lounge with me and DD, I would be unimpressed. That's my basic take on it - do what you like, but don't be cross if other people don't like it.

Which is where DP gets cross, and then where I get crosser!

fatmummy87 · 03/03/2017 12:22

If it was a choice between someone vaping and someone smoking around my ds then I would obviously choose vaping. I'd much rather neither though.

hollinhurst84 · 03/03/2017 12:24

That's what I mean, being in a different room. I respect if people don't want me to use it around them, but I would be HmmHmm if someone came out with one of the reasons I said about up thread because I could guarantee they haven't actually read any of the research and are just going off newspaper headlines
If they said oh I don't like the smell or I get s headache then I get that

fatmummy87 · 03/03/2017 12:26

Tbf I don't spray deodorant, perfume or cleaning products in the same room as ds so kind of put vaping into that category rather than the smoking category.

Applebite · 03/03/2017 12:26

In that case Hollinhurst, I wish you would come and stay in my spare room and set DP a good example Grin

Orangebird69 · 03/03/2017 12:58

Apple, where did I say that I deserved praise? ConfusedHmm

And, pray tell, what definitely COULDN'T be found problematic in the future?

hollinhurst84 · 03/03/2017 14:36

Perfect example just happened
I moaned about the rain
"Give up smoking and stop killing yourself then"
Um... I have? Sad

Applebite · 03/03/2017 16:46

It's in your defensive tone, Orange. You feel that you should be able to vape because it's better than smoking. Fine, in your own space.

But guess what - for those of us who have never smoked or don't smoke, no vaping is better than vaping! Your health choices shouldn't be inflicted on anyone else, however certain you are that the research is accurate. It's a totally unnecessary risk for non-smokers and non-vapers, even if vaping really does turn out in the end to be risk-free after all.

So if you're considerate, fine. If you're expecting other people to suck it up, like the OP, not fine.

Applebite · 03/03/2017 16:46

*sorry, like the OP's original message, not like the OP herself!!

PencilsInSpace · 03/03/2017 20:06

Applebite - sorry this is long, your posts have really annoyed me.

Your DH was a vaper when you got together. It's both nasty and pointless to keep having a go at him about it. You shouldn't get together with someone you want to change, and you certainly shouldn't have a child with them, it's a recipe for misery.

My DG got gangrene from smoking and lost part of her foot when I was a child. If you'd seen what I saw, it would have made you hate smoking for life too!

You do know that smoking tends to run in families, don't you? HALF of all life-long smokers will die from it, on average a decade early. Many more will endure chronic ill-health for their last 2 or 3 decades. There aren't really any nice smoking-related ways to go (maybe sudden heart attack?). Most smokers will have lost relatives to cancer, COPD, stroke ... or watched relatives cope with debilitating smoking-related diseases for years. I'm very sorry about your DG but it doesn't make you special. Most of us have 'seen what you saw' or similar, or worse.

what if passive vaping does turn out to be dangerous, just as passive smoking is

Do you understand why smoking is dangerous? Inhaling smoke from burning stuff (doesn't matter if it's dried organic kale) is really bad for you because smoke (any smoke) is chock full of carbon monoxide and carcinogenic particles. The vapour from someone's ecig isn't. It has four ingredients, all of which have very good safety records and is not burned, but heated to a vapour (technically an aerosol, like the visible steam from a kettle).

He puts his need to vape above my wishes and our DD. he's brilliant in every other way, but this one thing he simply has a block about, and I hate it.

It's you that has the block. He's been vaping 2 years longer than you've been together. Leave him alone.

we didn't ask smokers to start smoking when they knew full well it was harmful to themselves and others

Most smokers start as children. I was 12. None of us behind the bike sheds imagined we'd be on 20 a day in our 40's because none of us could imagine being 40. Most of us were hooked in a matter of weeks.

And if you only do it outside or in your own home (assuming your family are happy to take the risk too or that you live alone), then that's fine too. People glaring at you for doing it in those situations are being daft. But would you expect other people to be happy with it indoors or in their homes, just because you are?

Public Health England (AKA the government) have said that vaping absolutely should not be treated the same as smoking and that there is no justification for vape bans on health grounds. They are keen for smokers to switch to vaping because a lot fewer people will die (RTFT if you want links).

Er. It's absolutely nothing like anti-vaxxers, what a bonkers comparison

It was me who used the anti vaxxers comparison (which you'd know if you'd RTFT). Whenever there's a thread about vaping someone invariably pops up and posts a load of bullshit scary articles about how vaping is terribly dangerous. The effect of this is that it puts smokers off switching. So they don't. And they die. And the people around them are harmed. I think it's a pretty good comparison myself - two groups of people spreading scaremongering shit that harms people's health.

The more of your posts I read the sorrier I feel for your DP.

Everybody who has managed to quit smoking deserves a fuck ton of praise, whatever method they have used. They've done a fantastic thing for their health and the health of those around them, against very tough odds (over 90% of all quit attempts end in failure) Star

ThymeLord · 03/03/2017 20:14

Excellent post Pencils.

Flumpernickel · 03/03/2017 20:38

"Excellent post Pencils"

Seconded Wink

PencilsInSpace · 03/03/2017 20:45

'I despise vaping in public. The people who do it, IMO, are selfish and inconsiderate cunts. Do theybreally thunknthat other people want to walk behind them? Be around them? Smell their plume of horrible smoky shit?'

'huge clouds of sickly smoke.'

'vapers seem to not give a shit'

'Awful parenting.'

'The smell and billowing plumes of horrible smoke or steam or whatever are really offensive to me.'

'the ones who describe vaping as their hobby should get a life.'

'intensely twatty and anti-social'

'it stinks and is ridiculous'

'People vaping look like morons'

'Smells like cheap pound shop toilet cleaner.'

'Some amazingly selfish people on here but that is the sort of thing a normal person would be utterly ashamed of.'

'it's not a healthy option it's disgusting.'

'unfortunately they seem to have become 'Trendy''

'I predict it be the next health scare.'

'Vaping is no different from smoking. It's still a nicotine addiction no matter what way it is marketed.'

'it stinks and I'm sure it's going to turn out to be bad for us all, just as cigarettes did'

'Saw someone vaping in Morrisons. Shocking.'

'something people choose to take up that is totally unnecessary at best and harmful at worst'

'clouds of chemicals to be blown around your flat'

'those chemicals are getting to your brain after all!'

These quotes are all just off this one shortish thread.

krakentoast - Wow, vapers are defensive folk.

Gosh, I can't imagine why that would be Grin We're just trying to not die early from horrible diseases or harm people around us. We face flack like this every day from all sides.

If you actually care about health and preventing preventable deaths, pack it in.

If you care more about still having a group of people it's socially acceptable to stick the boot into now smoking is dying out, this is for you.

DianaMemorialJam · 03/03/2017 20:45

I love smoking too much

It's lucky I'm an anti social bugger Grin

Manupprincess · 03/03/2017 21:08

Public Health Wales and WHO take a different view to Public Health England. PHW has given advice against the use of ecig/vaping as it normalises smoking. This is the main reason I dont want anyone vaping around my child.
WHO have recommended it should be banned in public places as cigarettes are already.
www.wales.nhs.uk/sitesplus/888/news/30545

If you want to give up smoking then they can be great. They certainly reduce harm compared to cigarettes but it seems people get 'stuck' with the vaping. Certainly better than smoking but worse than no use at all.

Applebite · 03/03/2017 21:18

Whoa pencils, did the truth touch a nerve?!

I don't care how you justify it to yourself, so long as you keep it to yourself. Here's just one screenshot from the BHF saying vaping is not "harm free" and that the vapour . Why on earth should I take your word over theirs!? I prefer my heart and my baby's heart harm free, thanks. You can do what you like with yours.

As for commenting on my relationship - what if I said your relationship with your parents must have been pretty poor if they didn't notice their 12 year old was smoking enough to be "hooked within weeks"? Yeah, that would be an utterly horrible thing to say. Talking through your bum about other people's relationships when you know absolutely nothing about their situation is utterly horrible, isn't it!

Vaping around children?
Applebite · 03/03/2017 21:20
  • vapour contains carcinogens and irritants.

The BHF is hardly hysterical googling.

PencilsInSpace · 03/03/2017 21:24

That's from 2013 FFS!

PHE weren't taking a much different stance from that in 2013. Research and guidance move on fast in this field (because yes there is lots of research and it's ongoing). England have kept up, Wales haven't sadly because they don't have any money among other reasons.

And we know about WHO, RTFT.

Ginmakesitallok · 03/03/2017 21:28

Vaping normalises vaping. Vaping does not normalise smoking.

Notso · 03/03/2017 21:46

I wouldn't want my kids vaping so wouldn't vape around them. Simple as that.

PencilsInSpace · 03/03/2017 21:59

Please point me to the truth in your posts Apple.

I don't care if you don't like vaping. It's saving lives, including your DP's. I promise not to vape in your living room.

Point me at anything that has been declared 'harm free'. Anything at all.

You don't need to take my word but I'd have thought Public Health England, Cancer Research and ASH, among many others, would carry a bit of clout (again, RTFT!). I think though that all you're interested in is somehow proving that vaping is bad. Because it must be, right? It can't be right that former smokers are actually happy and excited that they've found a way of not dying but also not being miserable. How fucking dare they??

Even the BHF statement you have posted is positive, although it's clear they are gritting their teeth in saying it.

possible carcinogens and irritants, though at a much lower level than in conventional cigarettes
Versus a 50% chance of death. Yeah, I'll take that risk, given that I've been a nasty scummy nicotine addict since the age of 12.

PHE say they are 95% less harmful than smoking
Yup.

We would not advise non-smokers to take up ecigs but they can be a useful tool for harm reduction and to stop smoking
Very sensible advice.

What were you hoping to show with this screenshot?

harm free
Grin do you live in the actual world at all? Never ever feed your delightful PFB an aubergine or a tomato.

My parents were wonderful although they were both smokers. My father died in his early 60's from cancer, probably smoking-related. My mother has advanced COPD and needs a lot of help getting around and caring for herself these days. I'll miss her when she's gone, which won't be long now. I wish vaping had been around earlier because my lovely parents might have lived longer. Of course they never noticed me smoking age 12. They were smokers, they had no sense of smell.

I stand by what I said about your relationship. If you have got together and had a child with someone who you wish to change you are on a hiding to nothing. Good luck.

Applebite · 03/03/2017 22:11

Pencils - why should I have to prove that it's harmful? It's for the vaping industry to prove it's safe. And let's face it, their research isn't exactly disinterested, is it? Maybe in 50 years time you'll be proven right, maybe not. We don't know for sure and that's the point.

I am not convinced it is safe enough for my baby to inhale. I really don't care what you think of that. And yes she is delightful, thanks. Snarky comments about someone's child now, eh? All those nasty carcinogens really must be getting to your brain!

Look, you're scrabbling around desperately trying to justify your desire to vape rather than focusing on giving up and that's entirely your decision. But you really can't be surprised if other people dislike it. This one thread alone contains several posters who do!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.