Roisin Murphy

[WarriorN]

Is it true? Did did say this?

"Puberty blockers ARE FUCKED! Big pharma laughing all the way to the bank!"

older GC women saying they are fans of Roisin's music are obviously only pretending, jumping on a bandwagon.

Like most singles, this was only available for a short while.

I don't believe most of these people truly think Roisin is a transphobe. As this is a highly misogynistic movement, they probably think she is a silly middle aged woman who has listened to the wrong people and needs to be educated.

However, there are two things going on here, the desire to come down harder on doubters than unrepentant unbelievers "pour encourager les autres", and the potential for many people involved to boost their own profiles by attention seeking and virtue signalling.

I agree. I also think they are doubling-down because they can see the tide turning on puberty blockers, at least in Europe.

This is a good point, too.

@PaperWalkAndTalk , @Pudmyboy , @RealityFan

What we're observing are all hallmarks of ideologically-motivated activity - and never let a search for truth get in the way of a good witch-burning !

Another tell-tale is projection : they talk accusingly of cess-pools and vitriol, whilst empowering what can be seen on Twitter. One thing was a gif of a woman, in her underwear, tied up with with a flour-sack over her head, being drawn along in a tumbril...

It’s absolutely a message to stop other women speaking up.

Musicians regularly say (and do) worse and get shrugs. This is a warning.

Actually this is true. On some other spaces I've posted very considerate and polite push-backs on trans issues and the comments have been removed, whilst the hate-filled comments stood.

TRAs want to promote a narrative of victimisation and want all hate-filled comments to be seen as "evidence" of hatred whilst removing all sensible comments.

Wonder if X owner fanices starting a record label

@VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia

So was this, CD 2. . I once spotted Things To Make And Do on a cassette - not someone's mixtape, an official Echo release, at the time. Took a look on ebay and there's some there. When the batteries start going flat in your personal stereo, you get Maurice's album, for free ! 🤓

I have a thread running where I, seemingly counter intuitively, claim that 2023 is a watershed year for our collective PoV, despite what is a radicalising and ramping up in rhetoric and fervour.

Despite feeling nothing but anger and contempt for the record label's treatment of Roisin and SJB being let off misogynist hate speech in public, I do believe these two events are consistent with the litany of craziness we've had this year in particular.

If I'm right (don't put any money on it), the move to sanity is happening. And this move is predicated on sunlight shining thru more and more, both exposing the craziness, and causing it to burn or react.

Because in years to come, we'll look at the public burning/drowning/lynching of Roisin in 2023 as the start of the tail end of a movement where bullying in plain sight with tacit approval was permitted.

In any civil war, there are awful casualties even when the just side is starting to win. I think Roisin will be in this category.

'If I'm right (don't put any money on it), the move to sanity is happening'

I have a gut feeling that you are right, but no I'm not at the betting stage either! Not yet....

I've been listening to Louise Distras all morning on Spotify

I do feel the tide is turning, but that might just be because I’ve turned in the last year, and as everyone says, once you’ve seen it you can’t stop seeing it.

And there’s no turning back from the GC side, there are no persuasive or logical arguments for gender ideology once you’re aware of all the damage to vulnerable complicated children, and all the women’s rights-trampling in sports and single-sex spaces. It’s impossible to go back to the nonchalant shrug, to #BeKind and #NoDebate.

Roisin is a pyrrhic victory for TRAs. Unlike JKR or Glinner, she has been cancelled over a single FB message, which is exclusively about PBs.

@RealityFan

I'm not a religious person but I recall singing this at school. Roisin hasn't oppressed anyone or even endorsed oppression, quite the contrary - she has merely expressed concerns in private about unintended harm.

By contrast, we have people seeking to do actual harm to her, utterly undermining the idea that they are qualified to lecture the rest of us about virtue and we have no right of reply. This one goes out to them.

I hear you Vito!

<scrabbles around for things to make an do>

she has merely expressed concerns in private about unintended harm

All the more reason to crush her dissent. Most of the work raising awareness about the harms of puberty blockers, rapists in women's prisons, etc is done by talking to people quietly, not by making public statements. The point of this attack on Róisín is to make all GC people scared to even talk in private and so cut off our most very effective way of getting our message out.

As a tactic, it reminds me of how the Hitler Youth were encouraged to inform on their own families. Again, for the same reason: to prevent dissenters from influencing others.

More support here
https://www.spiked-online.com/2023/09/01/the-never-ending-persecution-of-roisin-murphy/

I wondered about this earlier; she didn't even say anything about transwomen not being women.

She made a point about a drug that isn't even licensed for that purpose in children!!

It's actually quite bonkers if you think about it.

Presumably it's insinuated because she said don't call me a terf and there's an image of Glinner's chin on the screenshot.

But she didn't say anything that needs protecting legally.

Thankfully, it does look like the demographics of the comments are beginning to better reflect the demographics of the actual audience.

Ther have been certain groups who have sought to make things all about them, in order to strengthen their bargaining position - basically, monopolise.

And you can see what they think of the rest of that audience, when some of us show our faces. We're told she's theirs, to do with as they see fit.

It's probably not for everyone cos algorithms but #IStandWithRóisínMurphy is trending a little

.

Nice - time to plaster her public FB page with

And respond to every cancelly-type post with