Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

'Trans Day of Vengeance' protest continues as planned following Nashville shooting

178 replies

IwantToRetire · 30/03/2023 01:06

Critics are questioning a transgender activist group's upcoming "Trans Day of Vengeance" protest, which is expected to go on as planned despite coming just days after a trans person walked into a Tennessee Christian school and killed six people, including three children.

Despite pushback, including Twitter removing social media posts promoting the event, it appears the "Trans Day of Vengeance" event is still slated for Saturday morning in front of the Supreme Court in Washington, D.C.

The event is being organized by the Trans Radical Activist Network (TRAN), which informed The National Desk (TND) it would not comment beyond a press release shared by the organization on its website.

https://abcnews4.com/news/nation-world/trans-day-of-vengeance-protest-continues-as-planned-following-nashville-shooting-trans-radical-activist-network-the-covenant-school

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
SquidwardBound · 31/03/2023 08:07

postop · 31/03/2023 08:02

Wouldn't it have been less tone deaf if they had just said something along the lines that it would be sensitive to consider the bereaved families and therefore appropriate to cancel their "day of vengeance"?

I‘m not sure that the activists who are at the forefront of this stuff are able to read the tone of anything.

They jump straight to claiming the position of victim, however incoherent that is.

And remember that this is the public stuff. Imagine what they were actually saying and suggesting before deciding to publicly go with ‘day of vengeance’. Terrifying.

MissPollysFitDolly · 31/03/2023 11:51

Thanks for the response SpicyMoth.

Like Florissante I prefer to stick to sex based definitions (what are the rules around here, I thought we weren't allowed to call named transwomen 'he'?).

It's possible to communicate with trans people without having to pretend they're a different sex and without mentioning that point even once let alone over and over. Anyway since most of them don't have dysphoria they should be robust enough to accept not everyone will play along.

nilsmousehammer · 31/03/2023 11:57

I thought I saw a thread earlier but now can't find it, saying that this event has been cancelled on the grounds of the organisers feeling that calling for a day of vengeance and violence might lead to someone getting hurt.

Later today they will be announcing that water is wet.

Kerfuffler · 31/03/2023 11:59

Page 6 of this thread @nilsmousehammer

nilsmousehammer · 31/03/2023 12:35

Thank you.

SpicyMoth · 31/03/2023 17:32

Steradent · 31/03/2023 07:02

Obvious disability is a really good explanation, just as an aside. Telling someone who is genuinely ill that they aren't is damaging as telling someone they are the opposite sex when they are not.

I would suggest that having an Invisible disability is the polar opposite of Trans yet both suffer. Trans suffers from misplaced kindness that isn't deserved for what is rooted in a basically cruel, selfish, lying and narcissistic behaviour. The person with an invisible disability suffers the behaviour that a narcissistic person puts out into the world, cruelty, lied, no help or kindness. They each get the opposite of what they deserve given to them by others.

The gaslighting that happens to someone with an Invisible illness is really damaging to them.

To be then gaslighted by someone inventing something on top of being gaslighted that you aren't ill when you are, is infuriating to the Invisible disabled, who get the least sympathy going, not that they request it, it's just a tough life.

If someone is low energy from say Hashimotos, you can see that they are low energy, some may confused it with laziness, some with hasimotos may happen to be lazy. Someone else can't tell without blood tests and ability to read the blood tests.

This is why I think those with Invisible conditions fall for trans, as they wonder if there are some tests that haven't been invented yet to explain what's going on. I noted that they are abusing really vulnerable people and those are the groups they infiltrated first. They stole empathy that should have gone to sick people and stole empathy from sick people who have so few resources and I am sure not everyone claiming these illness in these 'communities' has them, which makes those with Invisible conditions look like charlatans and those who are sick not access the services and support they could because it's been colonised by fakes.

I fully see what you mean!
I have diagnosed Borderline Personality Disorder and so just as one example I cry literally every day. I cannot remember a day where I didn't cry at least once - but I'm written off a lot as just dramatic or oversensitive or hormonal etc and it's very draining having to explain to people unfamiliar with it, because no one really truly understands what it's like to go through such intense emotional dysregulation. They think you can "Just calm down" or "Just stop crying".
Jobs have been especially difficult over the years.

SquidwardBound · 31/03/2023 17:38

nilsmousehammer · 31/03/2023 11:57

I thought I saw a thread earlier but now can't find it, saying that this event has been cancelled on the grounds of the organisers feeling that calling for a day of vengeance and violence might lead to someone getting hurt.

Later today they will be announcing that water is wet.

Except that they have of course missed the point. They have failed to recognise that by holding a day of vengeance they are the aggressors and they’re encouraging protestors to hurt people.

nepeta · 31/03/2023 18:10

postop · 31/03/2023 08:02

Wouldn't it have been less tone deaf if they had just said something along the lines that it would be sensitive to consider the bereaved families and therefore appropriate to cancel their "day of vengeance"?

Yes, of course it would have. But the 'be kind' demands all go only in one direction when it comes to this issue.

I have begun to look for empathy in the messages from the online trans activists towards anyone outside their group and have yet to see it. Indeed, the absence of empathy directed at suffering outsiders (of any type, say, women and girls in Afghanistan or victims of a natural disaster) is glaringly obvious once you spot it in that movement.

And I find this troubling, as I'm not sure how to communicate about compromises, for instance, with a group which doesn't seem to see anyone else as ever suffering at all.

nilsmousehammer · 31/03/2023 19:19

SquidwardBound · 31/03/2023 17:38

Except that they have of course missed the point. They have failed to recognise that by holding a day of vengeance they are the aggressors and they’re encouraging protestors to hurt people.

Well it was fairly obvious that the only risk to life and limb cared about was TQ+ political supporters. The double standards a la abusive personalities is always front and centre.

But it is a relief that they may have realised to risk inciting a mob where many members are likely to be vulnerable and unstable, who may be carrying and waving guns if the tweets are anything to go by, is a really bloody stupid idea in a country where the police carry guns and are trained to shoot first if they perceive a risk. Yes that would be a very major risk to the type of humans this mob claim to have the capacity to care about.

nilsmousehammer · 31/03/2023 19:27

nepeta · 31/03/2023 18:10

Yes, of course it would have. But the 'be kind' demands all go only in one direction when it comes to this issue.

I have begun to look for empathy in the messages from the online trans activists towards anyone outside their group and have yet to see it. Indeed, the absence of empathy directed at suffering outsiders (of any type, say, women and girls in Afghanistan or victims of a natural disaster) is glaringly obvious once you spot it in that movement.

And I find this troubling, as I'm not sure how to communicate about compromises, for instance, with a group which doesn't seem to see anyone else as ever suffering at all.

Yes, that ^^

I have looked too. And never yet seen it.

It seems a very alarming inability to see anyone outside of the group as fully and equally human.

And the binding characteristic of the group is adherence to the political belief system, not to be TQ+. Many are not themselves TQ+ and I have seen the treatment turned on a T person who dares to voice experiences or thoughts incompatible with the belief system: it's even worse than how they treat women. It's the same treatment meted out to any believer of theirs who dares to question, or who accidentally gets something wrong.

And now this political group is becoming actively violent in pursuit of its politics against others interests and equalities.

SerafinasGoose · 02/04/2023 14:58

It seems a very alarming inability to see anyone outside of the group as fully and equally human.

And the binding characteristic of the group is adherence to the political belief system, not to be TQ+. Many are not themselves TQ+ and I have seen the treatment turned on a T person who dares to voice experiences or thoughts incompatible with the belief system: it's even worse than how they treat women. It's the same treatment meted out to any believer of theirs who dares to question, or who accidentally gets something wrong.

Exactly this.

This is nowhere more starkly illustrated than through the old-school transsexuals who, from an early stage, were acutely aware of the damage this vociferous ideology posed to them as well as women. Those who spoke openly about it were vilified as 'Truscum'. And as for the attempt by a non-TQ member of Mermaids to sue Miranda Yardley, an actual trans 'woman' (who recognises he's male) for supposed 'transphobia', well, you really couldn't make it up. Except she apparently did.

An actual woman, suing a transsexual for transphobia. Give me strength.

As for the treatment they mete out to detransitioners, it's nothing short of tragic.

There are a number of trans people known to me who are increasingly appalled by the turn this has taken, and concerns that violent trans-activism makes their lives more, not less, uncomfortable if not downright dangerous. I know equal numbers (I work in academia so encounter this frequently) who are completely in thrall to GI.

I have to wonder how much more it will take for people to realize that this aggressive movement really doesn't care about trans people. A not inconsiderably proportion of these adherents have an entirely different agenda. They must have. Otherwise, why make a beeline for rape crisis centres and insinuating male criminals into prison estates full of vulnerable women?

This is a wholesale endeavour to normalise criminal sexual behaviour. That it's seriously hurting women there is no doubt of, but it's also causing incredible harm to the people who's interests it professes to accept. What it will take for the scales to fall from their eyes is another question.

SerafinasGoose · 02/04/2023 15:03

Sorry for the numerous grammatical errors on the above post. Typed on my small phone screen and my reading eyesight isn't great. 'Accept' should read 'protect!'

EmpressaurusOfCats · 02/04/2023 16:51

I have to wonder how much more it will take for people to realize that this aggressive movement really doesn't care about trans people. A not inconsiderably proportion of these adherents have an entirely different agenda. They must have. Otherwise, why make a beeline for rape crisis centres and insinuating male criminals into prison estates full of vulnerable women?

Have a look at this article by Janice Turner.
https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/db651234-9e7c-11ed-8201-2ed91f44d1e8?shareToken=e3a3d3c94293870aef57e7fab0fc626b
I’ve copied & pasted the most relevant paragraph.

‘Indeed, trans activists strategically targeted prison policy. James Morton, head of the Scottish Trans Alliance, formulated the Scottish Prison Service’s rules. By enabling the service “to include trans women as women on a self-declaration basis within very challenging circumstances”, he wrote, “we would be able to ensure all other public services do likewise”. In other words, if horrible things happen to female prisoners, no one will find out (or even care), so we can “prove” to the NHS or schools that self-ID is risk-free.’

SquirrelSoShiny · 03/04/2023 23:15

MorningPlatypus · 30/03/2023 16:42

Bold strategy.

So accurate 😁

PriOn1 · 04/04/2023 03:34

‘Indeed, trans activists strategically targeted prison policy. James Morton, head of the Scottish Trans Alliance, formulated the Scottish Prison Service’s rules. By enabling the service “to include trans women as women on a self-declaration basis within very challenging circumstances”, he wrote, “we would be able to ensure all other public services do likewise”. In other words, if horrible things happen to female prisoners, no one will find out (or even care), so we can “prove” to the NHS or schools that self-ID is risk-free.’

I have never really been able to work out whether Morton really thought that female prisoners were disposable and nobody would care, or whether it was genuine naivety, and the belief was that these men would be honourable and wouldn’t react like other imprisoned men, if allowed access to women.

Because if it was really the former, and Morton knew these men would behave exactly as any rational person would expect, then all that was created was a ticking time bomb.

One has to assume that Morton wanted to achieve permanent privileges for people claiming a trans identity. I realise the ticking time bomb is very slow to go off, precisely because it was largely under most people’s radar. Was the thinking that, by the time it did go off, that the other privileges would be in place and thus slow and difficult to remove?

Or does Morton revere men who claim they are women so much that there really was a naive faith that it would all be fine?

EmpressaurusOfCats · 04/04/2023 08:06

That’s a really interesting question because I always just assumed it was the first one, an act of extraordinary cold-bloodedness.

But if it was down to well-meaning naivety, Morton showed no sign of recanting when it became clear that there were problems.

easterbunnysbum · 04/04/2023 09:39

They're just anarchists in too small clothes.

nilsmousehammer · 04/04/2023 10:39

And less anarchists with any actual political knowledge, belief or purpose in the anarchy movement than just bellends liking the feelz and image while breaking stuff.

CryptoFascistMadameCholet · 04/04/2023 13:29

They identify as anarchists.

postop · 05/04/2023 20:25

Vengeance for what? I am struggling to think of anything.

RealityFan · 05/04/2023 20:47

postop · 05/04/2023 20:25

Vengeance for what? I am struggling to think of anything.

Those very words are violence.

Kinda handy for the wish-to-be-permanently-victimised cult.

Bláthannabuí · 05/04/2023 21:06

They have access to women's prisons, women's toilets, changing rooms, women's rights... What exactly are they avenging?

RealityFan · 05/04/2023 21:09

Bláthannabuí · 05/04/2023 21:06

They have access to women's prisons, women's toilets, changing rooms, women's rights... What exactly are they avenging?

That despite all of that, they're still deeply unhappy people.

Bláthannabuí · 05/04/2023 21:15

Imagine the uproar if we decided to have a Woman's day of Vengence to get back our spaces, toilets, changing rooms & human rights.
There would be a counter rally organisated within seconds to put us TERFs back in our box!

Bláthannabuí · 05/04/2023 22:15

TRAs gearing up to go into battle with labour canvessor.. 1st rule of battle never give away your game plan... Howling at the first comment.. Pretend to be GC.. Then go for the jugular 🤣🤣

'Trans Day of Vengeance' protest continues as planned following Nashville shooting
Swipe left for the next trending thread