Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to do so much for my kids?

338 replies

Skivvywoman · 11/02/2014 12:02

I don't think I am

But my friends think I'm mad to do everything for my teenagers,they get really irate about it
the only thing I don't do is iron for them as I was fed up ironing their clothes for everything to be scrunched up in drawers and wardrobe that it had to be reironed!!

I don't mind so why should others??

OP posts:
Skivvywoman · 16/02/2014 22:24

It's gone not to bad their room is a bloody tip!! But I've told them if it's not tidy Monday night I'm going in on Tuesday to clean it!
But yesterday ds2 put all my shopping away,hoovered,polished and wiped kitchen down without me asking Smile

I'll get them whipped into shape if it kills me Wink

OP posts:
NothingMoreScaryThanAHairyMary · 16/02/2014 22:50

Only read the first page but wanted to warn you. My grand mother did this for my aunt completely fucked her up, and made her a pretty hopeless adult. Gm then 'helped' bring up my cousin ( def not cousin) a more fucked up individual you could not find.

He us nearly 30 lives with ( and generally abuses) my dgm . I rang her the other day and just chatting said my dc's we're helping to change their beds ( dc's 8, 6 and 4) she was shocked that I would even ask. At nearly 30 his new gf washes his clothes ( in between gf's she expects his mother to!)

Please give them some responsibility and indepence before it is too late ( dgm did the toothpaste thing when daunt was in her 20's)

NothingMoreScaryThanAHairyMary · 16/02/2014 22:52

Bugger should have read the rest of the thread sorry skivvy hope it's going well

ISeeYouShiverWithAntici · 16/02/2014 23:27

Well done!

However I'm not sure telling them that if they dont do something, you will do it for them is as much of a threat as you think it is Grin

Skivvywoman · 17/02/2014 07:21

I know but the room I can't cope with a mess Hmm today after work I'll dump the duster polish and Hoover in the room if it's not done ds2 is off school this week he can help me Wink

OP posts:
JHTrotter · 17/02/2014 07:54

You are teaching them some worrying lessons, even in your attempt to "try to let them do it". This may not be how you mean it, but this is how it comes across from their point of view:

  1. No-one can be as good as mum at housework, so we don't bother trying. Even if we do try, it will not be good enough. Mum will be all exasperated in a martyrish way for a while, we'll ride that out, and in the end she will do it do for us.
  1. Mum does all this because she loves us - because I am me. This is the one that is more dangerous - it ties in with doing chores as a way of getting people to like you, and of other people doing it to show they love you, and the expectation this is normal in a relationship.

Is it all a control thing for you - you're a bit addicted to doing it all because it brings you comfort.

Sorry, I think you need to think some more and talk with your family gradual change with the reasons for it, rather than try to suddenly stop it all like a big 50s-housewife-joke and give up when that doesn't work because they just "can't do it as well as mum". It's not that funny.

Skivvywoman · 17/02/2014 07:59

If they keep their room tidy and make the beds that's good enough for me but I can't stand mess and I doubt that will ever change, I've reasoned with them about the beds which they have been doing, but this weekend they have let the room go to pot and it annoys me!

OP posts:
ISeeYouShiverWithAntici · 17/02/2014 08:53
Grin

be proud of how far you've come. Nobody can reasonably expect you to go from someone who controlled everything to someone who lets everything take care of itself in one week.

Instead of stepping in and doing it, you need consequences for them for THEM not doing it.

As in the real world.

In the real world, if they don't fulfil their obligations, nobody is going to come along and fulfil them for them. No, they will suffer in some way. If they don't go to work, nobody will step in and work for them and pass them the wage. If they don't clean their loo, nobody will hammer down their door and scrub it. If they don't pay their council tax, nobody is going to leap in and pay it for them.

No. They will suffer the consequences of not doing those things that it will be their responsibility to do.

So. Do you show them that if they don't do something it doesn't matter because it will get done anyway by someone else

or

Do you show them that if they don't do something, there will be a consequence for them that is unpleasant.

So do you tidy or do you remove?

Do you link any money you give them to tasks you expect them to do?

Don't forget that they have been waited on hand and foot for their entire lives. This is all new to them too and no doubt they expect that you will not sustain it and they just go along with it for a bit or not, no matter, because you will just go back to the habits that they have always known.

But you are doing so well already. It's just stuff for you to consider.

When you think that what we are suggesting to you is effectively a massive change of everything - it's HUGE!

mumeeee · 17/02/2014 10:36

You are doing very well Skivvy. However I do think you should try and leave their room to them. It's normal for teenagers to have untidy rooms. Are you able to just close the door and ignore it, Yes remind them to clean and tidy but don't go in there yourself even to put clean clothes or the hoover in there,

Skivvywoman · 17/02/2014 11:38

I give ds2 money every week to go to the football and I provide everything for him, ds1 I don't give him any money whatsoever,

I know I should just shut the door and leave it but I get all agitated knowing its a tip and in need of a clean, I wish I could just forget about it but I can't,
We don't live in the biggest of houses so I pass their door at every move!

Instead of tidying it I'm going to gather what's lying about and put in a pile for them to put away!

OP posts:
ISeeYouShiverWithAntici · 17/02/2014 11:44

That's a good idea.

mumeeee · 17/02/2014 13:24

Yes I've done that before with DD3. Be prepared for it just to stay in the pile though. Smile

Skivvywoman · 17/02/2014 16:01

As long as it's a neat pile I'm not going to move it Wink

Ds2 has tidied the room and made the beds Smile

I've hurt my arm and it's really sore to straighten or stretch I've pulled the Hoover out it's sitting in the hall but he keeps walking past it! Think I'll put a note on it saying "fucking use me"

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page