Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

KJK suing Australian Liberals for defamation

247 replies

fromorbit · 28/08/2023 10:51

UK women’s rights activist Kellie-Jay Keen has issued John Pesutto and his entire leadership team with defamation concerns notices
UK women’s rights activist Kellie-Jay Keen has issued John Pesutto’s entire Victorian Liberal leadership team with defamation concerns notices, giving them 28 days to apologise and pay compensation for making “grossly misconceived, wilfully vexatious, and wretchedly false” claims, or face federal court action.

In her legal letter sent to the Liberal leader, his deputy David Southwick, upper house leader Georgie Crozier and her deputy Matt Bach on Monday, Ms Keen claims their conduct has seen her become the target of “extreme hate, abuse, harassment, and stalking”, and culminated in her “being physically attacked” and “placed in life threatening danger” at a Let Women Speak rally in New Zealand.

Archive of full report from The Australian:
https://archive.is/lWNTN#selection-255.5-255.135

Brilliant move as it will really help Moira Deeming's case against her party. Also further reveals the crazy sexism going on in Australia.

NB Reminder Australian Liberals are actually politically somewhat like UK Tories.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
20
Helleofabore · 30/08/2023 14:12

So, in summary of the issues that the Liberal Party based their decision on is as follows: (starts at no. 7)

No. 7 - Gariepy
No. 8 - Video interview with Kay SOCO (I will await posters passing along information as to what Kay SOCO or what makes Soldiers of Christ Online deserving of representation in this list)
No. 9 - Hans Jørgen Lysglimt Johansen - no evidence that this was ever posted by KJK as declared in the dossier. She doesn't know him. This is a factual falsity in the dossier.
No. 10 - Barbie
No. 11 & 12 - Lisa Morgan who is making a comparison between the political movement of activism around gender identity ideology using Hitler's Mein Kampf. A comparison that does not make Lisa Morgan in any way a Nazi or a far right extremist.
No. 13-18 - deals with the Neo-Nazi group of men that infiltrated the Let Women Speak area that the Victorian Police were supposed to be making sure the women and all group were protected on the day. There is no evidence that they were in any way affiliated with KJK and the organisers and they have stated and I predict that KJK will state under oath that she had no idea who those men were.

It is also very clear that the bulk of this dossier is not based on credible or factual information.

BonfireLady · 30/08/2023 15:08

PorcelinaV · 30/08/2023 12:32

So, it was an Anti-Semitic joke she done, no question. Although I don’t think she realised or intended it to be anti-Semitic, she was caught up in the argument, fed up of being attacked

I wouldn't call something an "anti semitic joke" just because a Nazi uniform was involved.

Comedians can dress up as Nazis without it being in any way "anti semitic".

Presumably it's going to come down to balance of probability.
As she doesn't have a history of anti-Semitism (from what I understand), presumably the "associated with" isn't relevant here. On balance, I would hope that it would seem plausible for her to have used the image simply because she was smeared as "Nazi Barbie" owing to her blonde hair. Presumably the act of removing the swastika from the image shows that she did not agree with Nazi ideals (this is their logo, which represents the Nazi doctrine), so is also significant.

BillaBongGirl · 30/08/2023 16:04

Helleofabore · 30/08/2023 14:02

oh... thanks. I just spent over an hour delivering you information.

I will stop now. Thank you.

Hiya @Helleofabore we cross posted at same time there. I had a bit of an issue I had to tackle, but am back for a wee bit and will be catching up. Just want to say a quick thank you in advance as I see you’ve posted a lot of info in the interim.

BillaBongGirl · 30/08/2023 16:35

Norwegian Johansen neo nazi selfie

So that is an error in fact. Spartacus makes a good point though as in would that be enough to be defamation as I’m not sure it matters who posts a selfie? Perhaps it goes back to that link Spartacus had earlier..would it be “imputation” as in some sort of error that makes people think she’s best friends with this neo nazi and they went to the conference together?

what is imputation in the legal sense? Does anyone know? I’m a software nerd and this is what imputation means in my career field. So this is all confusing to me 😓

KJK suing Australian Liberals for defamation
Helleofabore · 30/08/2023 16:48

YetAnotherSpartacus · 30/08/2023 13:15

I'm not sure it will actually help to dissect the dossier or discuss what had been admitted to or explained or denied. I don't know much about defamation law but I think that other aspects such as intent and context come into it.

From listening to legal discussion about this, the case is highly likely to be limited to the dossier and the immediate interviews and published statements.

The statements in interviews and those released are contingent on the information presented in the dossier from what I can gather.

Pesutto is a lawyer. I would hope that the judge would hold him to a higher level of checking than a person with no political background and no legal training. He should have done due diligence on that poorly put together dossier before making any statements. It quickly became clear that he didn't.

As I said upthread, Moira is being represented by a legal team led by one of Australia's best defamation lawyers. Why do people think that KJK is not going to benefit from this, and we don't know yet who is representing her do we? Have I missed that? It is likely that Moira's team will be working closely with KJK's. I doubt they would have taken these cases if they didn't believe they had strong cases.

BillaBongGirl · 30/08/2023 16:55

Argh I have a 5 o clock thing. Running off again.

Helleofabore · 30/08/2023 17:09

What may also be brought up, either in the case for Moira or noted in the media, is that those Neo-nazis have attended other protests, yet Pesutto seems to have not said that any of those organisers are associated with Neo-nazis or has he.

Yet, this one event, he has. And has even had a dossier created.

Why the uneven treatment?

Helleofabore · 30/08/2023 19:15

Transcript for Neil Mitchell 3AW interview with John Pesutto: - 20th March 2023:

www.3aw.com.au/liberals-move-to-expel-controversial-mp-over-neo-nazi-rally-links/

John Pesutto: states at 0.38 and it goes from there.

‘she has had associations, Neil, with organisations, er, organisers of Saturday’s protest who have known links with nazis, nazi sympathisers, far right extremists, white supremacists. And can I just make a couple of things…’

Neil Mitchell: ‘Just before you do, just before you do.., who are you referring to there?’

Pesutto:: ‘Kellie Jay Keen’.

Mitchell: ‘And she has had associations with, she has got associations with Nazis? Who?”

Pesutto:: Well, ok, so, um, John Francois Gariepy. She has done videos+ with Richard Spencer, Mark Collick, Ku Klux Klan leader David Duke. There is a long ….’

Mitchell: “Were they videos or interviews?”

Pesutto:: ‘Videos, interviews. She shared platforms with this person … can I offer you a different perspective of this person Neil. This person is not someone who comes to this with a clean skin. She has known associations with, uh, I really just want to be able to set a few things straight Neil.

Mitchell: She does say she will be interviewed, she is willing to be interviewed by anybody.

PESUTTO:: Ah… no…. that that that is not right. Ah.

Mitchell: Ok.

PESUTTO:: Her history of activism actually has taken her into league with people with views that I cannot accept as consistent with Victorian values. Can I just say a couple of things at the top Neil.

MITCHELL: yep

PESUTTO:: First of all, this is not about free speech. I am perfectly comfortable with people debating issues they feel passionately about. Even Moira. Absolutely, people can have that. I have always said debate must be reasonable, respectful, inclusive. You can do that even in a robust setting. The problem here is that Moira just didn’t turn up to this rally. She had helped organise and promote it with people who have known associations. It is not about free speech. It is about people whose values are not consistent with mine. Not consistent with the Liberal Party or Victoria’s values.

MITCHELL: Well, did you tell Moira not to go?

PESUTTO:: Ah. No! But I don’t expect any member of the liberal team to be associating with people who have long rap sheets.

MITCHELL: But why didn’t you tell her not to go. Why didn’t you say, this is wrong, don’t do it.

Pesutto: Well Neil, I don’t have a problem with people airing their views. And the neo nazis who turned up to the rally made it clear that they were there to support this as we later found out.* And we later found out that one of the organisers, Angie Jones, who did a video with Moira and two other people, including Kellie Jay Keen later on, on Saturday actually posted this Neil. And I quote the tweet: ‘Nazi and women want to get rid of paedo filfth. Why don’t you?’

MITCHELL: Oh that is garbage, that is garbage.

PESUTTO:: Is that acceptable in 2023?

MITCHELL: No, of course not.

PESUTTO:: Is that acceptable.

Mitchell: Of course not.

Pesutto: And that is what it is about.

Mitchell: But I get back to the point. Why didn’t you avoid all this and just tell her not to be part of it?

Pesutto: Well Neil, I have that expectation of all members, but

Mitchell: Did you know she was promoting, she even raised it in parliament last week?

Pesutto: I, yeah. I am aware of these values that she’s had. And then I said..

Mitchell: Yeah, but were you aware that she was promoting this rally in the parliament and on twitter, and intending to go? Were you aware of it.

Pesutto:. I was aware that she was active in this space.

Mitchell: Were you aware that she was going to this rally and promoting this rally.

Pesutto: Well, I wasn’t aware that she was going to go to a rally that nazi activists would turn up at which

Mitchell: But that is not her fault.

Pesutto: Well, well she is associated with … and as you say, when the neo-nazis turned up, did she leave?

Mitchell: Well actually you could ask Matthew (guy??) the same thing about the dinners he has been to. But it is a fair point. She should have left. Did she?

PESUTTO:: I just want to emphasis that .. sorry, I don’t understand her to have left.

Mitchell : She didn’t. OK Ok. I won’t leave this point about … she five or six days ago was telling the world that she was going, she was promoting the rally, why didn’t you sit her down and say ‘this is wrong. Don’t do it or else?’ Did you know? Did you know she was promoting it and raised it in parliament.

PESUTTO:: Neil, I know she is passionate about this..

MITCHELL: no. But did you know she raised it in parliament?

PESUTTO:: I didn’t know she had raised the rally in parliament. No.

MITCHELL: Were you aware that she was tweeting, urging people to go?

PESUTTO:: No. I didn’t see her tweets.

MITCHELL: Well, you could have avoided it all if you knew that.

PESUTTO:: Well, but never the less Neil, we are left with a situation that we you have a member of the liberal team associating with people with these associations. Know public associations with these, and I just can’t, can’t understand. I am a party, a leader of the party who wants to govern for all Victorians. And the values that I’m espousing, as Liberal leader, are not consistent with those Nazi activists. I know Moira is not a Nazi, but my point is that she is associating with people who are. +++

And that brings them into a place that is unacceptable for me as leader. And I believe unacceptable for the party.

MITCHELL: Well a member of the Greens who is Jewish went ahead and didn’t have any problems.

PESUTTO:: Well that is a matter for them. I think in terms of the overall issues of what nazis mean, and what white supremacism means it is odious. And I am not prepared as leader of the party, to abide by any of it.

MITCHELL: Alright.

PESUTTO:: We want to govern in four years.

Mitchell: So, you are saying Kellie Jay Keen is a sympathiser of Nazis, correct?

PESUTTO:: Yes.

MITCHELL: And others are there as well?

PESUTTO:: Well certainly her, Angie Jones who Moira posted on social media about after the rally on Friday. Posted what I said before, I won’t repeat it. So it is not as if any of this is in doubt. It is on the public record. They are not Moira’s posts, granted. But we have got a Liberal member having done that. And I just don’t think that its acceptable.

MITCHELL: Did, did she object to what you told her?

PESUTTO:: I won’t go into the details of the discussion. You can imagine how someone would react to the news that I’m going to bring this application. But I believe it is the right thing to do, Neil. Right, we have a government in Victoria which is corrupt, incompetent and clearly exhausted. I want to be able to present an alternative. And as alternative Premier I want to make it clear to Victorians that my values, that the values of the party that I lead, are not consistent with Kellie Jay Keen. Never will be. Not consistent with Thomas Sewell or the Nazis who turned up on the steps of Parliament. Never will be. I will fight hate speech like that whereever I see it. And the party wants to govern in 2026 and beyond because our state needs it.

MITCHELL: ok. Did you …

PESUTTO:: This is not going to help us get to that goal.

MITCHELL: Did you, do you accept that the organisers of this rally and Moira Deeming had no idea that the Nazis were turning up?

PESUTTO:: I am not in the position to say that I can accept that. Because I, and the reason I say that is, I am not saying that Moira necessarily knew. Is that these people have known association with Nazi sympathisers and white supremacists, given their history. And Thomas Sewell, posted on social media that they were there to support that rally. So my point is, I am not saying Moira necessarily knew that, but I find it hard to believe that the other organisers didn’t.

MITCHELL: Ok um. It says something about your pre-selection processes, doesn’t it, that Moira Deeming got pre-selection.

PESUTTO:: Look Neil, as talented as I think I am, I cannot change the past. I can only assure all of our listeners of a couple of things. I do support free speech, but I believe this, this position that I am taking is consistent with that.

MITCHELL: OK.

PESUTTO:: I can’t support, and never will, hate speech. As for pre-selection processes, I am committed to making sure the party has better processes in place going forward. But again, free speech is an important part of what the Liberal party advocate. But hate speech is not, and never will be.

MITCHELL: Under your leadership, would you hope to avoid the ah pre-selection of the Moira Deeming?

PESUTTO:: Well again, I just want to indicate people are entitled to have a broad range of views across any political organisation. That is going to happen. I don’t have any objection to that at all. I have an objection, and will act, where anybody’s activities take them to an association with either right wing extremists or left wing extremists. Either way, it is not what Victoria is about and it is not the Victoria I want to lead.

MITCHELL: Do you want to her out of the party?

PESUTTO:: I think it is consistent with the position that I am taking. The party will need to consider what it does if the motion gets up. I expect it will, but the party and the members will need to make a decision about that. And I really need to be careful of the processes, they are for the party to decide. I think they will see, they’ll see obvious conclusions if the motion succeeds.

MITCHELL: When’s the parliamentary party meeting?

PESUTTO:: I have to give a period of notice. I would expect that that will be very early next week.

MITCHELL: It will look a bit silly if you don’t win it, won’t it?

PESUTTO:: Well, I can only do what is right Neil. I think this is the right thing to do.

The interview moves onto nazi salute banning.

Then comes back

MITCHELL: By the way, Angie Jones who we have spoken to, she says that tweet you refer to is taken right out of context and she had a history with the person tweeting it.

PESUTTO:: mmm… do .. Do you buy that?

MITCHELL: I don’t know. I’ll speak to her.

PESUTTO:: Well you know, please do. But it .. I can’t interpret it any other way.

Note that is KJK he is saying has done these videos!

+this is also false
+++ do you see it yet?

Helleofabore · 30/08/2023 19:15

This is interesting in regards to this dossier I suspect.

”I don't think it's open to me to be satisfied that Moira didn't know about their history," he told reporters on Monday.

”It took us all of about 20 minutes or so after the rally on Saturday to investigate the histories of these people.”

https://www.illawarramercury.com.au/story/8127050/vic-lib-leader-satisfied-mp-knew-rallys-nazi-links/

So, it was a very hasty put together document that he didn’t think to check… great lawyer and political leader that he wishes us to believe he is.

Then there is this arising from this dossier:

Pesutto told ABC radio that “Deeming not only attended this protest on the steps of Parliament, but was actively involved in different ways in the organisation and promotion of this protest at which there were speakers with known links to neo-Nazis.”

https://www.jurist.org/news/2023/03/victoria-mp-could-face-party-expulsion-over-attendance-at-neo-nazi-rally-amid-pending-state-ban-on-nazi-symbols/

This is the link to the ABC interview.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-03-19/victorian-liberals-move-to-expel-mp-who-attended-rally/102117788?utm_campaign=abc_news_web&utm_content=link&utm_medium=content_shared&utm_source=abc_news_web

At around the 3 minute mark he says this:

“Moira Deeming not only attended this protest on the steps of parliament, but was actively involved in different ways in the organisation and promotion of this protest at which there were speakers with known links to neo-Nazis,”

”I won't have any of it.”

”These values that we saw on the steps of parliament were not consistent with the values I and the Liberal Party stand for.”

”What I'm doing is a statement that we will not tolerate or ever accept any association with neo-Nazis and white supremacists or anybody who sympathises with them.”

And then

”We're very open to this. We'll work constructively with the government, as we have in the past, as with the banning of the swastika,"

”We support free speech but every sensible and reasonable person must know there are limits on free speech.”

”People who engage in actions and gestures which inspire hate and violence will never be acceptable in our state.”

Australia state MP could face party expulsion over attendance at anti-trans rally amid pending Victoria ban on Nazi symbols

John Pesutto, leader of the Liberal Party in the Australian state of Victoria, said Monday that MP Moira Deeming's presence at an anti-trans rally with neo-Nazi ties on Saturday is grounds for expulsi...

https://www.jurist.org/news/2023/03/victoria-mp-could-face-party-expulsion-over-attendance-at-neo-nazi-rally-amid-pending-state-ban-on-nazi-symbols/

Helleofabore · 30/08/2023 19:16

I am done right now.

Helleofabore · 30/08/2023 19:31

Helleofabore · 30/08/2023 19:15

Transcript for Neil Mitchell 3AW interview with John Pesutto: - 20th March 2023:

www.3aw.com.au/liberals-move-to-expel-controversial-mp-over-neo-nazi-rally-links/

John Pesutto: states at 0.38 and it goes from there.

‘she has had associations, Neil, with organisations, er, organisers of Saturday’s protest who have known links with nazis, nazi sympathisers, far right extremists, white supremacists. And can I just make a couple of things…’

Neil Mitchell: ‘Just before you do, just before you do.., who are you referring to there?’

Pesutto:: ‘Kellie Jay Keen’.

Mitchell: ‘And she has had associations with, she has got associations with Nazis? Who?”

Pesutto:: Well, ok, so, um, John Francois Gariepy. She has done videos+ with Richard Spencer, Mark Collick, Ku Klux Klan leader David Duke. There is a long ….’

Mitchell: “Were they videos or interviews?”

Pesutto:: ‘Videos, interviews. She shared platforms with this person … can I offer you a different perspective of this person Neil. This person is not someone who comes to this with a clean skin. She has known associations with, uh, I really just want to be able to set a few things straight Neil.

Mitchell: She does say she will be interviewed, she is willing to be interviewed by anybody.

PESUTTO:: Ah… no…. that that that is not right. Ah.

Mitchell: Ok.

PESUTTO:: Her history of activism actually has taken her into league with people with views that I cannot accept as consistent with Victorian values. Can I just say a couple of things at the top Neil.

MITCHELL: yep

PESUTTO:: First of all, this is not about free speech. I am perfectly comfortable with people debating issues they feel passionately about. Even Moira. Absolutely, people can have that. I have always said debate must be reasonable, respectful, inclusive. You can do that even in a robust setting. The problem here is that Moira just didn’t turn up to this rally. She had helped organise and promote it with people who have known associations. It is not about free speech. It is about people whose values are not consistent with mine. Not consistent with the Liberal Party or Victoria’s values.

MITCHELL: Well, did you tell Moira not to go?

PESUTTO:: Ah. No! But I don’t expect any member of the liberal team to be associating with people who have long rap sheets.

MITCHELL: But why didn’t you tell her not to go. Why didn’t you say, this is wrong, don’t do it.

Pesutto: Well Neil, I don’t have a problem with people airing their views. And the neo nazis who turned up to the rally made it clear that they were there to support this as we later found out.* And we later found out that one of the organisers, Angie Jones, who did a video with Moira and two other people, including Kellie Jay Keen later on, on Saturday actually posted this Neil. And I quote the tweet: ‘Nazi and women want to get rid of paedo filfth. Why don’t you?’

MITCHELL: Oh that is garbage, that is garbage.

PESUTTO:: Is that acceptable in 2023?

MITCHELL: No, of course not.

PESUTTO:: Is that acceptable.

Mitchell: Of course not.

Pesutto: And that is what it is about.

Mitchell: But I get back to the point. Why didn’t you avoid all this and just tell her not to be part of it?

Pesutto: Well Neil, I have that expectation of all members, but

Mitchell: Did you know she was promoting, she even raised it in parliament last week?

Pesutto: I, yeah. I am aware of these values that she’s had. And then I said..

Mitchell: Yeah, but were you aware that she was promoting this rally in the parliament and on twitter, and intending to go? Were you aware of it.

Pesutto:. I was aware that she was active in this space.

Mitchell: Were you aware that she was going to this rally and promoting this rally.

Pesutto: Well, I wasn’t aware that she was going to go to a rally that nazi activists would turn up at which

Mitchell: But that is not her fault.

Pesutto: Well, well she is associated with … and as you say, when the neo-nazis turned up, did she leave?

Mitchell: Well actually you could ask Matthew (guy??) the same thing about the dinners he has been to. But it is a fair point. She should have left. Did she?

PESUTTO:: I just want to emphasis that .. sorry, I don’t understand her to have left.

Mitchell : She didn’t. OK Ok. I won’t leave this point about … she five or six days ago was telling the world that she was going, she was promoting the rally, why didn’t you sit her down and say ‘this is wrong. Don’t do it or else?’ Did you know? Did you know she was promoting it and raised it in parliament.

PESUTTO:: Neil, I know she is passionate about this..

MITCHELL: no. But did you know she raised it in parliament?

PESUTTO:: I didn’t know she had raised the rally in parliament. No.

MITCHELL: Were you aware that she was tweeting, urging people to go?

PESUTTO:: No. I didn’t see her tweets.

MITCHELL: Well, you could have avoided it all if you knew that.

PESUTTO:: Well, but never the less Neil, we are left with a situation that we you have a member of the liberal team associating with people with these associations. Know public associations with these, and I just can’t, can’t understand. I am a party, a leader of the party who wants to govern for all Victorians. And the values that I’m espousing, as Liberal leader, are not consistent with those Nazi activists. I know Moira is not a Nazi, but my point is that she is associating with people who are. +++

And that brings them into a place that is unacceptable for me as leader. And I believe unacceptable for the party.

MITCHELL: Well a member of the Greens who is Jewish went ahead and didn’t have any problems.

PESUTTO:: Well that is a matter for them. I think in terms of the overall issues of what nazis mean, and what white supremacism means it is odious. And I am not prepared as leader of the party, to abide by any of it.

MITCHELL: Alright.

PESUTTO:: We want to govern in four years.

Mitchell: So, you are saying Kellie Jay Keen is a sympathiser of Nazis, correct?

PESUTTO:: Yes.

MITCHELL: And others are there as well?

PESUTTO:: Well certainly her, Angie Jones who Moira posted on social media about after the rally on Friday. Posted what I said before, I won’t repeat it. So it is not as if any of this is in doubt. It is on the public record. They are not Moira’s posts, granted. But we have got a Liberal member having done that. And I just don’t think that its acceptable.

MITCHELL: Did, did she object to what you told her?

PESUTTO:: I won’t go into the details of the discussion. You can imagine how someone would react to the news that I’m going to bring this application. But I believe it is the right thing to do, Neil. Right, we have a government in Victoria which is corrupt, incompetent and clearly exhausted. I want to be able to present an alternative. And as alternative Premier I want to make it clear to Victorians that my values, that the values of the party that I lead, are not consistent with Kellie Jay Keen. Never will be. Not consistent with Thomas Sewell or the Nazis who turned up on the steps of Parliament. Never will be. I will fight hate speech like that whereever I see it. And the party wants to govern in 2026 and beyond because our state needs it.

MITCHELL: ok. Did you …

PESUTTO:: This is not going to help us get to that goal.

MITCHELL: Did you, do you accept that the organisers of this rally and Moira Deeming had no idea that the Nazis were turning up?

PESUTTO:: I am not in the position to say that I can accept that. Because I, and the reason I say that is, I am not saying that Moira necessarily knew. Is that these people have known association with Nazi sympathisers and white supremacists, given their history. And Thomas Sewell, posted on social media that they were there to support that rally. So my point is, I am not saying Moira necessarily knew that, but I find it hard to believe that the other organisers didn’t.

MITCHELL: Ok um. It says something about your pre-selection processes, doesn’t it, that Moira Deeming got pre-selection.

PESUTTO:: Look Neil, as talented as I think I am, I cannot change the past. I can only assure all of our listeners of a couple of things. I do support free speech, but I believe this, this position that I am taking is consistent with that.

MITCHELL: OK.

PESUTTO:: I can’t support, and never will, hate speech. As for pre-selection processes, I am committed to making sure the party has better processes in place going forward. But again, free speech is an important part of what the Liberal party advocate. But hate speech is not, and never will be.

MITCHELL: Under your leadership, would you hope to avoid the ah pre-selection of the Moira Deeming?

PESUTTO:: Well again, I just want to indicate people are entitled to have a broad range of views across any political organisation. That is going to happen. I don’t have any objection to that at all. I have an objection, and will act, where anybody’s activities take them to an association with either right wing extremists or left wing extremists. Either way, it is not what Victoria is about and it is not the Victoria I want to lead.

MITCHELL: Do you want to her out of the party?

PESUTTO:: I think it is consistent with the position that I am taking. The party will need to consider what it does if the motion gets up. I expect it will, but the party and the members will need to make a decision about that. And I really need to be careful of the processes, they are for the party to decide. I think they will see, they’ll see obvious conclusions if the motion succeeds.

MITCHELL: When’s the parliamentary party meeting?

PESUTTO:: I have to give a period of notice. I would expect that that will be very early next week.

MITCHELL: It will look a bit silly if you don’t win it, won’t it?

PESUTTO:: Well, I can only do what is right Neil. I think this is the right thing to do.

The interview moves onto nazi salute banning.

Then comes back

MITCHELL: By the way, Angie Jones who we have spoken to, she says that tweet you refer to is taken right out of context and she had a history with the person tweeting it.

PESUTTO:: mmm… do .. Do you buy that?

MITCHELL: I don’t know. I’ll speak to her.

PESUTTO:: Well you know, please do. But it .. I can’t interpret it any other way.

Note that is KJK he is saying has done these videos!

+this is also false
+++ do you see it yet?

This interview has factual errors throughout. All based on that ‘dossier’ which he skited took just 20 minutes to create.

Here he states that KJK is a Nazi activist at +++ in the transcript.

BoreOfWhabylon · 30/08/2023 20:02

Thanks for the transcript @Helleofabore. Hard to see how he can row back from that.

I used to quite like Neil Mitchell, back in the 90s when I lived in Melbourne and listened to 3AW. Is he a big cheese with the station still? Wish he'd invite KJK on.

Looks like she's got a few more people in her sights too
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=LzVuHioGzfk

What good do lies do? #pesutto #liberalparty #LWS #BeTheBillboard #LetWomenSpeak

This is the original #AdultHumanFemale channel and home of Kellie-Jay Keen aka Posie Parker.If you would like to donate to help support us, click here ⇨ http...

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=LzVuHioGzfk

SidewaysOtter · 30/08/2023 20:59

Bloody good for her. Hope she wins.

Helleofabore · 30/08/2023 21:27

BoreOfWhabylon · 30/08/2023 20:02

Thanks for the transcript @Helleofabore. Hard to see how he can row back from that.

I used to quite like Neil Mitchell, back in the 90s when I lived in Melbourne and listened to 3AW. Is he a big cheese with the station still? Wish he'd invite KJK on.

Looks like she's got a few more people in her sights too
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=LzVuHioGzfk

I have never heard of Neil Mitchell but I must admit thinking as I typed this transcript this afternoon that he sounded rather like a misogynist as he kept saying ‘why did you let her’. But that might be just because I heard it so many times and not a true indication of his opinions.

He did attempt to check if Pesutto really meant to make the allegations against KJK and Angie. And at the end he alerted Pesutto to Angie stating that Pesutto had completely removed the context of her tweet and had then misrepresented it. That was a signal to Pesutto that maybe, just maybe he was talking bollocks.

ChokkaQuokka · 30/08/2023 22:23

Reading The Age this morning (main Melbourne broadsheet, mostly left of centre in line with educated élite readership), I noticed this quote in the story.

During the process, one party room motion against Deeming claimed Keen-Minshull had “publicly associated with far right-wing extremist groups including neo-Nazis activists”.

Keen-Minshull has denied this and claimed it was defamatory. The Age does not suggest she or Deeming are associated with neo-Nazis.

Translation: KJK has Pesutto over a barrel.
https://www.theage.com.au/politics/victoria/angry-liberals-to-thrash-out-leadership-team-s-defamation-demand-20230830-p5e0lj.html

‘Rebels without a cause’: State Liberals split over legal costs to defend Pesutto

New legal threats against senior state Liberals by a British anti-trans rights activist have reopened bitter divisions in the Victorian party, as MPs manoeuvre to oppose legal indemnity for the party leadership.

https://www.theage.com.au/politics/victoria/angry-liberals-to-thrash-out-leadership-team-s-defamation-demand-20230830-p5e0lj.html

Abhannmor · 30/08/2023 22:40

A Barbie doll in a German uniform is not an Antisemitic joke @BillaBongGirl . To make it into one you're going to need a lot of context. Whereas all you have is KJ flipping the bird at some scumbags who called her a Nazi.

This kind of stretch would get you into the Fantastic Four.

Helleofabore · 30/08/2023 22:46

chokka

I too noticed the Age’s The Age does not suggest she or Deeming are associated with neo-Nazis.

That is some interesting tap dancing.

Helleofabore · 30/08/2023 22:52

So, anyone got any info on Kay SOCO and why that interview was included in the dossier?

ChokkaQuokka · 30/08/2023 22:58

Helleofabore · 30/08/2023 22:52

So, anyone got any info on Kay SOCO and why that interview was included in the dossier?

No info, but the kind of intern who would have thought the rest of the dossier was acceptable discourse presumably thinks that right wing Christianity is beyond the pale and effectively Nazism.

BillaBongGirl · 30/08/2023 23:11

Abhannmor · 30/08/2023 22:40

A Barbie doll in a German uniform is not an Antisemitic joke @BillaBongGirl . To make it into one you're going to need a lot of context. Whereas all you have is KJ flipping the bird at some scumbags who called her a Nazi.

This kind of stretch would get you into the Fantastic Four.

The Barbie is in a Nazi SS uniform. They’ve sourced the image and KJK has via her lawyers publicly admitted to using it as her profile picture.

“The concerns notice also addresses a reference to Ms Keen’s use on the social media platform Spinster of a profile picture featuring a Barbie doll wearing a Nazi uniform.

“Our client instructs us that the profile picture was used on her Spinster account as an ‘in house’ ‘tongue-in-cheek’ retort to a group of left-wing feminists who publicly called our client ‘Nazi Barbie’ in debate on the social media platform,” the lawyers state.

There was also in the dossier a post she allegedly did under that profile featuring the comment “pridestapo” and the image of a Nazi eagle and Swastika super-imposed on the transflag. I’ve not seen any comment on how credible that is yet though.

Helleofabore · 30/08/2023 23:12

ChokkaQuokka · 30/08/2023 22:58

No info, but the kind of intern who would have thought the rest of the dossier was acceptable discourse presumably thinks that right wing Christianity is beyond the pale and effectively Nazism.

That has potential as a reason chokka. I also think the read it in the article (and that author probably lifted it from Wikipedia) and no one has checked who the fuck Kay at SOCO was, what the interview was about or anything. At this point, I really suspect that they just assumed this group was a hate group because someone put it down on Wikipedia as being ‘far right because they are a Christian group’ so must by ‘far right’. And nobody checked.

I must say that would surprise me though about the Libs. But maybe that is the factional difference between the Sydney Libs and the Melbourne Libs???

ChokkaQuokka · 30/08/2023 23:16

@Helleofabore
Im not connected to the liberal party (obvs!) but I think the hard right faction is smaller there, similar to Victoria being more lefty than NSW more generally.

also posting to say I’m dying to see what Chip Le Grand (the very senior journo who has been running the gender identity stories lately, including the one on the Lesbian Action Group) writes about KJK’s case.

BillaBongGirl · 30/08/2023 23:25

So it is the publicly known to associate with neo Nazis specifically that KJK is going after as defamation then? Great detective work everyone.

Not great news that Pesutto is a lawyer as I’d expect he chose his words knowing the legal parameters and wiggly weasel room for them.

BoreOfWhabylon · 30/08/2023 23:30

Thanks for The Age link Quokka. I notice they are very careful to state several times that the nazis "gatecrashed" KJK's event

Swipe left for the next trending thread