I think we already know what your internal dialogue is like by now. This post is another beauty, a real gem.
And it is full of misinformation too.
You have ignored the fact that even the Tavistock admitted there was NO studies that showed that hormonal treatments for children improved their life over non-medical treatments. Independent agencies have reviewed all the studies and released comment that there is none.
I am laughing too at your indignation that yes…. The studies have got poor methodology and weak conclusions. Didn’t you once proudly present us the Branstrom & Pachankis study as evidence? While never acknowledging that they retracted their conclusions because they had to admit that their conclusions were false? If that wasn’t you, I apologise.
Either way, you make claims constantly about the success of your treatment. You have previously admitted you know little about the current female teen cohort or you just won’t acknowledge that the current female cohort of children and teens are nothing like YOU. In fact reading your posts, you seem to lack any real perspective on what a normal and healthy childhood and teen life should be.
Your entire world is about you.
If I found out someone with your attitudes was in any position of direct influence such as mentoring or advising to my teen, I would be removing my teen. Not because of your trans status, but because of the attitude you have display over the years on MN. That you pride yourself as a listener isn’t surprising. It seems to fit the profile you wish to present. But you have shown here that you are only about you.
It also incenses you that due to this current female youth transitioner cohort might change the treatment paths for males too. YOU treat this cohort group with such contempt by ignoring their needs. I remember, you dismissing their needs because it might make it harder for males.
Yet, even YOU admit your ‘success’ may be due to PAIS. Yet YOU want all children, who most likely don’t have any differences of sex development to have treatments that may or may not have been more successful due to your ‘sluggish puberty’.
What is clear in every one of your posts is that you are so deeply entrenched in validating your own medical treatment that you seem incapable of acknowledging you are not the representative of the cohort of current transitioners at all.
Of course, I also think you have attributed some things that others have said that I haven’t on that list, but hey ho. It doesn’t matter. Considering your adherence to the falsehood that we believe in biological essentialism, more falsity isn’t much of an issue really is it?
I also think by now that anyone reading this thread probably has picked up much about your personality or psychology. You are incensed that women have told you that generally women can pick up male cues when someone sees a person in real life or through extended written communication, aren’t you? The women who love you have supported your belief that women can’t tell. I suspect other women who would have admitted otherwise can sense your true self and will simply continue that lie. Maybe you are a miracle and do pass completely until someone has to interact with you and you show your true nature.
You are also incensed that reality in no way supports your inpenetrable prose that you seem to have made up to magically allow you to claim any part of being female. You absolutely hate material reality it seems and I understand you are hugely offended when we laugh at all your carefully constructed prose. Those paragraphs you feel are wonderfully intelligent and clever. Yet, even the very basic foundation of all you wrote was false.
Feminists who reject that you should be treated as a female in matters when sex should be prioritised are not biological essentialists. Even though that is a misunderstanding you seem to have built your entire argument with feminists on.
And No one denies your existence, you are here and we are interacting with you.
Those two points- the mistaken attribution of bioessentialism and the hyperbolic claim we don’t want trans people to exist- are common falsehoods directly from twitter. And the repetition of these false points never makes them true anymore than the first time they were posited.
What you have shown on this thread is that your world is so carefully constructed and curated on such falsehoods. Whether it is your inability to understand the current female children and teens, or your magic prose written to allow you access to being a woman, or your inability to comprehend that you have no evidence that the medical treatments you advocate for are anything but experimental still. (making you an extreme activist) After all this time. You are making claim after claim based on falsity.
We are telling you so. Then your reaction is to dismiss our opinions in your very misogynistic way, while lying to yourself that we are just biological essentialists so we are easy to dismiss and vilify.
You have strawmanned your way through pages on this thread. It has been incredible to see.
But this post from you is just another peek into a mind that cannot simply comprehend that you are wrong. I think I have several reasons why you have that inability that I won’t share. They would be deleted. I doubt I am alone in deducing those reasons though, as your posts clearly show your disconnected thinking on numerous issues.