My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Mumsnet hasn't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. You may wish to speak to a medical professional before starting any diet.

Low-carb bootcamp

Defeating emotional eating

90 replies

OldBooks · 25/06/2017 19:39

It seems like several of us doing Bootcamp struggle with eating for all sorts of reasons that have nothing to do with hunger ... boredom, tiredness, stress, upset, and even when happy or celebrating.

I thought a thread where we can share experiences, resources and tips might help us stop self-sabotaging and increase our Bootcamp success. Just because cream is a bootcamp approved food doesn't mean you should eat a whole pot in one go because you had a crap day ...

I started a thread about this a while back so I will repost my story:
^Background (apologies for length): I have been a 'big girl' ever since I hit puberty, diagnosed with PCOS in my late teens. I seem to settle at size 16-18 and usually weigh around 90-100 kilos. I am now in my 30s and have just had DD2 which has obviously affected my tummy and I look flabbier than ever. I have lost weight in the past on low-carb diets or on 5:2 but always get derailed and never manage to maintain any loss.

My mother is a classic narcissist and we have a difficult relationship. One of her biggest sticking points is my weight. She herself is vain and insecure and constantly references her weight, what she is eating, how she needs to exercise etc. She grabs her tummy and says how disgusting she looks. This is almost a game or a habit as she never actually does anything to address it. Ever since I started to gain weight in my teens she has commented on it, screamed and shouted at me to lose weight, been extremely negative etc to the point of giving me a huge complex, shredding my self esteem/confidence and leaving me with disordered thoughts around food and eating. Of course she never actually helped me to take any positive steps to lose weight or begin exercising, and I have come to understand that in a way she actually wants me to be overweight as it reduces my threat to her vanity and she has sabotaged me to ensure I stay big, eg always bringing cakes/biscuits when she visits. I have struggled with depression and anxiety and have found my negative thinking about my appearance has affected my life, especially before I met my DH. For example missing a friend's wedding because I thought I looked hideous in all my outfits.

I was always a 'good girl', no drinking, smoking, boys and successful academically - eating was my only 'vice'. I comfort eat a lot, when I am stressed, sad, angry, bored etc I immediately crave sweet foods. I have only been able to maintain dieting/healthy eating during stable and stress free periods of my life, as soon as there is any difficulty I want to eat eat eat again. I also began to self harm in my teens and will still do so in extremis - I think that overeating and ruining my health by doing so is a form of self harm and fits with that mindset. But ironically I harm myself most over my weight, eg I once carved 'fat cow' into my stomach with a pair of scissors.

Now I have 2 daughters I am terrified of passing on my thoughts about my body image and eating to them. I want them to see me maintaining a healthy lifestyle, eating well with treats in moderation, exercising for pleasure and being positive, dressing well and taking care of myself no matter my size. But it is so hard to implement. I know how to eat healthily and about nutrition and what is good for me as a woman with PCOS. I know it will be beneficial to my long term health to eat a low carb, low sugar diet and maintain that. I know that my negative thoughts about my body and my low self esteem come from my mother. But I can't make myself stop thinking these negative thoughts. I can't approach a healthy lifestyle in a positive way, as a good thing I am doing for myself and my family. I feel resentful of the PCOS, deprived and sulky. I spiral into self-abusive comments, call myself useless, a failure, a waste of space. I fantasize about cutting my tummy.

How do I address the gap between what my rational mind understands (these negative thoughts come from my upbringing, a healthy lifestyle will be beneficial) and what my emotional self feels (waaaaa I want the cake it's not fair, why can't I have the cake, I shouldn't have the cake, just eat the cake, now look you fat bitch you've eaten the cake, you can't do anything right)?

It is so exhausting thinking about food constantly. I want to eat, I shouldn't eat, what can I eat... I just want to break this cycle and think about food normally!^

OP posts:
Report
OldBooks · 25/06/2017 19:41

These were some of the resources mentioned on that thread:

Books:
Paul Mckenna's Freedom from emotional eating and I can make you thin
Brain over Binge

Apps
Virtual Gastric Band app
Paul McKenna gastric band app

Web Resources
//www.drrogergould.com/programs-online/emotional-eating
//www.hypnosisdownloads.com/weight-loss/emotional-eating
//www.thehappinesstrap.com
nosdiet.com/

OP posts:
Report
OldBooks · 25/06/2017 19:43

And I should add to finish that the epic post I have copied above was written in December last year. The thread fizzled out, and I was not much better off. Eventually I found bootcamp in April which has gone some way to address some of the issues I mention.

OP posts:
Report
GoodBadOrIndifferent · 25/06/2017 19:44

Thanks oldbooks
Its definitely an issue for me. The only strategy that works for me at times is to try and delay eating, then if I'm hungry 10 minutes later I'll eat something.
I'll have a look at the books!

Report
moutonfou · 25/06/2017 19:49

I was always a 'good girl', no drinking, smoking, boys and successful academically - eating was my only 'vice'. I comfort eat a lot, when I am stressed, sad, angry, bored etc I immediately crave sweet foods

This rings so true with me. Very interesting.

All that helps me is trying to remember that I'll feel extreme pleasure for the 60 seconds I'm eating that chocolate bar, but then afterwards I'll be up 250 calories and no better off emotionally.

Otherwise, I try making a milky tea as a treat instead. Still has to be better than shovelling chocolate down me.

Report
dustmotesinthesun · 25/06/2017 20:05

Back on to read properly later but I have three things to recommend.

The Thin Woman's Brain by Dilia Suriel (fanastic in many ways. I learnt a lot)
Brain over Binge (not actually read it! But have seen it recommended so much on MN)
And this website Eat Like a Normal Person

The latter in particular suggests you ditch all dieting, but they are talking about dieting in the context of eating a small number of calories and being chronically starved. I think low carbing is still fine because you are eating real food and enough of it to feel full. Plus it's so much delicious stuff.

I've just been reading it today and it makes SO much sense. I'm really glad I read it. Really hoping it helps me.

Report
MOIST · 25/06/2017 20:26

I'm in. I've had brain over binge in my amazon basket for ages. Really should face up and read it.
I eat for any reason. It has absolutely nothing to do with hunger.
I have a really crap relationship with food and a worse one with my body. I hate it. I hate my fat bits. I hate looking like shit. I hate that nothing fits. I hate the way I look. I am big and ugly.
I also hate feeling like this. I have a good family (h and 2 dds). I love my job. I love my friends. I have a home. I have hobbies, a brain, things to do. There is no need to hate my body but I do. And it's down to me eating the wrong stuff for the wrong reasons.

Report
dustmotesinthesun · 25/06/2017 22:13

oldbooks what you've posted is so very sad.

I started putting on weight at 9. I think i was just very intolerant of carbohydrates. I became disabled as a teen and was very badly bullied and my way of surviving was to eat. It was a really good strategy in that it kept me alive.

I lost lots of weight at 18 but feeling frustrated with how slowly i was losing i did a vlcd. Lost 1.5 stone in a month and then in the year after that put on about 7 stones because it just seemed to fluck a switch in my brain. I literally felt i was starving and had the constant urge to eat. It was very frightening.

It nearly destroyed me really. I got most of that weught off by 25 but 3 times since then i've regained 2 stones. 3 times!! The last time was so humiliating. I couldn't understand how it could have happened. In fact why it did was i was very stressed and never learnt how to cope with bad feelings without eating. Also i slip into denial very easily about how quickly i can gain weight. The second and third times being in crappy relationships was a huge part of the problem which has made me really look at why i got into them. My standards are much higher these days.

I feel like i'm so nearly there with my issues. Just clearly not fully. Regain is so horrendous i never want to go back there. I really love this woe and it is now my normal. So i'm setting myself up for a lifetime of good eating at least, it feels.

Report
ScoobyDoosTinklyLaugh · 26/06/2017 08:26

Oldbooks that was a difficult to read bit thanks for sharing Flowers

I've always been a bit of a binge eater, but I always got away with it weight wise until I got pregnant.

I think I probably had an eating disorder when I was 15-18 as I severly restricted food, sometimes binged and excessively excercised. It improved when I went to university and drinking took priority for a while.

I'm the opposite in that I've never been a 'good' girl because I've smoked, drank, taken drugs from a teenager.

When I was pregnant with Dd and I stopped all the other fun stuff, the only treat I felt like I had left was food so I just ate cakes and pastries constantly. Interestingly I first noticed when I was pregnant that simple carbs gave me migraines.

After I had her, the first few months were so tiring and whenever I'm tired I just craved cake and toast as I felt like those foods gave me an energy boost.

She's 20 months now and its alot easier now we all get some sleep.

Anyway I've been low carbing for 8ish weeks now and I have lost weight but I'm still eating too much out of boredom and the compulsion to 'treat' myself. I feel great on this WOE, no big energy dips and headaches in the afternoon. I don't get awful and shakey when I'm hungry.

I still can't be trusted with cream, cheese, yogurt etc. I'm definately not going on mad food binges like eating a massive pack of biscuits but I've still eaten a pot of cream in a day!

My problem is picking when bored at home and I always want a bloody 'treat' of an evening. I think that comes from drinking and really I'm trying to replace the 'unwinding' ritual.

Report
OldBooks · 27/06/2017 07:09

Thank you all for joining and sharing your stories. I have been looking at inspirational / motivating quotes which I will list out when I get the chance.

If anyone reads or sees something useful do tell us, and if possible give us a synopsis.

Moist you express such strong hatred for your body, where do you think that has come from?

Dust I couldn't agree more with how humiliating it is to regain after a loss. Everyone gives you so much praise for losing weight (I have a massive problem with this but that's another discussion) and to put it back on feels like a moral or character failure rather than messed up bio-chemistry.

Scooby I am the same about wanting a 'treat' in the evenings, it seems to be totally programmed into me even if my main meal has left me stuffed. I read once that an experiment was done where rats were given a full meal then something sweet. After a while they stopped giving the sweet food. Even though they had eaten enough and shouldn't be hungry the rats were wandering around the cage looking for that sweet finishing food. When I get agitated looking for something sweet I tell myself I am being the rat!

Flowers for all of us.

OP posts:
Report
Yorkshirebornandbred · 27/06/2017 07:19

I struggle with the same issues. I joined bootcamp but have abandoned it because I feel deprived eating no carbs.

I've just read Paul McKenna I can make you thin and so much of it makes sense. However I haven't managed to implement it yet due to emotional eating.

I'll have a look at the books mentioned above.

Report
dustmotesinthesun · 27/06/2017 15:10

Yy to wanting a treat in the evenings. It's very hard to break that habit. A cup of fruit tea is helping me a lot.

The eat like a normal person website that i linked to above is pretty amazing i have to say. I have been devouring it. I have done a strict week (over that now i think) and tbh it's been the easiest week in ages. Definitely thanks in part to that website. I will summarise it at a different point if i have time but i can only say go and browse it. It makes so much sense.

Report
MOIST · 27/06/2017 21:16

No idea Old. Just 40 years of feeling ugly. It's irrational as I know I'm very ordinary really but I've never felt good enough at anything. Probably need therapy.

Report
Yorkshirebornandbred · 27/06/2017 22:03

MOIST I understand, feel the same Sad

Report
paintapicturebakeacake · 27/06/2017 22:19

I've been lurking and haven't posted for years, but reading this made me want to...

I've just finished four months of counselling for an eating disorder (restricting, not eating) but my issues come from the same place as yours seem to, I think.

You mention your mother making you feel guilty/sabotaging you. I learned so much in those sessions about where my anxious/self-loathing feelings came from, which I didn't think were unreasonable or unsubstantiated. I just accepted that voice in my head which was always so critical.

I know now that I felt like that for a reason, and my ED was a coping mechanism to get through these feelings. My counsellor taught me to be kinder to myself (which sounds simple, but actually took a lot of talking). It sounds like you've been raised not to feel good enough as you are, and some therapy with someone specialised in eating disorders might be able to retrain you to see yourself in a kinder light. Then, the issue with food, which is a distracting cycle and pre-occupation can start to be resolved. I hope that doesn't sound presumptuous, but your post struck a chord and I do hope that you get the help that you deserve.

Report
Ohyesiam · 27/06/2017 23:04

Take a look at Bright Line Eating, it's for compulsive/addictive eaters. Over only just started learning about it, but it s addressing all the really important stuff that sw etc never addresses.
Did the Paul McKenna thing a few years ago, and it was closer to the mark that diet stuff, but didn't get under my emotional eating.
Best of luck op x

Report
Flibbertyjibbit · 28/06/2017 16:31

I've been lurking on the bootcamp thread and it's taken me a few days to post here. Thanks for starting the thread oldbooks.

So I've had a tough few years with my health. Been on steroids for over 15 years now. Gained A LOT of weight. Had a successful year low-carbing about 4 years ago when I lost 5 stone, then my health detiorated which led to me being bed bound and gaining it all back again. I hit my highest weight earlier this year at over 20 stone!

I'm still on oramorph which is really sugary but it keeps my pain under control so I'm hoping I can continue low-carbing even if the oramorph ups my carb intake.

I am getting married next year and really want to feel like I have my eating under some kind of control alongside weight loss. I got into a bad cycle of rewarding myself with food then hating myself for eating cake, and then bingeing on all the bad stuff.

For me my success of not binging since I started bootcamp 33 days ago has been non-food rewards. A little treat at the end of each week - magazine, new book, manicure, new tshirt so far. It has really helped keep me going.

Thanks again for this thread Flowers

Report
BIWI · 28/06/2017 22:04

Flowers for all of you.

Facing the need to lose weight is tough enough. But when there are emotional issues, it's even harder. I take my hat off to all of you who are struggling.

I'm not really sure that the day-to-day chat threads are always sufficiently supportive (not that people don't want to help!) so this is a really good place to post.

Good luck to you all.

Report
Veryflummoxed · 29/06/2017 15:33

So behind on main thread that I've just got up to where you posted this link. I will be back to read the thread once I've caught up some more on the other one.

Report
OldBooks · 30/06/2017 21:38

Hello all, sorry have been quiet, have been feeling a bit low and finding myself in binge mentality. Today it seems AF is here again, as I have irregular cycles it can be hard to realise that my anxiety is worse due to PMT Hmm

I have been looking at quotes and ideas on Pinterest which I want to share.

General motivation:

  • The only place success comes before work is in the dictionary (said by Vidal Sassoon apparently)

  • You don't have to be good at it, you just have to do it!

  • Falling is only failing if you don't get back up

  • If the finish line is too far away, don't look at it. Look at your feet as they take the next step.

    Emotional eating:

    *Whatever the problem is, the answer is not in the fridge

  • If hunger is not the problem, eating is not the solution

  • When you eat because you feel sad or stressed, you are turning one problem into two

  • Food is not therapy

  • Eat to fill your stomach not your heart
OP posts:
Report
OldBooks · 30/06/2017 21:41

Some good questions to ask yourself when you want to eat

Defeating emotional eating
OP posts:
Report
OldBooks · 30/06/2017 21:44

Telling emotional hunger apart from real hunger. Remember physical hunger comes on gradually, you can ignore it and delay it, you feel it in your stomach. Anything you eat will satisfy it.

Emotional hunger comes on suddenly (usually after a trigger event). You need to eat urgently, but not just anything, usually only a specific food will do. The sensation of hunger is felt in the mind or as an "itch".

Defeating emotional eating
OP posts:
Report
OldBooks · 30/06/2017 21:55

Thank you for delurking to share your experiences paint. I would never think to contact a therapist who specialises in eating disorders as that phrase calls to mind the very very thin. There is an attitude that there is an implicit moral failing in being fat, some lack of control or ignorance. Whereas many overweight people are really suffering and projecting that suffering into their bodies.

Flibberty I like the idea of a weekly non food treat. C4 has written about her worries at using sugary oramorph, did you see that? The threads move so fast it is easy to miss things!

Yorkshire I am sorry you were not able to get on with bootcamp. Could you try a more relaxed version? It took me a few weeks to ease into it really, maybe start slower?

Will check out the other resources mentioned above and if I have the chance will try to summarise main points for everyone. I also have a half read book on emotional eating to finish which I will also summarise.

OP posts:
Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

FinallyHere · 03/07/2017 15:04

Thank you for starting this thread, Oldbooks. I identify with what everyone has posted here. LCHF bootcamp has been working well for me. I am however very well aware that I have been largely free of the type of stress that would usually have me go looking for the bottom of a large tub of ice creme.

One approach which has been helpful for me, has been Gillian Riley's www.eatingless.com. It's less about nutritional advice and more about how to make it a real and lasting part of your life with food. I am hoping that it might resonate with others on this thread.

It's obviously unrealistic to hope that I shall continue stress free for ever, but I feel that LCHF really works well for me and I see no reason to ever stop: the help I have found here on MN's bootcamp and others advocating the LCHF way of eating has been really helpful. It so encouraging when all the resources I rate come together and agree the same approach.

Anyone talking about low fat and calorie restriction looking at my mother, our GP and Slimming World I am finding really frustrating. No doubt different ways work for different people but...

Report
OldBooks · 03/07/2017 20:24

It's obviously unrealistic to hope that I shall continue stress free for ever, but I feel that LCHF really works well for me and I see no reason to ever stop

One thing I find reassuring about LCHF is that in extremis you can eat things that would be considered 'naughty' on almost any other woe, and therefore trick yourself into thinking you have indulged. Eating extra thick double cream with a spoon in front of the open fridge door was not my finest hour and of course will slow down loss, but it's better than eating lots of cake or biscuits and still has that comfort eating feel.

Thanks for the link, will check it out Smile

OP posts:
Report
OldBooks · 05/07/2017 07:34

Does anyone else undermine their NSVs? I had to tighten my bra today but have persuaded myself it has loosened in the wash, not that I have lost weight. Why do I fear success?

OP posts:
Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.