Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

.....to think that the casual racism shown towards Ferengi in ST:TNG is rather unpleasant?

221 replies

HalloweenyHerrena · 15/10/2012 16:48

I mean, the Ferengi have been carefully designed to be irritating but come on!

Picard saying "I have reluctantly let members of a particular ethnic group on baord the Enterprise - hopefully they won't cause trouble" just sounds wrong to me and is not in keeping with the happy-clappy 'We are here to encounter new life and not judge' ethos of the whole show. Unless the ethos is actually 'We are here to encounter new life and not judge them unless we find them personally repulsive, in which case we hoick our judgy pants right up'.

I may be over-thinking this but I still don't find it nice to watch, which is upsetting as I'm an avid TNG fan :(

OP posts:
ScarePhyllis · 22/10/2012 04:11

I've always wondered why women have to give birth in the ST universe. Can't you just lock onto the baby and beam it out? That's what I'll be requesting when the future gets here!

showtunesgirl · 22/10/2012 09:49

The only painless birth I recall was Troi's when she gave birth to a being that wanted to experience a corporeal body. And when Crusher asked if Betazoid births were pain free she said not according to my mother.

plutocrap · 22/10/2012 09:51

I thought that about childbirth, too, ScarePhyllis! (bloody hell, I first mistyped you as phallus! Shock). Too much sex on this thread!

Speaking of sex, and also of transporters, does anyone remember Janeway's affair with the man whose species was oppressing another species? Voyager smuggled the oppressed ones out, and the man tried to betray them, only to discover that Janeway hadn't told him the truth (I think they hid the refugees in the transporter buffer), either, despite their chemistry. He was another one to snog, but not marry.

ScaryBeardyDeadyman · 22/10/2012 10:02

What about when Paris and Janeway broke warp 10, turned into space slugs and had little space slug babies?

showtunesgirl · 22/10/2012 10:47

I'd forgotten about that episode. That one was trippy! Grin

Trills · 22/10/2012 10:50

I think everyone is better off forgetting about that one.

plutocrap · 22/10/2012 11:06

Oh! I had forgotten that! For ages, Voyager with popcorn and Pinot Grigio, was my DS-bedtime treat. Maybe a few of the episodes' plots slid away from me...

WhereYouLeftIt · 23/10/2012 23:32

"I've always wondered why women have to give birth in the ST universe. Can't you just lock onto the baby and beam it out?"

ScarePhyllis, this did happen in an episode of voyager called "Deadlock".

Valdeeves · 24/10/2012 00:19

I love this thread!! Have nothing intelligent to add, just lurking

MysteriousHamster · 24/10/2012 00:38

All this on Star Trek and no mention of Chris Pine as NewKirk? Shame on you all!

(I love the new movie, also liked DS9 a lot, am fondish of TOS and TNG and Voyager was largely awful imo)

plutocrap · 24/10/2012 00:39

WhereYouLeftIt, PLEASE admit you had to look up the episode title! Shock

Oh, come on, Valdeeves, not even a quick turn at "Snog, Marry, Avoid"? We won't be species-ist about any choices: you could even snog Species 8472, and we will accept it (I don't think they've been spoken for yet, whereas there's a lot of fighting over Picard, Paris and Chakotay: we'll be making do with holograms rather than polygamy, I think!)

plutocrap · 24/10/2012 00:42

NewKirk didn't do it for me. He's not as appealingly repressed as Spock and McCoy, and not as fun as Scottie and Chekhov, either!

Alisvolatpropiis · 24/10/2012 00:45

I had a massive crush on Worf as a small child! And had all the figurines from TOS and TNG. Went to a convention when I was 4,it's one of my earliest memories!

My OH doesn't like Star Trek. When he told me I had to seriously consider whether it was a deal breaker. Decided I would enforce liking it on him instead ;)

showtunesgirl · 24/10/2012 00:50

My DH didn't watch it when growing up.

WhereYouLeftIt · 24/10/2012 01:03

plutocrap, hands up, yes I did Grin. I could remember watching the episode so knew it was Naomi's birth in Voyager, but the only show I remember episode titles for is Doctor Who. Yes, I am both a Trekkie and a Whovian Grin.

jaggythistle · 24/10/2012 02:18

hmm, I'm better at episode names for The X-Files tbh. Blush

the worst thing about Voyager was the slight over reliance on holodeck based stories. those @?&%£# 'Fair Haven' things were awful. the ones with the Hirojans (sp?) were slightly less sucky i suppose. DH has not bothered with those box sets...

yesterday's lunchtime DS9 featured an alien race who...were humanoid and wore funny hats, with what looked like some beads from one of those massaging car seat liners hanging from them. cool.

plutocrap · 24/10/2012 09:25

As for over-reliance on the holodeck, I'm not surprised! In all those years "at sea", what else do we expect them to get up to? Better than drugs and killing one another, or stasis while a bored-to-suicide skeleton crew navigates Voyager back!

WhereYouLeftIt · 24/10/2012 10:55

Yep, I saw the holodeck as the Voyager crew being able to retreat to the safe and familiar, when being 75 years away from home got too much for them. I even liked Fair Haven! Exploring the dangers of tweaking your holo love interest to perfect them - and realising that it was exactly the wrong thing to do. Interesting idea.

Anybody out there a Farscape fan? I am far, far too into sci-fi.

jaggythistle · 24/10/2012 11:19

i was meaning the script writers reliance on it really. i quite understand the crew relying on it [grin

degutastic · 24/10/2012 13:05

I just found myself emotionally invested in Wesley's leaving starfleet academy / off to join the paedophile traveller episode on sky atlantic Blush

I loved farscape when I was younger. Am also a Whovian - I remember watching Peter Davison's incarnation when I was v young (repeats!). Basically I am just a massive sci fi geek Grin

degutastic · 24/10/2012 13:10

"not every species was humanoid though, there were a few energy beings and suchlike were there not?"

2D plankton, that's all I'm saying. They were the most awesome aliens ever. I mean in a fluffy, TNG sort of way... I remember struggling to get my head round the idea as a smallish child. Awesome.

showtunesgirl · 24/10/2012 13:23

What about Skin of Evil where they'd blatantly run out of money at the end of the series and it was a crappy oil slick? Grin

plutocrap · 24/10/2012 13:25

Remember the androgynous species that TNG met? One of them was seduced by Riker's beard Grin and realised she was a woman after all. That episode was classic sci-fi - present a current concern in a totally different context to circumvent prejudices - but it did make me feel a bit queasy as I'm not a Riker fan.

degutastic · 24/10/2012 13:27

googles skin of evil

dies laughing at oil slick wookie

Grin

don't remember that one!

kim147 · 24/10/2012 13:28

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.