Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Butch women and public loos-not sure if correct place to post..

262 replies

Lesbianactually · 09/10/2022 18:57

My partner is very masculine in appearance and is mistaken for a man all the time. This isn't usually a problem to her as she's aware of (and happy with) what she looks like.

However public loos (including in bars/restaurants etc) are a different story. It limits where we can go out, always has to be somewhere she feels comfortable, and these are few. Where she lives it isn't a very nice area and if I visit her she refuses to go out unless we're not drinking alcohol and/or will be very quick. First world problem I know, but I'd love for her to be able to leave the house for longer on occasion or for us to be able to share a few drinks and have some quality time. She lives with others so we don't get it at home.

She's better than she used to be. A few years ago she made herself quite poorly by holding the urge for up to 6 or 7 hours, & nowadays she won't do this, but largely through avoidance rather than management. She still panics if we go out, quite often. We live near a 'gay village' and she's fine there but last time we went with some friends, they wanted to go to a bar outside of it and she became visibly distressed as we were drinking alcohol and this means she needs the loo more often.

I've tried to help. The crux of the issue is she hates being confronted, told she's in the wrong loo. She's noticed if we're in a not so nice area, people are less tolerant/open minded and when they have confronted her they're quite nasty about it. In nicer areas she's less uncomfortable. In my local pub (we live quite far from one another) she's fine, and she has been confronted in there but she just responded that she was a woman and was there with her girlfriend and she'd show her ID if she wasn't believed. She wasn't upset by this at all but she has also in other places, had some people grab her and try to drag her out, get quite aggressive with her etc.

I know this is an anxiety-induced situation and perhaps does not need specific advice other than for her to get help for anxiety but just wondered if anyone else has experienced anything like this, anything that's good to say to people if she finds herself in this situation, any ways I can help?

She has a disabled key, from the time she made herself ill with this, but it isn't always practical to use that and it would be better for her to be happier to use the female loos generally. It's causing her unhappiness in life and limiting what she does/where she goes.

Thank you.

OP posts:
JohnsShirt · 11/10/2022 15:22

Freespirit42 · 11/10/2022 14:58

Not really that’s basic as fxxx because you have intersex people who see themselves as women who may have a penis and quite frankly when I look at her I don’t see that because we ain’t all obsessed with that

Ah, the intersex.
What took you so long?

JohnsShirt · 11/10/2022 15:24

CrossStichQueen · 11/10/2022 15:21

And yet interestingly in places like france the opposite sexes do share toilets

Yes they do there are floor to ceiling lockable cubical with sinks in many place there are also many many axes that remain male and female only. Whats your point?
As I said toilets are based on biology not gender as there are more than 2 genders so....

Tbf, every French toilet, every time, they really don't
It's a myth.
I've not looked at the stats, but faced with an actual choice, I'd put money on it that they'd prefer not to share.

CrossStichQueen · 11/10/2022 15:36

John in the larger cities like Paris many places do have unisex lockable single facilities but equally many are still separated by sex. As you get further out of the big cities you will rarely see unisex toilets.

SarahAndQuack · 11/10/2022 15:47

As someone else said upthread most women can tell who is male and who is female. I can't believe this happens every time you go out though!

Not this again.

OP, I'm really sorry, but for some reason, MN is full of women who are convinced most women can tell who's male and who's female/have never seen someone of ambiguous gender/have never ever met a butch woman who passes as male. Every time there's a thread about something like this they come out to explain how impossible it is.

It's not.

My DP gets this too, though thankfully rarely anything so nasty as a response. It is tedious.

lifeturnsonadime · 11/10/2022 16:00

And yet interestingly in places like france the opposite sexes do share toilets

People always bring this up and it isn't true. There are toilettes for hommes and toilettes for dames in much of France !

Shared toilets exist in small establishments just like they do here.

JohnsShirt · 11/10/2022 16:18

CrossStichQueen · 11/10/2022 15:36

John in the larger cities like Paris many places do have unisex lockable single facilities but equally many are still separated by sex. As you get further out of the big cities you will rarely see unisex toilets.

Exactly.
It's nonsense.

JohnsShirt · 11/10/2022 16:26

Can I also point out that sharing toilets, or using gender neutral toilets isn't the same thing as being happy with it.
I've done it several times this year and every time I've been unhappy about it.
I've never felt comfortable enough to speak up about it in person to the establishment, but actually, I'll now send emails which I really should have done.

Lesbianactually · 11/10/2022 19:54

Again not responding to trollhunters, but I am reporting posts as I think others are too- One has even implied that I have multiple accounts and/or am asking people to post on my behalf!

I am not trying to get into an argument about the damage the trans movement does, I’ve made my views clear on that I think but I created this thread for one reason only, I was hoping to get some support for a personal issue of my partners (and mine by default).

She’s less bothered about being questioned when it is done without animosity. I think the issue is the things that have happened in the past when she’s been addressed and confronted aggressively.

There was a recent ‘Tiktok’ trend where short haired, masculine dressing lesbians were making videos showing that they’d show their bra strap or bra, or emphasise their breasts with their hands, each time they were questioned in a female facility.

I am sorry that’s happened to people who’ve been through what you have, @marmiteloversunite . I hope it doesn’t happen to you, and that you’re well.
Many masculine lesbians I know don’t emphasise their breasts, a lot wear sports bras and baggier clothes, including my partner. I guess if breasts were more obvious people would question less, but that’s not part of who many of them are.
@FreezingThyme , I didn’t like that either ☹

@aurynne he isn’t bothered, as I’ve repeatedly said, and said in the OP, by being mistaken for a male. It’s this one issue, in loos. That’s the end of the anxiety about it. She’s even been picked out in certain situations where a male was needed and went along with it. A tradesperson delivering me a large item of furniture pointed at her (just me and my Mum present otherwise) as she came out of the door with a ‘I am SO glad to see him!’ didn’t bother her at all. She’d never, ever dress more feminine, it isn’t who she is and she’d feel as uncomfortable as I would had I to cut my hair, grow a beard and wear a man’s suit to go to a wedding. It just wouldn’t happen. I also think she’d look quite ridiculous in an obviously woman’s jacket.

@Diverseopinions , thank you. I really thought I’d made it clear in the OP, what I wanted from the thread and it wasn’t a political debate. I realise I may have been short sighted to not forsee one would happen however ☹

And thank you for the helpful post. You’re right, the anticipation of such reactions is seeming to be the cause of her anxiety. The getting staff on board in smaller places is a good idea. I do go with her when I can if I can, obviously not practical if we’re sitting just us in a restaurant for example, or at an event where we need to watch our seats/bags or such.

I honestly don’t think my partner would look female even with long hair! Not that she’d ever grow her hair. It’s cut in a typical male short back and sides style.
And to your other post, yes, it seems a lot of posters aren’t considering the awkwardness of such an encounter. I am talking to her regularly about it now, what makes her feel it more in some places than others, and how we can address that as a couple and as individuals.

@Mummyoflittledragon definitely agree there. Although sometimes the reactions are seeming to be genuine, women thinking a man has got the wrong loo by accident, I don’t think those have ever been accompanied by anger or animosity toward her, and haven't’ caused upset. She still is anxious when they happen but I am really trying to help her work through that.

@Disydoll12 you’re right and those factors anger me as much as they do you, but I think thatisnotyours has a point to make in general about the way mumsnet (and other forums I suspect) are. If something is outside of the realm of some poster’s lives, their instant reaction is to think It’s a made up scenario and the poster is lying. And I am proof that this isn’t always the case, and have also stuck up for other posters on other threads when they’ve been met with it, if a similar thing has happened to me.

@Notarealmum yes, I’ve been trying to get that point across. Transwomen usually present as female. My partner doesn’t.

@antelopevalley I agree, and It’s sad. We should embrace the diversity we have as females, and we should be able to continue to do that without this sort of thing, without changing ourselves.

@BingoLingFucker thank you. I have responded to that post but your response makes more sense. My partner would feel absolutely ridiculous was she forced to wear more feminine clothing. It would create a whole new source of anxiety. Keep being you 😊

@JohnsShirt I also thanked the homophobic, racist bloke who put my bin out when I forgot, some weeks ago. It doesn’t mean I agree with all he says and thinks. I thanked the poster for a specific thing. I think I’ve made it clear what I personally agree with and do not but this is not the purpose of the thread.

@Surplus2requirements it made me feel awful. And very sad. I’ve not said anything on this thread that isn’t the truth.

@MenopausalMe that’s true, I was hoping to perhaps hear from others who’d had experiences similar, before the thread turned into a bunfight-but a lot of it has been helpful and I am very grateful for that. 😊

Again, I believe I thanked her for a specific thing she’d said toward my OP, not the whole of her argument (which I do not want to get into, I started this thread about a different subject entirely, and a personal one, not a political one).
It is interesting that, actually. I think people just tend to be more polite? ‘rougher’ areas/establishments where aggressive behaviour is more the norm, seem to worry her a lot more.

@ChagSameachDoreen I am sorry it happened to you, but thank you for affirming me that it does happen. I am sure that would happen for her too, but getting over the anxiety of the anticipation of it happening is the thing. Same to
@LastnightIdreamtofsomebagels thank you. And I agree it isn’t the end of the world, I said such in my OP. But there are plenty of things published on MN every day that aren’t the end of the world, some very trivial. It’s a discussion forum. I am trying to help her with the anxiety, and some of the responses have been helpful and I am grateful for the understanding posters and the empathy.

@SarahAndQuack thank you, and thank you for apologising for something that’s really not your fault do you work in customer service Wink . It’s a known issue, I mentioned the ‘Tiktok’ trend surrounding it not long ago. Women sharing how they’d show their bra strap or bra, push their breasts up etc or simply tell people they possessed a vagina! My DP is a bit too anxious to do that unfortunately. I am hoping this can change.

The ONLY thing I’ll say regarding the trans debate is, I will discuss this on the feminist boards and have done before when it comes up- I don’t feel this thread is the right place, it wasn’t its intention but obviously other people are free to
discuss what they wish. I don’t like mixed-gender loos either and avoid them wherever possible. I voted against them at my old work. I was in a restaurant not so long ago that now do this and I will not go again. Transwomen tend to present as women, they do not tend to look like my partner does (as also stated by several other contributors to this thread).

Another encounter my partner had was when she told someone I know who hadn’t met her before that she was in fact, female, had them ask if she was transitioning (ie a transman)! Although this didn’t spark her anxiety, I personally found it quite offensive.

Women should be able to not look conventional, to not wear pink, to not dress in frocks and to wear their hair short, without it being an issue for others.

I am glad to see the trollhunting posts are mostly gone deleted now.

OP posts:
Lesbianactually · 11/10/2022 20:13

Response to @aurynne should say SHE isn't bothered, obviously. Now I'm waiting to get jumped on about a typing error. :)

OP posts:
aurynne · 11/10/2022 21:19

I've never said the OP's DP should dress more like a woman. She can dress however she likes. The OP said she goes for the masculine look, and sometimes gets mistaken for a man, and she doesn't mind. However, when this happens at the toilets it causes her great anxiety.

My previous post, which has caused great debate, was offering a possible solution TO HER ANXIETY. I wan't implying she was "causing" the aggression. I didn't imply "she was looking for it". In fact I wasn't implying anything, my post was completely blunt. When a person goes for a masculine look, other people can mistake them for a man. People cannot read minds or see chromosomes and figure out on one quick look if a person who has a masculine look is a man or a woman. A man in a women's toilet IS a problem, so if someone mistakenly thinks the OP's DP is a man, they may try to stop her going there. It has happened and it will continue to happen.

And for the OP's DP this is so anxiety-inducing that she makes herself sick by holding her urine or simply refuses to go out and have fun because of this.

The fact is, the situation is not going to change as long as people mistake the OP's DP for a man. And the OP was asking for advice.

My advice was, throw a more feminine piece of clothing on when that situation is likely to happen, so the chances of being mistaken for a man are smaller. Not "dress like a woman", not "you were looking for it". It really is not such a radical advice, or at least I don't see it like that. The OP is free to ignore it and move on. But there is no need to grab the comment and throw it around as an example of the reason behind all the ills in the lives of women and transgender people.

Gender didn't even come into this piece of advice, as far as I've read there are no gender issues at ll in this situation, both the OP and her DP are female and identifying as women.

aurynne · 11/10/2022 21:21

@Lesbianactually my comment above was directed at other posters' response to it. You are the only person in this thread who has actually read it and take it as face value. Which is the only thing that matters, as it is your loved one who has the problem. i am sorry to read my advice wouldn't help her. I hope she finds a solution to this.

Lesbianactually · 12/10/2022 17:48

Thank you, @aurynne . And I apologise for being abrupt with you. The tone of this thread went in a way I really didn't expect but It's not an excuse.

I am going to keep trying to get to the bottom of this anxiety she has. We can't control other people's actions only our own. I really hope nobody addresses her aggressively again, because even if she manages to feel more confident, that would likely send her back to square one. Thanks again to all who've responded with genuineness. :)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page