Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be pissed at DSis reason for not attending our wedding?

180 replies

dontcallmedeliah · 17/01/2012 12:12

(I know it is a wedding one ? so prepared to be called out on this but?.)

Me and DP are getting married after I have given birth to DC1. So getting married in March.
DP is an Icelander and so we are getting married in Iceland.

My family (Parents, siblings and their families are flying out to come to the wedding)

Flights all booked and paid for by my parents as a wedding present to us (for all of my family) - should point out that my dad works for the airline and got discount/deals with our flights

DSis2 phoned me up yesterday and asked what weather is probably going to be like when we are there.
Told her that the average temperature was around 2C in the day. She asked about the length of daylight. Told it would be about 11hrs a day.

Anyway she said she would phone me back.

When she did, she said her husband had been on the Internet and had discovered that it can be very very windy at that time, with lots of snow etc.

Well yes it is March and very far north.

She says that she and BIL think that it would be too cold for their DS who is 5. Has he isn?t use to such temperatures or snow (they live in the channel islands)

Well I was shocked ? told her to bring very warm things and they keep homes and hotels and other warm. And are more than use to the weather and how to deal with it.

Told her (in the way you could probably only say to a sibling) that Icelanders have dealt with the cold for thousands of years and they are fine and that we are bringing our newborn with us and DP has 3 DN who are all under 6 who are perfectly fine in weather.

She basically ignored all that and said that she and BIL have reached their decision and are not going to change their mind ? the 3 of them are not going.
I asked about the flight ? she said that she would just talk to Dad about them.

AIBU to think that is a stupid reason for not coming to your sisters wedding and to be mighty pissed at her?

OP posts:
wheredidiputit · 17/01/2012 14:05

Just except that she won't be there. It's her choice, enjoy you day with your family & freinds who are with you.

FWIW we gave my Dad & stepmother and my brother and wife 2 years notice and they both choose to go away on separate holidays.

BettySwollocksandaCrustyRack · 17/01/2012 14:06

Weddings are by no means a family obligation......and I believe that if people want to get married abroad which of course is fine, then they need to be prepared for the fact that some people might not go.....even because they just dont want to!

I hate the cold weather and to be honest, if my sis got married in Iceland I would be sorely tempted to skip it.......actually she got married in the middle east and I did go but that was before I had DS!

It's her decision if she doesnt want to uproot her DS for a few days and although YANBU for being a bit hurt by it, YABU if you think it is your right that she is there.

squeakytoy · 17/01/2012 14:13

When she did, she said her husband had been on the Internet and had discovered that it can be very very windy at that time, with lots of snow etc

Going back to that from the OP.. is it the husband who doesnt want to go I wonder (in which case, tell the misery to stay at home)... I am assuming you are not getting married outdoors, and it can be very windy with lots of snow in the UK in March. Would she have come to your wedding if you were getting married in London or Manchester? because there is every chance they can be that cold in March, and have a lot less daylight too!

StealthPenguin · 17/01/2012 14:23

How fucking PFB are some people????

YANBU.

Gumby · 17/01/2012 14:32

Reading between the lines her dh doesn't want to go
Give her a ring & tell her you really want her to be there
She can go on her own
It's not a case of you forgetting to have her as bridesmaid/ Maud of honour, is it?

Lambzig · 17/01/2012 15:35

I think its something like her DH doesnt want to go too or some other issue as the excuse given sounds ridiculous.

I am sorry for you as my view is that no matter how inconvenient it is, as long as you can afford it, I would always go to a close relatives wedding.

My DSis really let me down on my wedding day and I spent most of the morning crying instead of getting ready. Took me a couple of years to forgive her, so maybe its better that she is letting you know she wont be there so much in advance.

Blu · 17/01/2012 15:42

Why doesn't she come on her own and leave DN with her DH?

In the end, if she doesn't wnat to come, she doesn't. Upsetting but not the end of the world.

Leave your parents to feel aggravated over her wasting the flights - she's thier dd and they mut know what she can be like by now.

Have a great time without her, and then forget it - don't let it spoil your day, or the future.

StewieGriffinsMom · 17/01/2012 15:51

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

mockingjay · 17/01/2012 15:54

Well on the surface YANBU. Too bizarre to be the whole story though. Does her DS have a condition that would be worsened by the cold? Severe asthma?

I disagree that the OP 'chose' to have her wedding abroad. The groom is from Iceland. So wherever they had the wedding it would be abroad.

OrmIrian · 17/01/2012 15:54

YANBU. What a shame.

OrmIrian · 17/01/2012 15:56

And it isn't 'abroad' for the groom or for his family.

coffeesleeve · 17/01/2012 16:01

I've just come back from Iceland (in January). The temperature out there was comparable to what it is in the UK. Your DSis's family won't need much more clothing than they probably already have - maybe just a few extra vests & jumpers!

It's not the Arctic - most of Iceland is warmed by the gulf stream!

Hardgoing · 17/01/2012 16:01

My husband is also from 'abroad' and most of his family didn't attend the wedding (cousins etc). It was just the way it was and we didn't feel put out about it.

ElephantsAndMiasmas · 17/01/2012 16:03

YANBU

How odd of her - is her husband perhaps a bit unsociable/bossy/lazy and doesn't fancy it, and she doesn't want to start a fight over it. LUDICROUS to say that they won't cope going from Channel Islands to 2 degrees. I went to the supposedly subtropical (they are lovely in summer admittedly) Isles of Scilly in February once and have honestly NEVER been colder except in the Czech Republic with 3 foot of snow on the ground. Icy sea winds are unsurprisingly fairly common on islands.

mockingjay · 17/01/2012 16:08

Mine is too hardgoing. I wouldn't expect people to come overseas for the wedding, but I would want the truth not some crap excuse!

Northernlurker · 17/01/2012 16:15

Shock Well I agree she (they) are behaving badly.

So she doesn't come - she'll miss out but sounds like you'll more than manage without her. I wouldn't waste your energy on fretting when you have so much more important things to think about - like your baby Grin

fatlazymummy · 17/01/2012 16:21

2 out of my 4 siblings didn't travel to my wedding [from the N East to N. London]. 1 had already promised a friend that he would be best man on that day. The other didn't want to 'disrupt nappy training' - it turned out that her controlling ex husband didn't want to go [and wouldn't have allowed her to go on her own].
I was disappointed, but I had to accept it. Not everyone will want to travel to your wedding, even your own siblings. That's just the way it is.

fatlazymummy · 17/01/2012 16:23

Soory, meant 'potty training'.

keepingupwiththejoneses · 17/01/2012 16:27

Sounds like a bad case of PFB to me 'ds couldn't possibly go to somewhere cold'

Ifancyashandy · 17/01/2012 16:30

The fact she called you twice and came up with a spurious excuse makes me suspicious - I think she might be jealous / want to cause a scene. Otherwise she'd be honest about the reasons or would have declined prior to the tickets being purchased.

I agree with the previous poster that the way to respond is to kill with kindness. DO NOT rise to it. Let your parents deal with the cost implications. Smile sweetly and tell her you are disappointed she / they won't be there but that you understand. Tell her you look forward to going through the photo's with her afterwards! And then put it to one side and get on with enjoying your wedding. There is nothing you can do to change her behaviour but you can decide how you respond to it.

PuggyMum · 17/01/2012 16:36

YANBU. I agree that you should leave this now you to your parents to speak to your dsis and let them get to the bottom of it. Such a shame as I too would be there like a shot!! Families hey x

She'll be the one missing out...you'll have the new baby too so will be a time of joy and happiness.

Congratulations to you x x

Catsmamma · 17/01/2012 16:37

can the rest of the family winkle any more info out of her?? ...it's a spurious excuse for sure!

and is it just me hoping Jerseyspud is the actual sister ? :o

rebecklet · 17/01/2012 16:49

YANBU - it does all sound a little strange, there must be something more behind it.

I am going to Sweden for a work trip (all paid for, including food) and asked DH to come. All he'd have to pay was for flights and he didn't want to come as he thought it would be cold and boring. He still isn't too happy about it but is grudgingly coming along. Although I think he would act differently if it were my sister's wedding.

Saying that when I told my sister that we'd like to get married in the US (with 2 years notice) she asked if we could put it off by an extra year so that she could fit in another skiiing trip (not booked at the time). So I know how cheeky some people can be! She didn't come and we still had an amazing day :)

Just try not to let it get to you and know you will have a wonderful wedding just because you are marrying the man you love.

troisgarcons · 17/01/2012 16:57

The flights might be paid for but what about the accommodation? The Scandanavian countries are prohibitively expensive.

That is the risk you take when getting married abroad - not everyone wants the hassle of going. I assume she would have fly from CI to London/Manchester/change for Reji Rekj Iceland! It's PITA.

Factor in that she probably doesnt own Arctic Weather clothing and footwear, multiply that by three people. Multiply buying wedding outfits, gifts.

I doubt I'd bother going either.

Her excuse is naff though.

VeronicaSpeedwell · 17/01/2012 16:58

If this really and truly is the reason, then it is bizarre, and waiting until someone else had paid for her flights is outrageously rude. Iceland is really not that cold (and perhaps rather misleadingly named). I'd have loved to go there as a child, and I hope to take my own DC.

Have a great wedding, it sounds like your DP's family are going to give everyone who does turn up a very warm welcome.