Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Boohoo the poor menz: a BBC report on why men's feelings should be equal to women's in the abortion debate

275 replies

ByGrabtharsHammarWhatASaving · 29/08/2019 12:38

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-49240582

"Men are usually involved in an abortion in one of four ways, all of which can leave men traumatised when they come to reflect afterwards on their roles, say those running counselling groups for post-abortive men. Sometimes men coerce a woman into having an abortion against her will; others say they will support the woman's decision either way, while steering that decision toward abortion. Some men find out about the abortion for the first time after the fact, or the abortion goes ahead against their wishes."

Speaking as someone who was coerced into an abortion I didn't want, I couldn't give a fuck how traumatic it might be for him to later "reflect" on his actions. One day he'd be saying it was all my choice and he'd support me no matter what, the next day he'd be making plans to move country if I had the baby, the next he'd be threatening to use his contacts at social services to have the baby removed from me and saying he'd take full custody if I went ahead, then the next day he'd be bringing me gifts and begging me not to terminate. Shockingly that was quite a lot to cope with whilst also studying full time and experiencing such extreme morning sickness I could hardly think. Shockingly I decided that wasn't an environment I could justify bringing a child into. When I went for the surgery, because I was 11 weeks by the time I decided, he begged to be allowed to come with me, then never showed up because he decided to go shopping for a new BMW instead. I never heard from him again, but I lost the next 3 years of my life to severe depression over the guilt and regret I felt. I seriously and frequently considered suicide. I engaged in very high risk sexual behaviour in the hope of contracting some terrible STD which I felt was what I deserved. I went to the doctor several times but was rejected for help each time and told to basically get over it as it was "my choice". I was offered a single counselling session by the NHS with a woman who told me she "only really knew about miscarriages" and suggested I just make a list of pros and cons to look at when I felt sad. Ultimately I dropped out of university because the course material focused often on pregnancy which I found too upsetting. Many years later I now have 2 children but I still cry to think of the one who isn't here. So I don't give a shiny fuck how the man who got me pregnant feels now.

At the same time another friend I knew became pregnant by a man who was abusive to her but for religious reasons didn't want her to terminate. He would turn up to her house in the middle of the night screaming at her that she was a murderer. He made her life a living hell, but because of her termination she was able to finish her degree, leave that relationship, and is now happily married and professionally successful. So I don't give a flying fuck how the guy that got her pregnant feels now either.

""Men are meant to be protectors, so there is a sense of failure - failing to protect the mother and the unborn child, failing to be responsible," says 61-year-old Chuck Raymond, whose 18-year-old girlfriend had an abortion in the late 70s when he was a teenager."

I don't give a fuck, Chuck.

"He likens the mental and emotional anguish that can follow an abortion to battlefield post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)."

Post abortion stress syndrome isn't even a recognised condition for women yet, you know, the people actually trying to make the life changing decision in the midst of morning sickness, social pressure, and often male coercive control. The ones who actually have to choose between giving birth and raising a child, or going through an often traumatic medical procedure. And I don't believe for a second that these poor "traumatised" men actually wanted to raise the baby themselves, it's all about not being able to control the woman.

"It's changing now, men are fed up," Ms Bonopartis says. "Men had bought into how they have no say in this and that if they speak out, they are against women, but now the impact is being felt by more and more of them as the repercussions of 45 years of abortion are being seen."

FUCK. OFF.

FUCK OFF FUCK OFF FUCK OFF

I don't care if men are fed up. I don't care how sad they are, or if they feel emasculated by not being able to control women, or if they feel like being made to pay child support somehow gives them part shares in women's bodies, or if they think that they are the natural protectors of children and women (despite being their number one killers) and should therefore be allowed to "protect" a fetus by forcing it to be born to an unwilling mother when 9/10 times they have no intention of caring for it themselves. I don't give a single fuck and I am so angry that the BBC has run this "sympathetic" article which basically says men should be allowed to have a say in women's medical care. Men can state their preference for an outcome, fine, and they're allowed to be upset if that preference isn't followed, but they have no right, not now and not ever, to expect their preference to be given equal weight to a woman's.

So, fuck off BBC. Fuck off Alabama. Fuck off all pro forced birth people but especially pro forced birth men. Fuck off to my ex and to my friends ex, and to the exes of all the equally traumatised women I met in the one solitary non religious (i.e you need forgiveness) post abortion support group I was able to eventually find online because no one gives enough of a shit to form one in real life on behalf of women. Fuck off to anyone who thinks the decision over what happens to a woman's body should be in the hands of anyone but the woman herself. Fuckity fucking fuck off.

OP posts:
BarbaraStrozzi · 29/08/2019 18:29

That Reddit thread is superb!

Trohmaniac · 29/08/2019 18:29

I've seen that Reddit thread - the guy got his arse handed to him, didn't he? And rightly so.

Good example of why men can have all the feelings they like - and go and get counselling if need be - but ultimately it comes down to the women to decide what goes on in their own uterus.

placemats · 29/08/2019 18:44

Amen to your post OP.

These guys are all me, me, me, poor me.

When it comes to changing a nappy every four hours of every day, feeding every four hours of every day, washing twice a day, just for the baby, making three meals, changing bedding, cleaning the house, SUDDENLY, they fuck off.

LonginesPrime · 29/08/2019 19:04

"If men had to sign off on an abortion, I think you would see a 50% drop, and that's why the [abortion providers] don't want men involved," says Mr Purington.

This attitude is fucking terrifying.

That would be 50% of women seeking an abortion being forced to carry a pregnancy to term against their will because of men's 'rights'.

ErrolTheDragon · 29/08/2019 19:07

Get fucked, Alabama.

Or if you can't deal with the consequences, don't?

Trohmaniac · 29/08/2019 19:15

Errol Grin

MrGHardy · 29/08/2019 20:20

Yea, I skim read that this morning I think. At the beginning there is a part about how men are usually told not to tell women what they can and can't do with their body.

Then they go on to say how this is an ignored group of men in the debate. Only to basically tell the story of men who do just that - tell women what they can and can't do with their body.

What a lousy article.

Yes here: "Currently, the usual male perspectives that feature are legislators pushing to restrict abortion procedures, drawing the ire of pro-choice supporters accusing them of trying to legislate women's bodies."

But other way around, they first say this: "a voice rarely heard among the passionate multitudes in the US abortion debate"

The only difference is that this group is personally involved, but otherwise, everything else is the same. And somehow that means it is something totally different.

LonnyVonnyWilsonFrickett · 29/08/2019 20:21

That Reddit thread would be funny, if the boards here weren't full to bursting of 'he's changed since we had our much-wanted baby' threads.

Trohmaniac · 29/08/2019 20:26

That Reddit thread would be funny, if the boards here weren't full to bursting of 'he's changed since we had our much-wanted baby' threads.

And women with children whose partners have suddenly decided 'family' isn't for them and upped and left, leaving women financially worse off and emotionally broken.

StockTakeFucks · 29/08/2019 20:52

The men's voices are rarely heard when it comes to abortion ? What is the fucking majority sex in passing anti abortion laws and restrictions? What is the majority sex of prominent anti abortion groups?

That (shit penis worshiping and ball fondling) article lost whatever shred of credibility when they included men that fucking coerced women into abortions in the sad and "traumatised " group.

Go fuck yourselves...with a chair...up the arse!

woman19 · 29/08/2019 21:05

Worth following closely what's happening to Women's Reproductive rights in Hungary and Russia.

That's where this interesting path is taking british Women.

But not women in most of the other EU26.

MouthyHarpy · 29/08/2019 22:01

And another Amen.

Perhaps the intervention to consider men’s feelings should happen at the time just before they don’t take responsibility for their sperm.

MetalMidget · 29/08/2019 22:11

I read that article earlier and was all kinds of "What the actual fuck" about it.

Quite frankly, any man that wants to force a woman through pregnancy and childbirth is an extremist and should be shot into the sun.

Jesus fucking Christ.

ConcreteUnderpants · 29/08/2019 22:29

Excellent post OP.

Read it when I woke up and had the rage all morning.

I also don't give a fuck, Chuck

FleetsumNJetsum · 29/08/2019 22:35

The men's voices are rarely heard when it comes to abortion?What is the fucking majority sex in passing anti abortion laws and restrictions? What is the majority sex of prominent anti abortion groups?

Spot on Stock

This is the discussion to be had, not fucking boohoo menz feels

Fraggling · 29/08/2019 23:18

Also read this earlier and was going to start a thread.

My main question is.

Why did the bbc publish this shit? I find that v concerning to start.

Yes I'm sure men feel sad that they get no say, legally, either way. In whether, once a woman is pregnant, she keeps it or not. I can see that is difficult.

But. It's not their body. And more to the point, it's not their risk.

The man who said that the woman wouldn't even agree to adoption, and that was illogical. Has no idea, does he...

This is the new anti abortion approach, I think?

Missing in that article, as in anti abortion stuff, is any concept or acknowledgement whatsoever of the risks a woman takes in carrying and birthing a child. Death is not so common in usa, although way more common than it should be. But, other physical and mental health issues are common. There is no sense of that at all. As with the anti abortion people, pregnancy and childbirth are a nothing.

I was shocked to see this on BBC. Wtf is going on???

JanesKettle · 29/08/2019 23:34

OP, my first thought when I read the title of your thread was 'FUCK OFF', so I am glad to see the many reiterations of this thought in your post.

I've had more than one abortion anyway, and so far as I know, none of the 'fathers' gave a single shit.

The only people who should be involved in an abortion are a woman (natal, of whatever gender expression) and her health care provider.

Friends of mine had a late term termination of a severely disabled baby, and the dad was, of course, terribly upset, although acknowledging his experience was completely different to that of his partner, who was the person who was pregnant. He would not be opining that in the vast majority of terminations (before 16 weeks) fathers feelings matter in any practical way, because he's a decent guy.

I mean, sure, go to counselling if you need to process your male sadness. That's fine. But accept your feelings are pretty much a side issue when it comes to abortion itself.

JanesKettle · 29/08/2019 23:36

This is just the inevitable outgrowth of 'abortion is a peoples' issue' b/s, imo. Nice how all the gender diverse language vapors opened a door to men to have a say in abortion, thanks so much for that bit of progress.

MiniMum97 · 30/08/2019 00:32

I agree that it's totally 100% the woman's choice. It's her body and anything else is unthinkable.

However it's also ok, natural and understandable for a man to feel sad about the loss of a potential child if they wanted the pregnancy to go ahead.

Just because it's the woman's choice doesn't mean the man shouldn't feel sad. They are allowed to feel things. If they didn't care at all that would be pretty shit too.

Both men and women sometimes feel sad even when an abortion is their decision. And that's ok as well.

I had a miscarriage and was devastated even though I had ante natal depression and prior to the miscarriage was feeling disassociated and I wanted an abortion. It is hard to have the decision taken from you - you may grieve the loss like a death. It doesn't matter that it's the right way to go about things logically and morally, emotionally it can still be hard.

Society telling men that they can't feel things or express emotion is partly why there is such a high suicide rate in men so we shouldn't be discouraging them from expressing their feelings. Their feelings don't mean they get to decide or pressure women though.

StockTakeFucks · 30/08/2019 07:48

Men can feel sad, they're allowed their feelings. They can talk about those those feelings with friends,family and counsellors .

No one is saying they can't. But what they can't have is rights over a woman's body. And this is what it's all about it in the end.

Suing a clinic because they performed an abortion is not about sadness. It's about changing legislation, it's about setting a precedent , in a country where women's rights and choices are already being trampled all over . It's easier to get a gun than get an abortion in some US states.

bd67th · 30/08/2019 08:24

If these MPAs put $10 each into Vasalgel development, it would be on the market by Christmas. Then they could use their bodies, as is their right, to minimise the risk of causing a pregnancy, reversibly and with more reliability than a condom.

But they don't, because their "financial abortion" (aka defunding their child once born) and "men should have a say because abortion hurts our feelz" rhetoric is about controlling women and removing our rights, not male reproductive autonomy.

Agree with PP that the genderist "pregnant people" rhetoric that is spreading far and wide (Abortion Support Network, I'm looking at you) is creating a linguistic environment ripe for men to take over the conversation about abortion.

LangCleg · 30/08/2019 08:34

Suing a clinic because they performed an abortion is not about sadness. It's about changing legislation, it's about setting a precedent , in a country where women's rights and choices are already being trampled all over . It's easier to get a gun than get an abortion in some US states.

This.

HumberElla · 30/08/2019 10:17

Totally with you on this OP.

Im so over seeing Men’s feelz being weighed in the balance against women’s bodily autonomy, rights and experience. Knowing the scales are already loaded.

Fraggling · 30/08/2019 10:38

Minimum has anyone said men aren't allowed to feel sad?

These men want the legal right to force women to carry and birth children when they don't want to. That will make women more than 'sad' won't it.

Alltheprettyseahorses · 30/08/2019 10:49

Men do not have a say on this. Pregnancy and childbirth is debilitating at best and deadly at its far-to-common worst. But for those men who think they should - that means we say what happens in your healthcare. We would have the right to authorise medical procedures that have a good chance of leaving you incontinent, and we could make you go through bodily processes that will not only affect you physically and mentally but also ruin your future career, earning potential and social status, all against your will too. There's been far too much of this shit. That is quite enough.

Swipe left for the next trending thread