Which Tiffany Necklace for 16 year old DD?

[DFOD]

Which one would a 16 year old girl like best?

www.tiffany.co.uk/jewelry/necklaces-pendants/elsa-peretti-open-heart-pendant-GRP06386/

www.tiffany.co.uk/jewelry/necklaces-pendants/return-to-tiffany-double-heart-tag-pendant-37094692/

Fair enough, was just a thought.

I'm sure when I was 16 I'd have preferred the obvious branding.
Unfortunately those open heart styles can be bought places like Argos and few people would know it was Tiffany (if anyone) unless your dd told them- which would make her a bit uncouth.

Go for no. 2.

I don't particularly like either. I think at 16, I would have preferred the cash to spend however I wanted or to be taken away to do something as a treat.

What a fabulous idea - and will take her in the newly opened Elizabeth Line to Bond Street….

I actually went and bought no2 this afternoon from Westfield as I wanted her to have something to open and given the feedback on the thread seems like it’s what a 16 year old would want - the overt branding - not personal my style but I wouldn’t have appreciated my own 52 year old mothers taste when I was 16!

Thanks all for your help in getting me to the right decision …. I will gift her this and then take her along to the shop so that she can see if she preferred something else.

Just picked her up sitting from first GCSE exam …. it was OK … only another TWENTY TWO to go. Good luck to any others out there with DC sitting exams.

It really boils down to whether she prefers labels to be seen or subtly hidden. Sounds like she’s had an awful time - I’m sure she’ll love whatever you choose

@evilharpy Sorry if I came off as critical! I didn't mean it that way, just speaking as someone who watches a lot of Tiktok - and as such, sometimes comes across young creators even though they're not my preferred demographic to watch. It always sticks with me when they show very expensive tastes because I was so much more basic as a teen.

I hope she has a fab birthday, @DFOD

I like the second one, it's younger and more fun-you can buy silver cloths to keep silver looking fresh if it starts to tarnish.

I think you made the right choice @DFOD! The open heart one is very dated unless she is specifically into late 90s / early 2000s fashion - it's what Bridget Jones wore in the film 21 years ago.

2nd one but I have teenage girls and know how I would ultimately be wrong in my choice 🤣🥰

Oh god no you didn't at all! I just meant I could have been way off I was the same as a teen, they all seem to have designer stuff these days and I only lusted after crap from Tammy Girl!

www.tiffany.co.uk/jewelry/necklaces-pendants/crown-charm-GRP02344/

Personally I would have loved to give her this one as it reminds me of “straighten your crown” approach when life overwhelms you.

I have both and always reach for the 1st one (not that I wear them much anymore 🙄)

the second one I wear backwards if I don’t want the Tiffany’s to be seen 🤷‍♀️

my daughter who’s younger than yours always wears the 2nd one

My 16yo dd has the 2nd one but in the double silver hearts rather than one with a coloured back. She wears it all the time and it looks great with no tarnishing. She doesn't shower in it and puts perfume on before the necklace.

Funnily enough I passed these two by my friend who has a very 'on-trend' 21 year old dd when I was selecting an 18th b'day present for my dd. Her dd said that the 'Return to Tiffany' ones are a bit naff these days, however if she likes obvious labels it will be her thing. The first one is well-known and far classier.

Ps I didn't actually end up getting dd either, but I've been VERY tempted by the first one since my research!

100% return to Tiffany, the are loads of £10 copies of the open heart (not meaning to offend anyone who has one! They are pretty but you see lots of copies)

Second one

My dd picked number 2 although it might not count as a vote as she's 13! I would say number 2 as well

When I was Tiffany’s this afternoon they showed how the blue/pink heart could be worn as double silver as the colour is only on one side.

She has no expectation of what’s coming - I told her I was popping over to Sainsbury’s this evening to pick her up some PJs, slippers and a fluffy dressing gown for her birthday (winding her up) - she said sweetly that she would like a silver necklace to wear to her prom and that they do nice enough ones in Sainsbury’s…..!!

Second one

@DFOD That's so sweet!

The second one

2nd one for a 16 year old

The second one is really chavvy……looks cheap

I bought my DD the mini version of the 2nd one
www.tiffany.co.uk/jewelry/necklaces-pendants/return-to-tiffany-mini-double-heart-tag-pendant-GRP06366/
and she had the matching bracelet for her 18th.
She still wears them now and she is in her mid 20s