Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Butch women and public loos-not sure if correct place to post..

262 replies

Lesbianactually · 09/10/2022 18:57

My partner is very masculine in appearance and is mistaken for a man all the time. This isn't usually a problem to her as she's aware of (and happy with) what she looks like.

However public loos (including in bars/restaurants etc) are a different story. It limits where we can go out, always has to be somewhere she feels comfortable, and these are few. Where she lives it isn't a very nice area and if I visit her she refuses to go out unless we're not drinking alcohol and/or will be very quick. First world problem I know, but I'd love for her to be able to leave the house for longer on occasion or for us to be able to share a few drinks and have some quality time. She lives with others so we don't get it at home.

She's better than she used to be. A few years ago she made herself quite poorly by holding the urge for up to 6 or 7 hours, & nowadays she won't do this, but largely through avoidance rather than management. She still panics if we go out, quite often. We live near a 'gay village' and she's fine there but last time we went with some friends, they wanted to go to a bar outside of it and she became visibly distressed as we were drinking alcohol and this means she needs the loo more often.

I've tried to help. The crux of the issue is she hates being confronted, told she's in the wrong loo. She's noticed if we're in a not so nice area, people are less tolerant/open minded and when they have confronted her they're quite nasty about it. In nicer areas she's less uncomfortable. In my local pub (we live quite far from one another) she's fine, and she has been confronted in there but she just responded that she was a woman and was there with her girlfriend and she'd show her ID if she wasn't believed. She wasn't upset by this at all but she has also in other places, had some people grab her and try to drag her out, get quite aggressive with her etc.

I know this is an anxiety-induced situation and perhaps does not need specific advice other than for her to get help for anxiety but just wondered if anyone else has experienced anything like this, anything that's good to say to people if she finds herself in this situation, any ways I can help?

She has a disabled key, from the time she made herself ill with this, but it isn't always practical to use that and it would be better for her to be happier to use the female loos generally. It's causing her unhappiness in life and limiting what she does/where she goes.

Thank you.

OP posts:
RufusthefIoraImissingreindeer · 10/10/2022 13:04

Seems to me that the term GC has beeb changed

Used to be a feminist thing and meant critical of gender, thinking it was harmful

Now people have changed it to mean anyone who thinks you can't change sex ...so the vast majority of people, feminist or not

BingoLingFucker · 10/10/2022 13:15

aurynne · 10/10/2022 03:32

@Lesbianactually , your DP is female and happy to be a woman, but she is choosing to present herself in a way that makes her appear male. In a way, she cannot really complain if she is actually mistaken for a man, as she chooses to present herself in that way. If she is choosing to do this, then being mistaken for a male when she goes to the toilet will be one of the unfortunate consequences of her choice.

We cannot expect life to happen as we think it "should" happen, we need to live life as it is.

The elephant in the room that nobody seems to want to drag out is: she could also choose to dress more womanly when she plans to go out for a drink. this way the chance of being mistaken for a man when he goes to the toilet will be greatly reduced. Perhaps simply carrying a woman's jacket to wear on top of her more masculine clothes could do the trick?

These days we are so obsessed with individuality and the "sacredness" of expressing ourselves the way we want that we tend to forget that, if we do this, we need to accept the good and bad consequences of it.

If you dress like a man, you may be mistaken for a man. Fancy that!

If people think you're a man, many will try to stop you going into a women's toilet.

Ergo... if you don't want this to happen, don't present yourself as a man.

I’ve read up to this point, and had to respond.

This is disgusting victim blaming, and also plays into hideous gender stereotyping.

I dress in a very masculine way, I do this because that’s what feels comfortable. If I go out I dress in the same way, because dressing “more womanly” feels so alien and odd to me, it’s not who I am.

I am still a woman though, despite my clothes and my short hair Hmm

As for the subject of the OP, I hope your GF can find a way to feel more comfortable when out.

BingoLingFucker · 10/10/2022 13:20

antelopevalley · 10/10/2022 11:34

And aurynees comment that the solution is to dress "like a woman", is a perfect example of how some individual gender-critical women are making life harder for women who do not fit into neat boxes of feminine and largely gender conforming. Feminism used to be about fighting for women to be who we are in all our diversity, not to push us into boxes.

That poster isn’t gender critical if that’s her opinion.

Surely gender critical is trying to move away from boys = blue, short hair and dinosaurs and girls = pink, long hair and frills.

It’s bad enough that society has regressed back to shitty stereotypes, but let’s not lump those assumptions in with gender critical feminists.

BloodAndFire · 10/10/2022 17:18

antelopevalley · 10/10/2022 12:13

@CrossStichQueen Have you missed the comment in this thread saying women should dress like women - whatever that means. This is not uncommon in gender critical groups. Very anti feminist.

It really is relentless, isn't it. The horror of the possibility that someone might at some point take women's rights seriously - must be attacked using every possible lie, as often as possible.

reigatecastle · 10/10/2022 17:41

I agree in most cases it's entirely possible to tell if someone is male or female. Although the other day DH and were watching something on TV, which has previously featured someone who was trans. DH said what is it about this programme (and career path) that so many are trans. But I thought the person concerned was a masculine presenting woman (had quite a male voice but it does happen), he wasn't convinced and thought the person was a transwoman.

So I can believe that mistakes can be made, but it must be very rare. And short hair and jeans hardly means you're a bloke - I very rarely wear a dress or skirt but am very obviously female.

As for transmen not looking like "real" men, I did see an article recently about a transman who looked like a very convincing bloke with a beard - although it might have been a cleverly edited photograph.

ChampagneCamping · 10/10/2022 18:32

Freespirit42 · 09/10/2022 21:31

No it’s not positive as it’s harming cis women like this one that has been spoken about. The fact is a bloody rapist don’t need to pretend to be trans they just gonna rape any ways

studies show that mixed sex spaces yeald more male on female assaults

BloodAndFire · 10/10/2022 18:37

reigatecastle · 10/10/2022 17:41

I agree in most cases it's entirely possible to tell if someone is male or female. Although the other day DH and were watching something on TV, which has previously featured someone who was trans. DH said what is it about this programme (and career path) that so many are trans. But I thought the person concerned was a masculine presenting woman (had quite a male voice but it does happen), he wasn't convinced and thought the person was a transwoman.

So I can believe that mistakes can be made, but it must be very rare. And short hair and jeans hardly means you're a bloke - I very rarely wear a dress or skirt but am very obviously female.

As for transmen not looking like "real" men, I did see an article recently about a transman who looked like a very convincing bloke with a beard - although it might have been a cleverly edited photograph.

There is a world of difference between seeing someone on tv/online/on paper, and being in someone's presence in real life.

Lesbianactually · 10/10/2022 19:02

I am back at the thread now.

Last night I didn’t want to respond any longer-I am sorry to all the genuine posters who believe I am who I say I am, it was just awful to be posting about an issue that’s very real, and receiving such vitriol. I did send quite a few private messages to the people who’d responded with understanding and practical advice and thanked them.

To those who don’t believe this is genuine, and I am assuming you’ve been wrong at least once before in your lives, imagine just for one minute that you’re wrong on this occasion, how that person you’ve incorrectly judged is feeling.

I am a lesbian 100%. I am old enough to remember the days before the trans thing became such as it is now, and I struggle with a lot of it. I am now supposed to be open to dating a man who identifies as a female and if I say I won’t, or if I was single and refused to, I would be labelled as full of hatred, acting with discrimination or a turf (I know that’s not the correct initialism but I am not sure I am allowed to type the real one). I would not date a transwoman, or a man in any capacity and receiving messages that I have apparently made this up, and that my partner is male, is really awful. I can’t remember the last time I was addressed in such a vile manner, online or otherwise unless it was from ‘the other side’ i.e. men wanting to be accepted as women. This is the reason I felt I couldn’t come back to the thread. It’s the opposite of who I am and, while being told one’s a liar on the internet by a bunch of strangers shouldn’t (and probably wouldn't usually) hurt me, this really did.

I’ve not felt so erased and disliked in a long time, myself and on my partner’s behalf (I am SO glad she doesn’t know about this thread-this is the kind of thing that makes things so much worse).

Transwomen to my knowledge, present as female, and some things give away the fact that they’re male. My partner presents as male according to societal norms. There is nothing about her appearance that suggests female unless you have a keen eye and/or are used to those who carry her look-there are plenty of them, but not in a lot of circles.

I will also repeat, I have been on mumsnet for some years. I can do the thing a lot of people don’t like and mention Pom Bears, Penis Beakers and the sad but lovely thread about a drug dependent baby from EMIN, if that helps any. I am female and joined while raising my stepchildren with my ex partner. I am reasonably active on the feminist boards under a different username, although this username also has a nod to being a gay female.

One of the people who addressed me with disdain did tell me that Reddit Lesbian forums are full of men. I don't go on them often, but I will actively avoid them now, so thank you for that. I felt they were more aimed at the youngish community.

As I've already said, I most certainly did not 'expect' mumsnet to be 'full of feminine middle aged women'. I am not new, and I know mumsnet has a diverse community-I was hoping to receive some responses from those who may have experience with this kind of thing. It's why I put the title as I did and why I posted in one of the more active subforums.

I’ll respond to some of the posts now. Apologies if I miss any, It’s been a long day.

I am not responding to blatant trollhunters. Thank you @MNHQ for deleting the posts you have-some were truly awful.

OP posts:
Diverseopinions · 10/10/2022 20:05

I can totally see why OP's friend feels anxious about going out on the town.

It's not exactly a really great experience, knowing everyone in the cloakroom hates you, until you start to speak back to them, after they've told you to get out. Wow. I wouldn't mind at all going out to a pub, in that case. I'd actually feel really comfortable - NOT.

Does anyone seriously think that people, a bit inebriated, are going to back down when she speaks her protest,, and say: "Oh, terribly sorry - I can tell, now, you're female by your voice. Carry on. This cubicle's free now." No, they're more likely to be a bit flabbergasted and embarrassed about calling out a woman, and they'd probably not want to admit they've been horribly hurtful. I bet they'd maybe, go into a massive rant about men forcing their way in, and how they hate that.

What could they possibly say, anyway, to make OP's friend feel better? What a horrible situation for OP's partner to be in.

Lesbianactually · 10/10/2022 20:15

@CrossStichQueen you don’t have to believe me of course, but she doesn’t feel like she does for no reason. I am talking to her about it regularly trying to establish the actual crux of the issue. I’ve seen the aggression from women with my own eyes once and have no reason to not believe her about the other occasions but even without aggression, her anxiety is there from others misjudging her, and from the past, and that’s what I wanted help with.

@BloodAndFire that’s why I (largely mistakenly) thought it would be the right place. If not, I don’t know where the right place is. I guess I'll use the helpful advice I did receive and continue to try to support her with it. I do encourage her to get therapy but I am not sure she will, she find the idea daunting.

I would also not like for a transwoman to be with me in a private space, and neither would my partner. I wouldn’t be comfortable with that at all.

I realise however that this sort of issue is the collateral damage perpetuated by trans activists.

I have much the same views as Magdelen Berns. Although I’ve nothing against transwomen per se, I am against men in female only spaces however and against how the erasure of lesbians, and women in general, is now riding on the trans movement.

@JAC76 aside from her being a little paranoid about being a bit (not massively) overweight, I don’t believe there are deeper issues with her appearance. She’s a little vain even, I’d say, about how she looks!

@TonksInPurple I am sorry this happened to you and your ex too.

@CrossStichQueen I am being honest, but of course again
you do not have to believe me.

I am bemused as to how people are accusing people of being a same user (me?!) under a different name. How dare someone believe me and share their
own views and experiences….

@ChampagneCamping we are aiming at building up her confidence. This isn’t the worst issue in the world of course, but I am beginning to feel very bad for her, as well as irked that we can’t really out go on dates, for days out with others etc unless It’s to the same places.

@Freespirit42 thank you for affirming that this kind of thing does happen.

@CheezePleeze if you’re saying what I think you’re saying, we’ve been together a while and have had sex, and if she does possess a penis It’s an incredibly small one, I would go to say so far as non-existent.. I don’t know where the breasts came from either. Ridiculous. If you meant something else please clarify.

I could post a photo of us both naked I guess, but then that wouldn’t prove anything -I am betting the people who don’t believe me would just be saying she’s post op (eyeroll).

@RosieBartley I agree about it going in the wrong direction, as I’ve said lesbians and women in general are suffering. My partner is female, presenting as masculine doesn’t change hormones, chromosomes or genitals. Transmen tend to present as female to my knowledge/experience.

@Begoniasforever I do, I think I put that in my OP or a following post. She says it helps a little but it doesn’t take away the anxiety or paranoia she has. It's also not always practical.

@MintyGreenDreams Oh god Grin PLEASE shake her hand on my behalf, what a brilliant young woman! I wish my partner would do this.

@TheHoover it grates on me, it really does. Women’s rights are going backwards.
@hartof I am so sorry to read that ☹, your poor DD. It’s one reason I want my partner to handle this in the best way-we have the younger generations to be a good inspiration for even if in a symbolic way.

@Jibo I don’t think she’d go in the men’s. I don’t think she’d want to be around men while they’re using loos, I know I wouldn’t. And also if someone did recognise her as a female in there I guess the same thing could happen but the other way around.

@evilharpy thank you for sharing that experience but how awful for her. My partner doesn’t have any especially feminine facial features at all. If I look closely at her or imagine her in a wig, and perhaps not as tall/broad a build I guess… But she’s naturally quite a masculine looking person even without the clothing/haircut.

It does happen and although I’d rather it never did, I appreciate those who have experience with it sharing, if only because I guess it corroborates what I am saying, and that I haven’t made this whole thing up.

And @PeloFondo you’ve reminded me, I had a similar experience at school with a very similar girl. We went on a school trip somewhere and someone told her to get out of the girls’ loos. They didn’t think she was a boy though, they thought she was a man! She was about 10/11 but very tall and stocky. I still speak to her, she was my first crush 😊

I’d never have the imagination to post such a long-winded, detailed thread about something that was a blatant lie.

While I am on that subject, could someone please tell me why on earth anyone would? Is it just because it would ruffle some feathers? I have seen troll posts on here before seeking attention but I just can’t see why someone would do that on this subject, in as much detail as I gave.

@SeenYourArse as I put in the OP, she’s not generally, it doesn’t bother her one bit, she knows what she looks like. It’s just this one situation, in loos. I think It's more the being mistaken for a predatory man or a man wanting to hang about in a female only space, more than just a man, period?

@thatisnotyours I have seen that many a time on here. People just don’t believe something to be true unless they’ve seen something like it themselves, experienced it themselves or heard of it within their realm of life. I posted on a thread recently where I had that (it wasn’t as sensitive as this one so it didn’t bother me so much) but I did respond with something like ‘just because you haven’t heard of it, doesn’t mean It’s not true or the poster is lying!’

I find it bizarre. Humans are a diverse bunch who have very different experiences to others. Being so closed minded is odd.

@MrsNobodyMM . That post is helpful, thank you. I realise how people are sensitive to it and I am one of them (hence how upsetting it is to be thought of as a liar). It’s a minefield to try to deal with.
It seems so simple doesn’t it?! She can handle other situations better than the next person-It’s just this, it seems to be so upsetting for her, I am trying to figure out why by talking to her about it. She doesn’t seem to know fully either, which doesn’t help!

@5zeds I don’t think I’ve said it happens often, however it has happened enough times and over a long enough period of time (since she was a child), to have resulted in a chronic anxiety that happens often, much of the time we avoid going out because of it. That’s the issue, not that it happens every time we go out or such, because we don’t go out, unless It’s to a place she feels safe, (gay places or my local pub, very gay friendly) or we’re not out very long.

@bluelogo92 I am sorry your partner has this issue too, being asked to show her breasts is surely harassment?! I don’t know if that’s ever happened to mine.
Has she any ways she deals with it? She sounds similar, confident in most other ways just this one thing ☹Does she pinpoint why? Sorry, 20 questions.

Thank you @antelopevalley for affirming me. I struggle with how many people think it just never happens-it does!

@CrossStichQueen I do agree men have caused this issue. But I certainly felt ‘hated’ by women last night.

@mumoffloofs thank you for the lengthy post. It’s interesting, perhaps why she receives the reaction she does is she doesn’t look like a transwoman, she doesn’t present as a woman, she looks ‘manly’. I hope it dies down soon.

@antelopevalley isn’t that the truth ☹and to your second point, yes they are both an issue. The latter being much more of one to me personally, but this one being more of a ‘real’ issue for my partner.

The being pushed toward surgery is awful too. My partner (and some of my exes, quite a few friends) were all masculine presenting from a young age . That was okay back then, not ‘okay’ as in fully accepted, but they were labelled as ‘one of the boys’ or ‘tomboys’ etc. If they were young nowadays, I fear they’d be labelled as trans and encouraged to begin the process.

OP posts:
Johnnysgirl · 10/10/2022 20:24

Wow, op, you also knew a 10 year old girl who got mistaken for a grown man...

JohnsShirt · 10/10/2022 21:46

Op You say you felt hated by women, yet at least one of the ones you've thanked sees transwomen as women, is happy with them in our spaces, and as we know if twaw then it follows, can be lesbians.
Oof.
Women are, as you know sick of men wanting in our spaces, sick of people destroying our sex based rights, your partner seems to be collateral damage and it's not fair, however GC women are not to blame.
TRA's are, and I'm also fed up with handmaidens telling me I'm hateful for wanting, no needing, to stand up for those rights which no one should be touching in the first place.
It sounds like you agree with this though?

Surplus2requirements · 11/10/2022 08:34

@JohnsShirt I imagine most people would feel hatred from people that told them their experience was impossible and they are a liar

MenopausalMe · 11/10/2022 09:55

There may not be much you or your girlfriend can do directly. Just like there really isn’t anything the women here can do.

Men demanding access to women’s spaces and forcing themselves in have created this problem, along with people like freespirit42 (who you thanked above Confused ) cheering them on. Women are just trying to protect themselves from harm.

Interesting your girlfriend doesn’t have as much of a problem in ‘nicer’ (code for middle class) areas as we’re always being told by the trans rights activists its only the middle class women that object to males in their spaces…

Freespirit42 · 11/10/2022 10:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Freespirit42 · 11/10/2022 10:13

MenopausalMe · 11/10/2022 09:55

There may not be much you or your girlfriend can do directly. Just like there really isn’t anything the women here can do.

Men demanding access to women’s spaces and forcing themselves in have created this problem, along with people like freespirit42 (who you thanked above Confused ) cheering them on. Women are just trying to protect themselves from harm.

Interesting your girlfriend doesn’t have as much of a problem in ‘nicer’ (code for middle class) areas as we’re always being told by the trans rights activists its only the middle class women that object to males in their spaces…

Really let’s have a look shall we trans women have been using womens loos for decades I guess you may even have peed next to one and you would never know it’s not us wanting to police the toilets it’s you guys

Freespirit42 · 11/10/2022 10:15

Freespirit42 · 11/10/2022 10:13

Really let’s have a look shall we trans women have been using womens loos for decades I guess you may even have peed next to one and you would never know it’s not us wanting to police the toilets it’s you guys

Also I am working class now when I have been with my trans friend she never gets any issues in middle class areas or even really working class because most folks don’t give a dam contrary to this group

Freespirit42 · 11/10/2022 10:18

Can we stop seeing women as weak it’s bloody annoying you call yourselves feminists yet you portray women as scared weak women no man scares me at all as I don’t see men as potential rapists all the bloody time it’s unhinged

Jibo · 11/10/2022 10:22

Freespirit42 · 11/10/2022 10:18

Can we stop seeing women as weak it’s bloody annoying you call yourselves feminists yet you portray women as scared weak women no man scares me at all as I don’t see men as potential rapists all the bloody time it’s unhinged

@Freespirit42 You're the one sounding unhinged, replying to your own posts. Good for you that you don't feel males pose any physical risk to you but you don't get to make that decision for my 12yo daughter.

Johnnysgirl · 11/10/2022 10:22

no man scares me at all
If you think that keeps you safe I'm afraid it's you who's unhinged.

CrossStichQueen · 11/10/2022 10:26

It's odd to me that when we discuss the facts of male violence against women we, women, are deemed to be the bad ones as we portray ourselves as weak, and scared. Let's ignore the fact that 3 women a week are murdered by men in the UK alone but that's the women's fault as they are weak and scared apparently.

I doubt any one of the men who have murdered a women would have not done so if a feminist had said "oh women are strong and not scared" men know they can overpower us with strength and fear pretending otherwise will not save womens lives!

Freespirit42 · 11/10/2022 10:28

The three women a week are done by partners usually not by trans women so the point to be scared by them in loos is silly

Freespirit42 · 11/10/2022 10:29

Jibo · 11/10/2022 10:22

@Freespirit42 You're the one sounding unhinged, replying to your own posts. Good for you that you don't feel males pose any physical risk to you but you don't get to make that decision for my 12yo daughter.

I am not replying to my own post I didn’t write the post did I

CrossStichQueen · 11/10/2022 10:29

The three women a week are done by partners usually not by trans women so the point to be scared by them in loos is silly

How do women know which is a safe male and which isn't?

Freespirit42 · 11/10/2022 10:31

CrossStichQueen · 11/10/2022 10:29

The three women a week are done by partners usually not by trans women so the point to be scared by them in loos is silly

How do women know which is a safe male and which isn't?

Maybe look at the figures trans women are not causing the issues they are also victims of cis men and maybe not lumping them all into the same thing would help and then to get onto the original post maybe then some make looking women woukdnt be stopped going to the loo they need to tell these other gatekeepers to piss off