Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I have been shouted down by a friend re: another friends wedding gift.

188 replies

VinoTime · 04/06/2016 18:37

I was signed off work with mental health problems at the beginning of February. It was a pretty rough time, but I'm back to my old self now and doing good, and I was able to return to work this week Smile I was on full pay for the first month I was off, and then dropped to statutory. Frankly, I'm grateful to have received anything, though I think we can all appreciate/imagine how tight things can get financially while on SSP.

Anyway, for the past three months I have pretty much scraped by. I haven't fallen behind with anything and all of my payments for rent/bills, etc. are on track. We've had enough left over to keep me, 9yo DD, the cat and the dog fed and happy. All good. I haven't gotten into any debt to manage a standard of living we can ill afford right now, and I hacked our food budget to the absolute limit in May to treat DD on her birthday and pay for her school trips (they do a 'fun' week every May at her school and take the children on various outdoor pursuits. The thought of going cap in hand to the school unable to pay this mortified me, so I hacked every budget I could to pay it).

A good friend of mine got married earlier today. DD and I received an invitation to the evening do back in April. I have been putting whatever spare pennies I had in a jar to buy DD a pretty dress for it since then. Today we were able to go out and buy her a beautiful dress that we found on a sale rack and a cheap pair of sandals - they were total bargains and I still cannot believe our luck in finding them. I had no money for an outfit so I'm recycling a dress and a pair of shoes I found in my wardrobe - I'm hoping beautiful hair and makeup will carry me through it as the outfit isn't great Blush

My problem is a wedding gift/money. By the time we received the invite in April, the budget was eaten up with other things, including putting Holy Communion money aside for a friends set of twins. May's budget was dominated by DD's birthday and school trips. I got my SSP yesterday but council tax, childcare and various other first of the month type bills have demolished the lot. There's a little left over which will buy us food until my tax credits are paid in 2 weeks time. I've got nothing to give my friend for a gift. I've bought her a beautiful card, but I've got no money to put in it (they've got a wedding post box for cards/vouchers, etc.). Another close friend text me earlier to ask how much I was giving, and I explained the situation. She text me back: You can't give them nothing! It's their wedding! How the fuck would you feel if they did that to you?!

Sad

I can't give what I don't have. I could certainly pop some vouchers/cash in the post to them in two weeks time when I've got a bit of money, but I have nothing right now. Is that horribly unreasonable of me? I feel dreadful about it, but I can't change it. It is what it is. I was hardly going to prioritise a wedding gift over my DD's simple birthday this year or ban her from the school trips which gave her a very memorable week learning lots of different skills and experiences.

OP posts:
glenthebattleostrich · 04/06/2016 19:33

A friend of mine had little spare money when I got married so she gave us a lovely note /iou offering to pay for dinner for our first, fifth and tenth wedding anniversaries. It was so thoughtful (particularly as my mother told everyone we'd be divorced within a year). We've never 'cashed in' the voucher but the thought was lovely.

fussygalore118 · 04/06/2016 19:34

if it was my wedding I wouldn't give two hoots about whether you gave us a gift or not. I would just want you there x

Beeziekn33ze · 04/06/2016 19:34

Rae - I was thinking surely shouty critical 'friend' would, as so bothered, offer to lend the money until OP can afford it.
OP I hope you and DD have a lovely evening celebrating your friend's wedding.

Unicow · 04/06/2016 19:35

In this situation I would be annoyed if you gave me anything. Honestly.

Brummiegirl15 · 04/06/2016 19:37

I'm getting married this year and I would be so upset if one of my friends was worrying about not being able to give us a gift. I honestly do not expect gifts and even less so from those who are coming to the evening do.

Your friend is a cow

dynevoran · 04/06/2016 19:39

If it was me i wouldn't want anything at all. I would just want you to come and have a good time. It cant be so much about the presents now that you have to even say a gift will follow?! Write a nice sentimental meaningful message in a lovely card and go and have a nice time.

cosytoaster · 04/06/2016 19:40

When I got married (admittedly donkeys years ago) it wasn't the done thing for evening guests to give presents. I got a couple of token things but most people just brought a card. I'd write a nice, personal message in your card and then think no more about it.

RuggerHug · 04/06/2016 19:41

I would reply 'how kind of you to offer to cover the gift for me to bring . I will if course pay you when I can' (slowly).
But I'm a cowbag in a bit of a mood with people nowGrin

QuiteLikely5 · 04/06/2016 19:41

If you really want to give something can't you just borrow it???

xMumToTwox · 04/06/2016 19:41

You need to reply to your friends text - 'how would I feel? Absolutely fucking fine! Id rather guests spend time on sharing the day with me than spend money they just dont have.'

rookiemere · 04/06/2016 19:42

I don't know if you've read the other thread where the OP had the scout trip paid for despite having a lot of extra curricular expensive activities, but in your case you were absolutely deserving of the school hardship fund to pay for your DDs week in May and it makes me sad that you're trying to scrape funds together when you absolutely should have had that paid for.

Have a nice evening Smile. Oh and my top tip for wedding or indeed night out outfits is to go to charity shops. I've just got a pure silk Monsoon number for very little for a relatives wedding later this year.

TwirlsInTwirlsOutAgain · 04/06/2016 19:42

It's absolutely nothing to do with your friend, what a nosey mare.
I can honestly say if you had come to my wedding without a present/money, I really wouldn't have minded in the slightest.
I'd much rather you were there with us than how much money you put in the card!
Don't give it a second thought.

Stardust160 · 04/06/2016 19:44

If the wedding wasn't today I would of suggested some mugs or album frame from home bargains or B&M. My friend attended my day so and didn't bring a gift it didn't matter she wasn't working at the time and I didn't expect anything.

Gazelda · 04/06/2016 19:45

Glen your friend sounds lovely - what a great idea.
OP - put a note in a card to say how happy you are for them and to be invited to share in their special day. You know they'll understand that funds are tight right now, but as soon as you're back on your feet financially, you'll be treating them to a meal in their fave restaurant. Or a picnic hamper to take on a romantic day out. Or something else you know they'll love.

RaspberryOverload · 04/06/2016 19:45

OP, in your situation then I wouldn't want you to give anything. I'd be happy you attended, that would be present enough.

You've done really well Thanks and I hope you continue to feel better.

guinnessgirl · 04/06/2016 19:47

When I got married I can honestly say that I didn't keep track of who did or didn't give a gift. All gifts were received very gratefully but I didn't expect that everyone should, or could, give a gift. Your friend has been very unkind and YANBU.

ExtraHotLatteToGo · 04/06/2016 19:48

😁 at all the Weddng Etiquette posts 😁

'Another close friend text...' You seriously need to look at your friends list. What a bitch.

I would far rather you spent the money on things you and DD need or that give you & DD a bit of pleasure, than bought me a wedding gift. I'd just want you both there - that's all. I'd be really upset at a friend in your position spending money on me/buying gifts etc.

If I'd heard about what the other woman had said, my friends list would be one shorter.

I hope you're having a great time & that DD feels lovely in her new dress & sandels 🍾🍸😊

Optimist1 · 04/06/2016 19:52

Pretty unanimous views about the timing and size of the gift, OP, but I just wanted to congratulate you on keeping your finances under control during some difficult months without falling into debt. You should be really proud of yourself! Flowers

ExtraHotLatteToGo · 04/06/2016 19:53

WTAF are 'sandels'. I love my iPad mini, I'm far less fond of its auto correct 😖

Sandals. Sandals. Sandals. Sandals.

expatinscotland · 04/06/2016 19:54

Your friend is a twat. Just give them a nice card. You don't have to write an explanation. If they are good friends, explain in person or in a phone call. Don't post date a cheque or take a photo with money saying present to follow later or whatever. Just give them a card and tell them your circumstances in person/voice.

littlemonkey5 · 04/06/2016 19:57

I can categorically say the gifts/money/vouchers did not equal the amount of people who attended our wedding and I am sure about 40% of the guests put something in a card for us.

I also have to say that we got so much (small gifts and money which is what we needed), that we had to write on the back of their cards what they got so we didn't forget when we had to write and thank them all. I missed 3 people as their gift got lost in the others..... cue embarrassed me as my auntie asked what we put in our christening tube...... oops!

Don't worry about it, they will just be glad you could make it and made the effort to come.

Arkhamasylum · 04/06/2016 19:57

I would feel awful, AWFUL, if a friend felt pressured into buying me a wedding present she couldn't afford.

Write your lovely card, go with your daughter and have a great time. I can't remember what most people bought when I got married (it was a long time ago), but I'll always think fondly of those who had an obvious blast on the day Grin

expatinscotland · 04/06/2016 19:58

'OP - put a note in a card to say how happy you are for them and to be invited to share in their special day. You know they'll understand that funds are tight right now, but as soon as you're back on your feet financially, you'll be treating them to a meal in their fave restaurant. Or a picnic hamper to take on a romantic day out. Or something else you know they'll love.'

For real? She's a single mum at any rate. It's an evening invite. A meal in their fav restaurant could come to £50.

What's wrong with not giving them anything if it's an evening invite and you're stony skint?

If I knew my friend were brassic, or a lone parent on a low income or anything like that, I wouldn't want them to give me a present. I'd want her to use whatever she had spare on herself and her child.

Why do people feel compelled to offer expensive gifts they cannot afford?

MirandaGoshawk · 04/06/2016 20:00

I would agree about if you are only invited to the evening do then you aren't expected to get a present. We had a small wedding at lunchtime and then invited everybody we knew to a knees-up in the evening. We got lots of cards but only a few presents from the evening people. I wouldn't cross my mind to have expected a 'proper' present if people hadn't come to the actual wedding.

If you want to get her something, how about some pretty china from a charity shop? It depends on the friend of course, some people would be insulted. But I got a beautiful plate for a friend's birthday for a couple of quid because I knew it was the kind of thing she collects and she was thrilled! Or something like a lamp? If it's lovely and in good condition she may not mind that it's not new. Or she may - you know her!

Becca1818 · 04/06/2016 20:02

If either of them were any sort of friend they would understand your situation and understand that you can't afford a present

Swipe left for the next trending thread