Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to refuse to attend any family function that my sister-in-law attends? Point blank.

173 replies

chevytruck · 29/08/2012 22:42

This might be long.

Husband and his (only sibling) sister are chalk and cheese.
Always just 'tolerated' each other.
When I first met her I took an instant dislike but tolerated her politely and non-provocatively.
Then out of the blue (after being with her brother for approximately six years) we became friends. Not BFF's, don't get me wrong. But we were both planning weddings so spent time together doing wedding stuff, then exercise classes, then just general socialising.
This was great for about 2 years. I allowed myself to let my guard down and 'let her in'.
I married her brother almost a year before her wedding and things were still great.
Then at around her hen do/wedding she froze me out.
Suddenly and with absolutely no explanation. I was nine weeks pregnant at her wedding but no-one knew and she already had one child so jealousy isn't an answer in this situation I don't think.
I've always been timid (a history of 'friends' who bully at school) and so just kept my head down.
It spiralled. She refused to talk to me, look at me, sit in the same room as me at family events, segregated me on her hen-do and indoctrinated all her friends into her way of thinking. No big loss.
This continued until towards the end of my pregnancy when she was so foul at a family do that it reduced her mum to tears.
My husband approached her and her 'answer' was that she was very early stages of pregnancy and so had been keeping her head down. Everyone accepted that explanation. But ignored the fact she'd been treating me like that for over a year and she was weeks into her pregnancy. So once again it got dropped. I then removed her as a friend on Facebook as some of the digs at me were from her status updates.
So, for nearly four years I have been polite, taken the digs, been ignored, and 'not' noticed the rolling eyes and disdain until finally it all came to a head at her sons christening in Sunday.
It was meant to be a small family christening after which we were going out for a meal. Just me and DH, MIL, FIL, SIL, BIL and our five kids.
The day before I had a nasty fall down the stairs and after a trip to A&E ascertained nothing broken, but in considerable amount of pain went along as it would mean a lot to DH family, so he said.
So, I sit in the church. Immobile. And slowly it dawns on me that plans are being made for all SILs friends and kids to meet after the ceremony at a nearby pub. But all in hushed whispers. At least five friends I heard saying words to this effect.
In the car park after the service, she announces she's going home TO TIDY(?) on a sunny day, after her sons christening when all her friends are at the pub. At which point we're bundled into the car with one of her sons and grandparents make the decision to go ahead with said family meal and we drive on to a different restaurant to where everyone else was meeting.
Leaving her celebrating with everyone somewhere else, having left us (myself and husband) feeling snubbed.
I refuse to go and eat after reaching my limit of passive aggressive bullying.
Husband tells in-laws why rather than a white lie and then arguments with his patents ensue about me spoiling the day for the kids, and getting the wrong end of the stick. ''She's gone home to tidy", I keep bring told... Perlease.
So we have a quick drink, no lunch, allow the kids to enjoy each others company while we sit in silence and then finally go.
Husband and I row be ause I can't he back saying exactly what I feel about his sister. So we go to my mums for her to listen/mediate. Don't get any resolutions agreed but air grievances anyway.
My answer is to remove myself from anything she's involved in.
For good. Or until something changes drastically.

Husband and I are at utter end of fighting tether having gone round in circles for four days.
He feels I should be the bigger person and that I'm hurting him by not attending family stuff. "We're a team, who cares what she says/does?". A fact I'm not disagreeing with. But he's asking me to keep bending over and taking it up the a**e.
I removed myself from people I went to school with like her and I'm stronger for it. DH wants me to approach her and suggest bygones be bygones. BUT WHY SHOULD I? I've done nothing wrong and she's treated me appallingly for four years I just don't want to see her again. She's intimidating.
So. Very long story short...
Should I 'grin and bear it' and feel the bigger person, because my husband isn't having to attend things on his own (but with kids) or stick to my guns? And not put myself in the position of feeling intimidated by doing the only thing I can. Remove myself.
Or confront her by text maybe? Ask what I've done to offend her so badly. I don't want to but again DH thinks its a solution. One he's unwilling to try as it might jeopardise more relationships.
Sorry it's so long but I'm just exhausted with trying to talk ourselves into a solution and going round in circles so thought some fresh eyes might help.
Happy reading.

OP posts:
ErikNorseman · 29/08/2012 22:45

I think your husband should ask her what her fucking problem is!

snickers251 · 29/08/2012 22:49

What erik said!!

BuntCadger · 29/08/2012 22:51

Yanbu, she sounds like a controlling über bitch

nancy75 · 29/08/2012 22:53

She sounds like a nightmare but tread carefully, your ils are her mum and dad, they are always going to take her side over you.

Itsjustafleshwound · 29/08/2012 22:54

Personally, it would be better for you just to walk away. Unfortunately, it isn't just you involved, so I would just bite the bullet and make sure that I made the effort to be there in support of your family for these social events. Don't go out of your way to be welcoming or pretend that all is well.

Confronting her will just end in misery

parabelle · 29/08/2012 22:54

Have just taken a similar decision myself. Not going to any more family events my sister is at. Like you, I will not continue to be treated like this. I hope you stick to your guns and manage to resolve this situation.

maresedotes · 29/08/2012 22:54

I think you've done well putting up with her behaviour for 4 years. I don't think texting her to ask what's wrong is an option. She blamed pregnancy last time. Your DH should support you and go to family events on his own with the children and tell her why should she ask.

WhereYouLeftIt · 29/08/2012 22:55

Yep, this is your DH's problem to solve. His sister, his parents, his wife, his problem. And he should be backing you to the hilt. You said that they just tolerate one another, so he should be capable of calling her to account.

TheCraicDealer · 29/08/2012 22:59

Your SIL sounds like a looper- be glad you're not a blood relation.

However, do you want to be the one that puts the foot down and makes people choose between the two of you? The repercussions would be felt for years- weddings, funerals, PIL's significant birthdays, etc. You could say that it's not really fair to make that side of the family pick sides and negotiate the invitation-politics for every family event.

It might be better if you just try to minimise your exposure to her crazy-bitch tendencies, but leave yourself the option of going to these events and decide at the time if it's worth putting up with her. Tell your DH to man up though.

Mintyy · 29/08/2012 22:59

So where was she when she said she was tidying?

ChaoticismyLife · 29/08/2012 23:42

I think it's about time your DH started putting you first and pull his sister up on her nasty vile behaviour. He's supposed to love you and cherish you yet he allows his sister to act badly towards you and expects you to put up with it.

If he wants you to attend then he needs to pull her up every time she behaves badly towards you. HIBU to expect you to put up with it.

larks35 · 30/08/2012 00:03

Your SIL sounds weird, but I don't think that her weirdness should exclude you from family get-togethers. I think if you work on your "rock hard" defenses (by that I mean don't react at all, and if possible don't even registger the offence) then she will just look stupid to the rest of her family.

I think YWBU to not attend future family events because of her. Why do that? Okay, you're not stopping DH and your DCs but you are purposely taking you out of their family. Get yourself a thicker skin, ignore any silliness from SIL and make sure you enjoy family events, if only to stick two fingers up at her!

chevytruck · 30/08/2012 07:43

minty She was at the other (secret) pub where she'd agreed to meet all of her friends.
After yet another row last night I ascertained that the meal was never going to include us or PIL.
MIL had apparently huffed "that's charming" weeks ago when SIL mentioned that meal after was to be a 'friends only' affair.
But then conveniently forgot that when I was equally offended!

OP posts:
Triggles · 30/08/2012 07:58

Being in the same position myself, I think YANBU. My SIL has, for reasons unknown to not only myself and DH but her entire family, decided that she doesn't "accept" me or my adult DD in the family - even though I've been married to DH for over 7 years now. She's been horribly rude and put my elderly MIL in a very uncomfortable position over this.

DH & I simply refuse to socialise with her. DH backs me on this, although SIL attempts to sway him regularly. He's told her he will NOT choose her over me, and that she needs to apologise to me & DD over her behaviour.

It makes things complicated sometimes, but generally I just ignore her. To be honest, she has always been a drama queen, and we have enough stress in our lives without her always stirring things up, so it's actually a bit of a relief.

Just because someone is family doesn't mean you have to take their bullying.

HeartsJandJ · 30/08/2012 08:02

Another one who thinks you should not rule yourself out of future family stuff, even if just to make sure your children aren't exposed to her with no-one to look out for them.

But your DH should back you up and not let your SIL get away with this sort of behaviour towards you. Perhaps tell him there is one more chance for him to behave like a husband and not let SIL (or even MIL who doesn't sound great herself) bully you again, if you say you are uncomfortable and want to leave then he should go with you, even if it upsets things with his family.

WipsGlitter · 30/08/2012 08:06

She sounds like a looper. She's been rude to you and her own parents!! Why the white lie to them, it looks like they did know what was happening - you should have just gone with hem and enjoyed the meal.

Can you "put yourself in neutral" and just ignore her or do the bare minimum when you are together.

spidermanspiderman · 30/08/2012 08:13

Just out of interest when did you announce your pregnancy?

Bellyjaby · 30/08/2012 08:15

Yanbu, as triggles has said you don't have to put up with bullying because she's family. My mother put up with my gran for over 35 years, and when gran died my mother ended up with a burst ulcer and nearly died after all those years of stress. You don't need it.

But there's several really good pieces of advice here. The main one is telling your hubby to man up. If he wants to solve this with the sister he just tolerates he needs to get in there and sort it.

Personally I'd suggest meeting in the middle with dh. He can attend any events etc with his family and the kids. You'll also attend when it's a biggie, so a wedding/christening/special birthday, but you're not showing up to a bog standard family get together unless he sorts this mess out.

I've cut my own sister out of my life. My last 18 months have been bliss. But my little cousin is having his holy communion in November, he loves us both so I refuse to let my sisters actions ruin it for him, and I won't let her ruin it for my family. My mother asked what I planned to do, I said I'd keep my distance and I'd be polite but that's it. If she wants to do whatever that's up to her. I've always said over the last 18 months that I have my own kids, I don't need another one and I intend to repeat that if family ask.

eslteacher · 30/08/2012 08:22

She sounds like she's stuck in pre-teen girl mode, playing silly games, arranging secret meetings, one minute best friends with someone, the next freezing them out completely. Unable to be civil even at family events. None of that is adult behaviour.

I honestly think some people never fully grow out of this phase, and get off on the drama of it all. Probably control/self esteem issues there too.

TBH, I think the best retaliation is just to roll your eyes at her childish behaviour and act like the adult you are. Be the bigger person, go to the important family events and just ignore her. Rise above and refuse to let her actions have an emotional effect on you. She's just an overgrown teenager, why would you care about her petty manipulations? I'd go with weary acceptance here.

Iheardthatpardon · 30/08/2012 08:27

Why would you be offended by not being included in the after meal? The ILs were not included either. In your shoes, I would have happily gone with ILs, had a nice meal without toxic SIL & puerile friends. Can't see the prob myself. As to removing yourself in such a dramatic manner, well if you want to be the one blamed for family rift, go ahead. On the other hand, continuing to take part in family events and ignoring her jibes would be far more satisfying. She wants you excluded, you would be doing it for her!
Let it all wash over you, be oblivious to it. No satisfaction for her if you fail to rise to her baiting. Don't confront her yourself, it is for your DH to speak to her. Not for you, but for himself - ie why is she treating him & his family like this? Though tbh, I would say to him to ignore it too. No audience, no performance.
Good luck.

cansu · 30/08/2012 08:38

I can understand your dislike of her and her behaviour but.. I really can't see why you refused to go for meal. If she is no longer a friend then you shouldn't react as if your friend has shunned you at school. I laws were also excluded from pub. You are lowering yourself to her level by having a strop at the meal. If you disengage from her then you will continue to attend family events and just ignore her pathetic childish behaviour. If it makes you feel better bitch about her to your dh privately or make polite surprised comments about her rudeness. Eg I wonder why SIL decided not to come for a lovely meal rather than tidying? What a shame she's missing out. Big sympathetic smile.

EdithWeston · 30/08/2012 08:39

You need to work with your DH here.

Reducing your contact with his family can only be the answer if he agrees, else you are bringing the breach into your marriage too.

He wants you to "be the bigger person" - have you tried asking him what that actually means, in terms of how he wants his nuclear family to interact with the rest of his family? If you have some specifics, you might find some of it workable.

Hopeforever · 30/08/2012 08:49

Even though it is obvious that this is really hurting you and needs to be resolved, I am amazed at the way she treated her parents. How hurtful for them. I think my main concern on Sunday would have been for them and making it a pleasant experience for their sake.

How can you leave the kids grandparents out of the meal having invited them to the church.

Does you SiL have any parents in law herself?

diddl · 30/08/2012 08:50

I don´t get why you made such a fuss tbh as she had excluded all family?

But I´d not bother in future.

If husband wants to see his sister-fine.

Although why is he so bothered if he only "tolerates" her?

WillNeverGetALicence · 30/08/2012 09:07

Your SIL sounds quite immature and insecure. Obviously has issues...

But I actually think I agree with your DH. He is the important one here [in regards to his family, I mean that his feelings are most important to you, not his SIL or PIL]

He wants and needs you at these family events. It sounds as if he recognises how badly his sister behaves but is at a loss to know what to do about it.

I guess he could ask her what her problem is [and that could be helpful in letting sister know she's been rumbled] but it may not change her behaviour.

Your DH is not responsible for his sister. But he wants some connection with his family and wants you to be part of that.

And it sounds as if you have quite a good relationship with your PIL. Who also have been a little hurt or shocked by SILs treatment of them.

I think in this situation I would try and be the bigger person. Don't take any crap from SIL or attempt to befriend her [she has proven herself as no friend of yours]. Don't engage with her on facebook. But do accompany your DH to family events, be civil and polite to SIL but also maintain some distance.

I know this is all easy to say and hard to do... But don't let this be turned around into being YOUR problem or issue with DHs family.

This is SILs issue and she is the only one who can sort it out. Meanwhile you just keep being the pleasant and considerate DIL/SIL and you cannot then be drawn in or blamed in any way.

Play the long game OP and good luck!